[1. CALL TO ORDER]
[00:00:08]
>> I AM SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WHO WILL BE PRESIDING OVER THIS MORNING'S HEARING. YOU ARE HERE BECAUSE YOU RECEIVED NOTICE YOUR PROPERTY IS IN VIOLATION OF AN ORDNANCE.
YOU WILL BE GIVEN A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF TIME TO DO SO.
WE WILL CALL YOUR CASES SHORTLY. IF YOU DON'T MIND PLEASE STAND
FOR THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND REPUBLIC WHICH IT
[A. ADMINISTRATION OF OATH TO DEPARTMENTAL WITNESSES]
STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL.>> PLEASE REMAIN STANDING SO THE CLERK CAN SWEAR YOU IN FOR THOSE OF YOU THAT ARE GOING TO TESTIFY.
>> RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM YOUR TESTIMONY YOU ARE ABOUT TO GIVE WILL BE THE TRUTH.
>> YES. >> MADAME CLERK FIRST CASE IN COMPLIANCE 21.2036. SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK.
21 21-13200 BLOCK NORTH SECOND STREET JOHN NORTH ELSON. 21-1667300 BLOCK INDIAN RIVER DRIVE. 22-17 GOLD STREAM PARKING, 700 OCEAN. 21-3638 BOAT RAMP, LYNN MARIE SYLVIA. 21-1096 1712 AVENUE O.
21-2593 SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK. TERESA FERNANDEZ.
>> TWO THINGS, ANYONE HERE NEED AN INTERPRETER? NO. 2 YOU ARE BEING TELEVISED ON THE LOCAL TV STATION.
BE AWARE OF THAT WHEN YOU COME TO THE FLOOR.
TRUST ME PEOPLE WILL SAY I SAW YOU ON TV.
[A. 21-3641 PK 100 Blk AE Backus Ave Elizabeth Delaney, Kevin Delaney John Makolin]
MADAME CLERK CALL THE FIRST CASE.21-3641, 100 BLOCK ELIZABETH DELANEY AND KEVIN DELANEY.
YOU CAN COME TO THE PODIUM HANG TIGHT FOR A SECOND.
>> HELLO. >> CAN YOU STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD AND ADVISE IF YOU HAVE BEEN SWORN IN.
>> MY NAME IS ELIZABETH C. DELANEY.
YES I HAVE BEEN SWORN IN. >> THANK YOU.
>> WE ARE READY >> 2136-41 100 BLOCK OF AE BACKUS AVENUE, CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.
VIOLATION OCCURRED. >> PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE VIOLATION?
>> I DO. >> WHO IS THE VIOLATOR ON THE
VIOLATION? >> REGISTRATION ELIZABETH OR
KEVIN DELANEY. >> HAS MISS DELANEY SEEN THOSE
>> I HAVE MY OWN PHOTOGRAPHS. >> THANK YOU.
YES, THAT IS MY CAR. >> DO THE PHOTOGRAPHS FAIRLY AND
[00:05:01]
>> ADMITTED. >> IS THIS AN APPEAL?
>> YES, MA'AM, IT IS. >> DID YOU SUBMIT APPEAL
>> DO YOU HAVE THAT IN A PACKET? >> I DO.
>> WE'LL MOVE THAT IN. CITY'S COMPOSITE 2 SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. IT IS MISS DELANEY'S APPEAL AS WELL AS PHOTOGRAPHS ATTACHED TO HER WRITTEN APPEAL.
>> IF NO OBJECTION, THEY'LL BE ADMITTED.
>> BEFORE I PARKED THERE I LOOKED ACROSS THE STREET THAT SAID NO PARKING. MADE ME THINK IT WAS FOR THE OTHER SIDE OF THE STREET. THERE WERE NUMEROUS CARS PARKED WHERE I PARKED. I MADE SURE MY CAR WAS OUT OF THE STREET. I THOUGHT THAT I WAS NOT BREAKING IN PARKING VIOLATION. PARKING ORDNANCES OR WHATEVER.
I NEVER WOULD HAVE PARKED THERE HAD I KNOWN.
THAT IS ALL I HAVE TO SAY. I FELT THAT SIGN INDICATED FOR THE OPPOSITE SIDE OF THE STREET. SO I WAS JUST MISUNDERSTOOD, I
GUESS. >> MR. JOHN MAKOLIN DO YOU HAVE
A RESPONSE? >> IN SO FOR PARKING SIGN, REFERENCE DIRECTLY IN FRONT OF THE CITY PARKING LOT AE BACK KUS. THOSE WERE POSTED A WHILE BACK.
CITY ORDNANCE NO PARKING ON THE CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.THOSE WERE PO.
CITY ORDNANCE NO PARKING ON THE CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.
THAT DAY SEVERAL CARS, SEVERAL CITATIONS WRITTEN IN THAT AREA.
>> [INAUDIBLE] >> DO WE HAVE GOOGLE EARTH WE
>> MADAME SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WE WANTED TO GIVE YOU AN OVERVIEW OF THIS AREA GIVEN MISS DELANEY'S -- SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WHAT STAFF HAS TO SAY IS THERE WAS A PUBLIC PARKING LOT ACROSS FORT PIERCE MAIN STREET BUILDING, BACKUS.
VERY LARGE AREA BETWEEN STREET AND PARKING LOT.
THE STOP SIGN ON NORTH SECOND. IN ORDER FOR CLEAR VISION TO BE MAINTAINED NORTH ON NORTH SECOND TO BE ABLE TO SEE AE BACKUS.
VERY LARGE AREA BETWEEN PARKING LOT AND ROAD.
WE HAD TO PUT UP NO PARKING SPOTS TO MAKE SURE VISION REMAINED CLEAR. WE CANNOT PUT A NO PARKING SIGN ON NO PARKING SPOT. IT WAS NOT UP THERE ARE TWO BUILDINGS THERE. THESE VEHICLES PARKED EAST OF THE TWO BUILDINGS ON AE BACKUS. IF YOU WANT I CAN PULL THE
VISUAL UP IF YOU NEED IT. >> DO YOU NEED TO SEE THE
VISUAL? >> LARGE PARKING AREA -- I WAS GOING TO THE MARKET ON SATURDAY. I WAS PARKED JUST OUTSIDE OF THAT. AS I SAID, I GUESS I MISUNDERSTOOD WHAT THE PARKING CODE WAS.
I THOUGHT YOU WEREN'T ALLOWED TO PARK ON THE STREET.
IF YOU WERE OFF THE STREET. I UNDERSTAND THAT MIGHT HAVE BEEN A RIGHT-OF-WAY. I DIDN'T THINK THAT AT THE TIME.
I WAS -- I FELT LIKE I WAS STILL IN THE PARKING LOT ALTHOUGHIST
OUTSIDE THE RED LINE. >> CITY GIVING CITATIONS BEFORE
[00:10:09]
IN THAT AREA BECAUSE PEOPLE VIOLATE THE PARKING.>> HAD I KNOWN I WOULD HAVE NEVER PARKED THERE.
I WASN'T TRYING TO DO ANYTHING ILLEGAL.
I ALSO FELT LIKE THE $50 PARKING FEE WAS PRETTY OWNEROUS.
>> THE IT IS A PROBLEM. THERE ARE TWO GARAGES HERE.
ONE HERE AND FURTHER DOWN ON SECOND STREET.
PUBLIC PARKING, DOESN'T COST ANYTHING.
AND IF YOU ARE LUCKY YOU CAN GET A PARKING SPOT.
I UNDERSTAND THAT. I DIDN'T DO IT KNOWING I WAS BREAKING THE LAW. I WOULD HAVE CERTAINLY PARKED IN A DIFFERENT PLACE HAD I KNOWN THAT.
I THOUGHT BECAUSE THE SIGN WAS ON THE OPPOSITE SIDE IT WASN'T INTENDED FOR MY SIDE OF THE STREET.
IT WAS A MISTAKE OBVIOUSLY ON MY PART.
>> ANYTHING FURTHER? >> YOU HAVE TO BE KIDDING ME.
I AM SORRY THIS IS OUT OF MY CONTROL --
NOTHING FURD FROM STAFF. >> WHEN YOU GET THE TICKET ON THE BACK THERE ARE ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS.
A LOT OF PEOPLE WANT TO APPEAL IT.
THERE ARE ADDITIONAL COSTS. ALL RIGHT.
ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO, MA'AM.
>> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE PRESENTED AND THE TESTIMONY I FOUND A VIOLATION EXISTS AND DELANEY AND OR KEVIN DELANEY.
TOTAL DUE OF $60. HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY
>> YOU CAN APPEAL THIS FAMILY COURT.
>> I THINK THAT WOULD BE A WASTE OF MY TIME.
WHERE DO I PAY? >> WE ARE GOING TO ASSIST YOU
HERE. >> THANK YOU, GOOD LUCK.
>> NEXT CASE MADAME CLERK. >> I AM GOING AHEAD, 21-3649
[B. 21-3649 PK Orange/ Indian River Dr Dephne Lynette Newton John Makolin]
ORANGE/INDIAN RIVER DRIVE DAPHNE LYNETTE NEWTON.>> I AM GOING TO SWEAR YOU IN. RAISE YOUR RIGHT.
STATE YOUR NAME. >> DEPHNE LYNETTE NEWTON.
>> DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM YOUR TESTIMONY WILL BE THE TRUTH?
>> YES. >> REFERENCE CASE 213649, PARKING VIOLATION ORANGE/INDIAN RIVER DRIVE.
CITATION NO. 5662. VIOLATION OF CITY ORDNANCE 3435L PARKING ON THE CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.
>> IS THIS AN APPEAL AS WELL? >> YES, MA'AM.
>> DO YOU HAVE THE VIOLATION? >> I DO.
>> HAS RESPONDENT SEEN THE PHOTOGRAPHS?
[00:15:01]
>> YES. DO PHOTOGRAPHS -- HER APPEAL PACKET. DO THE PHOTOGRAPHS FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION AS YOU OBSERVED IT.
>> THEY DO. >> COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1 TAKEN AND CITY'S EXHIBIT 2. MISS NEWTON'S PACKET.
>> BOTH REVIEWED? >> ANYTHING ELSE?
>> STATE YOUR NAME? >> DEPHNE LYNETTE NEWTON.
>> HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO THE ALLEGATIONS?
>> I WROTE DOWN WHAT I WANTED TO SAY I AM NERVOUS.
I WOULD LIKE TO THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO ADDRESS THIS PARKING TICKET SITUATION THIS MORNING.
I ALSO LIKE TO APOLOGIZE FOR THIS INCIDENT.
I RECEIVED THE TICKET FOR PARKING IN THE GRASS BEHIND MY PLACE OF EMPLOYMENT. EMPLOYED AT THE LIBRARY.
SINCE THE START OF THE FARMER'S MARKET I HAVE BEEN WORKING IN THE AREA 36 YEARS. ESPECIALLY ON SATURDAY DURING HOLIDAYS. I DROVE ALL AROUND TRYING TO FIND A PARKING SPACE. WHEN I COME TO WORK I HAVE A BIG BACKPACK I HAVE BECAUSE I DON'T GO OUT TO EAT FOR LUNCH.
I UNDERSTAND THERE WAS A PARKING GARAGE BUT IT IS SO DIFFICULT TO WALK FROM ALL THE WAY. IT IS REALLY DIFFICULT ON THE WEEKENDS TO FIND A PARKING SPACE.
YEARS AGO I DID PARK ON THE GRASS A FEW TIMES.
I HAVE ALWAYS LIKED RUN OUT AS SOON AS THE PARKING SPACE, WE HAVE 15 MINUTES TO TRY TO FIND A PARKING SPACE.
THIS PARTICULAR MORNING IT WAS REALLY, REALLY DIFFICULT, I TOOK A CHANCE PARKING ON THE GRASS BEHIND THE LIBRARY.
I DID PUT A NOTE ON MY WINDOW TO COME SEE ME, I AM TRYING TO FIND A PARKING SPACE. I ENDED UP WHEN I WENT OUT TO PUT THE NOTE ON THE CAR, I ENDED UP, THOUGHT I SEEN A PARKING SPACE. ENDED UP BACKING UP, DAMAGED MY CAR THAT MORNING. IT WASN'T IN A PARKING SPACE.
HAD TO PARK BACK ON THE GRASS. SINCE YEAR 2000, WHEN THEY STARTED FARMER'S MARKET IN THE AREA, WE LOST OUR PARKING SPACE.
WE USED TO HAVE ONE WHEN THAT LIBRARY WAS FIRST BUILT 1999.
FOR SOME REASON WE LOST OUR PARKING SPOT.
MONDAY-FRIDAY PEOPLE DON'T HAVE A PROBLEM.
WE HAVE A PROBLEM EVERY SINGLE SATURDAY.
THIS IS MY FIRST OFFENSE. AND THAT IS ALL I HAVE TO SAY.
I JUST WISHED I HAD A PARKING SPACE ON SATURDAYS.
I WISH IT WAS EASIER. IT IS GOING TO CONTINUE TO BE A
HARDSHIP. >> IT IS EVEN HARDER DURING THE WINTER MONTHS BECAUSE THE SNOWBIRDS ARE HERE.
LAST WEEK I HAD TO PARK, LAST SATURDAY PASSED, I STARTED EARLY. I FOUND A PARKING SPACE UP ON SECOND STREET. I WISH I WOULD HAVE HAVE BROUGHT MY TOTE BACK. IT IS REALLY HARD TRYING TO GET TO WORK ON TIME WHEN YOU HAVE ALL THIS HEAVY LUGGAGE.
[00:20:02]
I DID GET A CHANCE TO, DURING MY LUNCH BREAK, I DID GET A CHANCE TO WALK UP ON SEVENTH STREET. PARKING LETS UP AROUND 12:00.12:00 FARMER'S MARKET ACROSS THE ROAD START CLEANING UP.
THEY START CLEANING UP, PEOPLE LEAVE AND EMPLOYEES, WE RUN OUTSIDE AND GET OUR CARS AND TRY TO PARK IT.
WE BRING IT BACK UP TO THE BUILDING.
IF WE DON'T SATURDAY AFTER WORK, IT WAS RAINING.
I HAD TO GO GET MY CAR I WOULD HAVE BEEN CAUGHT IN THE RAIN.
IT IS REALLY, REALLY DIFFICULT. THIS IS MY FIRST OFFENSE.
AGAIN NO PARKING ON THE GRASS. OTHER OUTSIDERS, PEOPLE PARKED ON THE GRASS, I THINK IT SHOULD BE A SIGN THERE.
THIS TICKET IS HALF OF MY PAY WORKING.
SOMEONE NEEDS TO PUT UP A NO PARKING SIGN.
A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE STILL PARKING THERE.
IT HAPPENED LAST SATURDAY, EVERY SATURDAY AT THE FARMER'S MARKET.
SOME PEOPLE GET TICKETS, SOME PEOPLE DON'T.
>> I HAVE BEEN PARKING DOWN HERE FOR 30 SOMETHING YEARS.
ONE JOB WE WOULD PARK TWO HOURS AND HERE IS THE TICKET WE WOULD ALL MOVE OUR CARS TO ANOTHER SPOT.
THIS IS NO CONSOLATION I GOT TWO TICKETS, TWO.
ONE ON [INAUDIBLE], OTHER I JUST SIMPLY FORGOT IT WAS TWO HOUR PARKING. THERE IS A SIGN THAT SAYS TWO HOUR PARKING. I SIMPLY FORGOT IT.
I AM VERY CAREFUL WHERE I PARK. NOW I USE THE GARAGE.
>> UH HUH. MIGHT NEED TO GET YOU A LITTLE
TOTE BAG. >> EVEN IF I ORANGE TO INDIAN RIVER DRIVE THAT IS A LONG STRESSFUL WALK BACK ANDFORD TO WORK. THIS IS MY FIRST OFFENSE.
AGAIN I THINK THAT I TOOK A CHANCE.
ALWAYS PARKED ON THE GRASS NEVER RECEIVED A TICKET.
THEY NEED TO PUT A NO PARKING SIGN ON THE GRASS BEHIND THE LIBRARY. JUST THIS SATURDAY PASSED I TOOK PICTURES OF CARS PARKED THERE. THEY ARE GOING TO PARK ON THE GRASS AND CONTINUE TO GET A TICKET BECAUSE THEY DON'T KNOW.
SOMEBODY SHOULD PUT A SIGN THERE THAT WAY NO ONE WILL HAVE TO EXPERIENCE WHAT I AM EXPERIENCING.
SHOULD BE A SIGN. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?
>> NO, MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> NO, MA'AM.
>> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED, I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS FOR A PARKING TICKET.
ISSUED TO DEPHNE LYNETTE NEWTON. I WILL FINE YOU $50 AND ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10. HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY
THE TICKET? >> CAN YOU GIVE ME 30 DAYS? I I'LL GIVE YOU 30 DAYS IF YOU DON'T PAY IT, COULD BE SENT TO THE COUNTY CLERK'S OFFICE YOU WILL ACCRUE ADDITIONAL FEES.
>> I THINK IS EXTREMELY UNFAIR TO THE COUNTY EMPLOYEES.
[00:25:08]
ALL OF US FEEL THE SAME WAY. SHOULD BE A NO PARKING SIGN.THIS SATURDAY COMING IT WILL BE OTHER PEOPLE PARKING ON THE GRASS. I AM INNOCENT IN THE SENSE I DIDN'T KNOW. FIRST OFFENSE IN 32 YEARS.
Y'ALL HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY. >> THANK YOU.
[D. 21-3642 PK 100 Blk AE Backus Ave Wolfgang Kutzner, Marjorie Kutzner John Makolin]
>> MADAME CLERK? >> NEXT CASE, 21-3642.
100 BLK AE BACKUS AVENUE. WOLFGANG CUTSNER AND MARGEORY
100 BLOCK AE BACKUS. VEHICLE REGISTERED TO A WOLFGANG OR MARGEORY KUTZNER. VIOLATION CODE DECEMBER 18TH, 2021. VIOLATION -- CITATION NO. 5672.
PARKING IN CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY. >> DO YOU HAVE PHOTOGRAPHS OF
>> HAS MR. KUTZNER SEEN THOSE PHOTOGRAPHS?
>> I HAVE A COPY. >> DO THOSE PHOTOGRAPHS ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION AS YOU OBSERVED IT?
>> THEY DO. >> IS THIS AN APPEAL?
>> YES. >> DID MR. KUTZNER PROVIDE YOU
WITH APPEAL PAPERWORK? >> YES.
>> SORRY DIDN'T HEAR YOU. >> YES.
>> IN THE SAME AREA AS THE FIRST VIOLATION WE HEARD?
>> IT IS. >> AT THIS TIME THIS IS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1 PHOTOGRAPHS. AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 2
RESPONDENT'S APPEAL PACKET. >> ALL RIGHT.
ANYTHING FURTHER MR. MAKOLIN? >> NO, MA'AM.
>> SIR, HOW DO YOU RESPOND? >> I AM IN THE SAME BOAT AS THE FIRST PERSON ABOUT PARKING THERE.
I AM COMMERCIAL METRO PIERCE. [INAUDIBLE] WE HAVE BEEN FOR 20 YEARS, WE PARKED. IT WAS CLOSE TO BEING FULL.
I PARKED WHERE I NORMALLY PARK FOR 20 YEARS.
>> ALL RIGHT. BASED ON THEE AND TESTIMONY, I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS.
WOLFGANG KUTZNER AND MARGEORY KUTZNER RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION, $50 AND ADMINISTRATIVE FEE TOTAL OF $60.
HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY THE TICKET?
>> I CAN PAY IT TODAY. >> ALL RIGHT.
YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> NEXT CASE IS 21-3352 400
[G. 21-3352 PK 400 Blk N Indian River Dr James M Westenhaver John Makolin]
BLOCK NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE JAMES M. WESTON HAIFR.[00:30:14]
VIOLATOR REGISTERED OWN VEHICLE JAMES WESTENHAVER.NOVEMBER 13TH, 2021. CITATION NO. 3081.
VIOLATION CITY ORDNANCE, 3435 T. PARKED IN A WORK SAFETY ZONE.
>> DID YOU TAKE PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE VIOLATION?
>> I DID. >> HAS MR. WESTENHAVER SEEN THE
>> THANK YOU. I DON'T NEED TO SEE THEM.
I KNOW WHERE I WAS. >> DO THE PHOTOGRAPHS FAIRLY AND
ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION? >> THEY DID.
>> IS THIS AN APPEAL? >> I ACTUALLY HAVE A PHOTO ON MY
PHONE. >> CITY WILL MOVE INTO EVIDENCE
COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1 PHOTOGRAPHS. >> ADMITTED AS SUCH.
>> IN THIS CASE $10 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE AS WELL AS
>> NO OTHER QUESTIONS FOR YOU. >> THANK YOU.
THANK YOU MR. WESTENHAVER -- >> I AM NOT GOING TO BELABOR THE WHOLE PARKING IN FORT PIERCE. I WAS ONLY IN THIS SPOT EIGHT MINUTES, MAYBE. MY DOG WAS IN MY SUBURBAN.
I WAS IN THERE EIGHT MINUTES TO CARRY FOUR BOXES IN AND OUT.
NO PARKING TO LOAD AND UNLOAD. IF I WENT IN AND HAD LUNCH.
GET THE TICKET DIDN'T KNOW WHAT IT WAS.
I GET BACK TO MY OFFICE, I GET BACK TO MY OFFICE.
I THOUGHT IT WAS A FLYER ON MY WINDSHIELD.
I GRABBED IT. THROUGH IT DOWN IN THE PASSENGER SEAT. I WAS BACK AT 12A TALKING TO THE OWNER. THEY HAVE BEEN GIVING PARKING TICKETS, I BET THAT IS WHAT IT WAS.
I WAS LED TO BELIEVE THEY ALREADY TALKED TO THE CITY ABOUT ALL THIS STUFF. THAT IS WHY I AM HERE TODAY.
I WAS UNDERSTANDING THIS WAS ALL TAKEN CARE OF.
IF I STOPPED AND HAD LUNCH, ABSOLUTELY.
DUDE, I WAS IN THERE MAYBE EIGHT MINUTES.
IF I WAS THERE TWO HOURS THAT IS MY BAD.
THERE WAS NOWHERE TO PARK. IF YOU LOOK AT THE PICTURES, CRAZY. SORRY.
>> ALL RIGHT. ANYTHING FURTHER?
>> NO, MA'AM. >> I FIND THAT VIOLATION EXISTS JAMES WESTENHAVER PERSON RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION, $50 FINE, $10 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE, $18 LATE FEE, TOTAL $78.
HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY IT?
>> I'LL DROP IT OFF IN A COUPLE OF DAYS THIS IS RIDICULOUS.
NO WONDER PEOPLE GET AGGRAVATED WITH THIS.
I WAS THERE EIGHT MINUTES, THIS IS ABSOLUTELY ABSURD THAT THE
CITY DOES THIS TO PEOPLE. >> ALL RIGHT.
THANK YOU, SIR. NEXT CASE MADAME CLERK.
>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.
>> YES, 30 DAYS TO APPEAL ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS.
[E. 21-1268 CE 2750 S US Highway 1 SP Sands LLC Heather Debevec]
>>> NEXT CASE, 21-1268 2750 SOUTH U.S. HIGHWAY 1.
SP LLC. >> DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM YOUR TESTIMONY IS ABOUT TO BE THE TRUTH?
>> CASE NO. 21-1268 2750 SOUTH U.S. HIGHWAY 1.
SP SANDS LLC. JUNE 18TH, 2021.
[00:35:08]
PROPERTY PROHIBITED SECTION REQUESTED TO KEEP DUMPSTERS CLEAN. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINES VIOLATION EXISTS. I HAVE PHOTOS.>> DO THE PHOTOGRAPHS FAIR LIP AND ACCURATELY DEPICT THE
>> TWO SETS OF PHOTOGRAPHS? >> SOME FROM ORIGINAL AND
YESTERDAY. >> DO THE ORIGINAL VIOLATION,
CLEARED UP SOME WHAT? >> HE SAYS YES, IT WAS.
STILL CONTINUES TO BE ISSUES. >> WHEN YOU WENT BACK OUT
YESTERDAY STILL ISSUES? >> YES, MA'AM.
>> AT THIS TIME CITY WILL MOVE INTO EVIDENCE COMPOSITE EXHIBIT
ANYTHING FURTHER MISS HEATHER DEBEVEC?
>> WE HAVE SPOKEN SEVERAL TIMES TRYING TO RESOLVE THE ISSUE.
THEY ARE INSTALLING GATES AND CAMERAS.
UNTIL THAT IS COMPLETED THEY DO NOT HAVE ACCESS.
THEY BELIEVE THAT MIGHT RESOLVE SOME OF THE ISSUES.
>> IS THIS AN APARTMENT COMPLEX? >> YES, MA'AM.
>> IS IT YOUR UNDERSTANDING IT IS TENANTS, RESIDENTS?
>> YES, MA'AM. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?
>> NOT AT THIS TIME. >> MA'AM AGAIN STATE YOUR NAME
FOR THE RECORD? >> [INAUDIBLE].
>> HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO THE ALLEGATIONS.
>> MANAGEMENT TOOK OVER FEBRUARY OF LAST YEAR, SINCE THEN MAJOR RENOVATIONS CONDUCTED. WE HAVE BEEN EXTREMELY UNDERSTAFFED IN TRYING TO WORK DILIGENTLY ON ALL OF THE THINGS DONE THROUGHOUT THE PROPERTY. THE DUMPSTERS AREAS MAINTAINED DAILY AS WE ARE OPERATING DURING BUSINESS HOURS.
THE BIGGEST PROBLEM OUTSIDERS THAT DISPOSE OF BULK ITEMS ON OUR PROPERTY. THERE IS NO WAY TO MAINTAIN OR KEEP TRACK OF THAT WHICH IS WHY HEATHER AND I DID SPEAK AND IN THE PROCESS OF INSTALLING GATES AND SECURITY SYSTEM.
THAT I THINK WILL DEFINITELY HELP DWINDLE DOWN THE BULK ITEMS AND PEOPLE THAT DO NOT LIVE ON SITE DISPOSING OF THEIR TRASH IN OUR DUMPSTERS. WE HAVE MADE HUGE EFFORTS TO MAINTAIN INSIDE COMPACTER AREAS. I HAVE A 320-UNIT APARTMENT COMPLEX, 20 BUILDINGS, AS MUCH EFFORT AS WE HAVE MADE I GUESS STILL HASN'T SATISFIED WHAT YOU ARE NEEDING SO -- NOT MUCH MORE I CAN DO UNTIL THE GATES AND SECURITY CAMERAS ARE UP.
THE GATES AND SECURITY SYSTEM ALL ON THE SAME SYSTEM NETWORK.
SO THE SECURITY CAMERAS ARE INSTALLED BUT THE GATE.
PERMITS PUSHED THROUGH. THAT IS BEING INSTALLED NOW.
LOOKING TO MARCH FOR IT TO BE ALL COMPLETE.
>> NO, MA'AM. >> DO YOU THINK YOU COULD GET THIS CLEANED UP IN THE 10 DAYS THE STATE IS REQUESTING?
>> YES. THE PROBLEM THAT I HAVE IS THAT WE CAN GET IT CLEANED UP. WE ARE NOT OPEN ON SUNDAYS FOR INSTANCE. IF YOU COME MONDAY MORNING, IT TAKES MY GUYS THAT I HAVE WHICH IS TWO, IT TAKES THEM THREE TO FOUR HOURS TO DO BOTH OF THE TRASHES ON SITE.
AFTER A WEEKEND. HONESTLY DEPENDS WHEN THEY ARE COMING BY. BECAUSE MONDAY THROUGH FRIDAY I AM ON TOP OF THEM FOR MAINTAINING TRASH AREAS AS WELL AS THE GROUNDS. BUT SOME DAYS, OBVIOUSLY ESPECIALLY AFTER A SUNDAY WHEN NOBODY HAS BEEN THERE WHEN WE COME ON MONDAY, IT IS OBVIOUSLY IN WORSE OFF CONDITION THAN IT
[00:40:03]
WOULD BE THROUGHOUT THE WEEK. >> OKAY.
ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO, MA'AM.
>> ALL RIGHT. BASED ON THE EVIDENCE PRESENTS, I FIND VIOLATION EXHIBITS, 2750 SOUTH HIGHWAY 1 SP SIGNS, IS RESPONSIBLE PARTY FOR THE VIOLATION.
I WILL GIVE YOU 14 DAYS TO COMPLY.
THAT SHOULD GIVE YOU TIME TO GET YOUR EQUIPMENT INSTALLED AND EVERYTHING SET UP AND EVERYTHING CLEANED.
AND SO WHEN MISS DEBEVEC COMES BY THERE WON'T BE A PROBLEM.
GOOD LUCK TO YOU. >> THANK YOU.
[A. 15-0433 CE 121 N 12th St Simon Castor Peggy Arraiz]
>> NEXT CASE 15-433. 121 NORTH 12TH STREET SIMON CASTER. I AM GOING TO SWEAR YOU IN.
RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.
>> SIMON CASTOR. >> DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM YOUR
TESTIMONY WILL BE THE TRUTH? >> I DO.
>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE PRESENTING THE NEXT THREE CASES THEY ALL
INVOLVE MR. CASTOR. >> 15-433.
121 NORTH 12TH STREET. MARCH 15TH.
20 -- A LIEN REDUCTION. VIOLATOR FIELD OF DREAMS LTD AND NOW MR. CASTOR CURRENT OWNER. SUBSECTIONS 9 AND 13 FOR NUANCE AS A CONDITION. MAY 22ND, 2015, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FOUND OWNERS IN VIOLATION, 10 DAYS TO COMPLY OR FINED $50 PER DAY. JUNE 4TH, 2015 INSPECTION FOUND VIOLATIONS CONTINUED FINES INITIATED.
AUGUST 14TH, 2015, FINES STOPPED BECAUSE PROPERTY IN COMPLIANCE OCTOBER 24TH, THEN RECENTLY JANUARY 22.
RECEIVED REDUCTION REQUEST. AMOUNT OF THE LEAN $3,490.
GRAVITY MINOR FOR OUTSIDE STORAGE.
OUTSIDE STORAGE REMOVED. TOOK FIVE MONTHS ROUGHLY TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE. NUMBER OF TIMES VIOLATOR PREVIOUS FINED ONE. NUMBER OF VIOLATION NOTICES 15 MOST FOR LOT CLEARING AND ONE FOR CODE ENFORCEMENT.
NOT AWARE OF EXTENUATING FACTORS THAT CAUSED THE FINE TO ACCUMULATE. PENDING VIOLATIONS SUBJECT PROPERTY? THERE IS ACTIVE CASE ON THIS PROPERTY ACTIVE LOT CASE 1301 BOSTON AVENUE AND 1810 TUCKER COURT. I ALSO NEED TO REVIEW ADMINISTRATION COSTS FOR PROCESSING THE CASE.
I NEED TO TAKE THIS DOWN A LITTLE BIT.
ADMINISTRATION CHARGES FOR PROCESSING, $1,163.29 AND APPLICATION FOR REDUCTION, HE OFFERED $600 TO RESOLVE THE LIEN. STAFF IS WILLING TO ACCEPT $600 WITH $250 APPLICATION FEE FOR PUTTING THIS IN FRONT OF CITY COMMISSION, $850 STAFF RECOMMENDING FOR THIS PARTICULAR CASE. PLUS $250 TO GO BEFORE THE CITY
COMMISSION. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?
>> NO, MA'AM. >> STATE YOUR NAME.
>> SIMON CASTOR. >> YOU HAVE HEARD THE TESTIMONY
[00:45:04]
SETTLING FOR $850. ARE YOU IN AGREEMENT WITH THAT?>> YES. >> $250 BUT $850 -- YOU WILL GET A NOTICE OF THAT DATE YOU CAN APPEAL IF YOU HAVE TO.
>> MR. CASTOR, STANDARD TO PRESENT TO 60 COMMISSION IS THAT
[B. 02-8888 CE 1810 Tucker Ct Simon Castor Peggy Arraiz]
1810 TUCKER COURT. SIMON CASTOR.
>> OKAY SPECIAL MAGISTRATE CASE 02-8888.
1810 TUCKER COURT. APRIL 23RD, VIOLATOR -- CURRENTLY OWNED BY MR. SIMON CASTOR.
VIOLATIONS 5-73 HOUSE NUMBERS AND 5-368 PROPERTY MAINTENANCE.
JULY 31ST, 2002. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE SESSIONS FOUND THE OWNERS IN VIOLATION. PROVIDED 15 DAYS TO COMPLY $100 A DAY. OCTOBER 22ND, ORDER ASSESSING FINE AND IMPOSING LIEN FILED. FEBRUARY 26TH, 2003, FOUND IN COMPLIANCE, FINES STOPPED. OF COURSE JANUARY 22, REDUCTION REQUEST FROM MR. CASTOR. BALANCE OF THIS LEAN IS $13,300.
AGAIN I NEED TO ADDRESS THE CRITERIA RULES OF PROCEDURE.
GRAVITY OR SERIOUSNESS MINOR. ALL ACTIONS TAKEN BUILDING HOUSE NUMBERS PUT IN A BUILDING AND NON-OP VEHICLE REMOVED.
TOOK 10 MONTHS TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE AND TWO OTHER CASES FOUND ON THIS PROPERTY. NOT AWARE OF EXTENUATING FACTORS. THIS IS FROM MR. -- OWNER AT THE TIME. ADMINISTRATION FEES FOR THIS
CASE. >> ADMINISTRATION CHARGES FOR THIS PROCESSING THIS CASE $1,418.74 LIEN IS A LITTLE LARGER, OVER 13,000. MR. CASTOR OFFERED IN HIS APPLICATION TO PAY $400. STAFF NOT AGREEABLE TO THAT OFFER. BUT WE ARE AGREEABLE TO REDUCE IT TO THE ADMINISTRATION CHARGES.
WHICH ROUND DOWN TO 1400. THEY ARE AT 1418.
1400 FOR ADMINISTRATION CHARGES. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?
>> NO, MA'AM. >> MR. CASTOR, ARE WE IN AGREEMENT WITH THAT. IT IS NOT GOOD FOR ANYBODY.
THAT IS SOMETHING ANY WAY TO THE END.
[00:50:01]
>> THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON FOR ALMOST 20 YEARS.
>> [INAUDIBLE] >> JUST TO MAKE SOMETHING CLEAR, MR. CASTOR PURCHASED THESE PROPERTIES 2018.
VIOLATOR WAS NOT MR. CASTOR. HE DID PURCHASE THESE IN THE TAX DEED SALE. HE IS WORKING ON ANOTHER PROPERTY HE OWNS, AVENUE G. THESE LIENS ARE SPREADING.
THAT IS WHY WE ARE ADDRESSING THESE LIENS TO GET THEM RELEASED FROM THE PROPERTY HE IS TRYING TO REHABILITATE.
>> MR. CASTOR -- I AM GOING REDUCE THESE LIEN FOR THE $1,400 ADMIN COST MISS ARRAIZ REQUESTED.
I HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THE -- THIS CASE STARTED BACK IN 2002 LIKE I SAID, THAT IS ALMOST 20 YEARS.
THIS CASE WILL GO 250 THAT INCLUDED IN THE 1400.
YES, MA'AM. I AM GOING TO ACCEPT THE CITY'S
OFFER OF 1400. >> THESE WILL BE GOING TO THE
CITY COMMISSION MARCH 7TH. >> ONE MORE.
[C. 09-0722 CE 1810 Tucker Ct Simon Castor Peggy Arraiz]
>> NEXT CASE 09-722. 1810 TUCKER COURT, SIMON CASTOR.
SAME PROPERTY. PER ADMITTED REQUIRED.
JANUARY 21ST, 2010, INSPECTION SORRY DECEMBER 2ND.
OWNERS IN VIOLATION, JANUARY 21ST, 2010, VIOLATIONS CONTINUED FINES INITIATED. JANUARY 23RD, 2012, AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE FILED. PROPERTY BROUGHT INTO COMPLIANCE CITY DEMOLISHED THE BUILDING. JANUARY 11, 2022, REDUCTION REQUEST FROM MR. CASTOR TO ADDRESS THE LIEN $71,940.
TO REVIEW SEVEN CRITERIA REQUIRED BY RULES OF PROCEDURE.
THIS IS A MAJOR VIOLATION. RESULTED IN PROPERTY BEING DEMOLISHED BY THE CITY. TOOK TWO YEARS AND 10 MONTHS TO BE BROUGHT INTO COMPLIANCE. SAME VIOLATIONS EXIST THAT WERE DOCUMENTED IN THE PRIOR CASE. REMARKING ADMINISTRATION FEES.
LET ME GET THIS SO WE CAN SEE EVERYTHING.
THE ADMINISTRATION COSTS FOR PROCESSING THIS CASE IS 2,0 -- THERE IS A SIGNIFICANT COST $1,650 IS THERE.
STAFF IS WILLING TO WORK WITH THAT NUMBER A LITTLE BIT.
AND BRING THIS ADMINISTRATION COST DOWN TO $2,000.
>> OKAY. YOU SAID YOU WERE WILLING TO
WORK WITH THE 1650. >> THAT IS WHERE INSTEAD OF
[00:55:08]
2600, WE'LL TAKE $618 AND DOWN TO 2,000.WILLING TO SETTLE 2,000 DOWN FROM $71,940.
>> I'LL TAKE IT. >> ALL RIGHT.
THANK YOU. BASED ON THE STIPULATION, I'LL REDUCE THE LIEN TO $2,000. THIS WILL GO BEFORE THE CITY COMMISSION FOR THEM TO CONSIDER AND ACCEPT OR REJECT.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. >> ONCE THIS, IF THE CITY ACCEPTS THIS, HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY?
>> STANDARD IS 60 DAYS. >> THAT IS FINE.
>> THAT IS FOR EACH CASE NOW. >> THAT IS FINE.
>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. [INAUDIBLE]
>> ALL RIGHT. THANK YOU GOOD LUCK.
ALL RIGHT ANYTHING FURTHER? >> YES, MA'AM.
[8. OTHER CASES]
NEXT CASE 21-2480. HOLD ON A SECOND, ISAAC.ISAAC, CAN YOU COME UP FOR A SECOND? ISOLATED SHOWERS
>> HELLO. >> IS THIS MISS GABRIELLA RAMIREZ. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE CLERK KATHERINE. YOU ARE ON SPEAKER.
CITY COMMISSION CHAMBERS. NEXT CASE 21-2480.
1001 YORK AVENUE. FRANCISCO RAMIREZ-DIAZ AND GABRIELLA RAMIREZ. MADAME SPECIAL MAGISTRATE THIS CASE CALLED UP -- I AM SORRY LET ME SWEAR YOU IN, SORRY.
CAN YOU PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND.
STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD. >> GABRIELLA RAMIREZ.
>> DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM YOUR TESTIMONY WILL BE THE TRUTH.
>> THIS CASE CALLED JANUARY 5TH, 2020 BEFORE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.
THERE WAS AN ORDER FINING IN VIOLATION.
>> THANK YOU. I WILL SET ASIDE THE ORDER
JANUARY 2022. >> YOU MAY PROCEED.
[01:00:15]
>> CASE INITIATED SEPTEMBER 29TH, 2021.
INITIATED BY MYSELF. FRANCISCO RAMIREZ.
SECTIONS 24, 19, 20, AND 21. OUTSIDE STORAGE, CITY REQUESTS SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS VIOLATION EXISTS I HAVE PHOTOS IF YOU WANT TO HAVE A LOOK AT THEM.
>> FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT VIOLATIONS AS YOU OBSERVED THEM?
>> THEY DO. >> PHOTOGRAPHS CITY'S COMPOSITE
CURRENT IF YOU WANT TO GO BACK. YESTERDAY'S DATE.
>> DID YOU GET A CHANCE TO LOOK AT THE PHOTOGRAPHS SENT TO YOU
>> HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO THE ALLEGATIONS?
>> I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO GET A STORAGE.
WHEN I RECEIVED THE PAPER, I WAS UNDER IT WAS THE OUTSIDE AROUND THE HOUSE. THAT IS WHERE I CLEANED.
I WASN'T AWARE IT WAS IN MY CARPORT.
SO I AM IN THE PROCESS GETTING A PERMIT FOR A SHED.
TO PUT UNDER MY CARPORT. >> HAVE YOU STARTED APPLYING FOR
I THINK IT IS APPROVED. YESTERDAY I CHECKED ON IT.
IT SAID SOMETHING ABOUT A VIOLATION.
EVERYTHING ELSE WAS TO BE APPROVED.
>> CAN YOU -- >> I FIGURED YOU CAN'T SEE IT UNLESS YOU WALK UP TO THE CARPORT LIKE THE PICTURES HAVE BEEN TAKEN. IT SAYS IF YOU HAVE TO WALK UP
TO THE FRONT OF THE HOUSE. >> SO SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, TWO PERMITS IN HOUSE. ONE IS FOR THE SHED IN PLAN CHECK. TWO APPLICATIONS.
AND THE SAME, THEY WERE SUBMITTED LOOKS LIKE IN JANUARY.
>> OKAY. LET ME DOUBLE CHECK THAT ON THIS ONE HERE. FEBRUARY 7TH FOR THE SHED.
APPLICATION PUT IN PLACE FEBRUARY 7TH.
>> PCR TO GET APPROVED. [INAUDIBLE] I'LL SET THIS FOR
[01:05:19]
THE NEXT COURT DATE MADAME CLERK.HOPEFULLY MISS RAMIREZ YOU WILL HAVE EVERYTHING COMPLETED.
IF NOT STAY IN TOUCH WITH THE CODE ENFORCEMENT DEPARTMENT SO YOU DON'T END UP BEING FINED FOR SOMETHING YOU ARE TRYING TO TAKE
CARE OF, OKAY? >> YES, APPRECIATE THAT.
I HAVE ORDERED MY SHED. THEY GAVE ME AN ESTIMATE.
I'LL CONTINUE THIS ANOTHER MONTH.
>> NEXT CASE 21-2474, 200 BLOCK SOUTH SECOND STREET.
REYNALDO MALAVE. >> WHEN YOU ARE READY.
>> REFERENCE CASE 21-2474. 200 BLOCK SOUTH SECOND STREET.
REYNALDO MALAVE. SEPTEMBER 21, 2021.
CITATION. >> CAN YOU REPEAT CASE NUMBER?
>> 21-2474. >> DATE THE CASE INITIATED?
>> SEPTEMBER 21ST, 2021. >> THANK YOU.
>> DID YOU GIVE US A VIOLATIONS. >> 3435P OVERTIME PARKING.
>> DID YOU TAKE PHOTOGRAPHS? >> I DID.
>> APPROXIMATELY WHAT TIMES? >> 9:30 HOURS.
FOLLOW UP 12:40 HOURS, BOTH ON SEPTEMBER 21ST.
>> $50 FEE ASSOCIATED? YOO YES.
>> ALSO $10 ADMIN FEE AND $18 LATE FEE TOTAL OF $78?
>> YES. >> DO THE PHOTOGRAPHS FAIRLY AND
ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION? >> THEY DO.
>> ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?
REYNALDO MALAVE HERE? I DON'T SEE HE IS PRESENT.
THERE IS NOT A REPRESENTATIVE ON HIS BEHALF.
HOWEVER BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS AND HE IS A RESPONSIBLE PARTY.
FINE HIM $50, ADMIN FEE $10, LATE FEE $18, TOTAL $78.
HE HAS 30 DAYS TO PAY. FAILURE TRANSFERRED TO COUNTY COURT HE WILL INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS.
30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> NEXT CASE 21-1355, NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE AND AVENUE B. CHRISTOPHER D. REAGLE.
>> GOOD MORNING, YOUR HONOR. >> MORNING.
>> MY NAME IS MICHAEL RABENECKER.
VIOLATOR CHRISTOPHER D. REAGLE. CITATION 5770.
[01:10:05]
CODE 3435S PARKING CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.FINE OF $50, ADMINISTRATION FEE $10, LATE FEE OF $18, TOTAL OF $78. I HAVE PHOTOS HERE TO INTRODUCE.
>> WHERE WAS THIS VIOLATION LOCATION?
>> LOCATION WAS NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE AVENUE B.
GRASSY KIND OF AREA. >> DO THE PHOTOGRAPHS FAIR LIP AND ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION?
>> YES, MA'AM. >> COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1, THE
PHOTOGRAPHS. >> ADMITTED AS SUCH.
>> IS THERE CHRISTOPHER REAGLE OR A REPRESENTATIVE NO ONE HERE ON HIS BEHALF. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY, VIOLATION EXISTS AND RESPONSIBLE FOR.
I'LL FINE HIM $50 FOR THE VIOLATION, $10 ADMIN FEE.
$18 LATE FEEL, TOTAL OF $78. 30 DAYS TO PAY, FAILURE TO DO SO COUNTY CLERK FOR ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS.
>> AND 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU. >> NEXT CASE 21-1343 JAYCEE PARK. QUIANA T. DUKES YOUNG.
>> CASE NO. 21-1343. PARKING AT JAYCEE PARK.
VIOLATOR, QUIANA T. DUKES YOUNG. CITY ASKING FOR $50 FINE, $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE, LATE FEE $18 TOTAL DUE OF $78.
I HAVE PHOTOS HERE TO INTRODUCE. >> DO THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION AS YOU OBSERVED IT?
>> YES, MA'AM. >> COMPOSITE EXHIBIT.
>> ADMITTED AS SUCH. ANYTHING FURTHER?
I DON'T SEE MISS YOUNG, I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS.
SHE IS RESPONSIBLE. FINE HER $50 ADMIN $10 LATE FEE $18, $78, 30 DAYS TO PAY. FAILURE TO DO SO MAY BE TRANSFERRED TO COUNTY COURT WHERE SHE COULD INCUR ADDITIONAL
COSTS, 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> NEXT CASE, 21-2296 SOUTH
CAUSEWAY PARK, MICHAEL T. YORK. >> ANOTHER CASE INITIATED BY ME.
21-2296 VIOLATION PARKING SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK.
INITIATED SEPTEMBER 5TH, 2021. VIOLATOR MICHAEL T. YORK.
VIOLATION CITATION 10592. PARKING IN CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.
PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE. CITY IS ASKING FOR $50 FINE, $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE, ALSO LATE FEE OF $18, TOTAL DUE $78.
>> DO THE PHOTOGRAPHS FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VVYGVIE -
>> ADMITTED. >> THEY ARE PARKED OUTSIDE THE YELLOW LINES. I DON'T SEE MICHAEL T. YORK IS PRESENT OR A REPRESENTATIVE. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS, I WILL FINE HIM $50, $10 ADMIN FEE, $18 LATE FEE, TOTAL OF $78.
HE HAS 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. COULD RESULT IN A CASE BEING SENT TO COUNTY COURT. HE COULD INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES
[01:15:02]
AND COSTS. >> THANK YOU, MA'AM.
>> 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> NEXT CASE 21-2879, 1140
AVENUE, CEPHUS CRUICKSHAK. >> INITIATED OCTOBER 26TH, 2021.
OWNER OF 1208 NOBLES TERRACE. VIOLATIONS ARE IPMC SIDEWALKS AND DRIVEWAYS. CITY REQUESTS SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS VIOLATIONS EXISTS, GIVEN 10 SOMEDAYS TO COMPLY.
>> DID YOU GIVE US THE CORRECTIVE ACTIONS NEEDED?
>> SAY THAT AGAIN? >> DID YOU GIVE US THE
CORRECTIVE ACTIONS. >> CAN YOU GIVE THOSE, PLEASE.
>> REPAIR POTHOLES LOCATED ON THE PARKING LOT OF THE BUILDING.
PERMIT MIGHT BE REQUIRED. SECOND TO REPAIR ALL BROKEN WINDOWS THROUGHOUT THE BUILDING AS WELL.
>> PHOTOGRAPHS FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEBIT THE VIOLATIONS?
>> ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> ANYBODY LIVING IN THESE
>> HE IS NOT PRESENT NEITHER IS A REPRESENTATIVE.
I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS, RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION.
I WILL GIVE HIM 10 DAYS TO COMPLY.
OR FINE OF $200 PER DAY ASSESSED.
>> THANK YOU, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.
>> YES. >> SORRY, 30 DAYS TO APPEAL AND 30 DAYS TO PAY OR FORWARDED TO COUNTY CLERK?
SORRY. >> I AM TROUBLED BY THESE
>> UH HUH. >> NEXT CASE 21-1160.
606, OHIO AVENUE. PETRA BIROO.
>> CASE NO. 21-1160. 606 OHIO AVENUE.
INITIATED BY MYSELF, 30TH, 2021 MAY.
SUBSECTION C 1, 2. HEIGHT RESTRICTIONS.
CORRECTIVE ACTIONS PLEASE REMOVE ALL WOODEN FENCE LOCATED IN FRONT YARD. FENCE LOCATED IN FRONT OF THE PROPERTY SHOULD NOT EXCEED FOUR FEET IN HEIGHT.
CITY REQUESTS SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS VIOLATION EXIST, VIOLATOR GIVEN 10 DAYS TO COMPLY. OR A FINE OF $150 A DAY ASSESSED. THIS PARTICULAR CASE, THEY ACTUALLY APPLIED FOR A PERMIT SOME TIME AGO.
BY THE PLANS THEY SUBMITTED DON'T MATCH WHATEVER THEY HAVE GOING ON RIGHT NOW. I DO HAVE PHOTOS IF YOU WANT TO TAKE A LOOK AT THOSE. JUST WANT TO THROW THAT OUT
[01:20:05]
THERE. >> PHOTOGRAPHS FAIRLY AND
ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION? >> THEY DO.
>> CITIES COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1, PHOTOGRAPHS.
>> THANK YOU, ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> I DON'T KNOW IF SHE WANTS TO TAKE A LOOK AT THE PLAN. ORIGINAL PLAN REVIEWS SUBMITTED.
>> CITIES EXHIBIT 2. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE PLANS SUBMITTED, YOU'LL SEE THE PLANS INDICATE A FOUR-FOOT FENCE IN THE FRONT. THEY INSTALLED SIX FOOT PANELS.
>> YES. DID THEY EXPLAIN WHY THEY
INSTALLED SIX-FOOT PANELS? >> NOT REALLY.
I WAS HOPING THEY WOULD SHOW UP. NO ONE HERE.
I AM NOT SURE THE REASON BEHIND IT.
>> ALL RIGHT. BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED, FIND VIOLATION EXISTS, 606 OHIO AVENUE. AND PETRA BIROO IS IN VIOLATION.
ABOUT HOW OLD IS THIS PERSON, DO YOU KNOW?
>> JUST GUESSING, PROBABLY LATE 40S, EARLY 50S.
>> OKAY. >> I KNOW SHE DOES HAVE A SON THAT IS PROBABLY LATE 20S. SO.
ASSUMING, NOT SURE. I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS AND SHE IS RESPONSIBLE. I'LL GIVE HER -- SHE HAD A PERMIT, RIGHT? I'LL GIVE HER 10 DAYS TO COMPLY WITH THE PERMIT. COMPLY WITH ALL PERMIT CONDITIONS OR FINE $150 PER DAY ASSESSED AGAINST HER.
30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU.
>> FOR THE RECORD, NEITHER SHE OR A REPRESENTATIVE PRESENT
AFTER BEING NOTICED. >> NEXT CASE 20-2761.
1607 NORTH 13TH STREET. ALTON BOSHER JR.
>> GOOD MORNING. WHEN YOU ARE READY.
>> GOOD MORNING CASE NO. 20-2761.
ADDRESS, 1607, NORTH 13TH STREET, MR. ALTON BOSHER JRP.
CASE INITIATED DECEMBER 23RD, 2020.
WENT FOR A HEARING, JULY 21ST, 2021.
EXCUSE ME, CONTINUED FOR 30 DAYS, SEPARATE HEARING AUGUST 18TH, 2021. CONTINUED FOR SIX MONTHS.
IPMC 304.1 EXTERIOR STRUCTURE GENERAL.
OBTAIN A PERMIT FROM THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT AND REPAIR THE OVERHANG OF THE FRONT DOOR. GIVEN 30 DAYS TO OBTAIN A PERMIT AND COMPLY OR FINE OF $50 PER DAY TO ASSESS.
PHOTOS TO SUBMIT. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?
>> NOT AT THIS TIME NO, MA'AM. >> ALL RIGHT.
I DON'T SEE HE IS HERE OR A REPRESENTATIVE.
BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED.
VIOLATION EXISTS, 1607 NORTH 13TH STREET.
HE IS THE PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION.
I WILL GIVE HIM 30 DAYS TO OBTAIN A PERMIT AND ALL CONDITIONS OR FINE OF $50 A DAY ASSESSED AGAINST HIM.
HE HAS 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> HOW WAS HE NOTIFIED?
[01:25:07]
>> CASES STATUTE [INAUDIBLE] SENT TO THE VIOLATOR CERTIFIED MAIL. GREEN CARD RETURNED SIGN PLACED IN THE FILE, UNSIGNED OR UNCLAIMED AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING SENT TO THE VIOLATOR REGULAR U.S. MAIL.
10 DAY PRIORS POSTED ON THE BULLETIN BOARD AND AT THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION WITH AFFIDAVIT POSTING.
IF THE GREEN CARD IS NOT RETURNED TO THE DEPARTMENT 10 DAYS BEFORE THE HEARING. POSTING COMPLETED IN THE SAME MANNER AS IF THE CARD WAS RETURNED UNCLAIMED.
GREEN CARD NOT RETURNED WITHIN 10 DAYS OF THE HEARING, HEARING POSTED ON THE BULLETIN BOARD IN CITY HALL.
>> THANK YOU, ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO, MA'AM.
* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.