Mar 15, 2023 Special Magistrate Hearing

[1. CALL TO ORDER]

[00:00:08]

>> GOOD MORNING, I AM AT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE PRESIDING OVER THE HEARINGS THIS MORNING.

YOU ARE HERE BECAUSE YOU GOT A PARKING CITATION AND WANT TO CONTEST, OR YOU HAVE BEEN NOTIFIED THAT YOUR PROPERTY IS POSSIBLY IN VIOLATION OF A PARTICULAR CITY CODE OF ORDINANCE PREVIEW GIVEN A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF TIME TO CORRECT THAT.

YOU HAVE NOT AND WANT TO BE HEARD YOUR CASE WILL BE CALLED SHORTLY.

WE ARE BEING RECORDED, IT IS LIVE. FORT PIERCE TV STATION.

BE MINDFUL OF THAT WHEN YOU COME IN. DOES ANYBODY NEED AN INTERPRETER? OR, IF YOU DON'T MIND, PLEASE STAND FOR THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND

JUSTICE FOR ALL. PLEASE STAY STANDING. >> PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT

[A. ADMINISTRATION OF OATH TO DEPARTMENTAL WITNESSES]

[B. IDENTIFICATION OF CASES IN COMPLIANCE OR RESCHEDULED]

GIVE, WILL BE THE TRUTH? >> YES. >> THANK YOU.

>> ALL RIGHT. WHEN YOU ARE READY, METAL CLICK HERE BECAUSE WE START WITH CASES IN COMPLIANCE OR RESCHEDULED. CASE 22-3329PK 100 BLOCK NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE. 22-3327PK , 100 BLOCK PREMIER LEADERSHIP SOLUTIONS.

22-3342PK100 BLK NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVEROBERT JOSEPH SCHNEIDERMICHAEL 22-3436PK100 BLK NORTH DEPOT DRIVEEMMANUEL SAINT PIERRE VERLINE LOUIS 22-3419PK100 BLK NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVEJABARI DANIEL SCHWEITZER 22-3423PK700 BLK BOSTON AVENUEERNANDO JOSE BENITEZ BAUTISTA 22-3427PK1000 BLK ANTILLES AVEEONEL VARGAS-HERNANDEZ3-64PK100 BLK NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE JASON MENDEZ-MARRERO 22-2140 PKOUTH CAUSEWAY PARKSHASTRIE SIEW, 22-3354 CE14 N 18TH COURTTRUMAN PERDUE 22-3412 CE651 OKEECHOBEE ROADAANJALI LLC 22-3454 ST 912 MIMOSA AVENUEARLEY LIMA ANA TOMAZ 22-2160PKSOUTH CAUSEWAY PARKOLIVIA ANN NEWSOME-HALL 22-2179 PKAYCEE PARKICHAEL JERMAINE GAITER 22-3455ST1916 MIMOSA AVENUE MVS MANAGEMENT AND INVESTMENTS LLC 22-3384PK100 BLK MELODY LANENA LUZ SANCHEZ 22-3393 CE716 S US HIGHWAY 1 & J SUNWEALTH DQ PROPERTY LLC 22-3191 CE17 HIALEAH AVENUE SALVADOR RUIZ 22-3400100 BLK NORTH DEPOT DRIVEVERONICA

[A. 23-276 2902 Avenue D Boys & Girls Club of St Lucie County Peggy Arraiz]

OUR FIRST TASTE TO BE 23 Ã 276-2902 AVENUE D BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB.

>> GOOD MORNING. >> GOOD MORNING. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THIS IS A FALSE ALARM APPEAL. IT HAS BEEN A MINUTE SINCE PWE'VE HAD ONE BEFORE US.

SO, MS. JENNIFER WILL BE PRESENTING THE BASIC FACTS OF THE CASE, AND THEN, A REPRESENTATIVE OF THE BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB WILL EXPLAIN THE REASON, JUSTIFICATION OF

FURTHER REPEAL REQUEST. >> WHEN YOU ARE READY. PRACTICES OPERATED BY THE BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB OF ST. LUCIE COUNTY. THERE WERE A TOTAL OF FIVE FALSE ALARMS THE FIRST ONE HAS NO CHARGE. THE SECOND OCCURRED ON SEPTEMBER 8, 2021 WITH $100 FINE. THE THIRD OCCURRED SEPTEMBER 13, 2021, WITH A $200 FINE. THE FOURTH OCCURRED SEPTEMBER 18, 2021 WITH A $400 FINE.

THE FIFTH OCCURRED SEPTEMBER 23, 2021 WITH A $500 FINE. A TOTAL OF $1200.

I ALSO HAVE FOR YOU, THE APPEAL REQUEST FOR YOU TO REVIEW. >> OKAY.

>> THANK YOU. IF THERE IS NO OBJECTION, LIKE TO ENTER THIS AS PART OF THE

RECORD. FROM THE BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB. >> YES.

>> THANK YOU. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I GUESS WE CAN MAKE THIS AN APPELLATE?

[00:05:02]

>> WE WILL. >> THANK YOU MA'AM. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?

AS A REPETITIVE OF THE BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB, GOOD MORNING. >> HI.

>> STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD PLEASE. >> KAYLA TURNER.

>> SAID IT AGAIN? >> KAYLA TURNER.> HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO THE ALLEGATIONS?

>> YES, IN THIS PARTICULAR TIME FROM OUR JIM DID NOT HAVE ANY AIR CONDITIONING, AND WE HAD TO CHANGE SOME MEASURES WITH ENTERING AND EXITING THE BUILDING.

WE ALSO HAD SOME STAFF CHANGES, WE HAD TO CHANGE ALARM CODING. IN THIS TIME, WITH THE WEATHER CONDITIONS OF OUR JIM, AS WELL AS OUTSIDE, IT WAS TRIGGERING OUR ALARM SYSTEM.

SINCE THEN, WE'VE ALREADY WORKED OUT WITH THE CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVES, AND MADE CERTAIN CHANGES. TO THE DOORS, AS WELL AS OUR ALARM SYSTEM.

THESE HAVE BEEN THE ONLY FOUR TRIPS THAT WE'VE HAD. WE HAVE NOT HAD ANY SINCE THEN.

>> OKAY. >> IF I MAY ADD ALSO, WE ALSO REVIEWED WHEN SOME OF THESE OCCURRED, WE HAD REVIEWED OUR CAMERA FOOTAGE, TO ENSURE THAT NOBODY WAS YANKING ON THE DOOR OR ANYTHING OF THAT NATURE. THERE WAS NO ONE ON CAMERA. MOST IF I'M NOT MISTAKEN, ALL

OF THEM, WERE TRULY TRIGGERED FROM THE WEATHER AS WELL. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?

>> NO MA'AM. OTHER THAN THAT, WE JUST APPRECIATE THE CITY ALLOWING US

TO USE THE BUILDING. >> THANK YOU. HAVE Y'ALL TRIED TO NEGOTIATE

THIS? IN TERMS OF MITIGATION? >> NO MA'AM.

OUR ONLY MEDICATION, THIS LETTER OF YOU, WAS WRITTEN BY MYSELF, PRESENTED TO OUR ADMINISTRATION. AND THEY COMMITTED IT VIA EMAIL ON MY BEHALF. TO MY KNOWLEDGE, THAT IS THE ONLY COMMUNICATION WE HAVE HAD.

OTHER THAN MY DIRECT COMMUNICATION WITH FACILITIES, TO THIS MATTER.

>> ARE YOU USING THE GYMNASIUM NOW? >> YES MA'AM.

SO, FOR THE PAST SEVERAL YEARS, THE CITY OF FORT PIERCE HAS THE BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB OF ST.

LUCIE COUNTY, TO UTILIZE THIS GYM AS A TEEN CENTER. RESERVE AGES 13 TO 18 DAILY.

WE CURRENTLY STILL HAVE THAT LEASE WITH THE CITY OF FORT PIERCE AS WELL.

WE OCCUPY IT MONDAY THROUGH FRIDAY. AS OPERATIONAL HOURS.

>> OKAY. ARE YOU IN A POSITION TO NEGOTIATE A SETTLEMENT OF THE

AMOUNT DUE? >> I DO, HAVE THE SUPPORT OF MY SUPERVISOR, EVERY DIRECTOR,

TANISHA JONES AND OUR CFO, PATTERSON. >> DID YOU ALL DISCUSS AN

AMOUNT THAT YOU LIKE TO PAY TO RESOLVE THE MATTER? >> NOT SPECIFICALLY.

BUT HONESTLY, WE APPRECIATE ANY REDUCTION TO THIS APPEAL. THAT YOU WOULD OFFER.

>> WHO IS IN CHARGE OF THE FIRE ALARM SYSTEM NOW? ALL THE STAFF, EVERYBODY KNOWS

THE CODE AND HOW TO DISARM IT AND ALL THE STUFF? >> AS A DIRECTOR, FULL-TIME EMPLOYEES, STAFF ARE AWARE PROCEDURES BUT THERE'S ALWAYS MYSELF OR ANOTHER FULL-TIME PERSON PRESENT, TO DISARM THE ALARM WHEN IT IS TRIPPED. MY SUPERVISORS CALLED AND OR MY CFO AND MYSELF ARE LOADED WHEN THE ALARM IS RINGING. .

[00:10:11]

>> THE BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB DO A LOT FOR THE COMMUNITY. >> YES MA'AM.

THIS LOCATION IS THE ONLY STANDALONE TEEN CENTER. NOT JUST IN FORT PIERCE BUT IN THE COUNTY. WE DEFINITELY SERVE A LOT OF YOUTH.

THIS PARTNERSHIP, WE HAVE GREAT STANDING RELATIONSHIPS WITH OUR COMMISSIONERS AS WELL.

THEY COME BY AND DO THINGS FOR US. IT IS DEFINITELY, THE BUILDING

IS UTILIZED TO ITS FULLEST CAPACITY. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, STAFF HAS GIVEN SOME LEEWAY TO NEGOTIATE OUTSIDE OF THIS COURTROOM, WHEN THERE IS CERTAIN JUSTIFIABLE REASONS. REASONS THAT WERE PRESENTED WERE NOT WITHIN OUR REALM TO ADDRESS, WHICH IS WHY IT IS IN FRONT OF YOU. I BELIEVE WE ARE JUST A BOYS

AND GIRLS CLUB ONCE UPON A TIME. >> YEARS AGO.

>> CORRECT. SO, IF I RECALL CORRECTLY, WHAT WAS DONE AT THAT TIME EXCHANGE OF COMMUNITY SERVICE. -- AGAIN, JUST BECAUSE IT IS OUTSIDE WHAT WE HAVE THE ABILITY TO DO, IS IN FRONT OF YOU FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION AND RECOMMENDATION.

>> WE ALSO PARTNER WITH THE CITY FOR SEVERAL EVENTS, HAVE ONE COMING UP AS A TEAM YOUTH EMPOWERMENT EVENT.EVERAL MEMBERS SIT ON THE FORT PIERCE CITY YOUTH COUNCIL.

IN THEIR HOSTING AN EVENT AT THE GYM SO, IN LINE WITH WHAT YOU JUST SAID, COMMUNITY SERVICE IS DEFINITELY SOMETHING THAT WE PARTICIPATE AND PARTNER WITH THE CITY OF FORT PIERCE WITH. IT IS A GRADUATION REQUIREMENT FOR OUR TEAMS AS WELL.

>> COMMUNITY SERVICE, THIS IS A TOUGH ONE FOR ME. ONLY BECAUSE I KNOW WHAT A GOOD JOB YOU ALL DO. I WANT TO -- DON'T WANT TO PUT A STUMBLING BLOCK IN YOUR WAY.

>> I'M NOT SURE WHAT HOURLY RATE YOU LIKE TO PUT PER HOUR. WHETHER, HOW MUCH WAS THE? WELL HUNDRED DOLLARS? SO, IF IT WAS -- HIM JUMPING BETWEEN 25 AND $50 PER

COMMUNITY SERVICE HOUR. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, CAN I? >> PLEASE HELP ME OUT HERE,

THIS IS A TOUGH ONE. >> I MIGHT HAVE A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT OPINION THAN EVERYBODY ELSE IN THE ROOM AT THIS TIME. I CERTAINLY ACKNOWLEDGE THE FACT THAT THERE IS AN EXISTING LEASE AGREEMENT WITH THE BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB, AND THERE CERTAINLY PARTNERS WITH THE CITY. I WOULD FEEL MORE COMFORTABLE, IF WE WERE OPERATING WITHIN THE GUIDELINES OF A MONETARY REDUCTION, WHICH IS SOMETHING THAT IS MORE CONSISTENT WITH TYPICALLY DONE IN OTHER CASES, I RECOGNIZE THIS IS A DIFFERENT TYPE OF CASE, AND ALARM APPEAL WHICH IS SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT WITH SOME OF THE OTHER THINGS PTHAT COME BEFORE YOUR HONOR. AND I KNOW ALSO, THAT THESE ARE LESS FREQUENT CASES THAT COME BEFORE YOU. I WILL ACKNOWLEDGE THAT, BUT I WOULD FEEL MORE ACCOUNTABLE IF WE WERE OPERATING WITHIN THE NORMAL REALM OF A POTENTIAL MONETARY REDUCTION.

WHICH IS 100 PERCENT WITHIN THE SCOPE OF YOUR AUTHORITY. >> ALL RIGHT.

I WILL -- WITH MUCH RELUCTANCE, I WILL REDUCE THE FINE TO $200. >> THANK YOU.

>> HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY THAT? >> I CAN PAY THAT WITHIN THE

NEXT TWO WEEKS. >> OKAY I WILL FIND THERE IS A VIOLATION OF THE BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB, WE REDUCE THE RELATION TO $200. I WILL GIVE YOU, LET'S SAY 30

[00:15:09]

DAYS TO MAKE THE PAYMENT. >> THANK YOU. >> WE DON'T PAY THAT PERIOD OF TIME, IT COULD POSSIBLY GO BACK UP TO THE $1200. MAKE SURE YOU PAY THAT.

>> YES MA'AM, THANK YOU. >> GOOD LUCK. >> MUCH APPRECIATED.

>> FOR THE RECORD, YOU WILL RECEIVE AN ORDER IN THE MAIL AND PAYMENT HAS TO GO TO CRY

WOLF. >> CRIED WOLF. >> IT IS THE ALARM COMPANY.

WE WILL NOTIFY THEM AND THEY WILL ACCEPT PAYMENT. OKAY?

>> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU, GOOD LUCK. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK.

NEXT CASE. >> NEXT CASE IS 23 ÃTHREE -- STACY MARIE GARCIA AND LINO

[G. 23-0383 PK 100 Blk of Marina Way Stacey Marie Garcia, Lino Garcia Charmaine Kirkland]

GARCIA. >> GOOD MORNING. >> GOOD MORNING.

>> WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> GOOD MORNING, CASE NUMBER 23 Ã0383 INITIATED FEBRUARY 3.

IT IS A CITATION PARKING ING CITATION APPEAL. THAT WAS ON THE 100 BLOCK OF GREENAWAY RILEY TO STACY MARIE GARCIA AND LINO GARCIA.

CITATION NUMBER 18798, CODE SECTION 34 Ã31 PARKING IN THE WRONG DIRECTION.

FINE OF $50, DEMONSTRATED FEE OF 10 ELSE, LATE FEE $18 TOTAL DUE $78.

THIS A REQUEST OF THE SPECIAL MUST REFUND THE RELATION EXISTS THEN IT WILL BE TOTAL DUE INDICATED ABOVE. TO PAY FOR SUCH FINE -- FAILURE TO PAY THE FILE WILL GO TO THE

COURT SYSTEM. >> ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO MA'AM.

>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, CAN I INQUIRE IF PHOTOGRAPHS WERE TAKEN?

>> YES. >> DID YOU TAKE THE PHOTOGRAPHS, CODE OFFICER KIRKLAND? OKAY TODAY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW? OKAY, THANK YOU MA'AM. AT THIS TIME I LIKE TO GIVE THE RESPONDENT AN OPPORTUNITY TO SEE THEM IF SHE HASN'T ALREADY. AT THE TIME REMOVE THE PHOTOS IN US THE CITIES ONE COMPOSITE.

>> WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> THANK YOU. ANYTHING FURTHER?

>> WE USUALLY -- >> SO, BEFORE I -- MAGISTRATE, AND BE HANDED A COPY OF THE PARKING CITATION APPEAL. THE FIRE JUST THAT, I JUST WANT TO ASK OUR CODE OFFICER KIRKLAND, IF THERE'S ANYTHING YOU WANTED TO SAY ABOUT THE PHOTOGRAPHS, OR ANYTHING ELSE

THAT YOU WANTED TO ADD BEFORE I MOVE ONTO THE NEXT THING? >> NO MA'AM.

>> OKAY. THANK YOU MA'AM. IN THAT CASE, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE I HAVE BEEN HANDED A COPY OF THE PARKING CITATION APPEAL AND I WOULD LIKE TO GO AHEAD AND MOVE THAT IN ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT. UPON EXHIBIT 1.

>> WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO MA'AM.

>> ALL RIGHT, STATE YOUR NAME PLEASE COME OFF THE RECORD. >> STACY GARCIA.

>> HOW DO YOU RESPOND? >> WELL, I AVERAGELY SEE BY THE PHOTOS I AM GUILTY.

I WOULD LIKE TO MENTION THAT I HAVE LIVED HERE FOR 30 YEARS, AND HONESTLY, NEVER KNEW THAT I COULDN'T PARK THAT WAY. ONE BEING, THERE'S NO SIGNS THERE.

I GUESS IT'S COMMON SENSE IS WHAT MY HUSBAND TELLS ME I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN.

BUT WHEN I ARRIVED AT COBB'S LANDING THAT MORNING, I WAS ONE OF THE FIRST VEHICLES THERE.

THERE WAS MYSELF THAT IT PULLED UP AND THEN, IN THE FEDERAL COMIC IS THAT THERE IS A

[00:20:04]

WE ARRIVED BASICALLY WHEN COBB'S LANDING HAD FIRST OPENED AT 11:00 A.M.

. WHEN I CAME OUT AROUND 12:30 PM AND REALIZED I HAD A CITATION, I'VE NEVER RECEIVED A PARKING VIOLATION EVER. SO, I DIDN'T REALLY KNOW WHAT IT WAS FOR.

AND WHEN I SAW WHAT IT WAS FOR, IT WAS HONESTLY, I HAD NO CLUE THAT I WAS ABLE TO PARK THAT WAY. AND LIKE I SAID, WHEN I PULLED UP THE GREYHOUND WAS PARKED IN THE SAME DIRECTION AND THERE WAS NO OTHER VEHICLES THERE. ON THAT SIDE OF THE STREET AT LEAST. I DIDN'T REALIZE I WAS IN THE WRONG.

>> ALL RIGHT, ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO. >> ALL RIGHT, BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED, FIND THAT THERE IS A VIOLATION.

STACY MARIE GARCIA. PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION.

I WILL IMPOSE A $50 FINE, $10 ADMIN FEE, $18 LATE FEE, TOTAL DUE OF $78.

HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY? >> REGISTRY BEFORE WE CONTINUE, THE $18 LATE FEE IS, SHOULD BE THERE BECAUSE SHE DID SUBMIT HER APPEAL PAPERWORK.

>> THANK YOU. >> I APOLOGIZE, WE MISSED THAT DURING VIEW.

>> SO BASICALLY, I WILL DELETE THE $18 LATE FEE. YOU'LL JUST HAVE A TOTAL FEE OF $60. HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY THAT?

I WILL GIVE YOU 14 DAYS TO PAY. >> OKAY. >> ALL RIGHT.

FAILURE TO PAY IT IN THAT PERIOD OF TIME COULD RESULT IN THE TICKET BEING FORWARDED TO THE CLERKS OFFICE, WHICH YOU WILL INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS.

ALL RIGHT, THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU. >> NEXT CASE WILL BE 23 Ã256

[B. 23-0256 PK 800 Blk Delaware Ave Jeffrey Scott Montpetit Michael Rabenecker]

800 BLOCK DELAWARE AVENUE. JEFFREY SCOTT -- >> GOOD MORNING.

>> GOOD MORNING YOUR HONOR. >> WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> HONOR MY NAME IS MICHAEL RABENECKER, CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER. BEFORE YOU HAVE CASE NUMBER 23 Ã256, PARK DEVELOPMENT TOOK PLACE THE 800 BLOCK OF DELAWARE AVENUE.

THE CASE WAS INITIATED JANUARY 25, 2023. THIS IS A CITATION APPEAL.

THE VIOLET IN THE CASE CAME BACK AS A JEFFREY SCOTT MONTPETIT.

THE CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 18981, A PARKING VIOLATION OF CITY CODE ORDINANCE 34 Ã30 1E.

PARKING PROHIBITED AT ALL TIMES.THE CITY IS ASKING A $50 FINE BE ASSESSED, INITIATION FEE OF $10, TOTAL DUE OF $60. I PHOTOS ARE DATE AND TIME STAMPED. INTRODUCE AS EVIDENCE, QUICK SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, CAN I LAY A FOUNDATION QUICKLY? CODE OFFICER, DID YOU TAKE THE PHOTOS?

>> YES MA'AM. >> TODAY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW?

>> YES MA'AM. >> THIS TIME I LIKE TO GIVE THE RESPONDENT AN OPPORTUNITY TO LOOK AT THEM. OR THE APPELLANT. APOLOGIZE USING THE TERMS

INTERCHANGEABLY. >> JEANNIE ME TO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THIS IS US? MY NAME IS JEFF MONTPETIT. I LIVE AT 804 DELAWARE AVENUE. I WILL ACKNOWLEDGE THAT THIS IS

[00:25:08]

>> RE HERE WHEN WE SWEAR EVERYONE IN? >> EXCUSE ME?

>> I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT YOU ARE SWORN IN. >> YES MA'AM.

>> JUST DOUBLE CHECKING. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. >> THERE WERE FOUR OR FIVE.

I THINK I FOUR CASES TODAY FOR MY FAMILY. >> I SEE FOR ON HERE.

>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, JUST TO CLARIFY, I WANT TO ASSURE THAT WE ARE TAKING THINGS IN ORDER.

JUST TO CLARIFY, THE PHOTOS THATFOUNDATION FOR, WITH A ONE CASER ALL

CASES? >> THIS IS THE FIRST CASE. THERE ARE SEVERAL CASES.

>> SO AS FAR AS THIS CASE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I WOULD MOVE THE PHOTOS IN AS A CITIES

COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1. AND I WILL HAND THOSE TO YOU NOW. >> IT WOULD BE ADMITTED AS

SUCH. >> AND THEN, I'VE ALSO BEEN HANDED THE PARKING CITATION APPEAL. ASKING THAT THE APPEAL PAPERWORK BE ADMITTED AS

APPELLANT EXHIBIT 1. THIS IS A COPY OF THE APPEAL, >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.

>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE I WANT TO INQUIRE OF CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER RABENECKER, IF THERE'S

ANYTHING MORE TO SAY ABOUT THE PHOTOGRAPHS? >> NO MA'AM.

>> SARAH, HOW DO YOU RESPOND? >> I WOULD LIKE, I BROUGHT MY MOTHER-IN-LAW, MY NEIGHBOR.

I LIVE AT 804, THIS IS JOYCE RANDALL LIVING AT 802. THERE HAS BEEN A HISTORY OF PARKING ISSUES ALONG DELAWARE AVENUE. WE BELIEVE THERE QUITE SOME TIME. THERE WAS A RENOVATION DONE MANY YEARS AGO, AND --

>> ONE AT A TIME, PLEASE. >> THERE IS A RENOVATION DONE ON THE STREET MANY YEARS AGO AND I WAS LIVING THERE WITH MY FAMILY. MY KIDS DIDN'T HAVE CARS BACK THEN BUT ANTICIPATED EXACTLY WHAT IS HAPPENING NOW, THAT WAS GOING TO HAPPEN.

I HAD ASKED THE CITY IF THEY COULD GIVE US AN ADDITIONAL CURB CUT WHEN THEY WERE GOING THROUGH ALL OF THIS. SO THAT I COULD ACTUALLY HAVE A CIRCULAR DRIVEWAY AND MY ORDER TO ALLOW ME TO ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE HOUSE, WHICH IS THE EAST SIDE, MY HOUSE DOES NOT BUMP OUT, THERE WAS ENOUGH ROOM FOR A COUPLE OF CARS TO POUR A DRIVEWAY.

UNFORTUNATELY, THEY JUST SAID THEY COULDN'T. MOVING FORWARD, WE FOUND OUT THAT I WON'T MENTION THE NAME BECAUSE THEY DO NOT KNOW BUT MY MOTHER-IN-LAW, HAD SPOKEN WITH SOMEBODY AT THE CITY ABOUT THE STRIPING THAT IS ALL UP AND DOWN DELAWARE AVENUE.

IN FRONT OF MY HOME WE HAVE TWO PARKING SPOTS. ONE DOWN THE STREET AND ONE SPOT IN FRONT OF MY HOUSE. I AM FORTUNATE THAT I HAVE ALL THREE OF MY ADULT CHILDREN STILL LIVING AT HOME. I THINK. SO MY POINT IS THAT, MASS IS OWNED C1. IS A C1 IN HIS OWN HOME. IF YOU JUST GO ONE BLOCK UP, YOU CAN SEE THAT THERE ARE MULTIPLE PARKING SPOTS THAT ARE END-TO-END, AND THERE IS NOT ALL OF THIS WHITE STRIPING ALL OVER THE PLACE. IT IS ALL ACROSS THE STREET, THAT IS WHY WE HAVE NO PARKING. I UNDERSTAND THEY DON'T WANT US PARKING ON THE LAWN ACROSS THE YARD. I CAN PARK ALL OF MY KIDS CARS AVAILABLE TO BE HERE IN FRONT OF YOU FOR PARKING IN MY YARD. BUT INSTEAD, I'M HERE FOR PARKING IN FRONT OF MY HOUSE.

THERE IS NOT ANY PARKING FOR MY FAMILY. I ONE PARKING SPOT IN MY FRONT YARD. ON THE SIDE. AND THAT IS IT! I HAD TO DO THIS BECAUSE I'M HOPING THAT ONCE AGAIN, WE'RE BACK HERE TO TRY AND GET SOMEBODY TO MAKE A CONCESSION WITH US. AND I UNDERSTAND YOU KNOW, THE GENTLEMAN IS TRYING TO DO HIS JOB. AND I CAN APPRECIATE THAT.

WHICH IS WHY AM NOT MAD AT HIM, JUST WANT TO GO TO THE PROCESS FOR RESOLUTION.

I MADE SOME CONCESSIONS, AND IT ENOUGH I SHOULD TALK ABOUT THE NEXT CASE, THE NEXT CASE OR THE OTHER CASE. BUT I HAD A 1972 DODGE RV PARKED OUT IN FRONT OF MY HOUSE. IT HAD AN UPDATED TAG, INSURANCE, IT RUNS AND DRIVES.

[00:30:03]

THEN SHE HAS NO PROBLEM WITH ME HAVING MY RV OUT THERE. HOWEVER, I WENT TO MAKE CONCESSIONS AND FIGURED I HAVE TO TRY TO BE ACTIVE HERE. I MADE SOME CONCESSIONS AND FOUND A BETTER PLACE FOR MY RV BECAUSE I'M DOING A RESTORATION ON THAT WITH MY DAUGHTER.

AND WE WILL JUST WORK ON ON THE WEEKENDS AND IS NOT IN FRONT OF MY HOME ANYMORE.

I MET HER JUST TO COMPLAIN AND SAY THAT THE MONEY, LISTEN, I WAS HIT -- IF YOU LIKE I WAS TARGETED TO BE TRUTHFUL. BECAUSE I GOT A TICKET, AND THEN, TWO DAYS LATER I GOT ANOTHER TICKET, AND IT WAS ALMOST LIKE WHEN I STARTED READING THEM AND SAYING OKAY, LET'S JUST HURRY UP AND HIT ALL OF THESE TICKETS SO WE CAN GO STRAIGHT TO COURT.

IT WAS EVEN A CONCESSION MADE WITH THE RV OR ANYTHING. IT WAS LIKE, LOOK AT THE TIMEFRAME ON THE TICKETS. ALL OF THE CASES COLLECTIVELY, TOGETHER AND I GUESS YOU SHOULD

BE THANKFUL I AM SO CALM. THAT'S ALL I HAVE TO SAY MA'AM. >> CAN I SAY THIS THING NOW?

>> YES PLEASE. >> STATE YOUR NAME. >> JOYCE RANDALL.

IN LOOKING AT THESE, AS OF THE DATE THAT THEY ARE TAKEN, JANUARY 22?

HELLO? >> YES MA'AM, SORRY ABOUT THAT. YES MA'AM THERE DATE AND TIME

STAMPED. >> MAY I ASK WHY YOU'RE OUT ON A SUNDAY GIVING TICKETS?> MA'AM, MY WORK HOURS ARE SATURDAY 8 TO 5 AND SUNDAY 8 TO 5.

>> AND SHA CONNIE CAME BACK AND GIVE A TICKET TO THE GUY ACROSS THE STREET.

THEN HE TRIED TO GIVE A TICKET TO SOMEBODY THAT WAS PARKED IN FRONT OF MY HOUSE AND NEXT DOOR

IN THE WRONG DIRECTION. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE I APOLOGIZE.

I'M GOING TO OBJECT THIS POINT AS ANCE. >> LET ME GO BACK TO THE

BEGINNING THEM. 28 YEARS AGO. >> HOLD ON NOW.

WE HAVE PROTOCOL IN HERE, OKAY? I'M GLAD YOU'RE NOT UPSET SIR BECAUSE IF YOU REALLY DO GET UPSET WE'VE GOT AN OFFICER HERE THAT WILL TAKE CARE OF THAT. SO, I'M GLAD YOU'RE ALL RIGHT.

OKAY HOLD ON MA'AM. DID YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE TO SAY?

>> DID YOU GO ON THE OBJECTION? >> YES. >> IS IT SUSTAINED?

>> SUSTAINED. >> OKAY. SEPARATELY, I THINK YOU TOUCHED ON THE ISSUE ALREADY MAGISTRATE. I WOULD ASK THAT THE COMMENTARY BE DIRECTED TO YOU, UNLESS THERE IS A SPECIFIC QUESTION THAT IS BEING POSED TO THE

WITNESS AS PART OF CROSS-EXAMINATION. >> I WILL DO THAT.

YOU UNDERSTAND THAT MA'AM, YOU DO NOT DIRECT COMMENTS TO HER, YOU DIRECT THEM TO ME.

OKAY? ALL RIGHT. ANYTHING FURTHER?

>> YES. >> OKAY LET'S TRY AND BE CALM AND CIVIL.

>> I THOUGHT I WAS CIVIL. I JUST ASKED WHEN HE WORKED. >> DO YOU HAVE ANOTHER

QUESTION? >> NO, NOT OF HIM. 28 YEARS AGO, I LIVED ACROSS THE STREET. I'VE BEEN ON THE STREET 21 NOW. ALMOST 30 YEARS.

WHEN THE START OF THE RENOVATION ON DELAWARE AVENUE, THEY TOLD US IT WAS TO HAVE ON THE STREET PARKING, TO GET ALL THE CARS BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T HAVE ANY BACK THEN.

AND TO GET ALL THESE CARS OUT OF PEOPLES YARDS. SO, BUT WHEN THEY DID THE STRIPING, BECAUSE THIS IS THE THIRD TIME WE'VE HAD PROBLEMS WITH GETTING TICKETS.

AND THE SECOND TIME, I DON'T KNOW WHO IT WAS, IT WAS SOME GENTLEMAN I GUESS AT CITY HALL TOLD US THEY MADE THAT MISTAKE IN THE STRIPING WHEN THEY DID IT.

BECAUSE EVERY BUSINESS, THIS IS COMING LOOK ON OUR STREET THERE, YOU KNOW, THERE'S RESIDENTIAL, THERE IS COMMERCIAL. AND WHAT THEY WERE TRYING TO DO WAS GIVE US PARKING SPOTS IN FRONT OF OUR HOMES THAT WE CAN USE.

BUT THEY DID IT WRONG BECAUSE THEY TREATED EVERY HOUSE AS COMMERCIAL.

EVERY COMMERCIAL FROM SEVENTH STREET ON DOWN, HAS PARKING LOTS.

SO, THEIR PLACES FOR THEIR CUSTOMERS AND WHATEVER TO PARK. OF COURSE, THEY DON'T ALWAYS DO THAT THE PARK LOT IN FRONT OF OUR HOUSES. BUT THIS GIVES US NO PLACE TO PARK. AND I DON'T KNOW WHEN, YOU CAN SEE, MAYBE YOU CAN'T.

ANYWHERE OUR HOUSE DOWN TOWARD SEVENTH STREET, THERE'S NO STRIPING AT ALL ON SOME OF IT.

[00:35:07]

BECAUSE IT IS WORN OFF AFTER ALL THESE YEARS. SO, WE'RE LEFT WITH THIS.

WHERE ARE WE SUPPOSED TO PARK? THE GUY ACROSS THE STREET, MOST PLACES ONLY HAVE A DRIVEWAY YOU CAN FIT MAYBE TWO CARS THERE. SO HE'S GOT FIVE CARS. SO WHERE ARE YOU SUPPOSED TO

PARK? >> LET ME ASK YOU SOMETHING. YOU DON'T HAVE ENOUGH, EITHER YOU CAN ANSWER THIS QUESTION. YOU HAVE ENOUGH PROPERTY WE CAN PARK YOUR CAR IS IN THE

PROPERTY? >> WE LIVE THERE AND HAVE TO GET UP AND GO TO WORK AND THE MORNING. WE DON'T HAVE ANOTHER, IT'S NOT LIKE, I HAVE A 1969 CHEVELLE THAT IS SITTING OUT FRONT. I'M TRYING TO SELL IT. SO I HAVE NO ROOM FOR ANOTHER CAR, IT'S TIME FOR IT TO GO ANYWAY. THAT IS THE ONLY VEHICLE THAT IS IN MY WAY, THAT COULD BE AN EXTRA PARKING SPOT. HOPEFULLY SOON IT WILL BE GONE.

>> WE DO HAVE DRIVEWAYS, BUT I MEAN, MIND YOU CAN ONLY FIT TO END.

AND I'VE OAK TREES IN MY YARD. IF YOU THINK ABOUT OAK TREES, THE ROOTS, I CAN BARELY GET OUT OF MY DRIVEWAY, IN AND OUT OF MY DRIVEWAY IF I PARKED BEHIND THE CAR IN FRONT OF ME.

BUT THE POINT IS, I MEAN, EVERY BUSINESS HAS PARKING LOTS. RESIDENCES DON'T.

AND YOU CAN SEE THE FRONT OF MY HOUSE, DID LOOK LIKE THAT BUT IT IS PRETTY WELL GONE NOW.

IT IS PRETTY WELL BEEN YOU KNOW, PEOPLE PARKED THERE, THIS THAT AND THE OTHER BUT THERE'S NO ROOM. THE GUY STREET LIKE I SAID, HAS TWO SPACES AND HE'S GOT TICKETS

BECAUSE THEY DID PARK ON THE GRASS THERE. >> ON A.

>> IS ON EIGHTH STREET. IF THE ONLY PLACE TO GET TO PARK SO HE'S GOT A TICKET.

THEY MOVED ONE OF THE CARS AROUND FRONT, LEFT MY GRANDDAUGHTERS THERE.

AND WHILE THESE WERE ALL BEING TAKEN, WE WERE IN TEXAS. WE DIDN'T KNOW.

WE WOULD HAVE TRIED TO DO SOMETHING BEFORE NOW. >> CORRECTION THAT STARTED WHEN

WE WERE IN TEXAS, GOT BACK A WEEK LATER AND IT CONTINUED. >> YES WE WERE IN TEXAS THE

18TH OR THE 19TH FOR THE NEXT WEEK. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?

>> YES MA'AM. I IMPLORE YOU TO PLEASE, HAVE A CITY WORK WITH US IN CONSIDERATION OF ADDING SOME ADDITIONAL PARKING SPOTS IN FRONT OF MY HOUSE.

THE MEASUREMENTS IF YOU CAME OUT AND DID THE MATH, TWO BLOCKS UP, THEY'VE GOT THREE PARKING SPOTS AND TO END TO END. IN A JUST DRIVE BY EVERY DAY

AND I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY I CAN'T BE SO LUCKY. >> SIR, HAVE YOU SPOKEN ANYBODY

AT CITY HALL ABOUT YOUR PROBLEM? >> THE MAYOR, AND SHE AFFORDED ONTO THE CITY MANAGER AND SOMEBODY ELSE, WHICH I DID NOT KNOW WHO IT WAS.IKE I SAID, THIS IS THE THIRD TIME FOR THE FIRST TWO TIMES WE WENT TO THE POLICE DEPARTMENT AND THEY

STOPPED GIVING US TICKETS. >> NOTHING WAS OFFICIALLY DONE. THEY JUST LEFT US ALONE.

TO LIVE OUR LIVES HAPPILY. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. CAN I MAKE A SUGGESTION? THIS IS PURELY MY SUGGESTION. STAFF CAN PROCEED AS THEY FEEL APPROPRIATE.

THE SCOPE OF YOUR AUTHORITY SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, IS LIMITED BY STATE STATUTE.

REALLY, ALL YOU CAN CONSIDER TODAY IS WHETHER OR NOT THERE IS A VIOLATION OF THE PARKING CODE. AND UNDERSTAND THE CONCERNS THAT ARE BEING EXPRESSED KIND OF COME OUTSIDE OF THE SCOPE OF WHAT YOU'RE ABLE TO DO THIS MORNING.

HAVING SAID THAT, THERE ARE MULTIPLE -- AM TOLD THAT THERE ARE MULTIPLE CITATIONS FOR

THIS. >> YES MA'AM.> FOR THE SAME APPELLANT.

I WOULD ASK -- IF YOU WOULD CONSIDER MAYBE, PASSING THIS CASE AND STEPPING OUT TO SPEAK WITH THE APPELLANT TO SEE IF THERE CAN BE ANY SORT OF RESOLUTION, SINCE THERE ARE

MULTIPLE CASES. IT IS COMPLETELY UP TO YOU. >> UNFORTUNATELY WE ARE FACED WITH THIS WE JUST EXPECT TO MAGISTRATE. A VIOLATION OR NOT.

WE DO NOT HAVE OKAY, FIRST OF WE CANNOT SAY DON'T KNOW WHO'S CAR THAT IS OR CANNOT SAVE THIS PERSON SCORE AND THIS PERSON CAR AND THEY HAVE THE RIGHT TO DO THAT.

WE SAY THIS IS AN AREA THAT SAYS NO PARKING, THERE'S A VEHICLE PARKED THERE WE WRITE A CITATION. WE CAN INTERPRET OR DECIDE WHEN AND WHERE, I CAN'T SAY I DON'T KNOW WHO'S CAR THAT IS. AND IF IT IS SOMEONE ELSE IN THE FAMILY AND THEY COME IN AND

[00:40:01]

AND WE MOVE ON. THERE IS PARKING ON DELAWARE. IT WILL REQUIRE SOME WALKING BECAUSE DOWN THE STREET, THERE IS AMPLE PARKING AVAILABLE. IT IS JUST NOT RIGHT DIRECTLY IN FRONT OF THEIR HOME. SO, STAFF MAINTAINS THAT THERE IS A VIOLATION OF THE PARKING CODE. THEY PARKED IN A NOT PARKING SPOT AND WE MOVE FORWARD.

>> MAY I SAY SOMETHING? >> YES. >> YES, THERE ARE PARKING SPOTS LIKE THREE HOUSES DOWN FROM ME. I HAVE A HANDICAP STICKER. MY DAUGHTER HAS A HANDICAP STICKER. MY GRANDSON, DOES NOT USE HIS NOW.

BUT HE HAS A HANDICAP STICKER. SO, I DON'T THINK -- UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ALL ARE SAYING.

YOU CAN'T REALLY COMICALLY JUDGING WHAT YOU SEE THERE AND THAT WE WERE IN VIOLATION.

BUT SOMEBODY NEEDS TO TELL US WHERE WE ARE SUPPOSED TO GO TO GET SOME JUSTICE HERE.

>> THE WORD AMPLE IS IN MY OPINION, INACCURATE. I UNDERSTAND WHERE YOU SIT, IT MIGHT BE. AND THIS IS A PROBLEM THAT WE HAVE HAD OVER AND OVER.

JUST BECAUSE YOU'RE DOING SOMETHING WRONG, AND THERE'S NOT BEEN, I'M ASKING FOR HELP TO MAKE IT RIGHT. AND I CAN COME IN HERE LOADED -- BUT I'M NOT BECAUSE I'M TRYING TO USE HONEY. AND I WANT TO DO IS NOT BE HERE IN ANOTHER TWO YEARS OR THREE YEARS. JUST BECAUSE IT WOULD STRIKE LIKE THAT, DOESN'T MAKE IT RIGHT. SO, MAYBE SOMEONE CAN DO SOME HOMEWORK WITHIN THE CITY AND FIND OUT IF THERE'S ANY YOU KNOW, REFERENCE TO TAKING THE STRIPES AWAY.

WHY COULDN'T YOU TAKE THE STRIPES AWAY? DON'T TELL ME JUST BECAUSE.

THANK YOU. OBSERVATION ADDRESS AM SORRY, MAGISTRATE.

>> THIS IS NOT WHERE WE CHANGE THE LOCAL RULE. >> UNDERSTAND THAT.

IT IS LIKE $700 AND THAT IS A BIG DOLLAR AMOUNT. QUICKLY LOG YOUR TIME TO SPEAK.

THIS IS A CASE WHERE YOU OU PARKED RE YOU PARKED IMPROPERLY.

ILLEGALLY. IF YOU HAVE FOUR CARS, OR FIVE IN YOUR HOUSEHOLD, AND YOU'VE ONLY GOT TWO SPACES OUT FRONT, YOU HAVE TO -- YOU HAVE TO FIND A WAY TO PARK THOSE OTHER CARS.

THIS IS NOT THE BODY WHERE YOU CHANGE THAT. THIS IS ENFORCEMENT.

I SUGGEST YOU TALK TO WHOEVER YOUR CITY COMMISSIONER IS. >> WE HAVE.

>> YOU SPOKE WITH YOUR CITY COMMISSIONER? >> YES, CURTIS JOHNSON.

>> YOU'RE GOING TO HAVE TO TALK TO HIM AGAIN. BECAUSE THIS IS NOT WHERE WE

MAKE CHANGES. >> WE UNDERSTAND. >> ANYTHING FURTHER? ALL RIGHT, BASED ON THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE PRESENTED I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS. JEFFREY SCOTT MONTPETIT, IS A PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. I IMPOSE A $50 FINE AND A $10 ADMIN FEE, TOTAL AMOUNT OF $60.

YOU HAVE 14 DAYS TO PAY. CAN YOU PAY WITHIN THAT PERIOD OF TIME?

>> NO MA'AM. >> HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED? >> ARE NOT SURE, AT THE CHECK WITH MY WIFE AND DO MY FINANCES. DON'T KNOW. I DON'T KNOW.

I HAVE TO FIGURE OUT. I CAN'T ANSWER THAT QUESTION BASED ON THE OTHER CASES THAT

ARE IN FRONT OF ME THAT I WILL BE WAITING FOR. >> OKAY I WILL GIVE YOU 30 DAYS

TO PAY. >> WE HAVE TO WAIT FOR THE REST OF THEM?

>> YES. FAILURE TO PAY COULD RESULT IN THIS CASE BEING FORWARD OVER THE COUNTY COURT. WHERE YOU WILL INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS.

30 DAYS TO PAY. >> MAGISTRATE, STAFF HAS ONE QUESTIO.

HE CITATION WAS ACTUALLY ISSUED TO THIS VEHICLE, WHICH IS A DIFFERENT OWNER.

MR. MONTPETIT HAS SUBMITTED THE APPEAL ON BEHALF OF THAT OWNER. O YOU WANT THE ORDER TO BE IN HIS NAME AS HE STEPPED FORWARD TO TAKE RESPONSE ABILITY?

>> THAT IS WHO IS ON THE DOCKET. >> JUST CONFIRMING.

[C. 23-0260 PK 800 Blk Delaware Ave Jeffrey Scott Montpetit Michael Rabenecker]

>> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR. >> THIS CASE -- 800 DELAWARE AVENUE. JEFFREY SCOTT MONTPETIT. THEY ARE ALL IN ORDER.

>> THANK YOU. >> WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> YOU WANT TO SIT DOWN?

>> YOUR HONOR, DO FOR YOU IS THE NEXT CASE, CASE NUMBER 23 Ã 260.

[00:45:04]

THE CASE WAS INITIATED JANUARY 25, 2023. THIS IS A CITATION APPEAL.

BY LATER IN THIS CASE, QUC)BEC AS A JEFFREY SCOTT 22-3423PK FIVE.

THE CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 18913 A PARKING VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 34 Ã31 HE PARKING PROHIBITED ALL TIMES MARKED BY WHITE LINES ON THE ROAD.

THIS IS A SECOND VIOLATION? >> YES. >> THIS IS A SECOND OFFENSE.

AND SO, THE FINE, THE CITY ASKING $100 FINE BE ASSESSED. $10 MINISTRATION FEE FOR A TOTAL DUE OF $110. THIS IS A REQUEST THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS THEM VIOLATION EXISTS, RILEY TO BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL INDICATED ABOVE FOR FAILURE TO PAY THE FINE RESULT IN A CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE DATE AND TIME STAMPED THAT ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE VIOLATIONS I WITNESSED.

>> AT THIS TIME? IF THE PHOTOS BE SHOWN TO THE APPELLANT?

>> AT THIS TIME SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THE PHOTOGRAPHS ARE IN.

>> WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> 122 AND 125. >> SEPARATELY SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I WOULD LIKE TO MOVIE PARKING CITATION APPEAL DOCUMENT IN, AS APPELLANT ONE.

>> WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> I MIGHT HAVE PUT THEM BACK TOGETHER.

>> WE DIDN'T DO THE -- >> THANK YOU. >> THIS IS THE SECOND OFFENSE FOR THE VAN. , THIS THE SECOND OFFENSE. WE MIXED THE ORDER UP.

OKAY. WE SHOULD HAVE DONE THEM DIFFERENT.

>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, AT THIS TIME, I WANT TO INQUIRE CODE OFFICER RABENECKER IF THERE'S

SOMETHING YOU WANT TO SAY ABOUT THE PHOTOGRAPHS. >> NO MA'AM.

YOU CAN SEE THE BOTTOM THERE WHITE LINED AND SLASHES THAT THAT SHOW THIS IS A PARKING

SPOT PROHIBITED AT ALL TIMES. >> THANK YOU. >> YOU'RE WELCOME.

MAYBE MENTION THIS IS A SECOND OFFENSE. THE FIRST OFFENSE WAS WRITTEN ON THE 22ND. YEAH, JANUARY 22. AND THIS IS JANUARY 25.

>> WE WERE OUT OF TOWN. >> IT DOESN'T MATTER. >> YOU ARE SAYING AS TO THIS

PARTICULAR VEHICLE, CORRECT? >> YES MA'AM. SECOND OFFENSE FOR THIS

VEHICLE. >> ALL RIGHT, ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO, YOUR HONOR.

>> RESPONSE? >> NO POINT. >> THAT IS DIRECTLY IN FRONT OF MY HOUSE. I MEAN, TO MY POINT, THERE IS ONE SPOT, AND THERE IS -- YEAH, THAT IS MY VEHICLE. PARKED ILLEGALLY IN FRONT OF MY HOME.

THREE DAYS. APART. LIKE I SAID, I FELT TARGETED.

>> ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO MA'AM. >> ALL RIGHT, BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED, I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS.ND THAT JEFFREY SCOTT MONTPETIT IS THE PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. I WILL IMPOSE -- THIS IS THE

SECOND VIOLATION. >> MAGISTRATE, I JUST -- MR. -- WILL DISAGREE WITH ME AGAIN BUT

IS THERE A SECOND CASE FOR THIS VEHICLE? >> THERE IS A SECOND CASE WHICH IS THE FIRST OFFENSE FOR $50. THEY'RE JUST OUT OF ORDER, I APOLOGIZE.

>> YOUR TESTIMONY THAT THIS IS A SECOND OFFENSE FOR THIS VEHICLE.

WE HAVE NOT TECHNICALLY HEARD ANOTHER CASE YET WITH REGARD TO THIS VEHICLE.

I JUST WANT TO PUT THAT OUT THERE. IN INTEREST OF KEEPING THE

RECORD CLEAN. >> ALL RIGHT. I WILL MAKE SURE THAT I TAKE

[00:50:03]

CASES FOR MR. JEFFREY SCOTT MONTPETIT. >> CAN I SAY SOMETHING?

>> SURE. >> IT IS MONTPETIT, IN THIS HAPPENED WHEN WE WERE ALL AWAY

IN TEXAS. >> FOR THE FIRST OFFENSE. >> AND MAYBE WELL THE 25TH.

HAT WAS WEDNESDAY. DID YOU COME BACK? YOU CAME BACK WEDNESDAY.

IT IS A SECOND OFFENSE BUT WE WERE NOT EVEN IN THE STATE. IS MAKING IT LOOK LIKE WE ARE JUST IGNORING IT OR JUST, YOU'RE DOING A HECKUVA JOB, THAT'S ALL I CAN SAY.

BUT, AND I MEAN THAT. BUT, WE WERE OUT OF TOWN. IT IS NOT WHAT WE WERE WILLFULLY DISREGARDING THIS. AND WE HAVE TRIED, LIKE HE SAYS, MAKE SOME CHANGES SINCE WE'VE BEEN BACK. BUT THERE'S ONLY SO MUCH YOU CAN DO.

>> ALL RIGHT, ANYTHING FURTHER? >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, AN OPTION, YOU COULD I SUPPOSE, EXERCISE, RESERVE RULING ON THE CASE UNTIL YOU HEAR THE SECOND CASE.

I DON'T KNOW. >> I WILL DO THAT. JUST BE CAUTIOUS.

I WILL RESERVE RULING ON THIS ONE, CALL THE NEXT CASE.>> ALL RIGHT.

I DON'T SEE WE HAVE THE JANUARY 22 ONE YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT, MIKE.

>> MAYBE I'M GETTING THE DATE CONFUSED? WHAT CASE NUMBER IS IT?

>> CASE NUMBER 23 Ã259. >> OKAY. WE WILL GO WITH THAT ONE NEXT.

[F. 23-0259 PK 800 Blk Delaware Ave Jeffrey Scott Montpetit Michael Rabenecker]

>> YOUR HONOR, THE NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU, CASE NUMBER 23 Ã 259, A PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT THE 800 BLOCK OF DELAWARE AVENUE. THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON JANUARY 22, 2023. THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE CAME BACK AS A JEFFREY SCOTT

MONTPETIT. MONTPETIT? >> MONTPETIT.

>> MONTPETIT. THE CITATION NUMBER IS 18985. VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 34 Ã30 1E. PARKING PROHIBITED ITE LINES STRIPED ON THE STREET.

THE CITY IS ASKING A $50 FINE BE ASSESSED IN THE MINISTRATION FEE OF $10 A TOTAL OF $60, SAY REQUEST THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A TOTAL INDICATED ABOVE. THOUGH TO PAY THE FINE RESULT IN A CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. YOUR HONOR, FOOTERS DATE AND TIME STAMP THE EQUITY PORTRAY

THE VIOLATIONS I WITNESSED. >> IF WE CAN SHOW THE PHOTOGRAPHS TO THE APPELLATE.

>> WHICH ONE ARE WE TALKING ABOUT? THIS IS THE LAST CASE.

>> IS THE FIRST ONE. >> OKAY SO WE'RE GOING TO DO THE FIRST ONE WITH THE RV.

OKAY I'M TRYING TO CATCH UP. >> THIS TIME WE MOVED THE PHOTOS INTO THE CITY ONE

COMPOSITE. >> ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> THANK YOU MA'AM.

>> THANK YOU. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, SEPARATELY, I'VE BEEN HANDED A COPY OF THE PARKING CITATION APPEAL. AT THIS TIME, I WOULD MOVE THAT

IN AS APPELLANT ONE. >> ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> OKAY AND HANDING BOTH

[00:55:08]

EXHIBITS TO YOU NOW. >> THANK YOU. >> SPECIAL METRIC, I WILL CLARIFY THAT THECASE INITIATED DATE IS SUPPOSED TO BE JANUARY 22 , THAT IS A TYPO.

>> OKAY, THANK YOU. I WILL MAKE THOSE CORRECTIONS, ORDERS TO REFLECT THAT.

>> THANK YOU. >> ANY RESPONSE? >> NOTHING OTHER THAN THE PICTURE, YOU CAN SAY CAN FIT MULTIPLE CARS IN FRONT OF MY HOME.

I GUESS I COULD PARK DOWN THE COUNTY, THE CITY GARAGE AND UBER THEY ARE TO GO TO WORK.

THAT'S AN OPTION. >> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS.

CASE NUMBER 23 Ã0259 PARKING VIOLATION CITATION. YOU WILL BE ASSESSED A FINE OF $50, $10 ADMIN FEE, TOTAL OF $60. AND I WILL GIVE YOU 30 DAYS TO PAY. IF NOT, THIS COULD BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY WHERE YOU WILL

INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS. >> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR.

>> YOU'RE WELCOME, NEXT CASE. >> OKAY. >> HONOR? THE NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU IS GOING TO BE CASE NUMBER 23 Ã 258.

[D. 23-0258 PK 800 Blk Delaware Ave Jeffrey Scott Montpetit Michael Rabenecker]

>> WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> YOU ANNA, BEFORE YOU IS CASE NUMBER 23 Ã258.

IT IS A PARKING CITATION WRITTEN AT THE 800 BLOCK OF DELAWARE AVENUE.

THE CASE WAS INITIATED, THERE IS AN ERROR ON THIS INFORMATION IN FRONT OF YOU.

THE CASE WAS INITIATED GENERALLY 22ND 2023 AT 9:13 AM. THE DESCRIPTION, THE VIOLATOR IN CASE CAME BACK AS JEFFREY SCOTT MONTPETIT, AND STEPHANIE LEE HOFFMAN MONTPETIT.

THE PARKING VIOLATION, NUMBER AND IS 18982. PARKING RELATION CITY ORDINANCE 34 Ã30 1E PARKING PROHIBITED AT ALL TIMES WHITE LINES STRIPED ON E STREET.

THIS IS A $50 OFFENSE. THE CITY IS ASKING THE FINE OF $50 BE ASSESSED, AND MINISTRATION FEE OF $10.ATE FEE OF $60. THE SAME REQUEST OF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A TOTAL DUE INDICATED ABOVE.

FAILURE TO PAY FINE RESULT IN A CITATION BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.

I PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE THAT HER DATE AND TIME STAMP. THEY ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE

VIOLATION. >> WE CAN SHOW THE PHOTOGRAPHS TO THE APPELLANT, PLEASE.

ASE. >> I THINK YOU SEE EVERY VIOLATION IS IN THE SAME SPOT.

BECAUSE WE DON'T T HAVE ROOM. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I HAVE THE PHOTOS AND AS A CITIES ONE

COMPOSITE PAIR. >> ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> SEPARATELY, I BE HANDED A COPY OF THE APPEAL BY THE APPELLANT I HAVE TO BE MOVED IN SEPARATELY AS APPELLANT'S ONE.

>> WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. H. HOW DO YOU RESPOND MR.

MONTPETIT? >> I DO HAVE APPRECIATION FOR THE LAW.

BUT SOMETIMES, IT JUST DOESN'T SEEM RIGHT. I'M STANDING IN FRONT OF YOU, AND I REALIZE THAT IT IS WHAT IT IS AND I CAME HERE. I GUESS I CAME HERE UNDER THE WRONG EXPECTATION. I EXPECTED TO GET SOME KIND OF HELP.

JOHN GETTING IS A CITY STICKING THEIR HAND IN MY POCKET. AND I'M GOING TO WALK OUT THAT

[01:00:06]

IT'S HOW I MAKE MY LIVING. A PARK THERE, GET UP AND GO TO WORK, GO HOME.

AND IT SEEMS LIKE A BIG INJUSTICE ME. BUT MAYBE THAT IS JUST THE VICIOUS CYCLE THAT I LIVE IN. WHICH IS THE CITY OF FORT PIERCE.

I USED TO BE PART OF THAT, LIVING HERE. I'M NOT SO PROUD OF ANYMORE

AFTER THIS EXPERIENCE. >> THIS MIGHT BE A LITTLE BIT OFF BUT YOU SAY YOU DRANK I'M SORRY, HE SAID HE WORKS SATURDAY AND SUNDAYS. I KNOW BECAUSE I'VE SEEN HIM

OUT THERE. HE GOES DOWNTOWN. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, AGAIN,

THIS IS AN EVIDENTIARY HEARING. I WILL OBJECT AS TO EVIDENCE. >> SUSTAINED. CAN'T

DISREGARD YOUR COMMENTS. >> I CAN ASK?I CAN'T ASK WHO IS THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER

DOWNTOWN? >> YOU CAN DO IT AFTER WE FINISH.

>> WHO I'M GOING TO ASK, HIM? >> SITTING HERE. >> OKAY.

I HAVE LOADS OF PICTURES OF VIOLATIONS DOWNTOWN. BECAUSE I'M THERE EVERY DAY.

>> ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO, YOUR HONOR. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?

>> NO MAN. >> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS.I WILL IMPOSE A $50 FINE. $10 ADMIN FEE.

YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL, FAILURE TO PAY IN 30 DAYS COULD RESULT IN THE CASE BEING SENT OVER TO THE COUNTY COURT. YOU WILL INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES INVOLVED.

NEXT CASE. >> HOW MANY MORE WE GOT? TWO?

[E. 23-0257 PK 800 Blk Delaware Ave Jeffrey Scott Montpetit Michael Rabenecker]

>> OKAY YOUR HONOR. BEFORE YOU IS CASE NUMBER 23 Ã 257.

THIS IS A CITATION THAT WAS WRITTEN ON THE 800 BLOCK OF DELAWARE AVENUE.

THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON JANUARY 29 2023. AT 10:58 AM.

THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE CAME BACK AS A JEFFREY SCOTT MONTPETIT.

AND A STEPHANIE LEE HOFFMAN MONTPETIT. THE CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 18929, VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 34-31E. PARKING PROHIBITED, WHITE LINES ON THE STREET. THIS IS A SECOND OFFENSE FOR THIS IS ASKING A $100 FINE BE ASSESSED. A MINISTRATION FEE OF $10 FOR A TOTAL DUE OF $110.

THE CITY IS REQUESTING AT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A TOTAL DUE ABOVE. -- HAVE PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE DATE AND TIME STAMP TO ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE VIOLATIONS I WITNESSED. .

>> I LEFT THE PHOTOS BE SHOWN TO THE APPELLANT. [INAUDIBLE]

>> THIS TIME REMOVE THE PHOTOS AND IS A CITY ONE COMPOSITE. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.

>> THANK YOU. TYPICALLY, I'VE BEEN HANDED A COPY OF APPELLANT PARKING CITATION APPEAL. I ASKED THAT TO BE ADDED AS APPELLANT ONE.

>> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. THANK YOU. >> YES MA'AM.

>> ANYTHING FROM YOU, MR. MONTPETIT? >> YES MA'AM PURE LASTING, AND

[01:05:06]

BECAUSE YOU ARE JUST READING THE FIGURES OFFER WHAT THE FINE IS AND I TOOK THE DAY OFF TO COME HERE AND I'M LOSING MONEY AND IS EVIDENTLY NOT THE VENUE TO TALK ABOUT THINGS TO HELP YOU KNOW, SOLVE SOME ISSUES. I SHOULD HAVE JUST PAID THE FINE AND WENT ABOUT MY WEIGHT.

AND TRY TO FOUND OUT YOU KNOW, THE CODE ENFORCEMENT GUY IS AND MAYBE HE IGNORE ME.

BECAUSE IT SEEMS LIKE THAT WOULD BE THE ONLY WAY. INSTEAD OF TRYING TO DO THE RIGHT THING, I JUST, I AM AT A LOSS FOR THE GOVERNMENT RIGHT NOW.

>> BUREAUCRACY. >> ANYTHING FURTHER? >> YES, MAY I HAVE THE PICTURES

BACK? >> THEY HAVE BEEN ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE.

WE CAN MAKE YOU A COPY OF THE PEER. >> I DON'T NEED IT, I'M JUST

GOING TO ASK HIM WHY -- >> ADJUST THE MAGISTRATE. >> WHEN HE IS OUT GIVING THESE TICKETS, I THINK ALL HE SEES IS THESE CARS. BECAUSE MONEY SITTING ON THE OTHER SIDE IN FRONT OF MY HOUSE ON STRIPES. WHY DID HE NOT GIVE ME A

TICKET? >> I HAVE NO WAY OF KNOWING THAT.

>> I CAN'T ASK HIM. >> I'M NOT DOING THIS. IF YOU WANT TO TALK TO HIM OUTSIDE AND THE CITY WANT TO TALK TO YOU, YOU CAN. NOT HERE.

>> OKAY. NO TRUTH OR ANYTHING HERE. GOTCHA.

>> HOLD ON JUST A MOMENT MR. MONTPETIT. >> YES MA'AM.

>> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED, FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS.

JEFFREY SCOTT MONTPETIT IS THE PARTY RESPONSIBLE. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, GOING THROUGH REMINDER THAT YOU HAVE RULING ON ONE CASE THEY HAD TO GO BACK TO.

>> 258? >> 260. >> ANYWAY, BASED ON THE TESTIMONY, I WILL IMPOSE $100 FINE, YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO PAY. PLUS THE ADMIN FEE.

FAILURE TO PAY TO RESULT IN US GOING TO THE COUNTY COURT, WHERE YOU COULD INCUR

ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS. >> $500 OR SOMETHING? >> WHAT I MAKE IN A WEEK.

>> THANK YOU, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. >> WHICH CASE DO I NEED TO

RULE >> 23 Ã260 . [INAUDIBLE]

>> READY? >> I'M SORRY ABOUT THAT. >> Ú23 Ã260.

THANK YOU, MADAM CLARK. ALL RIGHT, BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY.

I THINK WE ALREADY RULED ON IT, WE JUST NEED TO GO AHEAD AND IMPOSE THE VIOLATION.

THAT CASE HAS ALREADY BEEN HEARD. I WILL IMPOSE A FINE OF $100, $10 ADMIN FEE. YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. FAILURE TO PAY IT, COULD RESULT IN THE CASE BE TRANSFERRED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM, WHERE YOU WOULD INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES

AND COSTS. >> YOUR HONOR, HOW MANY DAYS TO PAY?

>> 30. >> 30 DAYS TO PAY? ON ALL OF THEM.

THANK YOU YOUR HONOR. >> ARE WELCOME. GENERALLY, IT IS 10 OR 14.

BUT IF IT IS ANY CONSOLATION, PROBABLY NOT. BUT I WILL GIVE YOU 30 DAYS TO

PAY. >> THANK YOU. >> YOU NEED TO REALLY TALK WITH

YOUR COMMISSIONER. >> I'M GOING UPSTAIRS TO THE MAYOR.

I'M GOING STRAIGHT THERE. >> WHOMEVER. GOOD LUCK.

>> SHE HAS WORKED WITH ME BEFORE. SHE'S THE ONE THAT GOT THE ONLY

YELLOW STRIP ON DELAWARE AVENUE. >> THANK YOU.

>> HE WAS BETWEEN HIM AND THE ARCHITECT NEXT DOOR.THERE'S A FIRE HYDRANT.

NORMALLY PEOPLE PARKED THERE? SO, I FINALLY CALLED. SHE GOT IT STRIPED.

AND PEOPLE QUIT PARKING THERE FOR QUITE A WHILE.> IN FRONT OF THE FIRE HYDRANT.

>> YEAH. AND THEN ACROSS HIS FREAKIN DRIVEWAY.

EXCUSE ME. >> ARE WE DONE HERE? >> YOUR DONE WITH ME.

>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR YOUR TIME. I APPRECIATE IT.

>> NEXT CASE 23 Ã222. 100 N. INDIAN RIVER DRIVE, DOWLER.

[H. 23-0222 PK 100 N Indian River Dr Warwick H Dowler, Jennifer Mary Dowler Charmaine Kirkland]

[01:10:19]

>> CHARMAINE. $18 SHOULD HAVE COME OFF. >> WHEN YOU ARE READY MS.

KIRKLAND. >> GOOD MORNING ANNA. CASE 23 Ã0222 INITIATED ON GENERATE 20 AUGUST 20, 2023. AT THE 100 BLOCK OF NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE.

THIS IS ALSO AN APPEAL, THE VIOLATOR IS WARWICK H DOWLER AND JENNIFER MARY DOWLER.

CITATION NUMBER 1784 CODE SECTION 34-31E, NO PARKING. FIND A $50 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10 AND TOTAL DUE IS $60. THE CITY REQUEST SPECIAL MINISTRY FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED A TOTAL DUE INDICATED ABOVE.

THEY ARE TO BE SUCH FARM WILL RESULT IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I DO HAVE PHOTOS DATE AND TIME STAMPED.

OF THE VIOLATION. >> THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION? THANK YOU, CODE OFFICER.FOR THE RECORD, WE'RE SHOWING THE PHOTOGRAPHS TO THE APPELLANT.

AT THIS TIME, REMOVE THE PHOTOS AND AS THE CITIES ONE COMPOSITE.

>> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> THANK YOU. I DO HAVE A COPY OF THE APPEAL FORM. WOULD YOU LIKE TO ADMIT THAT SEPARATELY? THANK YOU. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I HAVE BEEN HANDED A COPY OF THE APPEAL FORM THAT WAS FILED IN THIS CASE. I WOULD LIKE TO MOVE THAT AND

AS APPELLANT ONE. >> ADMITTED AS SUCH. THANK YOU.

>> THANK YOU. >> ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO MA'AM.

>> STIR, STATE YOUR NAME. >> WARWICK DOWLER. >> HOW DO YOU ESPOND?

>> WE HAD GONE TO THE FAIR, THE CRAFT FAIR. A COUPLE OF TIMES, I'D BEEN THERE BEFORE LOOKING FOR DISABLED PARKING. WE CIRCLED BACK AROUND AGAIN, AND THERE WAS A CAR PULLING OUT. SO, NO SIGNS SAYING NO PARKING.

WHEN WE PARKED IN THERE, WE WENT TO SEE ONE OF THE VENDORS. PARKING ENFORCEMENT PULLED UP BEHIND US, DIDN'T SAY ANYTHING. THAT THERE WAS NO PARKING. IF SOMEONE HAD, WE WOULD HAVE MOVED. MY DISABLED PATCH WAS IN FRONT AS YOU CAN SEE IN THE PICTURE.

WHEN WE CAME BACK, WE HAD TO TAKE IT NO MORE THAN 10 OR 15 MINUTES.

>> ANYTHING FURTHER? THIS IS YOUR CAR, THE TIMESTAMP OF JANUARY 28, 2023 10:53 AM.

RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOUR CAR, RIGHT THERE, ON THAT YELLOW STRIPING IT SAYS NO PARKING.

DO YOU WANT TO SHOW THIS TO HIM? >> I CAN SEE IT.

IT IS VERY FAINT. >> ALL RIGHT. I WAS SAYING THAT THERE BEEN OTHER CARS PARKED IN THEIR. WHEN WE CAME IN, THEN WE GOT THE TICKET.

>> ALL RIGHT, ANYTHING FURTHER? >> CODE ENFORCEMENT EVEN PARKED BEHIND US.

AND WATCHED US WALK OUT. >> WHO PARKED BEHIND YOU? >> PARK ENFORCEMENT.

>> AND HE STILL PARKED THERE? >> I WAS COMING BACK TO MY CAR TO -- I DIDN'T SEE THE NO PARKING IN FRONT. IF THEY HAD SAID SOMETHING, I WOULD HAVE MOVED MY CAR.

[01:15:01]

I CIRCLED BECAUSE THERE WAS NO DISABLED PARKING. >> ALL RIGHT.

ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO MA'AM. CHRIS BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY, I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS. AND THAT MR. WARWICK DOWLER IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. I WILL GIVE YOU 14 DAYS TO PAY. THE AMOUNT OF $50 FOR THE FINE,

$10 FOR THE ADMIN FEE. >> NO LATE FEE. >> NO LATE FEE.

A TOTAL OF $78. >> 60. >> $60, THANK YOU.

I DIDN'T EVEN READ IT. ALL RIGHT. YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.

AND AGAIN, YOU HAVE 14 DAYS TO PAY THAT TICKET. FAILURE TO DO SO COULD RESULT IN THE CASE BE TRANSFERRED OVER TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. WHERE YOU WILL INCUR ADDITIONAL

FEES AND COSTS. THAT'S IT. >> OKAY.

[A. 22-3378 CE 2002 Orange Avenue Knight Universal INC Heather Debevec]

>> THEY NEED TO FIX THAT. AT LEAST PUT A SIGN UP. >> NEXT CASE 22 Ã3378, 2002

UNIVERSAL AVENUE -- WILL UNIVERSAL INC.. >> GOOD MORNING.

>> GOOD MORNING SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. THIS IS 22 Ã3378 2002 ORANGE AVENUE, NOT UNIVERSAL INC.. CASE ISSUED DECEMBER 16 OF 2022.

IT WAS FOR SECTION 34 Ã35 SUBSECTION F PARKING PROHIBITED ON CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.

SECTION 125 Ã322 SUBSECTION EM FIVE. ALSO STORAGE COMMERCIAL.

SECTION 26 ÃTHREE STORAGE OF COMMODITIES, WHICH IS STORAGE OF COMMODITIES HAS BEEN TAKEN CARE OF. I WOULD LIKE TO R&D THAT. IT WAS REQUESTING REMOVE ALL VEHICLES, DISPLAYS, AND OTHER ITEMS FROM THE RIGHT-OF-WAY ON THE EAST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY.

AN SOUTHEAST CORNER. BRING IN OR REMOVE THE TOOLS, THE STARS, BOARDS AND OTHER LOOSE ITEMS FROM THE PARKING LOTS. REMOVE OR PLACE VEHICLES AND LOGIC? BEHIND AREAS OR GARAGE. REMOVE ITEMS FROM THE BEDS OF TRUCKS AND OPEN TRAILERS PLACE THEM IN A SHED OR CLOSE FACILITY WHICH ITEM NUMBER FOUR LIKE I SAID, IS REVIEW AND DETERMINATION. THE CITY IS REQUESTING OF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO COMPLY A FINE OF $150 PER DAY WOULD BE ASSESSED. I DO HAVE PHOTOS IN WHICH TO SUBMIT, MR. KNIGHT IS NOT A CHANCE TO REVIEW THOSE PHOTOS. THE LAST VIEW AHEAD OF THE PROPERTY, YESTERDAY.I NOTICED THAT THEY STARTED TO PUT UP A FENCE, TO SPEAK WITH MR. A SECOND THIS MORNING WHICH YOU WILL BE APPLYING FOR A PERMIT FOR THE FENCE.

WE DID SPEAK ABOUT THAT T THAT THIS MORNING. >> OKAY.

>> YOUR MAGISTRATE, IF WE CAN SHOW THE PHOTOS TO THE RESPONDENT, AND WHILE WE ARE

DOING THAT, I WILL ASK THE CODE OFFICER IF YOU TOOK THE PHOTOS? >> YES.

QUESTER THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW? >> YES.

>> THANK YOU. >> AT THIS TIME OF THE PHOTOS AND AS THE CITIES ONE

COMPOSITE. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. ANYTHING FURTHER?

>> NOT AT THIS TIME. >> THANK YOU. >> SIR, HOW DO YOU RESPOND?

>> TENANTS THAT ACTUALLY OCCUPY TWO DIFFERENT BAYS. THEY HAVE BEEN HELPING ME GET

[01:20:06]

AND I AM IN THE PROCESS OF CLEANING EVERYTHING UP AND GETTING EVERYTHING IN

COMPLIANCE. >> THIS IS K START DECEMBER 16. WHAT TOOK YOU SO LONG TO GET

GOING ON IT? >> THIS IS ACTUALLY, WORKING WITH THE TENANTS THAT ERE

THERE. IT WAS AS PRETTY DIFFICULT. >> HOW DID IT COME TO CODE?

>> AFTER REMEMBER CORRECTLY, THIS WAS A CASE WHERE SOMEBODY HAD COMPLAINED ABOUT THE VEHICLES PARKING ON RIGHT-OF-WAY.ND PEOPLE HAVING DIFFICULTY SEEING.

>> THANK YOU. ANYTHING FURTHER, MR. KNIGHT? >> NO MA'AM.

>> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED, FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS AT 2002 ORANGE AVENUE. AND NOT UNIVERSAL INC. IS RESPONSIBLE PARTY.

[INAUDIBLE] HOW LONG DO YOU THINK IT WOULD TAKE YOU TO GET THE REST OF THE STUFF CLEANED

UP? >> IT WAS POSSIBLE, 30 DAYS WOULD BE GREATLY APPRECIATED.

>> ARE YOU AMENABLE TO 30 DAYS? >> YES. AND I SAY THAT BECAUSE IF HE IS GOING TO GET THE PERMIT FOR THE FENCE, AND HAVE THE INITIATED, IT VERY WELL COULD TAKE THAT LONG. WHICH WOULD ASSIST IN THE OUTSIDE STORAGE COMMERCIAL,

WHICH WOULD FIX THAT ISSUE. OR POTENTIALLY FIX THE ISSUE. >> ALL RIGHT, ANYTHING FURTHER?

>> NO THANK YOU. >> I FIND THAT YOU ARE IN VIOLATION.

I WILL GIVE YOU 30 DAYS, YOU'VE GOT TO GET A PERMIT. >> YES, OF COURSE.

>> REMOVE ALL THE OUTSIDE STORAGE. TIRES, DISPLAYS AND OTHER ITEMS FROM THE RIGHT-OF-WAY OF THE EAST SIDE OF THE PROPERTY AN SOUTHEAST CORNER.

BRING IN OR REMOVE THE TWO LOOSE TIRES BOARDS AND OTHER LOOSE ITEMS FROM THE PARKING LOT. PUT VEHICLES BEHIND SCREEN AREAS OR GRUDGES AND -- PLACED THEM IN A SHED OR CLOSE FACILITY. FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THIS, WILL RESULT IN YOU BEING FINED $150 PER DAY. AND AGAIN, GIVING YOU 30 DAYS BECAUSE THE PERMIT WILL BE REQUIRED FOR SOME OF THESE THINGS.

ANY QUESTIONS? >> NO QUESTIONS. >> THANK YOU, GOOD LUCK.

>> THANK YOU. >> SPECIAL MEASURE I'M SORRY. I APOLOGIZE IF I MISSED THIS.

ONE OF THE SECTIONS WAS R&D. CAN WE BE SPECIFIC ABOUT WHICH SECTIONS YOU'RE FIGHTING IN VIOLATION IN WHICH SECTIONS, WHICH ARE THE ONE SECTION THAT IS R&D AND A STAFF COULD ASSIST

WITH THAT, IT MIGHT BE FASTER. >> REQUESTING R&D FOR SECTION 26 ÃTHREE STORAGE OF COMMODITIES. WHICH IS ITEM NUMBER FOUR UNDER THE CORRECTIVE ACTIONS.

>> ALL RIGHT THEN I WILL DO A REVIEW. AND SAY IT'S BEEN COMPLIED WITH. YOU ARE NO LONGER IN VIOLATION OF THAT.

>> THANK YOU. NEXT CASE. >> NEXT CASE 22 Ã3353.

[B. 22-3353 CE 311 N 18th Court Jose Torres Heather Debevec]

311 N. 18 COURT. JOSC) TORRES. >> GOOD MORNING.

>> GOOD MORNING. WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, CASE NUMBER 22 Ã3353 311 N. 18 COURT BY MR. JOSC) TORRES. CASE WAS INITIATED ON DECEMBER 16, 2022, FOR SECTION 30 Ã20 SUBSECTION C RESPONSIBLY FOR CONTAINERS.

I PMC 304.1 EXTERIOR STRUCTURE GENERAL. I CAN SEE VERSION 4.2 PROTECTIVE TREATMENT. THE REQUEST THAT THEY STORE TRASH AND RECYCLE BINS TO THE

[01:25:03]

PAINT THE PEELING AREAS OF THE HOME. THE CITY IS REQUESTING THE SPECIAL MINISTRY FINDS VIOLATION EXISTS VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 30 DAYS TO COMPLY OR FINE OF 100 DOLLARS PER DAY BE ASSESSED. I HAVE PICTURES THAT MR. TORRES

HAS NOT SEEN YET. >> ASKED THAT HE BE SHOWN THE PHOTOS.

WHILE THIS OCCURRING, I WILL ASK IF HE TOOK THEPHOTOS AND IF THEY FAIRLY INACCURATE DEPICT

WHAT YOU SAW. >> YES AND YES . >> OKAY.

>> I DIDN'T KNOW I COULDN'T KEEP THESE HERE. THAT'S QUITE EMBARRASSING.

>> STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD. >> SORRY, JOLUCAS TORRES.

>> IT IS COMING RIVER PHOTOS IN A CITY COMPOSITE. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.

>> . >> THANK YOU. >> NK YOU.

>> THANK YOU. HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO THE ALLEGATIONS AND EVIDENCE

PRESENTED? >> LOOKS QUITE BAD. I AM A LITTLE EMBARRASSED BY IT. BUT THERE IS A REASON WHY MY HOUSE FELL INTO THIS KIND OF DISREPAIR. THREE AND HALF YEARS AGO, I HAD TO BRING MY MOTHER HOME FROM A NURSING HOME. SHE STARTED HAVING INCONTINENCE.

SO THE PRICE OF THE NURSING HOME WENT UP TO ALMOST $4000 A MONTH.

INSTEAD OF 2500. I HAD NO CHOICE BUT TO BRING HER HOME WITH ME.

AND I COULDN'T WORK. SO I'VE BEEN TAKING CARE OF MY MOTHER, FOR THE LAST 3 1/2 YEARS. SHE FINALLY PASSED ON 14 OCTOBER.

THIS PAST OCTOBER. IT IS JUST NOW THAT I'M GETTING BACK ON MY FEET.I FOUND A GREAT JOB AND HAVE EVERY INTENTION OF FIXING THIS HOUSE. YOU KNOW, BECAUSE IT IS PAID FOR AND I DON'T HAVE ANY HOA. AND I HATE THE WAY IT LOOKS. I'M VERY EMBARRASSED BY IT.

>> DOES ANYONE LIVE IN THE HOUSE? >> JUST MYSELF.

BELIEVE IT OR NOT, IT IS CLEAN INSIDE. I KNOW IT LOOKS BAD OUTSIDE BUT JUST DID NOT HAVE THE MONEY TO FIX IT. EVERY TIME I TRIED TO DO SOMETHING, I WOULD COME UP SHORT AND BILLS WERE COMING UP. I WAS TAKING CARE OF HER BY MYSELF, EXCEPT FOR THE NURSES FROM HOSPICE.AND I DID THIS ALONE FOR 3 1/2 YEARS.

I'M NO FAMILY, EVERYONE IS DEAD. [LAUGHTER] EXCEPT FOR MY BROTHER. AND SO, I WAS JUST LASER FOCUSED ON TAKING CARE OF HER.

I HAVE PROOF FROM THE DOCTORS AND NURSES AND, THAT KNOW ABOUT THIS.

MY FRIENDS KNOW ABOUT THIS. BUT, SO THIS IS WHY DIDN'T FIX IT.

I JUST DIDN'T HAVE THE MONEY. I AM MAKING DECENT MONEY NOW. I HAVE EVERY INTENTION OF

FIXING THIS HOUSE. >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT, ANYTHING FURTHER

FROM EITHER PARTY? >> NOT AT THIS TIME. >> OKAY.

>> NO MA'AM. >> BASED ON EVIDENCE PROVIDED I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS ON 311 NORTH 18 COURT AND JOSC) TORRES IS A PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION.

YOU WILL BE GIVEN 30 DAYS TO COMPLY, FIND A $100 PER DATE ASSESSED.

I SUGGEST THAT YOU STAY IN TOUCH WITH MS. DEBEVEC. >> EVERYTHING WILL GET DONE.

THAT PROBLEM THERE, THE WOOD IN THE FRONT. THEY USED TO BE A CARPORT.

I WANTED TO TURN THAT BACK INTO A CARPORT, -- >> SIR?

>> YES MA'AM. >> DOES ANYTHING ELSE. A LOT OF STUFF YOU WANT TO DO,

YOU HAVE TO GET A PERMIT. >> THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE SAID YOU MAY IN FACT NEED AN

[01:30:02]

>> THANK YOU. >> YOU WILL RECEIVE AN ORDER IN THE MAIL BUT DO YOU HAVE THE

CONTACT INFORMATION? >> NEXT CASE 22 Ã3448 2501 SUMMERS BOULEVARD.

[C. 22-3348 CE 2501 Sunrise Boulevard Erin Patrick Heather Debevec]

AARON PATRICK. >> GOOD MORNING. I WILL GO AHEAD AND SWEAR YOU IN. PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE

RECORD. >> ERIN PATRICK. >> DO YOU SWEAR THAT THE

TESTIMONY YOU GIVE WILL BE THE TRUTH? >> YES.

>> ARE WE READY? MAGIC THIS IS 22 Ã3348. 2501 SUNRISE BOULEVARD, MS. ERIN PATRICK. CASE INITIATED ON DECEMBER 7 OF 2022.

IT WAS FOR I PMC 702.4 EMERGENCY ESCAPE OPENINGS COVERED WINDOWS.

SECTION 24 Ã1920 APRIL 20, 2024 21 SUBSECTION 4 OBJECT PARKING ON OTHER THAN PAVEMENT WHICH WOULD LIKE TO REQUEST R&D ON. 304.2 PROTECTIVE TREATMENT I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO REQUEST R&D PEERS TO REQUEST AND REMOVE OPEN OR TAKEDOWN SHUTTERS, THIS IS REQUESTING SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO COMPLY OR FINE OF $100 PER DAY BE ASSESSED. I DO HAVE PHOTOS IN WHICH TO

SUBMIT, WAS MITCH PATRICK HAS NOT SEEN AS OF YET. >> OKAY.

>> WHILE SHE'S LOOKING AT THE PHOTOS, I WILL ASK YOU TO THE PHOTOS AND IF THEY FAIRLY AND

ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW. >> YES MA'AM. >> THANK YOU.

>> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> THE CITIES ONE COMPOSITE? >> YES.

>> THANK YOU MA'AM. STATE YOUR NAME. >> ERIN PATRICK.

>> HAVE EVEN SWORN IN? >> YES. >> RESPHOW DO YOU RESPOND TO TH

VIOLATIONS? >> EVERYTHING IS IN COMPLIANCE NOW.

FINISHED LAST NIGHT AND THIS MORNING. I SENT PICTURES TO HEATHER THIS

MORNING. THEY ARE IN HER PHONE. >> THE TEXT MESSAGE PHOTOS I SAW THIS MORNING, ARE STRICTLY THE FRONT OF THE HOME. WHICH DOES NOT INDICATE THE

SHUTTERS ON THE SIDE. >> IF YOU GIVE ME A MOMENT I WILL CHECK THE EMAIL.

>> SEND THE PICTURES OF THE SIDE. >>.

[INAUDIBLE] >> IS UP TO. >> YOUR HONOR, THE PHOTOS DO SHOW THE SIDE IN WHICH THE SHUTTERS ARE OPENED. YOU ARE WELCOME TO TAKE A LOOK

AT THE PHONE AND EMAIL, TO SEE AS SUCH, IF YOU WISH. >> I TRUST YOU.

>> I WILL GET DATE AND TIME STAMPED PHOTOS TODAY. >> YOUR HONOR, SUBSEQUENT TO THE HEARING, I WOULD ASK THAT YOU GIVE US THE OPPORTUNITY TO SUPPLEMENT THE FILE WITH COPIES

OF THE PHOTOS. >> HEATHER, IS R&D ALSOFOR THE ENTIRE CASE THEN?

>> YES MA'AM, THANK YOU. SORRY . >> OKAY.

PHOTOGRAPH WILL BE ADMITTED AS EVIDENCE. LOOKS LIKE YOU'VE DONE EVERYTHING YOU WERE SUPPOSED TO. THIS HAS BEEN CURED AS OF TODAY'S DATE. JUST MAKE SURE YOU KEEP IT THAT WAY.

[E. 23-84 CE 2604 Robin St Lorens Dessources Marie M H Dessources Isaac Saucedo]

>> YES MA'AM. >> THANK YOU. NEXT CASE IS 23 Ã8426 O4 ROBIN

STREET. DESSOURCES. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.

[01:35:04]

UNFORTUNATELY, WAS NEVER REDUCED TO WRITING TO AN ORDER. IT WAS DONE OUTSIDE, BUT NEVER BROUGHT BACK INSIDE TO BE FINALIZED. WE REALLY JUST ASKING FOR TO BE FINALIZED WITH THE WRITTEN ORDER TO PROVIDE FINANCE. THIS MORE OF A PROCEDURAL

REVIEW. >> OKAY AND WHAT WAS THE AGREEMENT?

>> GOOD MORNING. THE AGREEMENT WAS TO GET A DOUBLE PERMIT FEE FOR TWO TREES, WHICH WAS 35 BY TWO. A TOTAL OF 70C. WOULD YOU BE GRAND TOTAL OF $140 TOTAL. PLANTED TWO NEW TREES, WHICH HAVE BEEN DONE ALREADY.

I DO HAVE PHOTOS TO PROVE THAT. AND TO REMOVE ALL OF THE STUMPS AND GRIND, REMAINING TREES THAT WERE CUT. THAT WERE LEFT. I DO HAVE PHOTOS HERE IF YOU WANT TO TAKE A LOOK AT THEM. THE ONLY THING REMAINING IS TO PAY REMAINING $140.

>> THANK YOU. >> ARE YES AND THE MAGISTRATE ADOPT A STIPULATION?

>> YES. WE CAN REDUCE IT. >> ARRAY.

THE ORDER THAT REFLECTS THE PARTIES THEN. >> OKAY.

BASED ON THIS DEPLETION BETWEEN THE PARTIES, THEY WILL AGREE TO THE RESPONDENT PAYING $140 FEE.

CLIENT TO NEW TREES, REMOVE THE STUMPS, AND GRIND THE STUMPS THAT ARE ALREADY THERE IN THE

YARD. DOES THAT COVER IT? >> THAT IS CORRECT.

>> THANK YOU. SIR, DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING TO SAY?

>> NO, THANK YOU. >> YOU'RE WELCOME. I'M GLAD YOU GOT IT TAKEN CARE

OF, GOOD LUCK. >> FOR THE RECORD, MY NAME IS ISAAC WITH THE CITY.

[LAUGHTER] I DON'T KNOW IF YOU WANT TO PRESENT THE EMMA GOT FROM PAUL STATING WHAT HE WAS REQUIRING. MAGISTRATE, I UNDERSTAND THAT YOU ALREADY ADOPTED E PARTIES TIES AGREEMENT AND EXPECT TO ISSUE A WRITTEN ORDER, BUT I DO WANT TO MAKE THE PHOTOS A PART OF THE FILE. AND I AM ASKING THAT THEY WOULD JUST BE ADMITTED AS CITIES ONE

COMPOSITE. >> THEY WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.

>> AND ALSO, I WOULD LIKE THE EMAIL, DOESN'T NECESSARILY NEED TO BE AN EXHIBIT, BUT IS A WRITING, THE PARTIES AGREEMENT REDUCED TO WRITING. THAT IS WHAT WILL BE USED TO

DRAFT THE ORDER. >> THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT, YOU'RE FREE TO GO.

[A. 22-2047 313 N 17th St Ricky D Brown, Linda B Brown Isaac Saucedo]

THANK YOU, GOOD LUCK! >> THANK YOU. >> NEXT CASE 22 Ã2047 REGION 13 N. 17TH STREET. RICKY D BROWN AND LINDA B BROWN.

MA'AM, WERE YOU SWORN IN THIS MORNING? OKAY.

ARE YOU GOING TO HAVE SOMEONE ELSE WITH YOU? >> NO, IT IS JUST ME.

>> OKAY. PLEASE RAISE YOUR HAND AND STATE FOR THE RECORD.

>> LINDA B BROWN TO REQUEST USE WHERE THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE ABOUT TO GIVE WILL BE THE

TRUTH? >> YES. >> THIS CASE NUMBER 22 Ã2047, 313 N. 17TH STREET. THE CASE INITIATED ON JUNE 16 OF 2022.

VIOLATORS ARE RICKY D BROWN AND LINDA B BROWN. -- IN FORT PIERCE.

THE VIOLATIONS WERE EXTERIOR STRUCTURE GENERAL. I PMC 702.4 EMERGENCY ESCAPE OPENINGS COVERED WINDOWS, SECTIONS 24 Ã19, 2021 SUBSECTION NUMBER ONE AND FIVE FOR OUTSIDE STORAGE. SECTION 123 Ã37 SUBSECTION 12 LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE, I PMC FIGURE 4.13 WINDOWS, SKELETON DOORFRAMES. SECTION 24 19, 21 SUBSECTION 10 D, NON-OPERABLE VEHICLES. ON DECEMBER 7, 2002, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, FOUND THAT THE OWNER WAS IN VIOLATION IN ORDER TO COMPLY WITH IN 10 DAYS OR BE FINED $150 PER DAY.

ON FEBRUARY 14 OF THIS YEAR, AN AFFIDAVIT OF NONCOMPLIANCE WAS SIGNED BY MYSELF.

THERE WERE 21ST, OF THE SAME YEAR, A NOTICE WAS SENT TO THE OWNER ADVISING THEM THAT THE -- THEY HAVE THE RIGHT TO APPEAL. FEBRUARY 27 THIS YEAR, A REQUEST WAS RECEIVED AND AS OF

[01:40:04]

FINE IS $6030. I HAVE PHOTOS. >> WHILE WE --

>> PHOTOS. >> WHILE THE RESPONDENT IS LOOKING AT THE PHOTOS, I ASKED IF -- DID YOU TAKE THE PHOTOS AND DID THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW?

>> YES. >> AT THE TIME REMOVE THAT CITIES ONE COMPOSITE.

>> MAY I? THE CRITERIA AND ADMIN FEES. >> I CANNOT HEAR YOU.

JUST JUMP IN. >> OKAY PIERCE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE? JUST TO FOLLOW SOME OF OUR PROCEDURES TO REVIEW THE CRITERIA.

THAT CONSIDER THROUGH RULES AND PROCEDURE, THE GRAVITY OR SERIOUSNESS OF THE VIOLATION WAS MODERATE. ANY AND ALL ACTIONS TAKEN TO CORRECT THE VIOLATIONS, THEY DO COMPLETE THEM TO THE MINIMUM STANDARDS REQUIRED. THERE WERE NO PRIOR VIOLATIONS.

I ALSO WANTED TO BRING TO YOUR ATTENTION, AND ADMINISTRATION FEES THAT WERE ALSO USUALLY CONSIDERED IN THIS MATTER. THE COST FOR THE PROCESSING OF THE CASE DEMONSTRATION FEES, TO COME TO A TOTAL OF JUST OVER $1000. THAT DOES INCLUDE THE $400 OF WHAT STAFF CONSIDER SOFT COSTS. SO WE CAN TAKE THAT INTO CONSIDERATION WHEN DETERMINING A REDUCED AMOUNT, IF THAT IS WHAT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WISHES TO DO.AGAIN, TOTAL

FINES WERE $6000. >> AND YOU ARE ASKING -- >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, STAFF

WOULD RIRECOMMEND REDUCTION TO $1000. >> OKAY.

ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NOT FOR ME, NO. >> MA'AM, WOULD YOU STATE YOUR

NAME FOR THE RECORD? >> LINDA BROWN. LINDA B BROWN.

>> THE CITY IS AGREEING TO REDUCE THIS AMOUNT FROM $6000 AND WHATEVER IS COMMON TO

$1000. ARE YOU IN AGREEMENT WITH THAT? >> YES, THANK YOU.

>> HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY THAT?60 DAYS, AT LEAST 30 DAYS.

>> I WILL GIVE YOU 60 DAYS TO PAY. >> THANK YOU.

YOU HAVE TO PAY WITHIN THAT 60 DAY PERIOD OF TIME. IF NOT, THE AMOUNT WILL REVERT

BACK TO THE ORIGINAL AMOUNT THAT THE CITY HAS ASKED FOR. >> IT WILL BE PAID.

>> THANK YOU, GOOD LUCK. >> THANK YOU. THANK YOU ALL.

[B. 22-1168 CE 214 Hialeah Ave Lester Spainhoward (Est), Vivian L Spainhoward Heather Debevec]

QUESTION I APPROACH WITH THE PHOTOS FOR THE FILE, PLEASE? >> THANK YOU.

NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã1168 214 HIALEAH AVENUE. SPAINHOWARD.

>> WERE YOU SWORN IN THIS MORNING? WERE YOU SWORN IN THIS MORNING?

BOTH OF YOU? >> YES. >> MAY I SWEAR HIM IN, PLEASE?

>> YES. >> PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE

RECORD. >> BRIAN DODGE. >> JUICE WHERE THE TESTIMONIES

WERE ABOUT TO GIVE WILL BE THE TRUTH? >> I DO.

>> THANK YOU. CAN YOU ALSO STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD?

>> LESTER SPAINHOWARD JUNIOR. >> THANK YOU. >> WHEN YOU'RE READY.

>> CASE NUMBER 22 Ã1168 214 HIALEAH AVENUE, LESTER 22-3423PK AND VIVIAN L SPAINHOWARD. CASE WAS INITIATED ON MARCH 30 OF 2022.

IT WAS FOR SECTION 125 Ã322 SUBSECTION C, SUBSECTION 1, SUBSECTION 2. HEDGES AND HEIGHT RESTRICTION. OCTOBER 5, 2022, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE ROSS FOUND THE OWNERS OF VIOLATION, GIVE 30 DAYS TO COMPY OR BE FINED $50 PER DAY.

NOVEMBER 18 OF 2022, EXTENSION OF TIME IS GRANTED TO THE OWNERS, DECEMBER 20, 2022, AFFIDAVIT OF PARTIAL COMPLIANCE FOR RESPONSIBLE CONTAINERS, AFFIDAVIT NONCOMPLIANCE FOR MANY VIOLATION BOTH SENT TO THE OWNER. JANUARY 4 OF THIS YEAR, A LETTER SINCE THE OWNER, FEBRUARY 3 OF THIS YEAR, AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE WAS

SENT TO THE OWNER. FEBRUARY 14, [INAUDIBLE] >> THE SERIOUSNESS OF VIOLATION

[01:45:10]

NO PREVIOUS VIOLATIONS. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, WE HAVE COMPILED THE ADMINISTRATION COSTS FOR ADMINISTERING THE CASE FILE. AND IT DOES INCLUDE THE SOFT COSTS OF $450, WHICH WE DO TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION. I'M SORRY, I DID NOT PUT ON

HERE HOW MUCH THE FINE CAME TO. KAT, DO YOU HAVE THAT BY ANY CHANCE?>> I DO NOT AT THIS

TIME. LET ME SEE. >> BECAUSE THE FINE RAN FROM DECEMBER 20 THROUGH FEBRUARY 3. BUT AGAIN, STAFF IS RECOMMENDING THE REDUCTION TO $1000. I DON'T HAVE THE TOTAL AMOUNT THAT WAS DUE.

BUT IT WAS -- LET ME... HEATHER, DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING IN THE FILE WITH THAT?

>> I JUST HAVE WHAT YOU HAD PLACED ON THE SCREEN. >> MAY I SEE THE MASSEY LETTER? THE MASSEY LETTER SHOULD HAVE THE -- IT WAS RUNNING AT $50 PER DAY FROM DECEMBER 20 THROUGH FEBRUARY 3. ROUGHLY, 45 DAYS, ROUGHLY THAT IT RAN AT $50 A DAY.

CALCULATOR? SORRY. 45C0.

>> 2250. >> THE FINE IS ABOUT $2250. I APOLOGIZE.

WE USUALLY HAVE THAT ON THE DOCUMENT. CAN YOU PULL THE ADMIN BACKUP?

[01:58:27]

>> HOW MUCH TIME? >> I'M SORRY, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE?

[01:58:29]

>> ARE YOU READY? >> WE ARE READY.> I WAS WAITING ON YOU.

OKAY. WHAT IS THE RECOMMENDATION? >> THAT WAS RECOMMENDING $1000.

>> OKAY. >> I DO WANT TO POINT OUT 450 THAT IS SOFT COSTS, SPECIAL

METRIC COULD TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION.>> OKAY. ALL RIGHT.

STATE YOUR NAMES. >> -- 22-3423PK JUNIOR. >> BRIAN SCOTT --

>> THE CITY RECOMMENDATION IS $1000? >> I DON'T APPROVE THAT.>> WE

DON'T AGREE WITH THAT. >> WE DON'T AGREE. >> I WILL LET YOU ALL --

>> IF I COULD STAY FOR A SECOND? >> SURE.

HOLD ON . REVIEW ALL SWORN IN? >> YES MA'AM.

>> YOUR NAME? >> BRIAN DIED. >> CAME IN FRONT OF YOU OCTOBER 1 LAST YEAR. PERTAINING TO A CITATION THAT HAD TWO COMPLAINTS ON FROM THE CODE ENFORCEMENT. ONE OF THEM WAS VERY RIDICULOUS.

IT WAS, THERE WAS NO LETTERS OR NUMBERS ON THE MAILBOX. WHICH YOU HAD TO NOTIFY AND RETRACT BECAUSE THEY COULD NOT SEE THE NUMBERS BECAUSE THEY PUT THE SIGN FOR THE VIOLATION OF THE MAILBOX PIT IS WHAT WE ARE DEALING WITH HERE. WE'RE GETTING SIGNS WE VIOLATED AND CITED FOR THESE THINGS THAT PEOPLE CANNOT SEE. OR THEY ARE MAKING UP.

[02:00:02]

WERE VERY HARD. MY MOTHER-IN-LAW IS VERY ILL. VERY INCAPACITATED.

INDIGENT. AND SO IS MY BROTHER-IN-LAW. HE JUST GOT TO WHERE HE COULD WALK. MAYBE FOUR WEEKS AGO. HE ALMOST DIED.

MAYBE THE SAME TIME LAST OCTOBER. I'VE BEEN DOING THIS, HELPING OUT MY FAMILY. I THOUGHT EVERYTHING WAS RESOLVED BECAUSE I TRIMMED ANIMATION THE VIOLATION SIGN IS OFF THE MAILBOX. THEN THERE SOMETHING ABOUT SOME GARBAGE CANS. MY TRUCK AND TRAILER PARK ON THE SIDE OF THE ROAD, I KNOW THEY ARE NOT THERE VERY OFTEN. MAYBE A DAY OR TWO OUT OF PLACE.

BECAUSE YOUR PEOPLE THAT ARE NOT ABLE TO WALK. MY BROTHER-IN-LAW CALLED ME THE OTHER DAY. TELLS ME HE GETS ANOTHER CITATION NOTICE.

AND THERE'S 1000 OR $1100 FINE IMPOSED. I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW THIS $450 FINE IS. BECAUSE YOU ARE IMPOSING ON MY FAMILY.

I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW WHAT THESE OTHER FINDS ARE. BECAUSE WE ARE NOT IN VIOLATION. WE FIX THE VIOLATIONS. WHY DO YOU KEEP COMING AFTER MY MOTHER-IN-LAW? ENTER PROPERTY? BECAUSE SHE DOESN'T HAVE A PRETTY PRISTINE HOME? IS THAT WHAT IT IS? MAGISTRATE.

BECAUSE IF IT IS, WE NEED TO START GOING DOWN A DIFFERENT PATH IN HERE.

>> IS HE THAT THE PROPERTY HAS BEEN COMPLIANT. >> IT IS IN COMPLIANCE.

>> OKAY AND THEN YOU ARE CITED FOR THE PROPERTY BEING IN NONCOMPLIANCE AND THE CITY IS

AGREEING TO REDUCE THE FINE. >> I DO AGREE TO ANY FINES. IF ALL $50 FINE, THAT WAS A FIRST INITIAL INSTANCE THAT SOMEBODY CAME OUT AND SAID WE NEEDED TO TRIM THE TREES.

WHICH, WE DID KNOW WE NEED TO TRIM THE TREES. MY FATHER-IN-LAW PASSED AWAY A YEAR AGO. MY MOTHER-IN-LAW CANNOT MOVE. OUTSIDE OF HER HOME.

AND MY BROTHER-IN-LAW JUST GOT OUT OF THE HOSPITAL. THESE THINGS ARE VERY VERY RUDE. AND ALMOST UNCONSTITUTIONAL. ISTEN TO WHAT I'M SAYING.

$450 THAT YOU ALL ARE PROPOSING, VERY VERY UNCONSTITUTIONAL.

>> WHAT WAS THE $450? >> RIDICULOUSNESS. >> WHAT WAS THE 454?

>> RIDICULOUS. YOU TELL ME WHAT IT WAS MA'AM BECAUSE I WANT TO KNOW.

I WANT TO KNOW. IT'S SOFT. SAFE, SOFT, WAS IT? SOFT. QUICK SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. APPARENTLY HE DIDN'T UNDERSTAND. I WILL BE EXPLAINED. THE FINES WERE INITIATED.

DECEMBER AT $50 PER DAY. HE ACCUMULATED TO OVER $2200. >> THE MAGISTRATE JUSTMENTIONED THAT THE FINE , THAT THE CITATIONS WERE RESOLVED. SO, HOW CAN THIS CONTINUE IF

THE THINGS WERE RESOLVED? >> THE FINES CONTINUED AT $50 A DAY BETWEEN THE DAY OF NONCOMPLIANCE, SIMMER 20TH, AND WHAT WAS BOUND TO BE IN COMPLIANCE ON FEBRUARY 3. $50 PER DAY, THE FINES ACCUMULATED TO $2250. WE ARE BEFORE YOU TODAY, TO ADDRESS THOSE FINES, AND DETERMINE WHETHER THE FINE SHOULD STAY AS IS, $2250.

OR IT SHOULD BE REDUCED TO A DIFFERENT DOLLAR AMOUNT. STAFF ASSEMBLED THE ADMINISTRATION CHARGES FOR PROCESSING THE CASE.WHICH IS THE FORM ON YOUR RIGHT.

AND SO, ALL THOSE FEES ARE FOR THE PROCESS IN THE CASE. MAILING LETTERS, PHOTOGRAPHS.

IN THIS, IS A $450 FEE, WHICH STEPH SAYS ARE CONSIDERED SOFT COSTS.

WHICH THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE CAN CONSIDER. THE TOTAL OF THE MINISTRATION CHARGES IS $1134. STAFF IS RECOMMENDING REDUCED NOT TO A TOTAL OF $1000.

BUT IT IS UP TO THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, TO DETERMINE WHICH -- THE, WHAT IF ANYTHING,

SHOULD BE DUE TO THE CITY. >> MAY I SPEAK ONE MORE TIME? >> ARE YOU LOOKING AT THE FILES

APPEAR ON THE SCREEN? >> YES MA'AM I SEE IT RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME.

[02:05:01]

>> OKAY. >> LIKE I SAID, I CAME IN THIS THING TRYING TO BE A GOOD CITIZEN, TO HELP OUT THE ISSUE WITH CODE COMPLIANCE. TRY TO HELP OUT MY FAMILY.

THERE WAS NO OTHER INDICATION, NO INFORMATION. I JUST ASKED MY BROTHER IN LAW AGAINST GOT NO NOTICE OF ANYTHING. WHEN IT CAME BACK TO THIS WHEN I CAME TO THIS HEARING, THERE WAS TWO ISSUES. FINES BEING IN FOES, THERE WAS NONE OF THAT. WE ALREADY WORKED ON IT MA'AM. WE ALREADY STARTED TAKING CARE OF IT. WE STARTED DOING IT. THIS IS JUST A FEW MONTHS OLD.

I HAVE BEEN WITNESS TO THINGS GOING ON FOR 10 YEARS, 10 YEARS, AND YOU'RE LETTING PEOPLE GO FOR $6000 REPRIEVES. I'M JUST ASKING FOR A LITTLE BREAK.

MY MOTHER-IN-LAW IS ABOUT DEAD. MY BROTHER-IN-LAW IS ABOUT DEAD.

HELL, WE ARE ALL ABOUT DEAD! CUT US A BREAK. -- CUT US A BREAK.

THIS IS ILLEGAL. $450 IS ILLEGAL. ALMOST HALF THE FINE.

I DON'T EVEN WANT TO TALK ABOUT THAT BECAUSE THAT IS RIDICULOUS! I WOULD SAY $100 AND WE WILL BE EVEN. WASTING MY TIME, EVERYBODY

ELSE'S TIME. THAT IS HOW I FEEL ABOUT IT. >> SIR, THE CASE IS OPEN FOR

NINE MONTHS. >> A SHORT AMOUNT OF TIME. THAT IS A VERY SHORT AMOUNT OF TIME. VERY SHORT. CONSIDERING THE SIX YEARS TERM THAT WE JUST WITNESSED HERE IN THIS BODY. AND LEE, AND THE FOLKS HE WAS SO EAGER TO GIVE THEM A BREAK. $6000? LET'S WORK IT OUT MA'AM.

LET'S WORK THIS OUT. >> YOU'RE IN VIOLATION, IS DIFFERENT.

>> IS $6000 FOR SIX YEARS. AND YOU'RE TALKING NINE MONTHS AND $1300.

THERE IS A BIG DIFFERENCE. WORK WITH ME MA'AM, THAT'S ALL I'M ASKING.

>> I WILL AGREE WITH THE STATE AND REDUCES TO $1000. HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO

PAY IT? >> I WILL HAVE TO TALK TO MY MOTHER SHE'S ON SOCIAL SECURITY

AND DISABILITY. I WILL HAVE TO TALK TO HER. >> AND RENAME AGAIN FOR THE

RECORD? >> HOW CAN WE DIDN'T GET HIS NO PICTURES OR NOTHING?

>> LESTER -- SPAINHOWARD JUNIOR PICKWICK THIS IS A FARCE. WE DID GET THE RESPECT OF THE SAME PEOPLE HERE FOR THIS LIMITED SHOWS NO PICTURES, NOTHING GOT DOCUMENTED.

WHAT'S GOING ON HERE? >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I WANT TO PUT A FEW THINGS ON THE

RECORD. >> THANK YOU. >> I KNOW THAT THE TIMELINE WAS MENTIONED EARLIER. BUT I WANT TO COVER IT AGAIN, JUST OF THE RECORD IS CLEAR.

THERE WAS A REGULATION FOUND ON OCTOBER 5, 2022. AT THAT TIME, THERE WAS AN ORDER TO COMPLY OR FINES OF 50,000 BE ASSESSED. NOVEMBER 2022, IT WAS APPARENTLY, AN EXTENSION OF THAT 30 DAYS GRANTED. WHICH THEN, GIVE THE RESPONDENT MORE TIME TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE. SO, DECEMBER 2022, AN AFFIDAVIT OF PARTIAL COMPLIANCE WAS FILED AS TO CONTAINERS, I ASSUME THAT WERE ON THE PROPERTY.

AND ON THE SAME DATE, AN AFFIDAVIT OF NONCOMPLIANCE, WAS FILED AS TO OTHER REMAINING VIOLATION. AND SO, I THINK SUBSEQUENTLY ON FEBRUARY 3, OF THIS YEAR, AN AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE WAS SENT. SO, THE REASON THERE ARE NO PHOTOS IN THE RECORD AT THIS TIME, IS BECAUSE NO ONE IS SAYING THE RESPONDENTS ARE NOT IN COMPLIANCE AS OF THIS DATE. THE ISSUE IS JUST, THE TIME IT TOOK TO CLEAR THE LAST ISSUE.

IT IS MY UNDERSTANDING THAT STAFF IS ASKING THE FINES ASSOCIATED WITH THE ADDITIONAL

TIME, BE REMOVED COMPLETELY. IS THAT ACCURATE? >> JUST REDUCED.

>> REDUCED. >> $1000. >> $1000.

IT'S -- SO, I JUST WANT TO MAKE IT CLEAR THERE ARE NO PHOTOS IN THE RECORD.

IN NOTICING THE PROPERTY IS NOT IN COMPLIANCE RIGHT NOW. IT'S JUST THAT I TOOK A LITTLE BIT OF EXTRA TIME TO DO THAT. AND THAT, THE PROCEDURAL POSTURE WE ARE IN.

[02:10:01]

>> CLOSE TO SIX YEARS? >> AGAIN, I WILL NOT COMMENT ON OTHER CASES.

>> WE ARE GOING TO COMMENT. >> WE ALLOW YOU, THE CITY WILL ALLOW YOU TO MAKE MONTHLY

PAYMENT. >> MA'AM, WE DON'T NEED TO MAKE MONTHLY PAYMENTS ON A FRAUDULENT CHARGE HERE. THIS IS FRAUDULENT. OKAY? WE GOT THE NOTICE IN OCTOBER. WE CLEANED UP, IT WAS A FALSE ISSUE ABOUT THE MAILBOX.

THAT WAS NOT ANYTHING TO SPEAK OF. AND IT WAS THE TREES.

WE GOT THEM DONE. HOW IS IT NOW, THAT WE ARE $1000? WE GOT IT STRAIGHTENED OUT. THERE WAS NO OTHER COMMUNICATION BETWEEN THE ORGANIZATION, AND MY BROTHER-IN-LAW. BECAUSE WHEN HE GOT OUT OF THE

HOSPITAL, HE WAS HANDLING IT. WHO'S A PERSON YOU SPOKE TO? >> HEATHER.

>> IS HEATHER HERE? >> RIGHT HERE SIR. >> YOU ARE THERE.

>> I'M HERE. >> YOU SPOKE TO MY BROTHER-IN-LAW AFTER I SPOKE TO EDDIE SAID WAS GETTING DONE AND YOU SAID EVERY LOOK GOOD. SO YOU COME BACK AND FILED ANOTHER FINE ON US? I WOULD LIKE TO KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON.

>> FINES -- HOLD ON A MINUTE. YOU'RE GETTING CARRIED AWAY. >> NO MAN GETTING TO THE BOTTOM

OF THIS RIDICULOUSNESS. >> HOLDERMAN WANT TO TRY AND HELP YOU TO ENTRY PEOPLE AVE TRIED TO EXPLAIN TO YOU WHAT'S GOING ON. EXCUSE ME.

THE PROPERTY WAS REPORTED AS NEEDING TO BE TAKEN CARE OF. >> AND IT WAS.

IN THE ALLOWABLE TIME. >> EXCUSE ME, OKAY? >> YES MA'AM.

>> FOR WHATEVER REASON, IT TOOK A WHILE TO COME INTO COMPLIANCE.

I THINK YOU SAID FOUR MONTHS? >> NINE. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THE CASE INITIATED IN MARCH. WE DIDN'T BRING HEARING UNTIL OCTOBER.

THEN WE STARTED FINES IN DECEMBER. >> MARCH?

>> I DON'T KNOW NOTHING ABOUT MARCH. >> SHE JUST TOLD YOU THAT IT

STARTED IN MARCH. >> WHERE THE FINES IMPOSED AT THAT TIME? NO. THERE WERE NO FINES I CAME IN OCTOBER THERE WERE NO FINES.

YOU GIVE ME 30 DAYS TO CLEAN IT UP. >> SIR, YOU DIDN'T COME INTO

COMPLIANCE UNTIL DECEMBER 20 2022. >> I DON'T UNDERSTAND HOW THAT IS. THERE WAS ONLY TWO ISSUES. THE MAILBOX, AND THE FENCE.

AND WE CLEANED THE FENCE UP. WHERE ARE THE PICTURES TO PROVE THIS? THAT'S WHAT I'M TRYING TO TELL YOU MA'AM. IF WE NEED TO HAVE ANOTHER HEARING ON THIS, WE SHOULD DO THIS AND GET YOUR STUFF TOGETHER BECAUSE WE WILL COME READY. BECAUSE YOU WANT TAKE MY MOTHER'S HOUSE AND LET THESE

OTHER FOLKS LEAVE A $6000 WITH 280. >> SIR.

>> THAT'S WHERE I'M T. >> DO WE HAVE A FILE? HOLD ON A MINUTE.> YES

MA'AM, YOU GOT MY TIME. >> DO HAVE A FILE WITH PICTURES OF THE PLACE BEFORE THEY DO EY

DO THE REPAIR? BEFORE THEY CLEANED UP? >> YES MA'AM.

>> DO YOU, YOU WANT TO CONTINUE THIS? YOU HAVE TO COME BACK.

AND I HOPE WHEN YOU DO, >> LOSE MY ATTITUDE? THEY COVERED ABOUT $450 I'M

HAPPY. >> YOU ARE A GROWN MA'AM. >> YES MA'AM.

>> BUT WHEN YOU COME HERE YOU ABIDE BY THE RULES LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE.

>> I HOPE I HAVE BEEN. I'VE NOT BEEN DISRESPECTFUL I DIDN'T SAY ANYTHING.

>> YES YOU HAVE. >> YOU JUST DON'T LIKE MY DEMEANOR.

>> WHEN HIS NEXT HEARING? >> YES MA'AM. >> 17 MAY.

OR ACTUALLY, WE CAN SQUEEZE HIM IN ON 5 APRIL. >> OKAY IS ALL RIGHT WITH YOU?

>> YES MA'AM.> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, FOR THE RECORD, YOUR RESERVING RULING AT THIS POINT. WE WILL CONTINUE THE HEARING AT WHICH TIME YOU WILL CONSIDER

ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE, IF -- >> HE WANTS TO SEE THE PICTURES SO WE WILL SHOW HIM THE

PICTURES. >> YES MA'AM. >> AND SHE CAN CHANGE HER OFFER IF YOU WANT TO. BECAUSE YOU'RE MAKING THEM DO ADDITIONAL WORK NOW THAT YOU

DON'T WANT TO PAY FOR. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE I BELIEVE THE PHOTOS ARE AVAILABLE AT

THIS TIME. >> WE WILL CONTINUE, IT'S FINE WE WILL BRING IT BACK.

>> WILL WILL DO IF YOU CAN MAKE PHOTOCOPIES AND GIVE THEM COPIES OF THE PHOTOS FOR THEM

TO TAKE HOME WITH THEM. >> IT'S GOING TO BE APRIL 5, WEDNESDAY AND HERE IN THE SAME

PLACE AT 9:00 A.M. . >> WE WRITE THAT DOWN FOR US,

PLEASE? >> SURE. LET ME SEE IF I HAVE -- YOU

WILL RECEIVE SOMETHING IN THE MAIL AS WELL. >> WE DID RECEIVE ANYTHING

[02:15:04]

THERE IS NO INFORMATION. >> HEATHER WILL TAKE CARE OF ALL THAT.

SO WE CAN MOVE ONTO THE NEXT CASE. >> WILL PROVIDE THE PHOTOS TODAY, CORRECT?

WE CAN CONTINUE OUR HEARING. >> TO BE CLEAR, ARE THOSE PHOTOS THAT WERE ALREADY ENTERED IN EVIDENCE OF PREVIOUS STATES? P?

>> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> I THINK THEY ARE LEAVING THE BUILDING.

>> GO GET THEM, HEATHER.AKE YOUR FILE, TAKE YOUR FILE! TAKE YOUR FILE AND GO GET THEM.

>> OKAY! >> ALL RIGHT, I'M JUMPING TO 7A.

[A. LC/Multi 513 N 14th St Dominique Etienne Peggy Arraiz]

REDUCTION BEFORE YOU. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THIS IS A LEAN REACTION OF DEMOLITION CASES THIS UNDER THE NEW RULES OF PROCEDURE. THESE NEVER, THESE TYPES OF CASES NEVER CAME FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION BEFORE UNTIL THE NEW RULES OF PROCEDURE ADOPTED LAST YEAR. THIS IS THE FIRST ONE THAT HAS COME BEFORE YOU.

>> OKAY. >> WE HAVE, THEIR ACTION, I COMBINED THREE REQUESTS INTO ONE AGENDA ITEM. SO WE DO NOT FALL BACK AND FORTH BETWEEN DIFFERENT AGENDA ITEMS. I WILL READ THIS FROM THE TOP THIS IS FOR ADJUSTER NUMBER 513 N. 14TH STREET. OWNED BY DOMINIQUE ETIENNE. WE ARE TODAY FOR A LEAN REDUCTION OF LOT CLEARING AND DEMOLITION.ITEM NUMBER ONE, WE HAVE I WILL HIGHLIGHT THIS RIGHT HERE SO WE HAVE THREE COLUMNS. THIS THE AMOUNT DUE.

THIS IS WHAT THE APPLICANT REQUESTED. THIS IS STAFF RECOMMENDATION.

WE WILL DO THE SAME FOR ALL THREE TYPES. THIS IS LOT CLEARING NUMBER ONE. WE THE CITY INCURRED FEES, $2557.74.

ADMINISTRATION FEES OF $2253.49. ADMINISTRATION CHARGES THAT ARE ASSESSED DURING EACH OF THE LOT CLEARING THAT ARE DONE. INTEREST HAS ACCRUED TO $4369 AND 96 --. HEARING CHARGE OF $250. TOTAL DUE TO THE CITY IS 10,000 FORTON $7.89. THE APPLICANT HAS REQUESTED THAT ALL OF THE COST WITH THE EXCEPTION OF THE HARD COSTS OF $2557.74 BE WAIVED. STAFF IS RECOMMENDING THE REDUCTION TO BE THE HARD COST OF $2557.74. THE MINISTRATION CHARGES AND HEARING FEE OF $250 FOR $5161.23. DO YOU WANT ME TO READ ALL OF THEM AND AT THE SAME TIME? OR WANT TO DO EACH INDIVIDUALLY?

>> WE CAN DO EACH ONE INDIVIDUALLY FOR THE RECORD. >> OKAY.

AT THIS TIME, I'M GOING TOO FAR. THE FIRST REQUEST FOR LOT CLEARING REDUCTION IS FROM $10,407.89, APPLICANT IS REQUESTING 2557.74 STAFF

REQUESTING 5161.23. >> STATE YOUR NAME? >> DOMINIQUE ETIENNE.

>> WE SWORN IN THIS MORNING? >> I DID. >> THANK YOU.

SORRY ABOUT THAT. >> I PURCHASED THE PROPERTY FROM A TAX BID I DID REVIEW THE FILES, BUT THERE WERE SOME PAPERS I DID NOT FULLY REVIEW. BUT AFTER PURCHASE IT, WORK ON THE TITLE, I WAS TRYING TO SELL THE PROPERTY. THAT IS WHEN I HAD THE PROBLEM WITH THE CLOSING. AND I THINK THE LEAN IS TOO HIGH.

I WAS WONDERING IF IT CAN BE REMOVED. IT WAS THERE BY THE PREVIOUS

OWNER. BEFORE THE PROPERTY SALE. >> HE BOUGHT THIS PROPERTY,

FROM THE COUNTY. >> YOU BUT ON A TAX SALE. >> YES.

>> THE PROPERTY NEEDED CLEARING. IS THAT CORRECT?

[02:20:06]

>> NO MA'AM. THESE THINGS WERE IN EXISTENCE WHEN SHE PURCHASED THE

PROPERTY. >> THEY WAS IN BEFORE. >> OH.

>> YES. I WAS ONE OF ITS CAN BE REMOVED FOR THE BEST THAT CAN BE DONE.

>> I HAVE A BUYER TRYING TO BUY IT. HE IS PLANNING ON BUILDING IT, HE SAYS WITHIN A FEW MONTHS. THERE IS A PROGRAM TO BUILD, I CANNOT AFFORD IT.

I THINK IT COST SO MUCH NOW FOR ME TO WORK ON BUILDING A. AND I THINK THE BUYER IS BETTER TO BUY IT AND BUILD IT. BUT HE CANNOT BITE WITH ALL OF THE LIENS.

THAT'S WHAT I COME TO SEE IF THEY CAN BE REMOVED. >> THE AMOUNT DUE IS $10,407.89. THE COURT IS TRYING TO REDUCE THAT.

IT'S IN HALF. >> THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY AS OF NOW IS 13,000.

AND A LOT OF OTHER EXPENSE I DID FOR THE TITLE WORK. TOTAL IS ABOUT 6000.

AND HAVE LIKE A CLOSING STATEMENT HERE. I DO KNOW IF IT WILL HELP.

>> IS THE 6000 FOR ALL THREE LOTS? >> NO.

THE REASON I SAY 6000, BECAUSE HE PAID A COMPANY FOR TITLE INSURANCE.

CERTIFICATES, CERTIFICATION FOR THE BUYER TO BE ABLE TO HAVE TITLE INSURANCE ON THE PROPERTY. IT HAS TO DO WITH THE TAGS, TO MAKE SURE EVERYTHING WAS DONE

RIGHT, TO THE AUCTION BEFORE THE AUCTION. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.

THIS PROPERTY HAS BEEN A VACANT PROPERTY THE CITY HAS BEEN MAINTAINING FOR MANY YEARS.

IT WENT UP FOR TAX SALE DATE WHICH IS HOW MS. DOMINIQUE ETIENNE PURCHASED IT.

WHEN YOU BUY A TAX DEED, HE ALSO BY THE LIENS THAT EXIST ON THE PROPERTY.

SHE'S ATTEMPTING TO GET A WARRANTY DEED TO TRANSFER THE TITLE, IN ORDER TO DO THAT SHE HAS TO CLEAR THE LIENS UP. IT IS A SINGLE PROPERTY BUT THERE ARE THREE MAIN TYPES OF LIENS. TWO DIFFERENT LOT CLEARING LIENS, AND ONE DEMOLITION LEAN ALSO. THESE ARE JUST THE FIRST GROUP OF LIENS FOR LOT CLEARANCE.

THAT IS BEING ADDRESSED AT THIS TIME. >> YOU UNDERSTAND THAT?

>> YES I DO UNDERSTAND. >> PEGGY, DO WE NEED TO SUBMIT THIS INTO EVIDENCE?

WHAT SHE HAS? >> YES. I HAVE TWO PAPERS.

THIS HAVE TO DO WITH THE CLOSING AND -- >> I THINK I HAVE ANOTHER QUESTION. AND THAT ONE -- CERTIFICATION FOR TITLE INSURANCE.

THAT'S WHAT IT'S FOR. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I SUPPOSE WE CAN GO AHEAD AND

ADMIT THESE AS RESPONDENTS ONE COMPOSITE. >> IS AT OUR PROPERTY?

-- OUR COPY? >> YES. >> THESE WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. THE TOTAL AMOUNT YOU ARE ASKING FOR,

>> IS ALWAYS POSSIBLE. LESS THAN A THOUSAND. >> TOTAL AMOUNT YOU ARE ASKING

FOR? >> STAFF IS RECOMMENDING THE HARD COST LESS ADMINISTRATION CHARGES OF 2353.49 AND HEARING FEE OF $250 FOR TOTAL OF 5161.23 SPECIAL MAGISTRATE IF YOU WANT WE CAN PULL UP RULES OF PROCEDURE IF YOU WANT TO REVIEW THEM FOR ANY REASON.

>> YOU'RE ASKING FOR 5161.23 TOTAL? NO, THAT'S THE FIRST LEAN.

>> THE FIRST SET OF LIENS. >> THE OTHER ONE IS 480. >> YES, I DID NOT PRESENT THAT YET. BUT I CAN. IF YOU WISH, THERE IS A SECOND GROUP OF LOT CLEARING LIENS BASICALLY, THE REASON FOR THAT IS HOW THE CITY FUNDED IT AT

[02:25:03]

MENSTRUATION FEE OF 100, JUST OF 208 15, PENALTIES OF 4163 AND HEARING FEE OF $250.

THE TOTAL DUE FOR THAT SET OF LIENS IS 730.55. THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING EVERYTHING BE WAIVED EXCEPT THE HARD COST, WHICH IS 130.77 AND STUFF IS RECOMMENDING THAT CAUSE THE APPLICATION FEE. AND A THIRD LINK DEMOLITION THAT OCCURRED ON THE PROPERTY.

THE CITY INCURRED FEES $2200, COMMISSION FEES OF $81.05. INTEREST 4087. 87, -- APPLICATION FEE FOR THE REDUCTION OF 250 FOR A TOTAL OF $7216.32.

THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTING ALL OF THE COST EXCEPT FOR HARD COST BE WAIVED.TAFF IS RECOMMENDING THE ADMINISTRATION FEES AND APPLICATION FEE. OF 2531.

ALTOGETHER THERE IS 10,400, 700 AND -- THE APPLICANT REQUESTING TO PAY 2500, 130 AND 2200.

STAFF IS RECOMMENDING 5161, 480, AND 2531. >> THAT IS A TOTAL OF WHAT

YOU'RE ASKING, 8172.28? >> IF YOU RAN THOSE UP WILL BE 8000 SOMETHING, YEAH.

>> YES. AND 10, 17, 18,000 ROTHYS WHAT DO THE CITY.

IT WOULD BE WAVING APPROXIMATELY $10,000. >> YOU UNDERSTAND THAT MS.

DOMINIQUE ETIENNE? >> YES, I UNDERSTAND. BUT THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY IS NOT SO HIGH. IT IS A LOW VALUE PROPERTY. THAT'S WHAT I WOULD LIKE FOR IT TO BE REDUCED. TO LESS THAN A THOUSAND.ND I HAVE A BUYER.

HE PLANNED ON BUILDING SOMETHING ON THE PROPERTY. I THINK IT WOULD BE GOOD FOR THE AREA. FURTHER PROPERTY. INSTEAD OF BEING VACANT.

>> I SHOW TOTAL FOR THE CITY OF 8172.28. DOES EVERYBODY ELSE HAVE THE

SAME AMOUNT? >> THAT SOUNDS CORRECT. >> MA'AM, YOU'VE GOT THREE

LOTS. 8172.28 IS NOT BAD! >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE IT IS ONE

LOT. >> 25 LIENS TOTAL, I BELIEVE. BETWEEN LOT CLEARING AND DEMOLITION ON THE ONE LOT. THAT'S WHAT COMES UP WITH THESE TOTALS.

THERE WAS APPROXIMATELY, DID I GIVE YOU THE LIST OF LIENS? >> I CAN PULL THAT UP.

I MIGHT HAVE IT. >> HERE IS A LIST OF LIENS WE HAVE.

WHICH I CAN PRESENT INTO EVIDENCE. BUT THERE IS, ONE, TWO, THREE, FOUR, FIVE, SIX, SEVEN, EIGHT, NINE, -- 26 LIENS IN TOTAL. ON THIS PROPERTY.

THESE ARE THE TOTAL AMOUNTS DUE. >> AND YOU DON'T FIND WHERE

8172.28 WORKS, FOR THE CITY HAS DONE FOR THE PROPERTY? >> I THINK -- I DO THINK THE CITY SPEND A LOT OF MONEY FOR THE PROPERTY, YES. BUT THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY IS NOT, IT IS NOT SO HIGH. IF IT WAS WORTH MORE LIKE 20,000, 25,000, I WOULD UNDERSTAND. BUT THE PRICE FOR THE PROPERTY. AND I UNDERSTAND FOR MANY YEARS, AND HAVE PROBLEMS FOR A LONG TIME. AND THAT'S WHY NOW I THINK IT IS BETTER YOU KNOW FOR SOMEONE TO OWN IT. SOMEONE THAT WOULD DO SOMETHING. BECAUSE BUILDING SOMETHING ON THE PROPERTY EITHER A SMALL BUSINESS OR A HOUSE, I THINK IS BEST TO CLEAR IT OUT AND JUST RESTART IT.> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE? THIS INFORMATION WAS SHARED WITH STAFF.

[02:30:05]

RITA CAN BE GREATER REDUCTIONS CONSIDERED. BUT IT DOES REQUIRE BUILDING WITHIN A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF TIME AND THEIR REQUIREMENTS. THEIR BENCHMARKS HAVE TO BE MET. WE DIDN'T PROVIDE THE INFORMATION TO MS. 11 BUT SHE

DID DECLINE THE OFFER. >> YES BECAUSE I'M NOT READY TO DO SOMETHING ON THE LOT.

KNOW I HAVE TO COME UP WITH A PLAN. I CANNOT JUST WAIT ON IT.

I HAD TO COME, TRY, I LOOK FOR COMPANIES BUT IT IS PRICEY AT THE MOMENT TO BUILD SOMETHING

ON THE PROPERTY. >> WANTED TO CONTINUE THIS? >> THIS IS AT HER REQUEST.

>> DID YOU UNDERSTAND? I MEAN YOU BOUGHT IT AT A TAX SALE.

LOOK UP THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY? HE DID LOOK TO SEE IF THERE ANY LIENS ON IT AT THE TIME?> ACTUALLY, I DID LOOK AT THE FILES.UT I DID NOT LOOK AT ALL THE FILES. I LOOK AT I THINK THE FIRST AND TO SECTION BUT WHEN THEY LEAN ISSUE COMES UP, I WENT BACK TO SEE WHAT I MISSED AND I SAID WAIT A MINUTE I DID NOT SEE THAT. SO WHEN I GO BACK, I SEE MORE SECTIONS.

IT HAS SO MANY PAPERS. USUALLY PROPERTIES ARE LOOK UP IN TAX LIENS YOU KNOW, BEFORE PURCHASE, THEY DON'T HAVE THAT MANY FILED. I BOUGHT ANOTHER ONE, IT IS ONLY ONE SECTION. BUT THAT ONE WHEN I WENT BACK, THUS I NOTICED THE LIENS WAS THERE. I DID NOT NOTICE THEM. IF I DID NOTICE THE MODE TRY TO WORK YOU KNOW THE LIENS OUT BEFORE EVEN PURCHASE. PURCHASE THE PROPERTY.

>> QUITE FRIENDLY, I DON'T SEE WHERE THIS 5000, $8172.20 IS UNREASONABLE.

IT SOUNDS LIKE YOU'VE BEEN BUYING AND SELLING TAX SALE DEEDS FOR A WHILE.

>> NOT A WHILE, I'M NEW TO IT. I WAS TRYING TO FOCUS -- I RATHER BUY STUFF HERE THAN IN OTHER COUNTIES. I WAS FOCUSING IN ST. LUCIE COUNTY.

I AM NEW TO IT. NOW I AM RUNNING AND GETTING MORE EXPERIENCE, I AM NEW TO IT. I AM NEW TO IT. THE OTHER ONE I DID WELL WITH IT. BUT THIS ONE I MISSED IT BY MISTAKE THEY DID NOT LOOK AT

THE FILE PROPERLY. >> DID YOU UNDERSTAND WHAT MR. REYES SAID ABOUT THE LEAN?

>> YES, I DO UNDERSTAND. I DO UNDERSTAND. BUT THERE ARE SOME COUNTY THAT IN A SITUATION LIKE THAT, USUALLY WOULD REDUCE THEM. BECAUSE THEY WANTED TO BE GOOD DANNY. THEY JUST WANT, THEY WANT, THEY WERE THE PROPERTY TO BE BACK IN THE MARKET BEING USED. NOT JUST SIT THERE BECAUSE I HAVE A LEAN ON IT.

I DON'T KNOW. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I THINK WHAT MR. REYES WAS TRYING TO POINT OUT THAT WE HAVE PROGRAMS, BUT THEY MAY NOT FIT THE NEEDS OF THIS PARTICULAR RESPONDENT. SO, THE MATTERS BEFORE YOU, TODAY, AT HER REQUEST, SHE CAN EITHER REQUEST THAT YOU RULE TODAY IF THERE IS ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE THAT SHE HAS TO PROVIDE, SHE CAN ASKED TO PROVIDE THAT. I HAVEN'T HEARD THAT FROM HER

BUT IS EITHER WILL MAKE A DECISION TODAY OR NOT. >> YOU UNDERSTAND THAT MS.

DOMINIQUE ETIENNE? >> YES. >> I JUST FIND THE CITIES OFFERS PRETTY GENEROUS. IT COMES TO A TOTAL THAT THEY ARE ASKING FOR YOU $8172.28.

IT IS A BIG DIFFERENCE FROM THE TOTAL DUE INITIALLY WAS $10,407.89.

>> I UNDERSTAND. >> LOT 1. I JUST DON'T THINK THAT THERE

[02:35:04]

ARE FRAME BAD. >> IS JUST THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY.

IT IS NOT SO HIGH BECAUSE I RESPIN A CERTAIN AMOUNT ON THE TAX DEED PLUS THE TITLE.

THE CERTIFICATION FOR TITLE INSURANCE. ABOUT 6000 ALREADY.

+8000 PAST THE VALUE OF THE PROPERTY. TRY TO SELL ALL THE FEES THAT COME. IF I KEEP IT TO GO WITH THE BUILDING PROGRAM, IT WILL BE A LONG-TERM. I WON'T BE ABLE TO DO IT RIGHT AWAY.

I WAS TRYING TO LET SOMEBODY ELSE READY TO WORK ON IT, HE WILL BE READY IN A FEW MONTHS.

I THINK THAT'S WHAT HE DOES. HE BUYS THE PROPERTIES, HE BILLED THEM.

HE'LL BE MORE READY TO WORK ON THE PROPERTY THEN I CAN. BECAUSE IT WILL BE A LONG TIME

FOR ME TO WORK ON BUILDING SOMETHING ON THE PROPERTY. >> I AND WILLING TO GO WITH THE

CITY RECOMMENDATION. I THINK IT IS FAVORABLE. >> I UNDERSTAND.

AS ANYTHING FURTHER FROM THE CITY. >> JUST TO GIVE THE TOTAL DUE, DUE TO THE CITY CAME TO $18,454.76. AS OF THE TOTAL OF ALL THREE

GROUPINGS OF LIENS COMBINED. >> FIRST ONE, TOTAL DUE RECOMMENDATION FIVE, SECOND

RECOMMENDATION WAS 480? >> YES MA'AM. >> THIS THIRD ONE

RECOMMENDATION IS 2531.05. >> YES MA'AM. >> THE TOTAL COMES TO?

>> IT COMES TO -- >> I WANT TO MAKE SURE SOMEONE ELSE HAVE WHAT I HAVE.

>> BEAR WITH ME. I WILL DO IT TOGETHER. -- IT KEEPS COMING UP WRONG.

8172.28. >> THAT'S WHAT I HAVE. THEY'RE MAKING A RECOMMENDATION

TOTAL. 8172.28 FOR THE THREE PARCELS. >> OKAY.

OKAY SO, NOTHING CAN BE DONE FOR THAT AMOUNT? THAT IS THE ONLY DECISION THAT

CAN BE DONE? >> THAT'S WHAT I'M GIVING YOU MA'AM.

I THINK IT'S FAIR. >> I UNDERSTAND. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, JUST TO REVIEW, SHE HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS PARTICULAR THING TO THE CITY COMMISSION.

UNFORTUNATELY, THERE IS ANOTHER APPLICATION FEE FOR TAKING THE ADDITIONAL STEP.

>> DID YOU UNDERSTAND THAT MS. ETIENNE? >> YES, I DO UNDERSTAND.

I HAVE A QUESTION. IF THE FEE FOR THE CITY IS HIGHER THAN THE TAX DEED, I DON'T THINK A PROPERTY SHOULD GO IN THE TAX DEED. BECAUSE IN THAT CASE, I DON'T KNOW, MAYBE FOR THE OTHER PROPERTIES IS BETTER, BUT IN THAT CASE, IT'S MORE THAN WHAT THE TAX DEED PRICE WAS. AND I DON'T THINK THE CITY, WANT PEOPLE TO COME AND BUY THE PROPERTIES AND WORK WITH THEM. A LOT OF THEM ARE JUST SITTING THERE.

A LOT OF COUNTY DOES THAT. THEY WORK AND ALLOW PEOPLE TO COME AND MAKE IT MUCH AFFORDABLE. FOR PEOPLE TO BUY AND BRING THE PROPERTY IN GOOD STATUS.

I DON'T SEE -- >> I BOUGHT A TAX DEED WANTS. YOU HAD TO DO HOMEWORK BEFORE

YOU BUY THESE PROPERTIES. AND YOU HAVE TO MAINTAIN THEM. >> SO, LET'S SAY NOBODY BUY

THEM, WHAT HAPPENS TO THE PROPERTY? >> SOMEBODY WILL BUY THEM.

AND I'M WILLING TO BET YOU PROBABLY GOT A BUYER WAITING. >> OKAY, I UNDERSTAND.

SO, I HAVE A QUESTION. DO I HAVE THE -- TO HAVE THE OPTION, THE BUILDING PROGRAM

OPTION FOR THE PROPERTY STILL? >> I DON'T KNOW MA'AM I'M JUST A SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.

YOU HAVE TO TALK WITH SOMEONE IN THAT DEPARTMENT. >> OKAY.

>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. >> IF YOU'RE NOT HAPPY WITH THE DECISION YOU CAN APPEAL TO THE CITY COMMISSION. AND ASK THEM FOR A REDUCTION. THAT IS BORDER CITY

COMMISSIONERS. $250 FEE FOR THAT? >> ADDITIONAL $250 TO GO BEFORE

[02:40:05]

THE COMMISSION. YES MA'AM. >> YOU HAVE TO PAY 250 TO GO

BEFORE THE COMMISSION AND THEY MAY NOT GRANT YOUR WISH. >> BUT IT MIGHT BE ANOTHER DAY

LIKE THIS AGAIN. >> IT WOULD BE A NIGHT, RIGHT? >> WHAT ARE JUST GOING TO SAY TO MS. ETIENNE, SHE IS TRYING TO DO IT UNDER A WARRANTY DEED. SHE IS A BUYER WILLING TO BUILD, THAT BUYER MAY WISH TO SPEAK TO THE INFO REDEVELOPMENT PROGRAM COORDINATOR AND PURCHASE AS IS, KNOWING THAT THERE IS A MUCH BETTER REDUCTION PROCESS IN PLACE.

BUT IT DOES REQUIRE A BUILDING. SO, IF SHE HAS A PURCHASER INTERESTED IN BUILDING, I SUGGEST THAT PRIOR TO THE SALE TAKING PLACE, THAT THE POTENTIAL BUYER SPEAK TO OUR INFILL REDUCTION PROGRAM COORDINATOR. BECAUSE THIS IS THE PROCESS THAT SHE'S CHOSEN TO FOLLOW. THERE IS A MUCH BETTER ONE THAT THE CITY HAS.

BUT IT DOES HAVE REQUIREMENTS TO BUILD. SHE HAS SOMEONE THAT WANTS TO BUY AND BUILD, PERHAPS YOU WILL BE INTERESTED BUYING IT AS IS AND GOING TO THAT REDUCTION.

ECAUSE IT IS A PROGRAM THAT IS IN PLACE, THAT WE WANT THESE LOCKS TO BE TRANSFERRED AS SHE

INDICATED. AND WE WANT THEM TO BE BUILT. >> OKAY.

I LIKE THAT OPTION. I DID TALK TO THE BUYER. THE BUYER, HE SAID HE PLAN ON BUILDING ON IT. AND I DID TELL HIM HE MIGHT BE THE ONE BECAUSE HE ALREADY PAID FOR THE SURVEY. AND MOSTLY I'M HERE BECAUSE OF HIM.

BECAUSE HE GO FAR. THE TITLE INSURANCE DID NOT DO THE WORK ON TIME.

HE SPEND MONEY AND I TRY TO WORK WITH HIM TO SEE IF WE CAN BUY THE PROPERTY.

BUT I WILL LET HIM KNOW ABOUT YOU KNOW, WHAT YOU SAY. SO, WOULD HE HAVE THE OPTION?

>> MAGISTRATE -- >> PLEASE GO. >> WE CERTAINLY CANNOT GIVE LEGAL ADVICE. FROM THE DAIS, NONE OF US CAN. AND I DEFINITELY DON'T WANT TO TAKE ANY POSITION THAT MIGHT HURT ANYBODY'S ABILITY TO APPLY FOR A PROGRAM THAT THE CITY OFFERS. SO, WE HAVE HAD A HEARING TODAY, YOU HAVE QUESTIONED MS. ETIENNE EXTENSIVELY. IF SHE IS INTERESTED IN STILL APPLYING FOR THE OTHER PROGRAM, IT MIGHT MAKE SENSE, TO CONTINUE HIS HEARING TO A LATER DATE, TO SEE IF SHE WANTS TO MOVE FORWARD WITH THE APPLICATION. RATHER THAN TAKE ACTION TODAY, THAT COULD HINDER THAT, THAT -- THAT CAN HINDER THE APPLICATION.

BUT THAT NEEDS TO BE HER DECISION AS TO WHAT SHE WANTS TO DO.

OTHERWISE, I THINK YOU KNOW, THE CITIES POSITION, I DON'T WANT TO SPEAK FOR MR. REYES.

WE PRESENT OUR CASE FOR OUR SIDE OF THE CASE AND WE WOULD ASK FOR YOU TO RULE.

UNLESS SHE'S ASKING FOR SOMETHING ELSE PROCEDURALLY. >> I THINK SHE UNDERSTANDS.

HIS KNOWLEDGE IS -- IT SOUNDS LIKE SHE HAS A BUYER. >> I CANNOT TELL HER FOR SURE THAT SHE WILL QUALIFY FOR THE PROGRAM AFTER GETTING A LEAN REDUCTION.

>> OKAY. >> SHE NEEDS TO CONSIDER IN TERMS OF WHAT SHE IS ASKING YOU TODAY. AND I SAID AS AN OBSERVATION, NOT AS ADVICE TO HER.

>> OKAY. SO, YOU UNDERSTAND BASICALLY, THAT I DID REDUCE IT PURSUANT TO WHAT THE CITY WANTS. BUT I GUESS YOU WANT TO CONTINUE THIS NOW?

>> I WAS GIVEN BY THE COURT ENFORCEMENT WAS 5000 TO PAY IF I DECIDE WITH THE BUILDING PROGRAM. BUT I WANT IT TO BE REDUCED TO LOWER.

BUT YOU SAY IT CANNOT BE. I WOULD JUST THINK ABOUT WHAT TO DO.

ABOUT THE PROPERTY. >> ALL RIGHT, REMEMBER IF YOU WANT TO APPEAL IT IS $250.

AND THEN, THEY MAY OR MAY NOT GRANT YOUR REQUEST. >> YEAH, I DID THEY'LL COME BACK LIKE THAT AGAIN BECAUSE I'M A SMALL BUSINESS. I CLOSE MY DOOR TO BE HERE.

SO, AND WOULD HAVE TO PAY AND I'M NOT SURE WHAT'S GOING TO BE THE OUTCOME.

>> THE TITLE COMPANY. >> DOES SHE WANT TO GO FORWARD WITH THE LEAN REDUCTION TODAY? AND GET YOUR ANSWER AND RULING? WHAT DOES SHE WANT TO PUT A PAUSE ON IT AND LOOK INTO OTHER

CITY PROGRAMS? >> PUT A PAUSE ON IT. I WILL GO REVIEW IT.

>> I THINK SHE'S A BUYER RIGHT NOW WAITING ON HER. >> YES, I DO.

>> I APOLOGIZE FOR YOUR TIME, MAGISTRATE. I JUST WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT

WE DO THIS CORRECTLY. >> WHERE CAN I TAKE THIS NEXT TO YOU?

[02:45:05]

I DON'T WANT TO COME TO THE HEARING AGAIN. >> PERHAPS WE CAN TALK HER OFF

THE RECORD. >> YOU HAVE TO COME TO ANOTHER HEARING.

>> YEAH BECAUSE IT TAKE A LOT OF TIME AND AFTER CLOSE MY WORKPLACE TO BE HERE.

AND I'M NOT SURE. >> MS. ETIENNE AT ANOTHER TIME, WE WILL BE HAPPY TO HEAR YOU.

>> HAVE A COUPLE QUESTIONS FOR THE RECORD. >> WERE JUST POSTPONING IT.

NOT TAKING ANY MORE ACTION. >> OKAY ARE WE DONE? >> NO DATE.

>> GOING TO COME BACK? >> NO, WE ARE DONE. >> WE REDUCED IT.

>> WERE GIVEN THE OPTION TO PURSUE YOU WILL BEFORE WE MAKE THE OFFICIAL RULING.

>> WE BARTER FOR APPLYING FOR THE PROGRAMS BY REDUCING IT TODAY.

IT IS MY UNDERSTANDING PRIOR TO THIS HEARING FROM THE CONVERSATIONS WITH STAFF, AND ALSO FROM WHAT SHE SAID AT THE BEGINNING OF THE HEARING, WAS THAT SHE DIDN'T WANT TO PARTICIPATE IN THAT PROGRAM. DIDN'T WORK FOR HER. BUT AS WE GET TO THE END OF THE HEARING SHE SEEMED TO HAVE WAVERED FROM THAT. AND NOW SHE'S THINKING SHE MAY WANT TO PARTICIPATE IN THE PROGRAM. BUT SHE IS CONCERNED A LEAN REDUCTION TODAY, WOULD BE ONE TYPE OF RELIEF THAT MIGHT BAR HER FROM THE PARTICIPATION.

AND BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW THE ANSWER TO THAT, I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT WE ARE DOING

EVERYTHING CORRECTLY. >> MY QUESTION IS, IS MS. ETIENNE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING FEES? A TOTAL OF $750.

>> NOT TODAY. >> MS. ETIENNE, WIDOW FOR TODAY.

>> OKAY, NO PROBLEM. >> KATZ WILL BE IN TOUCH WITH YOU TO FOLLOW UP.

>> THANK YOU. >> MAY I REQUEST A BREAK? WE HAVE ONE MORE? I'M SORRY. I'M SO SORRY! WE HAVE ONE MORE.

ONE MORE PERSON PRESENT BEFORE WE TAKE OUR BREAK. I AM SO SORRY.

>> AND I'M SORRY TOO. I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT -- WE ARE DOING EVERYTHING RIGHT.

[C. 22-843 CE 1410 N 25th St FT PIERCE COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES LLC Heather Debevec]

THAT'S ALL. >> WHAT DID WE MISS? >> OUR NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã843.

1410 N. 25TH STREET, FORT PIERCE COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES LLC.

PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND THE STATE UNIT FOR THE RECORD, SIR.

>>. [INAUDIBLE] >> DO YOU SWEAR FROM THE

CUSTOMER YOU ARE ABOUT TO BE WILL BE THE TRUTH?> I DO. >> THANK YOU.

>> OKAY SPECIAL MAGISTRATE THIS IS CASE NUMBER 22 Ã843 1410 N. 25TH STREET.

OWNED BY FORT PIERCE COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES LLC. BEFORE YOU TODAY FOR A MASSEY HEARING. THE SECTIONS IN VIOLATION WERE 2419 MAINTENANCE OF NUISANCE ON PROPERTIES. PRODUCTIVE TREATMENT, I PMC 304.2 PROTECTIVE TREATMENT, I CAN SEE 302.3 SIDEWALKS AND DRIVEWAYS. IN SECTION 117 SECTION 3 SUBSECTION B REMOVAL OF SIGNS. NOVEMBER 2, HE FOUND THE OWNER VIOLATION AND PROVIDED 30 DAYS TO COMPLY OR BE FINED $100 A DAY. ON JANUARY 11, 2023 AFFIDAVIT OF NONCOMPLIANCE WAS SENT TO THE OWNER. AND ON FEBRUARY 1, THE MASSEY NOTICE WAS SENT. THERE WERE EIGHT, WE DID RECEIVE A MASSEY REQUEST BACK.

HOWEVER AT THIS TIME, THE PROPERTY IS NOT IN COMPLIANCE. SO, WE ARE ADDRESSING THE MATTER IN ITS ENTIRETY, THE PROPERTY IS NOT IN COMPLIANCE, FINES OR RUNNING HOWEVER, HE

HAS REQUESTED A HEARING. >> THE PROPERTY IS NOT IN COMPLIANCE.

>> THIS IS REGARDING THE PARKING LOT. PAVING OF THE PARKING LOT.

AND WHAT I WILL SUBMIT IS A COPY OF THE LETTER THAT WE RECEIVED, ADDRESSING THE

CHALLENGE THAT HE HAS FACING -- >> CAN WE -- SORRY, SORRY. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THE COPY OF THE LETTER, AND AS PART OF OUR FILE BUT I WANT TO MAKE SURE HE HAS A CHANCE TO SEE IT.

HAVE YOU SEEN THIS? >> I HAVE A COPY. I PROVIDED IT.

>> OKAY. I GUESS WE WILL JUST -- PUT IN AS RESPONDENTS ON --

[02:50:02]

>> OKAY, I READ IT. HAVE YOU BEEN SWORN? >> HE WAS JUST SWORN IN, YES.

>> AND TELL ME WHY YOU ARE HERE. >> I'M HERE FIRST OF ALL, THE PROPERTY IS IN COMPLIANCE EXCEPT FOR THE PARKING LOT. IT HAS CRACKS, I DID REQUEST WITH THIS LETTER, INFORMATION I GOT FROM THE CONTRACTORS, EXTENSION UNTIL THE -- BECOME AVAILABLE BECAUSE -- [INAUDIBLE] I COULD HAVE SHORTCUT AND JUST HAD IT FIXED AND IN COMPLIANCE. I WAS GIVEN THE TIME, BUT DATED FEBRUARY 1, IT SAYS I AM ALREADY BEING FINED. AND NOT GIVEN ENOUGH OPPORTUNITY TO CHECK ON THE CONCRETE. HOWEVER, I STARTED ON THIS PROPERTY 2016.

I HAVE PICTURES FROM 2017, OF THE SAME >> IN THE PARKING LOT. AND NOBODY EVER LOOKED AT IT OR SAID ANYTHING UNTIL I TOOK IT. THEN ALL OF A SUDDEN, WE GET OF FINE BUT NOT ENOUGH TIME TO FIX. AND JUST DON'T THINK IT'S FAIR. THE LETTER HERE DID SAY REQUESTING -- FEBRUARY AND MARCH. THE HEARING NOVEMBER, SEND SOMEBODY THAT WORKS FOR ME AND I FELT -- THE FIRST THING YOU SAID SOMEBODY SAID THERE WAS DISCREPANCY. THAT I SUBMITTED A FORGED LETTER.

THE DISCREPANCY SAYS IT'S A PO BOX ADDRESS. BUT IT IS A STREET I JUST DON'T

SEE THE DISCREPANCY BECAUSE COMPANIES -- AND IN THE IRS -- >> SIR?

>> YES MA'AM. >> DO YOU WANT TO GRANT YOU SOME TIME TO GET THE CONCRETE?

AND STOP THE FINES? >> YES. >> THIS IS NOT THE TIME TO WEAR THEM BECAUSE YOUR PROPERTY IS NOT COMPLETED. OKAY? WE CAN ENTERTAIN THAT AFTER THE WORK HAS BEEN DONE. THEN IT WOULD PASS INSPECTION.

>> THAT WOULD BE THERE. PLEASE FOR THE RECORD, CORRECT THAT EVERYTHING HAS BEEN IN

COMPLIANCE EXCEPT FOR THE PARKING LOT. >> THIS IS NOT THE TIME TO DO THAT. I TOLD YOU. WE FINISHED, COME BACK AND

ADDRESS THE ISSUES. >> UNDERSTAND WHAT SHE JUST SAID THE PROPERTY IS

NONCOMPLIANCE AT ALL. I HAD FIVE VIOLATIONS. >> DO YOU HEAR WHAT I'M SAYING?

>> JUST TO BE CLEAR, HE IS INDICATING THERE STILL A FEW OTHER THINGS THAT NEED TO BE

ADDRESSED. >> DID YOU HEAR THAT? TELL HIM WHAT ELSE NEEDS TO BE

ADDRESSED OUTSIDE OF THE CONCRETE. >> YES MA'AM.I UNDERSTAND HE MAY WANT TO FIX THE PARKING UP BEFORE AND THE STRIPING OF THE PARKING SPACES.

BUT THERE ALSO STILL THE ISSUE WITH FINES ARE NO LONGER IN BUSINESS THERE.

THAT NEED TO BE -- >> DID YOU UNDERSTAND THAT? >> YES.

THE PAINTING WAS DONE, ALL THE SIGNS OF BEEN TAKEN CARE OF EXCEPT ONE OF THEM THAT WE HAVE PROBLEM TAKING IT OFF THE BUILDING. ANNA SPOKE WITH MS. HEATHER.

I EXPLAINED FOR HER THE SITUATION. I TOLD HER TO GIVE ME TIME AND I WILL GET IT FIXED. IT IS JUST HARD TO FIND SOME PLACES THAT DO THIS.

EVERY TIME I SPEAK WITH SOMEBODY, -- I RESPECT WHAT YOU DECIDE.

I AM A LAW-ABIDING CITIZEN LOOKING TO INVEST MORE IN FORT PIERCE.

I SERVED ON THE CDC OF VERO BEACH FOR 70 OR SO -- I JUST WANT FAIR.

THAT'S ALL. I APPRECIATE IT. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE APPARENTLY THERE'S A PERMIT APPLIED FOR. I SPOKE WITH MS. BACK IN THE BILLING DEPARTMENT THROUGH EMAIL MARCH 8 OF THIS YEAR. THERE WAS AN ISSUE WITH PERMIT.

THAT THEY HAD TO REDUCE SOME THINGS WITH THE ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT.

SO, I DON'T HOW FAR THE COMPANY IS WITH THAT OR NOT AT THIS, THIS DATE.

BUT THERE WAS APPLICATIONS FOR SUCH. >> DID YOU EVER GET THAT

PERMIT? >> THEY HAD SUBMITTED THE STRIPING AND FOR ME TO SUBMIT

-- WE WERE GOING TO GO OVER WHAT WE HAVE. >> I WANT TO CHECK WITH THE

BILLING DEPARTMENT. >> YEAH BUT I AM ON TOP OF IT AND I WANT TO DO THINGS RIGHT.

[02:55:07]

AND I WOULD HAVE BEEN IN COMPLIANCE.> JUST MAKE SURE. IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE WE NEED

TO DO WITH THIS CASE? >> NO MA'AM. DO YOU WANT TO SET UP A DATE

CERTAIN? >> WHEN DO YOU THINK YOU HAVE EVERYTHING STRAIGHTENED OUT

WITH THE SIGN AND THE CONCRETE? >> AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. IT'S JUST THESE DAYS, I CAN

SHOW YOU TEXTS OF PEOPLE THAT -- >> I'M NOT QUESTIONING THAT.

>> I DON'T WANT TO SAY DATE AND BE IN VIOLATION AGAIN. I CAN PROMISE AS SOON AS I CAN.

BECAUSE I DON'T LIKE THE WAY IT LOOKS. TO BE HONEST WITH YOU.

ON SOME THINGS. >> YOU THINK APRIL WILL BE SOON ENOUGH? I'VE OTHER PEOPLE TALK ABOUT A SHORTAGE OF CONCRETE OR BEING HARD TO GET.

>> CAN I RESPECTFULLY GET -- TO BE ON THE SAFE SIDE? >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARINGS

IN JUNE. >> HE SAID NO. >> WE WON'T BE HERE JUNE 7.

>> WHAT ABOUT MAY? >> APRIL 5. >> APRIL 5 IS THE NEXT ONE BUT

WE WANT TO GET HIM SOME TIME. >> THE 17TH IS AFTER THAT. >> RIGHT.

MAY 17? WILL YOU BE HERE? >> I WILL BE HERE HEATHER, WILL

YOU BE HERE? MAY 17. >> MAY 17.

GOOD LUCK. >> THIS IS YOU STOPPING FINES UNTIL THAT DATE?

>> SAY THAT AGAIN? >> ARE YOU STOPPING FINES UNTIL THAT DATE?

>> WELL -- >> SORRY. >> WHAT IS YOUR RECOMMENDATION?

IS EVERYTHING DONE BUT THE PAVEMENT? >> YES.

STRIPING OF THE PARKING LOT AND THE SIGN. OBVIOUSLY, THE STRIPING CANNOT

BE DONE INTO THE PARKING LOT IS DONE. >> LET'S LEAVE IT.

LET'S LEAVE IT ON THE MAY DATE. >> ARE WE GOING TO LEAVE THE FINES RUNNING?

THE FINES? THE SAME? >> NO, HE SAYS HE CAN'T GET IT

DONE. >> THERE WAS A LOT OF SCIENCE ON THE WINDOWS AND THE BUILDING. I GOT THEM ALL DONE EXCEPT ONE OF THEM.

IT IS NOT EVEN VISIBLE AT THE END THAT I -- I SPOKE WITH MS. HEATHER ABOUT IT.

I TOLD HER I'M WORKING ON IT. THE STRIPING, I CANNOT GO DO STRIPING IN THE PARKING LOT.

>> YOU THINK YOU CAN HAVE THE WINDOWS DONE BY APRIL? >> THE SIGN?

I MEAN -- >> LET'S GIVE HIM APRIL.>> APRIL?

>> THE SIGN? OR THE SIGN IN THE CAR CANNOT? >> DOING IT ALL BY THEN.

OKAY? >> BY MAY 7, RIGHT? >> YOU JUST GIVE ME MAY 7 DATE.

> MAY 17. >> I THOUGHT YOU SAID THAT. >> I DID.

>> I'M FOLLOWING UP ON HEATHER'S QUESTION, WHICH WAS THE FINES.

WILL THEY BE STOPPED? NO. >> NO BECAUSE HE HASN'T DONE

THE WORK. >> OKAY, SORRY TO. >> PETERS ASKED ME YOUR HONOR,

IT WILL BE OKAY IF YOU STOP AND I TOLD YOU YES, PLEASE. >> WE CAN ADJUST T THE FINES ONCE YOU CORRECT EVERYTHING. AS SOON, AS YOU DO GET THE WHATEVER DONE, THE WINDOWS WERE STRIPING. LET MS. HEATHER DEBEVEC KNOW IT AND SHE WILL COME OUT TO

INSPECT. >> YES MA'AM. >> FROM THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT

OR WHOMEVER. THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU.

>> NOW I WOULD LIKE TO RENEW MY REQUEST. CAN WE TAKE A BRIEF BREAK

BEFORE WE COME BACK TO THE CASES THAT ARE NOT HERE? >> OKAY WE WILL DO THAT.

[J. 23-0008 Ave B and N 29th St Glebert Duverge Larry Stephens]

>> GOOD MORNING. >> GOOD MORNING. >> TO HAVE THE RIGHT CASE, FEBRUARY 3, 2008? QUESTION WHEN YOU HONOR, THIS CASE 23008, MR. GEORGE GILBERT.

[03:00:01]

$10 LATE FEE. I'M SORRY, $18 LATE FEE, $10 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE.

TOTAL OF $78. THE CITY REQUEST THE SPECIAL MINISTRY FIND THE VIOLATOR AS IS THE RIGHT LEADER BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE INDICATED ABOVE, FAILURE TO BE SO DEFINED WILL RESULT IN CITATIONS BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.

I HAVE PICTURES FOR EVIDENCE. >> THINK OF YOUR CODE OFFICER, DID YOU TAKE THE PHOTOS?

DO THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW? >> YES I DID.

>> AT THIS TIME HE MOVED THEM INTO THE CITY COMPOSITE. I WILL NOTE THAT THE RESPONDENT

IS NOT PRESENT. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. ANYTHING FURTHER?

>> NOT AT THIS TIME. >> ALL RIGHT. I FIND THAT GLEBERT DUVERGE, IS

NOT PRESENT. NEED IS A REPRESENTATIVE. >> 31. SORRY.

>> GLEBERT DUVERGE IS NOT PRESENTLY THERE IS A REPRESENTATIVE ON HIS BEHALF.

BASED ON EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED I FOUND HE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE CITATION IN THE MATTER. CITATION 18156 PK I WILL IMPOSE A $50 FINE, $10 ADMIN FEE, $18 LATE FEE A TOTAL DUE OF $78. 14 DAYS TO PAY. FAILURE TO PICK A RESULT IN THE CASE BEING TRANSFERRED TO THE COUNTY COURT WHERE HE COULD INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES AND

COSTS. 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU.

[K. 22-2156PK South Causeway Park Regina Yvette Spann Larry Stephens]

>> YOU'RE WELCOME. >> LOOK LIKE THE NEXT ONE IS NOT GOING TO BE THERE.

>> OKAY. >> NEXT CASE 22 Ã2156 S. COUNTRY PARK.

GINA EVETTE SPANN. >> YOUR HONOR, THIS IS 22 2156 S. CAUSEWAY PARK.

THE OFFENDER IS REGINA EVETTE SPANN, SEVEN THE 4TH OF JULY 2022.

THE CITATION NUMBER 17 925, THE CO-CITATION 34 Ã35 ZERO NO PARKING.

THE COURT IS ASKING THAT YOU ASSESS IF ON A $50 ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10 AND LATE FEE OF $18 TOTALING $78. THE CITY REQUEST THAT IF THE SPECIAL MINISTRY FIND THE VIOLATOR AS IS THE VIOLATOR ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE AMOUNT INDICATED ABOVE.

FAILURE TO PAY SUCH A FINE WILL RESULT IN A CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT

SYSTEM. I ALSO PICTURES HERE. >> OFFICER STEVENS, DID YOU TAKE THE PICTURES? DO THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW?

>> YES, I DID.> NOTING THE RESPONDENT IS NOT PRESENT, I'LL ASK TO MOVE THIS PHOTOS INTO

CITY ONE COMPOSITE. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. THE RESPONDENT IS NOT PRESENT.

NEITHER IS A REPRESENTATIVE ON HER BEHALF. HOWEVER, BASED ON THE EVIDENCE PRESENTED, FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS. SHE IS THE PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. I WILL IMPOSE A FINE OF $50, $10 ADMIN FEE.

$18 LATE FEE, A TOTAL OF $78. ALL PAYABLE WITHIN, HOW MANY DAYS? 14 DAYS. IF NOT, IT SHOULD BE ADVISED THAT THE CASE COULD GO TO THE CORCOUNTY COURT SYSTEM WHERE THEY COULD INCUR ADDITIONAL COST.

>> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU AGAIN. >> GOOD JOB!

[D. 22-3219 CE 1025 Chipola Rd Juliet Williams Dixon, Derrick Anthony Dixon Isaac Saucedo]

[LAUGHTER] >> I HAVE GREAT TEACHERS. >> YOU DO.

YOU REALLY DO. >> NEXT CASE 22 Ã3219 1025 CHIPOLA RDULIET WILLIAMS

DIXON, DERRICK ANTHONY DIXON. >> IS CASE INITIATED NOVEMBER 16 AT 2022.

[03:05:04]

IN CORAL SPRINGS, FLORIDA. VIOLATIONS ARE PROTECTIVE TREATMENT.

CORRECTIVE ACTIONS WERE TO PRESSURE WASH AND PAINT DETERIORATION.

IF THE CITY IS REQUESTING THE SPECIAL MINISTRY FIND VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR WILL BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO COMPLY OR FINE OF $150 PER DAY ASSESSED. I DO HAVE PHOTOS.

I DID SPEAK TO THEM THIS MORNING. THEY DID COME IN.

THEY STATED THAT THEY WOULD HAVE THE VIOLATION CORRECTED. PRIOR TO THE 10 DAYS.

I'M STILL PRESENTING THE CASE IN CASE. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, HE TOOK

THE PHOTOS, THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW? >> YES.

>> I APOLOGIZE IF WE SAID THIS ALREADY. AT THIS TIME REMOVE THE PHOTOS

AND AS A CITY ONE COMPOSITE. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. AGAIN, NEITHER OF THE PARTIES ARE HERE. HOWEVER, NEITHER IS A REPRESENTATIVE ON THEIR BEHALF.

BASED ON THE EVIDENCE PRESENTED, I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THAT -- DIXON ARE RESPONSIBLE. THEY WILL BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO COMPLY, OR A FINE OF $150 PER

DAY. >> THANK YOU. >> HOLD ON.

[F. 22-3214 CE 1014 Chipola Ave Precision Rentals And Investments Llc Isaac Saucedo]

OKAY, THAT WOULD BE MY RULING. 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> GOOD, NEXT CASES 22 Ã3214 1014 CHIPOLA AVEPRECISION RENTALS AND INVESTMENTS LLC.

>> THIS IS 22 Ã3214 1014 CHIPOLA AVENUE PRECISION RENTALS AND INVESTMENT LLC.

FROM HERE IN FORT PIERCE. VIOLATIONS RIP MC -- EXTERIOR STRUCTURE GENERAL, 304.2 PROTECTIVE TREATMENT, 304.7 ROOF AND DRAINAGE AND SECTIONS 123 Ã37 SUBSECTION 12 FOR LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE. THE CORRECTIVE ACTIONS WERE TO REPAIR DETERIORATED TRIM THROUGHOUT HOME. TO PRESSURE WASH PAINT WHERE MOLDING OR DETERIORATION HAS OCCURRED. TO REPAIR DETERIORATED ROOF AND TRIM ALL OVERGROWN BUSHES, TREES, SHRUBS AND GRASS PER THE CITY IS REQUESTING THE SPECIAL MASTER PLANS A VIOLATION EXISTED VIOLATED GIVEN 10 DAYS TO APPLY OR FINE OF $150 PER DAY BE ASSESSED.

I HAVE PHOTOS. >> DID YOU TAKE THE PHOTOS AND THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY

DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW? >> YES THEY DO. >> THANK YOU.

NOTING THE RESPONDENT IS NOT PRESENT. I SUBMIT THESE.

>> ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> THE PARTIES ARE NOT PRESENT. NEITHER IS A REPRESENTATIVE.

HOWEVER, BASED ON THE EVIDENCE PRESENTED I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS.

DO YOU THINK 10 DAYS WILL BE ENOUGH TIME TO START?> HE IS AWARE OF THE SITUATION.

ACTUALLY, HE CAME IN PRIOR, THE PREVIOUS HEARING. AND HE STATED THAT THERE WERE PERMITS APPLIED FOR, OR HE HAD ACTIVE PERMITS. I'M SORRY.

HOWEVER, THEY APPLY FOR THEM THEY NEVER PAID FOR THEM. SO, THIS IS WHY IT WAS

SCHEDULED. >> OKAY. >> I MEAN, I UNDERSTAND THERE'S A LOT OF WORK TO BE DONE. BUT AT THIS POINT, HE WAS AWARE.

>> JUST, THE PERMITS ARE APPROVED, JUST NOT PICKED UP. >> ACCORDING TO BUILDING, IN ORDER FOR THEM TO BE ABLE TO SUBMIT THE FULL PERMITS, THEY HAVE TO BE PAID FOR.

AND NOTHING WAS EVER PAID FOR. IT JUST KIND OF STOOD THERE. >> THEY WERE HERE LAST MONTH, WEREN'T THEY? THE LAWYER WAS. WAS HE HERE FOR THEM?

>> IF I'M NOT MISTAKEN, HE'S GOT SEVERAL PROPERTIES. IT WASN'T FOR THIS ONE THOUGH.

>> OKAY. >> OKAY, ALL RIGHT. THEY WILL BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO COMPLY. $150 PER DAY ASSESSED, 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.

[A. 22-3391 CE 2002 Orange Avenue Eddy's Garage Heather Debevec]

>> THANK YOU. >> NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã3391 2002 ORANGE AVENUE EDDIE'S GARAGE.

[03:10:01]

>> I'M GOING TO DO THIS REAL QUICK. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE THIS IS NOT A CASE REALLY TO PRESENT, THE MATTER WAS HEARD BY YOU AT YOUR LAST HEARING.

THE RULING WAS MADE. BEFORE THE DAY WAS OVER, REPRESENT OF EDDIE'S GARAGE COUNTER TO THE CITIES CLERK OFFICE. THIS IS A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT.

INDICATED THERE WERE NO LONGER BUSINESS, WHICH IS WHY HE HAD NOT RENEWED IT.

UNFORTUNATELY, HE WAS A VERY TIMELY WITH IT. YOUR ORDER WAS JUST A VERBAL ORDER, IT WAS NEVER SIGNED OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT. WE'RE JUST ASKING THAT YOU

VACATE THAT ORIGINAL ORDER THAT YOU ISSUED VERBALLY. >> THAT I DO WHAT?

>> MAYBE I SAID IT WRONG. >> NO, YOU SAID IT RIGHT. THERE WAS AN ORAL PRONOUNCEMENT MADE AT A PRIOR HEARING. STAFF IS ASKING YOUVACATE THE ORAL ORDER .

HE DID NOT SIGN ANYTHING. IT WAS NEVER REDUCED TO WRITING.

I THINK YOU CAN VACATE IT NOW AT THIS TIME. >> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY, VACATE THE PREVIOUS ISSUED ORDER IN THIS CASE. NEXT CASE.

[A. 22-3428PK 500 Blk Pinewood Drive Ean Holdings, LLC Michael Rabenecker]

>> NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã3428 500 BLOCK OF PINEWOOD DRIVE AND HOLDINGS.

MICHAEL? THE LAST ONE. [LAUGHTER]

>> WHEN YOU ARE READY. YOUR HONOR, THE NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU IS CASE NUMBER 22 Ã 3428 A PARKING RELATION THAT OCCURRED AT THE 500 BLOCK OF PINEWOOD DRIVE.

THE CASE WAS INITIATED DECEMBER 11, 2022. THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE CAME BACK AS A IAN HOLDINGS LLC. THE TICKET NUMBER WRITTEN IS 18657 A PARKING VIOLATION OF 34 Ã35 ASKED PARKING ON THE CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY FOR THE CITY ASKING A $50 FINE BE ASSESSED A $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE, LATE FEE OF $18 FOR TOTAL OF $78. THE CITY REQUESTED THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS A VALUE TO BE ASSESSED TOTAL INDICATED ABOVE.

THEY ARE TO PAY SUCH A FINE WILL RESULT IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I FIRST INTRODUCED THAT ARE DATE AND TIME STAMPED AND

ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE VIOLATIONS I WITNESSED. >> RESPONDENT IS NOT PRESENT,

WE HAVE THIS AS A CITY COMPOSITE. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.

>> THANK YOU MA'AM. >> I FIND THAT THE PARTIES NOT PRESENT.

NEITHER ARE THE REPRESENTATIVES. ON HIS BEHALF.

BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND PRESENTED I SEE THAT VIOLATION EXISTS.

EAN HOLDING LLC IS THE PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. I WILL ORDER $50 FINE, $10 ADMIN FEE AND $18 LATE FEE FOR A TOTAL DUE OF $78. THE PAYMENT MUST BE MADE IN 14 DAYS. FAILURE TO DO SO, COULD RESULT IN THE CASE BE TRANSFERRED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM WHERE HE COULD INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS.

[L. 23-66PK 100 Blk Melody Lane Taryn Elise Powell Michael Rabenecker]

>> THINK YOUR HONOR. CHRISTMAS CASES 23 Ã66 100 BLOCK MELODY LANE TARYN ELISE

POWELL. >> IN THIS CASE BEFORE YOUR CASE NUMBER 23 Ã66 VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT THE 100 BLOCK OF MELODY LANE. THE CASE WAS INITIATED GENERALLY JUNE 20, 2023. THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE CAME BACK AS A TARYN ELISE POWELL.

HE CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 18666, A PARKING VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 34 Ã35 PK PARKING BUREN POSITANO. THEY ASSESSED A $50 FINE, $10 MISSION FEE AND A LATE FEE OF $18 FOR $78 DUE. THE CITY REQUESTED SPECIAL MEDICINE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED AT THE TOTAL ABOVE. -- THE ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE

VIOLATIONS I WITNESSED. >> NOTING THE RESPONDENT IS NOT PRESENT CITY MOVE THE PHOTOS

[03:15:04]

AND CITY COMPOSITE ONE. >> THEY WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.

>> SOMETHING IS IN THE WATER. BASED ON THE EVIDENCE PRESENTED I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THAT TARYN ELISE POWELL IS A PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION.

I WILL GIVE HER, I WILL FIND HER $50, ADMIN FEE OF $10, RATE FEE OF $18 -- PAYABLE WITHIN 14 DAYS. IF THE PARTY FAILS TO DO SO, SHE SHOULD BE NOTIFIED THAT THIS COULD BE RESULTING IN A TICKET BEING TRANSFERRED OVER TO THE COUNTY CLERKS OFFICE.

WHERE THEY COULD INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS. 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.

[M. 22-3429PK 500 Blk Pinewood Drive Ean Holdings, LLC Michael Rabenecker]

>> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR. >> NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã3429 500 BLOCK PINEWOOD DRIVE, EAN

HOLDINGS. >> YOUR HONOR, THIS CASE BEFORE HE IS CASE NUMBER 22 Ã3429 PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT THE 500 BLOCK OF PINEWOOD DRIVE.HE VIOLIN CASE CAME BACK AS EAN HOLDINGS CASE INITIATED DECEMBER 11, 2022. THE CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 18658 A PARKING VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 34 Ã35 ASKED PARKING ON THE CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY. THE CITY ASKING THE $50 FIND THE ASSESSED INITIATION FEE OF $10 AND LATE FEE OF $18 FOR TOTAL OF $78. THE CITY REQUESTED FOR SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED TOTAL DUE INDICATED AS ABOVE. FAILURE TO PAY CERTIFY RESULTS IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I PHOTOS ARE DATE AND TIME SAFT AND ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE

VIOLATIONS, I HAVE WITNESSED IT. >> NOTING THAT THE RESPONDENT IS NOT PRESENT I MOVE THE PHOTOS IN AS CITY ONE COMPOSITE.

>> THEY WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. >> DID I PULL UP THE RIGHT ONE?

>> WHAT? THERE ARE TWO CARS PARKED. >> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE PRESENTED, I MAKE THE FINDING THAT THE PARTY IS GUILTY. THAT BEING HOLDINGS.

PI WILL GIVE THEM IMPOSING A FINE OF $50, ADMIN FEE OF $10, LATE FEE OF $18, TOTAL DUE 78 DAYS -- $70 PAYABLE IN 14 DAYS. THEY SHOULD BE NOTIFIED TO PAY THIS AMOUNT.

IT COULD RESULT IN THE CASE BEING FORWARDED OVER TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM WHERE THEY COULD INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS. 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.

[N. 22-3328PK 100 Blk Marina Way James Donald Baumann, Jr. Natalia Baumann Michael Rabenecker]

>> THANK YOU. >> ARE WELCOME. >> NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã332-8100 BLOCK MARINA WAY. JAMES DONALD BOWMAN JUNIOR, NATALIA BOWMAN.

QUESTION IS CASE BEFORE YOU CASE NUMBER 22 Ã3228 A PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT THE 100 BLOCK OF MARINA WAY. THE CASE WAS INITIATED DECEMBER 3, 2022.

TVIOLATORS IN THE CASE CAME BACK AS JBAUMANN JUNIOR, AND NATALIA.

PARKING AT ANY TIME. THE CITY ASKING THE $50 FINE 50 FINE BE ASSESSED A DEMONSTRATION FEE OF $10 LATE FEE OF $18 FOR TOTAL OF $78. I PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE THE DATE AND TIME STAMP AND ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE VIOLATIONS I WITNESSED.

>> THANK YOU. AT THIS TIME, NOTING THE RESPONDENT IS NOT PRESENT THE

CITY WILL MOVE THE PHOTOS AS THAT ONE COMPOSITE. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.

I FIND THAT THE RESPONDENT IS NOT HERE. HOWEVER, THIS EVIDENCE PRESENTED, DEFINED A VIOLATION EXISTS. AND THEY PAY A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $50. ADMIN FEE OF $10, LATE FEE OF $18.

A TOTAL DUE OF $78. THIS FEE IS PAYABLE WITHIN 14 DAYS.

THE PARTY SHOULD BE ADVISED, SHOULD THEY FAIL TO COMPLY, IT COULD RESULT IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. WHERE THEY WILL OR COULD INCUR

[P. 22-3331PK 600 North Indian River Drive Holly Noel Tallant Michael Rabenecker]

ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS. 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU YOUR HONOR.

[03:20:02]

>> WHAT APPEARED NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã333-1600 NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE.

HOLLY NOEL TALLANT. CHRISTMAS CASES 22 Ã3331. A PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT THE 600 NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE. THE CASE WAS INITIATED DECEMBER 3, 2022. THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE CAME BACK AS A HOLLY NOEL TALLANT.

CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 18623 A PARKING VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 34 Ã35T PARKING IN A SAFETY ZONE. THE CITY ASKING THE $50 FINE BE ASSESSED INITIATION FEE OF $10 LATE FEE OF $18 FOR TOTAL OF $78 CITY REQUEST THEIR SPECIAL MAGIC FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED TOTAL DUE IS INDICATED ABOVE. FOR TO PAY SUCH A FINAL RESULT IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I PHOTOS DATE AND TIME STAMPED,

ACCURATELY WHICH ARE THE VIOLATIONS I HAVE WITNESSED IT. >> THANK YOU.

RESPONDENT IS NOT PREGNANT, MOVING THIS PHOTOS AS CITY ONE COMPOSITE.

>> THANK YOU. >> THE PARTIES NOT PRESENT. IT IS A REPRESENTATIVE ON HIS OR HER BEHALF. HOWEVER, I FIND A VIOLATION, HE IS RESPONSIBLE OR SHE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. I WILL IMPOSE A FINE OF $50, $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE, $18 LATE FEE, A TOTAL OF $78. IT WILL BE PAYABLE WITHIN 14 DAYS.

FAILURE TO DO SO COULD RESULT IN THE PARTIES CASE BEING TRANSFERRED OVER TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM WHERE HE OR SHE WOULD INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES AND COSTS.

[Q. 22-3437PK 100 Blk North Depot Drive Mase Destin Cook Michael Rabenecker]

>> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR. >> NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã3437 100 BLOCK NORTH DEPOT DRIVE, MASE

DESTIN COOK. >> NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã3437. 100 NORTH DEPOT DRIVE.

THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE CAME BACK AS A MASE DESTIN COOK CITATION NUMBER 18633, A PARKING VIOLATION CITY ORDINANCE 34-35 P. THEY ASKED THAT A FINE BE ASSESSED LATE FEE AND TOTAL DUE OF $78. THIS A REQUEST FOR SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A TOTAL DUE IS INDICATED ABOVE.

FAILURE TO PAY RESULTS IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.

I FIRST INTRODUCED DATE AND TIME STANDARD ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE VIOLATIONS I

WITNESSED. >> SUCH A MAGISTRATE NOTING THE RESPONDENT IS NOT PRESENT THE

CITY THROUGH THE PHOTOS AS CITY ONE COMPOSITE. >> WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.

>> THANK YOU MA'AM. TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE PRESENTED, FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS. EXCUSE ME. AND THAT MASE DESTIN COOK IS A PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. I WILL IMPOSE A $50 FINE, $10 ADMIN FEE $18 LATE FEE FOR TOTAL OF $78 14 DAYS TO PAY, FAILED TO DO SO COULD REAP ROLE IN THIS BEING TRANSFERRED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM WHERE THEY CAN INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES

[R. 22-3415PK 100 Blk North Indian River Drive Kendra Lea McMillan Michael Rabenecker]

AND COSTS. >> THIS CASE 22 ÃMARCH 4, 2015, 100 BLOCK NORTH INDIAN

RIVER DRIVE. KENDRA LEA MCMILLAN. >> THE NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU CASE NUMBER 22 Ã3415, PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT 200 BLOCK NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE.

THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON DECEMBER 10, 2022. THE VIOLATOR CAME BACK AS A KENDRA LEA MCMILLAN. THE SITE PATIENT NUMBER IS 18638 36 PARKING VIOLATION CITY ORDINANCE 34 Ã30 5T PARKING IN A SAFETY ZONE. THE CITY ASKING THAT A $50 FINE BE ASSESSED A $10 MINISTRATION FEE, AND LATE FEE OF $18 FOR TOTAL OF $78.

THE CITY REQUEST SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A TOTAL DUE IS INDICATED ABOVE. FURTHER TO PACE A DIFFERENT RESULT IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.

I FIRST INTRODUCED DATE AND TIME STAMP. THESE ARE THE VIOLATIONS.

I WITNESSED IT. >> NOTED THE RESPONDENT IS NOT PRESENT THE CITY MOVE THEM IN

AS THE CITY ONE COMPOSITE. >> THEY WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.

[03:25:03]

>> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED I FIND THAT THE PARTY IS NOT PRESENT.

THAT BEING KENDRA LEA MCMILLAN. NEITHER REPRESENTATIVE NOR ON HER BEHALF I FIND THE VIOLATION OCCURRED I WILL IMPOSE A $50 FINE $10 ADMIN FEE. $18 LATE FEE.

A TOTAL OF $78 THE AMOUNT IS DUE AND PAYABLE WITHIN 14 DAYS. FAILURE TO PAY SHOULD RESULT OR COULD RESULT IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM, WHERE HE OR SHE WILL

[S. 22-3425PK 1100 Blk Rosedale Avenue Amanda Yajaira Duran Michael Rabenecker]

>> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR. >> NEXT CASE IS 22 Ã3425 1100 BLOCK ROSEDALE AVENUE, AMANDA YAJAIRA DURAN. CHRISTMAS CASES 22 Ã3425 PARKING VIOLATION OF THE 1100 BLOCK OF ROSEDALE AVENUE. THE CASE WAS INITIATED DECEMBER 11 2022.

THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE CAME BACK AS AMANDA YAJAIRA DURAN. THE CITATION NUMBER IS 18654 PARKING VIOLATION CITY ORDINANCE 34 Ã35 ASKED PARKING ON THE CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.

THE CITY ASKING A $50 FINE, AND MINISTRATION FEE $10 LATE FEE OF $18 A TOTAL DUE OF $78.

THE CITY REQUEST A SPECIAL MAGIC FINDS VIOLATIONS AT THE VIOLATOR BE ASSISTED TOTAL DUE IS INDICATED ABOVE. FAILURE TO PAY SUCH A FINE RESULT IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COURT SYSTEM. I FIRST INTRODUCED DATE AND TIME STAMPED THE ACCURATELY

PORTRAY THE VIOLATIONS, I WITNESSED IT. >> THANK YOU THE RESPONDENT IS

NOT PRESENT. THIS COMPOSITE ONE. >> ADMITTED AS SUCH.

>> I FIND THE RESPONDENT, AMANDA YAJAIRA DURAN, IS NOT PRESENT.

NEITHER IS A REPRESENTATIVE ON HER BEHALF. HOWEVER, I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS. SHE'S THE PARTY RESPONSIBLE. I WILL IMPOSE A 50 DELPHI, $10 ADMIN FEE, $18 LATE FEE, TOTAL OF $78 DUE. PAYABLE WITHIN THE 14 DAY PERIOD. FAILURE TO DO SO COULD RESULT IN A CITATION BEING FORWARDED

[T. 22-3426PK 1100 Blk Jasmin Avenue Anthony Jermayne Johnson, Jr. Michael Rabenecker]

30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU YOUR HONOR. >> LAST CASE TODAY IS 22 Ã 3426, 1100 BLOCK JASMINE AVENUE. ANTHONY JERMAYNE JOHNSON, JR..

>> YOUR HONOR, NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU, IS CASE NUMBER 22 Ã3426. A VIOLATION OCCURRED AT 1100 BLOCK OF JASMINE AVENUE. THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON DECEMBER 11, 2022.

THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE CAME BACK ASA ANTHONY JERMAYNE JOHNSON, JR. .

THE CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 18655A PARKING VIOLATION OF ORDINANCE 34-35 S. -- A TOTAL DUE OF $78. THE CITY REQUESTS IF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A TOTAL DUE INDICATED ABOVE.

FAILURE TO PAY SUCH A FINE RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARTO THE CONTY COURT SYSTEM.

I FIRST INTRODUCED DATE AND TIME STAFF AND THE ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE VIOLATIONS, I

WITNESSED IT. >> THANK YOU. THIS PERSON IS NOT PRESENT.

REMOVE THESE PHOTOS IN AS A CITY COMPOSITE ONE. >> IT WILL BE AS MENTORS -- ADMITTED AS SUCH. MR. JOHNSON IS NOT PRESENTLY THERE IS A PARTY REPRESENTED HIM. HOWEVER, I DO FIND THAT HE IS A PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. I WILL IMPOSE A $50 FINE, $10 ADMINISTERED A FEE, $18 LATE FEE. A TOTAL OF $78. PAYABLE WITHIN 14 DAYS.

HE SHOULD BE ADVISED FAILURE TO PAY WITHIN THE TIME COULD RESULT IN A CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. HE COULD INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES

AND COSTS. 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR.

>> WE ARE DONE. >> -- TAX CASES REQUIRING A HEARING STATE STATUE 162.12 NOTICE OF HEARING WAS SENT TO THE VIOLATOR CERTIFIED MAIL. IF THE GREEN CARD IS RETURNED SIGNED COMMENTS PLACED IN THE FILE. IF IT IS RETURNED UNSIGNED OR UNCLAIMED, AN AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING WITH THE NOTICE OF HEARING AND CLOSE, SENT TO THE VIOLATOR YOUR REGULAR US MAIL FOR 10 DAYS PRIOR TO THE HEARING, NOTICE HEARING IS POSTED ON THE BULLETIN BOARD IN CITY HALL. NO SEVERE ALSO POSTED AT THE

[03:30:01]

CASE IS NOT MANDATED BY THE STATE STATUTE MAILING OF THE NOTICE OF HEARING ARE HANDLED IN THE SAME MANNER STATED PRIOR. THE GREEN CARD IS RETURNED UNSIGNED, UNCLAIMED OR NOT RETURNED WITHIN 10 DAYS OF THE HEARING, A NOTICE OF HEARING IS

POSTED ON THE BULLETIN BOARD IN CITY HALL. >> ALL RIGHT, WE ARE ADJOURNED.

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.