[00:00:03]
FOR THE FORT PIERCE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING FOR OCTOBER
[1. CALL TO ORDER]
4, 2023. >> GOOD AFTERNOON, I AM FRAN ROSS. I AM THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE PRESIDING OVER THIS AFTERNOON'S HEARINGS.
YOU ARE HEARING BECAUSE YOU RECEIVED NOTICE THAT YOUR PROPERTY WAS POSSIBLY IN VIOLATION OF A PARTICULAR CITY CODE OR ORDINANCE. YOU WERE GIVEN A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF TIME TO CORRECT THAT. AND FOR THOSE OF HOW ARE HERE AND WISH TO BE HEARD, I WILL CALL YOUR CASES SHORTLY.
ONE THING I LIKE TO TELL PEOPLE. EVERYBODY HERE WILL BE HEARD IF YOU DESIRE AND IF YOU HAVE A TRAFFIC TICKET AND FOR WHATEVER REASON YOU IT DOESN'T GO YOUR WAY, YOU WILL INCUR ADDITIONAL GUYS AND COSTS. THOSE WHO NEED AN INTERPRETER, WE WILL LET YOU KNOW -- YOU LET US KNOW.
WE HAVE INTERPRETERS THAT ARE PRESENT.
IF YOU DON'T MIND -- AGAIN WITH THE TRAFFIC TICKETS.
YOU WILL INCUR ADDITIONAL GUYS AND COSTS IF YOU ARE GUILTY OF THAT. AND YOU NEED TO BE MINDFUL OF THAT. IF YOU DON'T MIND, PLEASE STAND FOR THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. THE PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.
AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS.
ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND
[A. ADMINISTRATION OF OATH TO DEPARTMENTAL WITNESSES]
JUSTICE FOR ALL. >> WILL YOU PLEASE REMAIN STANDING SO THE CLERK CAN SWEAR YOU IN.
>> THANK YOU. PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND.
DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE ABOUT TO GIVE WILL BE THE TRUTH? YES.
[B. IDENTIFICATION OF CASES IN COMPLIANCE OR RESCHEDULED]
>> THANK YOU. >> WHEN YOU ARE READY, MADAM
CLERK. >> I WILL START WITH THE CASES IDENTIFICATION OF CASES IN COMPLIANCE OR RESCHEDULED.
CASE 23-1965, SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK.
P.V. HOLDING CORPS. 1454, 2400 SOUTH OCEAN DRIVE UNIT 313. QUINN AND ACOG JR.
CASE 1296, 308 AVENUE A EAST COAST LAND HOLDING LCC.
12-12 THE 5, EAST COAST LAND HOLDINGS LCC.
23-1684, 2101 SOUTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE.
AND 400 SOUTH OCEAN DRIVE UNIT V 325, MALDANADO.
1536, 2500 SOUTH OCEAN DRIVE UNIT 3, 1013 GORY.
1601 BAHIA, SMALL. AND 23-1458, 2400 SOUTH OCEAN DRIVE, UNIT V, 111. SANTANGELO.
CASE 23-1513, 2400 SOUTH OCEAN DRIVE DRIVE, UNIT V 315, JIMENEZ. 23-1524 SOUTH OCEAN DRIVE V 733.
KOSCIELNIAK. 23-1504, 2400 SOUTH OCEAN DRIVE V 724 WINTER. 23-1540, SOUTH OCEAN DRIVE 811 O'BRIEN. 23-1533, SOUTH OCEAN SKRIEF 1132, SEILER. 23-1878, 1802 ORANGE AVENUE.
23-18801727 OKEECHOBEE ROAD. 1727 OKEECHOBEE LCC.
[A. Lot Clearing 317 N 11th St Leslie Wexler Peggy Arraiz]
23-1432, 1361, BINNEY DR DRIVE, FRAVEL.THE PROPERTY LESLIE WEXLER. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE I WILL BE PRESENTING THIS VERY CLEARLY. THIS IS A CASE RECALLED BEFORE YOU A LOT CLEARING REDUCTION REQUEST FOR 317 NORTH 11TH STREET OWNED BY MISS LES LESLIE WEXLER.
THIS HAS COME BEFORE YOU AND CAME TO A STIPULATION.
SHE WAS GOING TO APPEAL IT TO THE CITY COMMISSION AND RESOLVED WITHOUT TAKING THAT STEP. IT IS COMING BACK BEFORE FOR THE AGREED UPON STIPULATED $2465.79. ALL THE CRITERIA REMAINS THE
[00:05:02]
SAME. NOTHING HAS CHANGED AND I WILL PULL IT UP JUST FOR RECORD. THE GRAVITY OF THE VIOLATION WAS MINOR. LANDSCAPING ISSS.>> THE VIOLATOR DID NOTHING TO CORRECT IT AND THE VENDOR HAD TO VOLUNTARILY CORRECT IT. THE NEW ITEMS DON'T APPLY BECAUSE WE HAVE A NEW OWNER AND THEY APPLY TO THE OLDER, $ $2665.79. AND BRINGING BEFORE YOU AS A
STIPULATED AGREEMENT. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?
>> WAS THERE AN AGREEMENT ON TIME TO PLAY.
HAVE YOU DISCUSSED HOW LONG IT WOULD TAKE YOU TO PAY?
>> ANYTHING FURTHER. >> NO, MA'AM.
>> BASED ON THE STIPULATION BETWEEN THE PARTIES I WILL REDUCE TO 2564.79 AS PREVIOUSLY DONE.
YOU HAVE 24 MONTHS TO PAY IT. I HAVE TO ADVISE YOU IF YOU DON'T PAY IT WITHIN THAT PERIOD OF TIME IT WILL REVERT BACK TO THE ORIGINAL AMOUNT. YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.
GOOD LUCK. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH.
>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, CAN YOU BRING YOUR MICROPHONE IN FRONT
[K. 23-1407 STR 715 S Ocean Drive, Unit D MERMAID SEASHORES LLC Heather Debevec]
OUR NEXT IT WAS 23-1407, OCEAN DRIVE, MERMAID SEASHORES LLC.>> YOUR HONOR. IF I MAY, ON BEHALF OF THE
RESPONDENT MERMAID SEASHORES. >> HOLD ON, SIR.
JUST A MINUTE. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, BEFORE THE PRESENTATION I BELIEVE THERE WILL BE A REQUEST BASED ON PAPERWORK FILED BY THE ATTORNEY A VERIFIED WRIT OF PROHIBITION TODAY. THERE HAS BEEN NO ORDER YET ON SAID EX-PARTE WRIT OF PROHIBITION.
BUT I BELIEVE HE WILL PROBABLY BE ARGUING RELATED TO WHAT HE FILED. SO I WILL LET HIM MAKE HIS OWN
ARGUMENT FOR HIMSELF. >> YES, YOUR HONOR.
>> LET'S HEAR FROM THE CITY FIRST AND THEN YOU WILL RESPOND.
>> YOUR HONOR, AS A PRELIMINARY MATTER TO ASK THE HEARING BE CONTINUED TO HAVE THE CIRCUIT COURT RULE ON A PETITION OF WRIT
HOW DOES THE CITY RESPOND? WE ARE PREPARED TO GO FORWARD TODAY, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. TO MY KNOWLEDGE, THERE HAS BEEN NO ORDER. I DID DO -- UNLESS -- UNLESS THEY HAVE CASE LAW TO THE CONTRARY, I FOUND NOTHING THAT DIVESTS YOU OF JURISDICTION TO PROCEED TODAY BECAUSE THERE HAS BEEN NO ORDER. I DID LOOK FOR THAT.
I WAS UNABLE TO FIND SUCH. IF THEY HAVE SOMETHING THAT SAYS THAT THOUGH, OBVIOUSLY I WILL BE HAPPY TO REVIEW IT BUT NO ORDER AT THIS POINT. IT WAS FILED TODAY IN AN EX-PARTE FASHION. AGAIN, I DON'T KNOW IF THAT IS SOMETHING THAT CAN BE DONE. TYPICALLY IN ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE, IT WOULD BE AN ISSUE RELATED TO IT IS MY UNDERSTANDING. SINCE THERE IS NO ORDER, WE ARE PREPARED TO GO FORWARD AND CASE LAW TO THE CONTRARY, I AM HAPPY
TO REVIEW THAT. >> IN ADDITION TO THAT ISSUE, YOUR HONOR, MOVE CLIENT WOULD LIKE TO RECUSE YOUR HONOR.
WE CAN DO THAT IN WRITTEN FORM. I LEARNED THAT AFTER SPEAKING WITH HER TODAY. WE COULD DO THAT IN WRITTEN FORM WITH OR AFFIDAVIT WITH A CONTINUANCE OR WE CAN PRESENT THAT NOW OR A MOTION WITH TESTIMONY THAT I LISTED FROM HE HER.
>> WHAT IS THE REASON FOR THE RECUSAL? SHE FEARS BIAS BASED ON YOUR CLOSE RELATIONSHIP TO AN INDIVIDUAL WHO IS VERY ANTAGONISTIC FOR HER.
>> WHO IS THE INDIVIDUAL? SHOULD I PUT MY CLIENT ON THE
STAND. >> I WOULD HAVE TO HAVE NOTICE,
[00:10:01]
YES. WHO IS THE INDIVIDUAL I HAVECLOSE CONTACT WITH. >> WHAT IS HIS NAME.
>> COMMISSIONER JOHNSON CURTIS JOHNSON.
>> HE IS AN ELECTED OFFICIAL, BUT I DON'T HAVE CLOSE CONTACT WITH HIM. I AM NOT GOING TO RECUSE MYSELF FOR THAT. I RARELY SEE COMMISSIONER JOHN JOHNSON.
>> COULD WE PUT MY CLIENT ON THE STAND AND MAKE A RECORD OF WHAT
>> MICHELLE DANELICK. >> WHAT IS YOUR RELATIONSHIP
WITH THE HER MADE SEASHORES. >> OWNER.
>> WHY DO YOU BELIEVE THAT THE MAGISTRATE WOULD BE BIASED
TOWARD YOU IN THIS HEARING? >> PRESIDENT MAGISTRATE WILL BE BIASED BECAUSE A LONG-STANDING HISTORY WITH UNETHICAL BEHAVIOR THAT GOES TO SHOW WITH COMMISSIONER CURTIS JOHNSON AND WAS HELD TO THE STANDARD FROM THE FLORIDA BAR WITH REGARD TO THIS. AND I HAVE ALREADY HAD RETALIATORY BEHAVIOR FROM THE CITY WITH SPECIFIC TO MR. JOHNSON. AND I BELIEVE THE -- THE CASE FROM THE FLORIDA BAR IS 95-3167519A.
>> WHO -- THAT INVOLVED ME? YES, MA'AM.
>> WHEN? THE HEARING WAS ON NOVEMBER 20, 19 1995.
>> I DON'T KNOW WHAT SHE IS TALKING ABOUT.
IF SHE HAS PAPERWORK. >> I HAVE A WELL-FOUNDED BEAR I WILL NOT GET A BIASED HEARING -- UNBIASED HEARING BY YOU TODAY BECAUSE OF YOUR -- THERE IS A REPORT OF MISCONDUCT FROM THE FLORIDA BAR WITH REGARDS TO YOU AND -- HAND THIS COMMISSIONER WHO HAD A CHARGE ON HIM PRIOR TO HIM BECOMING A COMMISSIONER.
I HAVE THE ENTIRE FILE, YOUR HONOR.
>> I DON'T HAVE ANY IDEA WHAT YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT.
SERIOUSLY. NOW IF YOU HAVE PROOF OF THAT AND YOU WANT TO GIVE IT TO THE CITY ATTORNEY, YOU CAN DO THAT.
>> WAS IT THE WHOLE FILE. >> THE ENTIRE FIRE.
>> JUST THAT WHOLE FILE. >> YES.
>> MR. SAUCEDO CAN GRAB IT FROM YOU.
THANK YOU. >> THIS IS RELATED TO A DEFENDANT, ALFRED PERRY AND NOT CURTIS JOHNSON.
>> IT HAS TO DO WITH CURTIS JOHNSON AS WELL.
>> COULD YOU PERHAPS -- >> ELABORATE.
>> HOW IT INVOLVES MR. JOHN ON. >> ACCORDING THE 122-PAGE DOCUMENT, IT BASICALLY STATES THAT HONORABLE ROSS WAS A PUBLIC DEFENDER AT THE TIME AND SHE WAS REPRESENTING MR. ALFRED AND WHAT HAD OCCURRED WAS THAT HE WAS SHOT BY CURTIS JOHNSON, WHO IS NOW COMMISSIONER. AND IN THAT YOU WERE THE PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR MR. ALFRED, BUT YOUR COMMENTS TOED JUDGE IN THE CASE LED TO MR. ALFRED BEING ARR ARRESTED AND ALSO JAILED AND HE CONTRACTED HIV WHILE PROTECTING COMMISSIONER CURTIS JOHNSON. IT IS ALL IN THERE.
>> AND WHAT IS THERE BETWEEN YOU AND CURTIS JOHNSON?
>> CURTIS JOHNSON HAS A LONG HISTORY WITH REGARDS TO
[00:15:05]
RETALIATORY BEHAVIOR TOWARD ME DIRECTLY, INCLUDING AND NOT LIMITED TO THE SHORT-TERM RENTAL ARENA WHERE I HAVE BEEN AN ADVOCATE FOR MANY YEARS, ABOUT FOUR YEARS.>> MA'AM, I DON'T HAVE A CLUE AS TO WHAT YOU ARE SAYING.
I REMEMBER ALFRED PERRY. AND I DO REMEMBER WHAT I SAID TO
HIM. >> OKAY, WELL IT ALSO INVOLVED CURTIS JOHNSON. MR. JOHNSON WAS LET GO FREE BASED ON COMMENTS THAT I BELIEVE THAT YOU HAD MADE TAMPA ALL IN THE RECORD IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO READ IT.
IT IS 1 2 PAGES THOUGH. >> I REMEMBER THAT.
>> THE FLORIDA BAR THEN DID A FORMAL REPRIMAND.
>> DID A MINOR REP A MAN AND. SAID I SHOULD HAVE SAID WHAT I SAID TO HIM IN COURT. AND THAT WAS IT.
>> AND CURTIS JOHNSON WENT FREE BECAUSE OF IT, AFTER HE SHOT
ALFRED PERRY. >> I WAS NOT A PROSECUTOR.
I WAS A DEFENSE ATTORNEY. >> RIGHT, FOR MR. ALFRED.
>> YES. >> BUT ON THE OTHER SIDE WAS THE DEFENDANT, CURTIS JOHNSON, WHO THEN WAS FREED.
>> WELL, YOU HAVE TO TALK TO THE PROSECUTOR'S OFFICE ABOUT THAT.
>> IT IS ALL IN THE PAPERWORK BECAUSE BASICALLY STATES THAT YOU HAD ASSISTED THE JOHNSON FAMILY -- YOU HAVE SOME RELATIONSHIP WITH THE FATHER OF THE JOHNSON FAMILY.
IT'S -- I DON'T KNOW -- >> I DON'T KNOW WHERE YOU GET THAT FROM. I DO KNOW THAT MRS. JOHN SON GRW UP IN THE SAME TOWN I DID, BUT -- SHE IS MY GRANDMA'S AGE.
SO WHEN I CAME ALONG, SHE WAS -- SHE HADN'T MOVED DOWN HERE.
>> WELL, YOUR HONOR, I DON'T FEEL LIKE I CAN GET -- I HAVE A WELL-ROUNDED FEAR I WILL NOT BE ABLE TO GET AN UNBIASED, YOU
KNOW, HEARING HERE WITH YOU. >> I AM NOT GOING TO RECUSE
>> YOUR FACTS ARE MISLED. I DON'T KNOW WHAT YOU ARE
I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO STATE ON THE RECORD THAT GOVERNMENTAL RETALIATION IS A WELL-FOUNDED SUPREME COURT RULING FOR LOSMAN VERSUS RIVERA BEACH. I AM SURE YOU ARE FAMILIAR WITH.
>> NO, I AM NOT. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I THOUGHT THEY WERE ELICITING TESTIMONY RELATED TO WHAT SHE BELIEVES
YOUR CONFLICT IS. >> GOES TO SAY --
>> SHE DOES HAVE AN ATTORNEY THAT CAN ARGUE FOR HER, BUT THIS WAS SUPPOSED TO BE A QUESTION SESSION RELATING TO TESTIMONY FROM HIS CLIENT. SO I WILL ASK THAT WE GET BACK
TO WHAT WE WERE ASKED TO DO. >> I AM TESTIFYING MY WELL-ROUNDED FEAR AND WHY I FEEL I AM ENTITLED TO PUT THAT ON THE
RECORD, YOUR HONOR. >> YOU CAN PUT THAT ON THE RECORD, BUT I DON'T THINK YOU HAVE ANY LEGAL FOUNDATION TO RECUSE ME. NOW WHAT IS YOUR GRIEVANCE? AS PREVIOUSLY STATED, I HAVE A WELL-FOUNDED FEAR THAT PROCEDURAL AND MY RIGHTS TO DUE PROCESS WILL NOT BE TREATED IN A JUST AND FAIR SITUATION HERE TODAY IN FRONT OF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FRAN ROSS, AND I WILL NOT BE GIVEN A FAIR AND IMPARTIAL HEARING DUE TO WHAT THE FLORIDA BAR HAS ALREADY RULED AGAINST YOUR HONOR WITH REGARDS TO WHAT THE CITY
ATTORNEY HAS IN HER FILE. >> YOU ARE GOING BY MISS LAGARZO
AND IRS DANZANEK. >> I AM LOOKING THROUGH YOUR PAPERWORK AND FIND NO RELATIONSHIP TO CURTIS JOHNSON.
DO YOU KNOW WHERE IT IS? I CAN UNDERLINE IT FOR YOU.
>> I WILL TELL YOU WHAT. THIS IS TAKING UP MORE TIME THAN I IMAGINE. COUNSELOR, DO YOU NEED TIME TO LOOK AT THESE DOCUMENTS? SO IF THERE IS SOMETHING IN THERE THAT IS RELATED TO CURTIS JOHNSON, I WILL BE HAPPY TO LOOK AT IT, BUT I THINK IT -- RELATED TO THE RECUSAL AND
[00:20:04]
DISQUAL DISQUALIFICATION, IT SAYS THAT UNDER STATUTE -- AND THIS IS FROM RULE 3 OF THE RULES OF PROCEDURE FOR THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.SO UNDER RULE 3-B, PURSUANT TO FLORIDA STATUTE 112-314.
THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WILL NOT DECIDE ANY CASE FOR THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE'S PRIVATE GAIN OR LOSS OR OF GAIN OR LOSS OF WHICH THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HAS BEEN RETAINED ORB THE GAIN AND LOSS OF A PARENT, ORGANIZATION OR SUBSIDIARY OF A CORPORATE PRINCIPLE BY WHICH THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.
AND THE PRIVATE GAIN OR A LOSS OF A RELATIVE OR BUSINESS SOEFB, ASSOCIATES. SUSPECT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE SHOULD NOT DECIDE ANY CASE WHEN THE IMPARTIAL AT MAY REASON ME BE QUESTIONED BY THE CODE OF THE JUDICIAL CONDUCT.
IN THE EVENT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATES DETERMINES THERE IS GROUNDS FOR DISQUALIFICATION, THE DEPARTMENT WILL REFER THE CASE TO ANOTHER SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.
THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE SHOULD PUBLICLY STATE THE GROUNDS OF RECUSAL AND UPON 15 DAYS REQUIRE THE VOTING CONFERENCE 8-B MEMORANDUM. SO THAT IS THE -- THE SUBSECTIONS FOR RECUSAL OR DISQUAL DISQUALIFICATION. SO IT IS REALLY YOUR DECISION WHETHER YOU BELIEVE UNDER 3E OR CODE 143 YOU SHOULD RECUSE YOURSELF BASED ON ANY SORT OF FINANCIAL GAIN OR LOSS FOR THOSE LISTED INDIVIDUALS OR YOUR IMPARTIALITY IS REASONABLY QUESTIONED. AGAIN, I AM STILL HAPPY TO LOOK THROUGH WHAT THEY HAVE, BUT I -- AS I WAS TRYING TO SKIM THROUGH, IT IS A GIANT FILE. I SAW NOTHING RELATED TO CURTIS
JOHNSON IN THAT FILE. >> I TELL YOU WHAT.
>> SURE. >> AND IN LIGHT OF THIS MOTION, AND HOW MANY PAGES IS IT? HER FILE -- I DON'T KNOW HOW LONG HER FILE IS. IT'S --
>> SHE SAYS IT INCLUDES A REPORT THAT IS 122 PAGES.
>> I AM GOING TO CONTINUE THIS SO THAT WE CAN GO THROUGH THE DOCUMENTS AND MAKE A DECISION. SO I CAN LEAVE THEM FOR YOU,
YOUR HONOR. >> YOU CAN LEAVE THEM WITH THE
CITY ATTORNEY. >> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR.
>> NEXT HEARING IS -- ONE SECOND, SIR.
SIR, ONE SECOND. >> WE WILL GIVE YOU THE HEARING
DATE FOR THE NEXT HEARING. >> OKAY.
VERY WELL. >> OUR NEXT HEARING WILL BE FOR
NOVEMBER 1 AT 1:30. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WITH YOUR PERMISSION WE WILL CONTINUE TO NOVEMBER 1 AT 1:30 P.M.
>> ALL RIGHT, THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR.
OUR NEXT CASE IS CASE 23-2120, JAYCEE PARK, REGINALD TOUSSAINT.
I WANT TO GET FOR THE RECORD WE WILL BE CONTINUING 1715 UNIT D
ANDL, BOTH L, BOTH CASES. >> WHEN YOU ARE READY, MR.
[E. 23-2120PK Jaycee Park Reginald Toussaint Michael Rabenecker]
RABENECKER. >> GOOD AFTERNOON, YOUR HONOR, MY NAME IS MICHAEL RABENECKER AND EMPLOYED WITH THE CITY OF FORT PIERCE AS A PARKING ENFORCEMENT SPECIALIST.
BEFORE IS YOU CASE NUMBER 23-2120, A PARKING CITATION THAT WAS WRITTEN AT JAYCEE PARK. THE CITATION APPEAL.
THE VIOLATOR CAME BACK AS A REGINALD TOUSSAINT.
CITATION NUMBER 20070. PARKING CITATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 34-31-P, PARKING IN A HANDI CAPPED SPACE.
THE CITY IS REQUESTING THAT A $250 FINE, $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE WITH A TOTAL DUE OF $260 THE CITY REQUESTS THAT IS THE
[00:25:02]
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION EXISTS THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED IN TOTAL DUE ABOVE.FAILURE TO PAY SUCH A FINE WILL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS THAT ARE TIME AND DATE STAMPED. WAIT, DOES HE NEED TO SEE THEM? AT THIS TIME THE CITY WILL MOVE IN AS COMPOSITE 1, THE
PHOTOGRAPHS. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.
ANYTHING FURTHER? NO, YOUR HONOR.
>> SIR, STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.
>> REGINALD TOUSSAINT. >> HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO THE
ALLEGATION? >> I RESPOND TO THE -- THE SIGNS WERE CONFUSING TO ME, TO BE HONEST.
THE WAY THEY ARE STACKED ON TOP OF EACH OTHER.
I MEAN, THAT IS -- THAT IS ALL I CAN SAY, YOUR HONOR.
THAT I WAS GENUINELY CONFUSED BY THE SIGNS.
>> SIR, DID YOU FILE AN APPEAL ON THIS? LIKE YOU SENT IN LIKE PAPERWORK CONTESTING IT?
I BELIEVE SO, YES. >> DO WE HAVE THOSE? IT SHOULD BE IN THERE. IT IS IN THE PACKET.
>> THE PHOTOGRAPHS. >> CAN I SEE THOSE, SPECIAL MASTER? YES.
>> DID YOU SEND YOUR OWN PHOTOGRAPHS IN.
>> I MAY HAVE A PICTURE OF HOW THE -- I BELIEVE I MAY HAVE.
>> THERE ARE NO PHOTOS. >> IT IS OUT OF ORDER.
THE LAST PAGE OF THIS IS WHAT HE SENT IN.
>> RIGHT. AND NO PHOTOS OF THE SIGNS, THAT HE SENT IN BUT PHOTOS OF THE SIGN INCLUDED IN MY PACKET.
>> SO PART OF WHAT WE ENTERED, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, IS HIS EXHIBIT THAT IS THE LAST PAGE. I HAVE MOVED IT TO THE END.
SOME THAT IS THE PAPERWORK YOU FILLED OUT AND SENT IN.
>> I AM NOT SURE. I DON'T EVEN --
>> DO YOU WANT TO LOOK AT IT? NO, I KNOW WHAT I SENT IN.
IF I SENT IN A PHOTO -- I AM NOT SURE IF I SENT ONE IN.
>> I THOUGHT YOU HAD PHOTOS BECAUSE OURS WAS OUT OF ORDER.
I MOVED YOUR PAPERWORK TO THE VERY END AND ALL OUR PHOTOS ARE
>> OKAY. ANYTHING FURTHER, SIR? I CAN ACKNOWLEDGE NOW THAT I SEE THE SIGNS, BUT AT THE TIME IN ALL HONESTY, THEY WERE CONFUSING AS FAR AS THE PARKING AVAILABILITY WHERE TO PARK WITH THE TRAILERS AND TRUCKS AND WHICH WAS HANDICAPPED. I DON'T HAVE ANYTHING ELSE TO
SAY AFTER THAT. >> ANYTHING FURTHER? I WILL JUST POINT OUT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE NO BOAT TRAILER AND NO HANDICAP STICKER. EITHER WAY, IT IS STILL A
VIOLATION. >> ARE YOU LOOKING AT THE PHOTOGRAPH THAT IS ON YOUR SCREEN?
I AM, YOUR HONOR. >> SO WHAT WAS CONFUSING ABOUT THAT? THE TRAILER SIGN.
BECAUSE I DROPPED -- I HAD BROUGHT A TRAILER WITH A FRIEND PRIOR TO THIS AND LIKE I SAID IT WAS SO CONFUSING, YOUR HONOR.
SO MANY LINES AND SO MANY DIFFERENT -- IF YOU SEE HOW IT IS SET UP AT JAYCEE PARK, IT IS ONLY LIKE A NARROW WAY TO PARK.
IT WAS CONFUSING TO ME. THAT IS THE HONEST TRUTH.
>> ALL RIGHT, ANYTHING FURTHER? NO, YOUR HONOR.
>> ALL RIGHT, BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND THE TESTIMONY PRESENTED I FIND THAT A VIOLATION EXISTS THAT REGINALD TOUSSAINT IS THE PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION.
YOU WILL BE FINED $250 FOR PARKING IN THAT HANDICAP SPOT, AN AS ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10D WITH A TOTAL DUE OF $260.
>> IS THERE ANY WAY TO ASK THE COURT TO MITIGATE THE GUYS AT
I DON'T HAVE THAT THAT AUTHORITY.
>> OKAY. HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY THAT? PROBABLY NEED TWO MONTHS, MAYBE
IN ORDER TO PAY THAT. >> I WILL GIVE YOU 30 DAYS TO PAY, AND FAILURE TO PAY IT WILL HAVE ADDITIONAL GUYS AND COSTS BEING ASSESSED AGAINST YOU. AND FAILURE TO PAY COULD RESULT IN A FINE OR CITATION BEING SENT OVER TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM
[00:30:07]
WHERE YOU WILL INCUR ADDITIONAL GUYS AND COSTS.30 DAYS TO APPEAL DECISION. GOOD LUCK.
>> 23-2444 SOSOUTH CAUSEWAY PAR I MEANA WRIGHT TROUTMAN.
[F. 23-2444PK South Causeway Park Ameenah Wright Troutman Michael Rabenecker]
>> WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> YOUR HONOR THE NEXT CASE IS 23-24444 PARKING CITATION THAT OCCURRED ON SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK.
THE CASE INITIATED AUGUST 27, 2023.
CITATION APPEAL. THE VITAMINER IN THE CASE A AMEENAH WRIGHT TROUTMAN. 20328 PARKING VIOLATION OF 34-31-E, PARK PROGRAM EXHIBITED ASKING FOR A $50 FEE, ADMINISTRATION FEE $10 AND TOTAL OF 60.
THE CITY REQUESTS THAT IF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION EXISTS, THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE AS INDICATED ABOVE FAILURE TO PAY WILL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COURT SYSTEM.
>> I HAVE MY OWN PICTURES. I AM NOT DISPUTING ME BEING PARKED THERE. I AM DISPUTING THERE WASN'T ANY SIGNS TO SAY NO PARKING -- SORRY, IS IT MY TURN?
WAS THIS AN APPEAL? THE LAST PAGE.
>> THOSE WERE HER PHOTOS. >> WHAT A I WILL MOVE IN SPECIAL MAGISTRATE IS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1 FOR THE CITY ARE THE PHOTOGRAPHS AND ON THE RESPONDENT'S BEHALF -- CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG, DO YOU WANT THE PHOTOGRAPH YOU SUBMITTED WELL THE CITATION APPEAL THAT YOU BROUGHT IN FOR THE SPECIAL
MAGISTRATE TO REVIEW. >> DO I WANT TO SEE IT? DO YOU WANT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE TO HAVE THEM TO
REVIEW. >> IS THAT NOT SOMETHING THAT IS
AUTOMATICALLY DONE. >> IF YOU MOVE YOUR EVIDENCE IN, YOU CAN. BUT I CAN MOVE IT IN ON YOUR BEHALF. IS THAT SOMETHING YOU WOULD LIKE
>> ON HER BEHALF, I WILL MOVE ONE AND TWO, HER APPEAL
PAPERWORK AND HER PHOTOGRAPH. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.
ANYTHING FURTHER. >> NO, YOUR HONOR.
>> HOW DO YOU RESPOND? >> FIRST I WOULD LIKE TO SAY THIS IS MY FIRST TIME EVEN COMING TO THIS PARK BEFORE.
SO I WASN'T FAMILIAR, BUT, AGAIN, WHEN I PULLED UP, I PARALLEL PARKED IN BETWEEN OTHER CARS.
I DIDN'T SEE ANY SIGNS THAT SAYS NO PARKING SO I ASSUMED THERE WAS PARKING THERE BECAUSE AT LEAST THREE OR FOUR CARS PARKED THERE ALREADY. ASSUMED.
I LOOKED AROUND. I DIDN'T SEE ANY SIGNS THAT SAID NO PARKING. I DON'T WANT TO GIVE AWAY MY MONEY, SO -- I THOUGHT I WAS CAUTIOUS.
I WAS AT THE BEACH. WHEN I CAME BACK, I HAD A TICKET
ON MY CAR. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THIS WAS A SITUATION WHERE ONE PERSON CHOSE TO PARK IN THE ROADWAY.
ACTUALLY A ROADWAY. BECAUSE THEY PARKED THERE, FIVE MORE CARS PARKED THERE. UNFORTUNATELY ALL FIVE CARS GOT CITATIONS. BECAUSE IT IS ACTUALLY NOT -- IT IS A ROADWAY. IT IS NOT A PARKING AREA.
SO IT IS UNFORTUNATE THAT ONE PERSON CHOSE TO DO THAT AND STARTED A TREND BUT IT IS NOT A PARKING AREA AT ALL.
IT IS ACTUALLY A ROADWAY. >> THAT IS FINE, BUT NOTHING
THAT SAYS NO PARKING. >> ISN'T THERE A SIGN THAT SAYS PARKING IN DESIGNATED SPACES ONLY.
>> RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU. SIGNS AT BOTH ENTRANCE THAT SAY PARK IN DESIGNATED SPACES ONLY AND SIGNS THROUGHOUT THE PARK PARK IN DESIGNATED SPACES ONLY. THE DESIGNATED SPACES ARE DESIGNATED BY THE PARKING BUMPER, NOT THE ROADWAY.
>> AGAIN, I NEVER EVEN BEEN TO THIS PARK BEFORE.
AND I FOLLOW -- BECAUSE I DID NOT SEE ANYTHING THAT SAID NO PARKING SO, YOU KNOW, IT WASN'T CLEAR.
OBVIOUSLY IF I SAW A SIGN THAT SAID NO PARKING, I DEFINITELY WOULD NOT HAVE PARKED MY CAR THERE.
UNFORTUNATELY LIKE SHE SAID, I FELT LIKE EVERYBODY WAS PARKED THERE. I FELL IN LINE.
I ASSUMED IT WAS A PARKING SPACE.
>> OKAY, DID YOU SEE THE SIGN? >> NO, I DID NOT.
[00:35:04]
>> A SIGN AT THE ENTRANCE AND SIGNS THROUGHOUT THE PARK.
I FREQUENTLY DRIVE OVER THERE BECAUSE WE GET SO MANY
VIOLATIONS FROM OVER THERE. >> OKAY.
BUT WHEN I PULLED ON THE DRIVEWAY, I DID NOT SEE THE LITTLE SIGN ON THE BOTTOM OF THE SIGNAGE.
AGAIN. WHERE I PARK, IT DIDN'T SAY ANYTHING ABOUT PARKING AND I DIDN'T -- HOW AM I TO KNOW THAT IS DESIGNATED. A ROW FULL OF CARS THERE AND MY FIRST TIME GOING TO THAT PARK BEFORE.
>> ALL RIGHT. ANYTHING FURTHER?
>> BASED ON EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED I FIND THAT A VIOLATION EXISTS AND THAT AMEENAH WRIGHT TROUTMAN IS THE PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION.
IMPOSED A $50 FINE, $10 ADMIN FEE WITH A TOTAL OF $60.
YOU HAVE 18 DAYS TO PAY IT. IF NOT THIS COULD BE FORWARDED OVER TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM WHERE YOU WILL ACHIEVE GUYS AND COST. YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.
>> I PLAN TO DO THAT. THANK YOU.
>> GOOD LUCK. WHEN YOU ARE READY.
[L. 23-786PK 400 Blk Pinewood Drive Linnes Finney, JR Michael Rabenecker]
>> MY NEXT CASE 23-786. PINEWOOD DRIVE.
LARRY FINNEY JR. >> YOUR HONOR, THE NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU IS CASE NUMBER 23-786, A PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT THE 400 BLOCK OF PINEWOOD DRIVE.
THE CASE INITIATED MARCH 19, 2023.
A REGULAR CITATION PRESENTATION. THE VIOLATOR CAME BACK AS A LINNES FINNEY JR., 19187, 34-31L PARKING IN THE CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY. ASKING FOR $50, $10 ADMIN FEE AND LATE FEE OF 18 FOR TOTAL OF $78.
IF THE IF I REQUESTS THAT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION EXISTS VIOLATORS WILL BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE.
AND WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.
I HAVE PHOTOGRAPHS THAT ARE DATE AND TIME STAMPED.
>> CAN I SEE THE PHOTOGRAPHS? >> AND MR. FINNEY, I BELIEVE YOU SENT A LETTER IN. DO YOU WANT TO ADMITTED ON YOUR
AND THE PHOTOGRAPHS. >> I KNOW YOU KNOW HOW TO DO THAT YOURSELF. WOULD YOU LIKE FOR ME TO DO IT?
YOU CAN GO AHEAD AND DO IT. >> ANYTHING YOU WOULD LIKE FOR
US TO ADMIT, HAND IT TO US. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WHAT MR. FINNEY HAS A LETTER ADDRESSING YOU AND A PHOTOGRAPH AND A GOAL R GOOGLES MAP IMAGE AS RESPONDENT EXHIBIT 1.
AND BEHALF OF THE CITY AS -- THE CITY EXHIBIT 1 COMPOSITE PHOTOGRAPHS. I AM SORRY I DIDN'T PUT HIS EVIDENCE OR EXHIBIT STICKER ON THERE.
[00:40:02]
OKAY, MR. FINNEY. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, WILL THAT
BE ADMITTED AS EXHIBIT NUMBER 1. >> THEY WILL BE ADMITTED INTO
EVIDENCE. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THE SHORT STORY IS, THIS -- THIS LOCATION TO THE LEFT OF MY CAR IS AN ENTERPRISE RENT-A-CAR LOCATION. ON THAT PARTICULAR DAY, I WENT TO ENTERPRISE -- I WAS GOING TO JACKSONVILLE.
I HAD A NUMBER OF PEOPLE GOING WITH ME.
WE WERE IN A LARGE SUV. I WAS -- I PARKED IN THE FRONT OF THE BUILDING. I WAS -- AND THEN I WAS TOLD I COULDN'T PARK IN THE FRONT OF THE BUILDING.
WHEN I ASKED THEM WHERE CAN I PARK -- SHOULD I PARK.
THEY DIRECTED ME TO THE SIDE OF THE BUILDING.
THAT'S WHERE I PARKED. THERE WAS ANOTHER CAR PARKED IN FRONT OF ME WHEN I PARKED THERE. THERE WAS NO INDICATION, NO SIGNS OR ANYTHING INDICATING THAT WAS A CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY ON GRASS. WHEN WE RETURNED THAT SUNDAY, I -- I FOUND THE TICKET. AND ALTHOUGH THIS IS CLEARLY HEARSAY, MY CONVERSATION WITH ENTERPRISE WAS BASICALLY THEY DON'T KNOW WHO TOLD ME TO PARK ON THE SIDE.
COUPLE OF WEEKS LATER, I LEFT CHURCH, AND THE FIRST PHOTOGRAPH THAT I WAS SHOWING YOU, I WENT BY ENTERPRISE AGAIN AND IN THE SAME LOCATION WAS ANOTHER VEHICLE PARKED THERE.
AND AS I DRIVE THERE THROUGH, I KEEP -- I HAVE SEEN VEHICLES PARKED ON THAT GRASSY AREA. IT IS NOT IN THE ROADWAY SO NO INDICATION FOR ME TO KNOW THAT THAT WAS A CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.
THE GOOGLE MAPS WHICH I JUST SHOWN YOU IS THE ACTUAL GOOGLE
AERIAL VIEW I TOOK OFF MY -- >> WAIT UNTIL 2:20.
THE NATIONAL ALERT. >> WE WERE GOING TO TAKE A BREAK AT 2:20 BUT THEY BUMPED US BY TWO MINUTES.
>> SO I HAVE A SITUATION THAT BASICALLY WAS TOLD TO PARK IN THAT LOCATION. ANOTHER VEHICLE PARKED IN THAT LOCATION. THERE WAS NO INDICATION OF NO PARKING AT THAT LOCATION. I RETURNED, AND I -- I SEE VEHICLES PARKED THERE BEING DIRECTED THERE AS RECENTLY AS PHOTOGRAPHS. I HAVE NO KNOWLEDGE THAT THAT WAS A RESTRICTED AREA. IT DOESN'T LOOK LIKE A RIGHT-OF-WAY ALTHOUGH IT PROBABLY IS, NO INDICATION THAT NOBODY CAN PARK THERE ESPECIALLY WHEN THEY TOLD ME TO PARK ON THAT SIDE. YOU KNOW, OBVIOUSLY THIS IS A PRINCIPAL THING FOR ME. I CAN PAY FOR THE $50.
I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING WRONG. I DID WHAT THEY ASKED ME TO DO.
>> DID YOU TELL THEM YOU GOTTEN A TICKET?
>> I TOLD THEM IF I GET A FINE, I AM GOING TO SUE THEM.
>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, STAFF INFORMED ME BASED ON M MR. FINNEY'S TESTIMONY AND WHY THE LETTER WAS SENT LATE.
THERE IS NO OBJECTION OF MOVING THE $18 LATE FEE.
SO STAFF WILL BE ASKING FOR THE $50 FINE AND $10 ADMIN FEE AND A
>> YES, MA'AM. >> HOW DO YOU RESPOND TO THAT?
>> AGAIN, NO NOTICE -- NO INDICATION AT ALL THAT IS CITY PROPERTY OR A VIOLATION OF A RIGHT-OF-WAY.
I MEAN, I GOT TO HAVE NOTICE BEFORE YOU DECLARE ME IN VIOLATION OF SOMETHING THAT IS PLAIN AND OBVIOUS.
PARTICULARLY IF THEY TELL ME TO PARK OVER THERE.
WHAT -- YOU I MEAN, I DIDN'T HAVE ANY OTHER OPTIONS.
IT IS NOT AS IF I DECIDED ON MY OWN TO PARK THERE.
>> YES, MA'AM, WE HAVE HEARD THIS ARGUMENT NUMEROUS TIMES.
CLEARLY A CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY. YOU HAVE AT THAT SIDEWALK RUNNING RIGHT THERE. THAT CLEARLY SHOWS THAT WE ARE RUNNING A SIDEWALK THROUGH CITY-OWNED PROPERTY OR GOVERNMENT-OWNED PROPERTY. ADDITIONALLY, IF YOU LOOK AT THE
[00:45:03]
BACK END OF HIS VEHICLE IT IS OVER THE SIDEWALK.YOU ALSO CANNOT PARK ON A SIDEWALK.
>> IT IS NOT OVER THE SIDEWALK. THE ANGLE OF THAT PHOTOGRAPH DOES NOT SHOW THAT OVER THE SIDEWALK, COUNSELOR.
>> I AM FAMILIAR WITH THAT AREA. THAT IS A PROBLEM.
>> HOW LONG WAS THE CAR PARKED THERE.
>> FOR THE WEEKEND. WE LEFT THERE FRIDAY MORNING AND GOT BACK THAT SUNDAY -- SUNDAY AFTERNOON AFTER 12:00.
ENTERPRISE WAS CLOSED. I CALLED THEM THE FOLLOWING DAY.
>> AND WHAT DID THEY SAY WHEN YOU CALLED THEM?
>> I CALLED THEM AND TOLD ME THINK TOLD ME TO PARK OVER THERE. I GOT A TICKET OVER THERE AND I SAID WHY DID YOU TELL ME TO PARK OVER THERE.
AND THE RESPONSE WAS, WELL, WE LET PEOPLE PARK UP FRONT.
AND THAT I DON'T KNOW WHO TOLD YOU TO PARK THERE.
I SAID, WELL ANOTHER VEHICLE WAS OVER THERE.
HE SAID I DON'T KNOW WHO TOLD YOU -- HE DIDN'T SAY ANYTHING ABOUT HIS KNOWLEDGE OF THAT BEING A CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY.
I SAID, WELL, I AM GOING TO CONTEST THE TICKET.
IF I GET FINED -- I KNOW IT IS ONLY $50, I WILL HAVE TO COME BACK. HE ACTED LIKE HE DIDN'T CARE.
>> CITY? OUR POSITION REMAINS THE SAME, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. I FRANKLY DON'T KNOW NO INDICATION WHERE YOU SEE A SIDEWALK THAT YOU CAN'T PARK NEXT TO A SIDEWALK. THAT IS NOT AN INDICATION TO ME
THAT IS CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY. >> AND THERE IS NOT A NO PARKING
SIGN OVER THERE. >> NO, MA'AM.
I HAVE BEEN THERE A NUMBER OF TIMES LOOKING FOR SOMETHING.
THERE IS NOTHING THERE. >> I HAVE BEEN THERE TOO, THERE
ISN'T ANYTHING THERE. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, M MR. ARRAIZ WILL PULL UP THE PROPERTY APPRAISER'S WEB SITE FOR THATADDRFOR THAT ADDRESS. PINEWOOD.
>> AS YOU CAN SEE, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE -- YOU WILL HAVE TO ZOOM OUT A LITTLE BIT. THE PARCEL'S OWNERSHIP ENDS AT
THE SQUAWK. >> THERE IS NO INDICATION THAT -- I MEAN HOW IS ANY NORMAL CITIZEN GOING TO PULL UP A WEB SITE AND SEE WHERE THE PARKING IS -- WHERE THE CITY'S LAND IS LOCATED. I MEAN, THAT -- THAT IS AN
UNREALISTIC EXPECTATION. >> I KNOW YOU KNOW AND EVERY -- WE ARE PRESUMED TO KNOW THE LAWS OF THE STATER IN, THE COUNTY WE ARE IN AND THE CITY WE ARE IN. ALL OF THE RULES ARE POSTED ONLINE FOR OUR PARKING RULES. BUT YOU ARE PRESUMED TO KNOW THE LAWS OF THE JURISDICTION OF WHICH YOU ARE.
>> LACK OF WARNING. LACK OF NOTICE.
THERE IS NO WAY IN THE WORLD I WOULD HAVE KNOWN THAT ENTERPRISE DOESN'T OWN THAT PROPERTY. THEY TELL ME TO PARK OVER THERE.
LAST THING I WILL POINT OUT, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, AND I KNOW YOU HEARD ME SAY IT REPEATELY. WE CANNOT PUT NO PARKING SIGNS.
WE WOULD HAVE PARKING SIGNS EVERY TEN FEET IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ROAD. WE CANNOT DO THAT.
>> COUNSELOR, I DON'T DISAGREE WITH YOU.
MY PROBLEM IS BEING DIRECTED TO PARK OVER THERE.
>> THAT IS THE PROBLEM I GOT. THEY TOLD YOU TO PARK THERE.
>> YEAH. >> I MEAN IT IS NOT --
[00:50:05]
>> IF THEY HAVEN'T TOLD ME TO PARK THERE, I WOULD HAVE PARKED
AT THAT CHURCH RIGHT BEHIND IT. >> THAT, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THAT IS YOU TO DETERMINE IF THAT IS IS A VALID DEFENSE FOR PARKING THERE. THAT IS YOUR IN THE POSITION YOU ARE IN. AND I AM IN THE POSITION I AM
IN. >> YOU KNOW, IF THEY TOLD HIM TO PARK OVER THERE AND HE DID. I MEAN HE IS NOT --
>> I CAN TESTIFY TO THIS. I HAVE WRITTEN SEVERAL TICKETS THERE, EVEN FOR ENTERPRISE RENTAL CARS AND I REMEMBER ONE DAY A LADY COMING OUT, AND SHE WORKED THERE.
I SAY THESE CAN'T BE PARKED HERE.
SHE SAID OKAY AND DROVE ON. BOTH VEHICLES THAT WERE OWNED BY ENTERPRISE GOT TICKETS. SO THEY HAVE BEEN GIVEN NOTICE THAT IS A RIGHT-OF-WAY AND NOT PART OF THE LAND.
I CAN'T TESTIFY THAT WAS THE LADY THAT WAS WORKING, BUT I DO KNOW I HAVE WRITTEN ENTERPRISE VEHICLES TICKETS.
AND THEY PAID THEM. THAT IS ON RECORD.
AND THEY DON'T PARK THERE ANYMORE.
>> BUT THEY TELL PEOPLE TO PARK THERE.
>> I DON'T HAVE RECORD OF THAT, BUT I DON'T HAVE TESTIMONY OF
THAT. >> I JUST TESTIFIED TO IT.
>> AND YOU WERE PARKED THERE FOR TWO DAYS.
>> I WAS GONE. I WAS IN JACKSONVILLE.
>> YOU WERE IN JACKSONVILLE. >> THERE ARE NO SIGN IS UP THERE
THAT SAY YOU CAN'T PARK. >> NO.
>> BELIEVE IT OR NOT, THIS IS A TOUGH ONE.
I MEAN, NOT LIKE HE DELIBERATELY PARKED THERE.
HE ASKED THEM WHERE CAN I PARK. THEY TOLD HIM OVER THERE.
>> AGAIN, THAT IS WHY YOU GET TO MAKE THAT DECISION, AND I DON'T.
YES, MA'AM. >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR HELP,
COUNSELOR. >> YOU ARE VERY WELCOME, YES, MA'AM. [LAUGHTER]
ALL RIGHT. >> IF THIS WHEPS YOUR DECISION NOT THAT I KNOW IT DOES OR NOT, BUT YOU KNOW THIS ALREADY UNDER THE CODE. YOU HAVE DISCRETION ZERO FOR UP TO $500. WE ASK FOR $50 AS A STANDARD, BUT YOUR DISCRETION IS A $0 FINE UP TO $500 FINE.
>> ALL RIGHT. I AM GOING TO CHARGE YOU THE $10 ADMIN FEE AT THE CITY INCURS IN PROCESSING.
YOU ASKED IF YOU COULD PARK THERE.
THEY TOLD YOU COULD PARK THERE. I DON'T KNOW WHAT ELSE YOU COULD HAVE DONE. $10 ADMIN FEE THAT THE CITY INCURS IN BRINGING THESE CASES BEFORE THIS BODY.
HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU NEED TO PAY IT.
>> I COULD PAY IT TODAY. >> OKAY, GOOD LUCK.
NEXT TIME, BEWARE. >> WELL, I KNOW WHAT THE CITY
RIGHT-OF-WAY IS NOW. >> THANK YOU.
>> THANK YOU, MR. FINNEY. >> I CAN GO AHEAD AND SEND YOU A LINK AFTER THE HEARING. 14 DAYSES TO PAY.
>> SIR, ARE YOU GOING TO BE PAYING IT TODAY?
YES. >> I CAN SEND HIM A LINK.
I ALREADY AGREED TO SEND HIM A LINK.
>> YOU ARE GOING TO SEND HIM A LINK.
>> 14 DAYS TO PAY FOR THAT ONE. >> YES.
>> I AM SORRY, MR. FINNEY -- SPECIAL AGE IN STRAIGHT -- DID YOU TELL HIM HE HAS 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.
>> YEAH, BUT I DOUBT HE WILL APPEAL $10.
[M. 23-2248PK South Causeway Park Karl David Kahmann Michael Rabenecker]
>> THANK YOU, MR. FINNEY. OUR NEXT CASE IS CASE 23-2248 SOUTH SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK, CARL DAVID KAHMANN.
HELLO. I WILL GO SWEAR YOU IN.
RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND SAY YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.
>> KARL DAVID KAHMANN. >> THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE ABOUT
TO GIVE WILL BE THE TRUTH. >> YES.
>> THE NEXT CASE IS 23-2248, A PARKING CITATION VIOLATION THAT
[00:55:05]
WAS WRITTEN AT SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK.CASE WAS INITIATED MARCH 18, 2023.
A REGULAR CITATION OCCASION. THE VIOLATOR COMES BACK AT KARL DAVID KAHMANN, PARKING VIOLATION, 19185, 34-31F PARKING PROHIBITED. FINE $50, $10 ADN FEE AND LATE FEE OF $18 TO $TOTAL 78. THE CITY REQUIRES AND I HAVE PHOTOS THAT ARE DATE AND TIME STAMPED.
>> MR. KAHMANN, HAVE YOU HAD A CHANCE TO SEE THE PHOTOGRAPHS.
>> I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THEM. OKAY, THIS IS A DIFFERENT VIOLATION. THIS IS SOMETHING ELSE I SAW.
I THOUGHT THIS WAS A DIFFERENT TICKET.
I AM GUILTY OF THAT. ALL I WOULD LIKE TO SAY I DISCONNECTED MY TRAILER AND MY TRUCK TO WAIT FOR A PARKING PLACE TO OPEN. AND I WAS PARKED IN FRONT OF A CITY DUMPSTER AND I ACTUALLY KNOW THE PEOPLE, BECAUSE I AM THERE AT SUNRISE AND I HAVE COFFEE WITH THEM AND I KNEW THEY WEREN'T COMING TO PICK UP THE GARBAGE.
SO I PARKED THERE WAITING FOR ANOTHER PLACE TO OPEN UP.
I THOUGHT THIS WAS A DIFFERENT CASE.
>> WE WILL MOVE THE PHOTOGRAPHS IN AS CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1.
>> WHEN YOU SAY YOU THOUGHT THIS WAS A DIFFERENT CASE.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN? THERE IS ANOTHER PARKING TICKET THAT I AM FIGHTING RIGHT NOW THAT I WAS -- IN THIS SAME AREA ON THE SAME BEACH. AS I WAS DRIVING DOWN THE DIRT ROAD, THE SAME TRUCK AND TRAILER AND A WOMAN WAS STUCK IN HER WHEELCHAIR IN THE SAND, AND I PULLED OVER ALONG THE POST, JUMPED OUT OF MY TRUCK. HER HUSBAND ONLY HAD ONE LEG AND I HELPED HER BACK ON TO THE BLUE MAT THAT GOES FROM THE WATER TO THE HANDICAPPED SITUATION. AND THE OFFICER THAT CAME THERE WAS THREATENING ME. HE WROTE ME A TICKET.
I TRIED TO EXPLAIN TO HIM I WAS HELPING SOMEBODY.
BUT HE HAD PERSONAL VENGEANCE FROM ANOTHER CASE.
AND I HAVE THE VIDEO HERE OF HIM THREATENING ME.
YOU GOT AWAY LAST TIME, BUT THIS TIME I GOT YOU AND HE WROTE ME A $50 TICKET. I HAVE IT ALL ON VIDEO.
>> BUT THAT IS NOT BEFORE THIS COURT.
>> THAT IS NOT THE TICKET, NO. >> YOU HAVE OBJECTIONS TO THIS
TICKET? >> ONLY THE FACT I WAS JUST -- I DISCONNECTED AND IN FRONT OF A GARBAGE DUMPSTER AND JUST WAITING FOR SOMEONE OF THE TRAILER AREA BECAUSE TRAILER PARKING RIGHT ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THAT.
AND I WAS JUST WAITING FOR SOMEONE TO MOVE SO I COULD HOOK UP AND PULL BACK IN. I EXPLAINED IT TO HIM WHEN HE GOT THERE. BUT INSTEAD HE WROTE TWO TICKETS, ONE FOR EACH VEHICLE, FOR MY TRUCK AND MY TRAILER.
BUT I AM RIGHT IN FRONT OF THE GARBAGE -- AND I BELIEVE -- I BELIEVE IT WAS ABOUT 3:00 IN THE AFTERNOON AND GARBAGE COMES AT ABOUT 6:30. I KNOW BECAUSE I AM USUALLY THERE FOR SUNRISE AND I HAVE THAT -- I PICK UP GARBAGE FROM THE BEACH AND I STATED THAT FROM MICHAEL THAT -- THAT I KNEW THEY WEREN'T COMING AND I WAS JUST WAITING FOR A SPOT.
AS YOU KNOW, CAUSEWAY PARK IS A POPULAR BEACH.
>> A PARKING PROBLEM PRETTY MUCH ALL OVER THE CITY.
BECAUSE SO MANY PEOPLE HAVE MOVED HERE.
>> EXACTLY. >> YOU WILL GET TICKETED.
I CAN WITNESS THAT. >> I KNOW.
I ACTUALLY HAVE THREE RIGHT NOW. ONE OF THEM -- THE ONE I WAS
HOPING THIS WAS -- >> SIR, LET'S TALK ABOUT THIS
ONE. >> YES, MA'AM, YES, YOUR HONOR.
>> ANYTHING FURTHER? NO MA'AM.
>> NO, YOUR HONOR. >> I WOULD LIKE TO SAY ALSO THAT I AM EXTREMELY POOR RIGHT NOW. I DON'T TAKE ANY GOVERNMENT CHECKS AND I AM AN ARTIST AND DURING THE SUMMER IS MY HARDEST TIME. IF YOU ARE GIVING A FINE, PLEASE ALLOW ME TO GET WITH MY OTHER TICKETS AND MAKE PAYMENTS,
BECAUSE I CAN'T AFFORD IT. >> I CAN ONLY ADDRESS WHAT IS BEFORE ME RIGHT NOW. OKAY.
BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED I FIND A VIOLATION IS HERE AND KARL DAVID KAHMANN IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. A FINE OF $50, ADMIN FEE OF $10 AND LATE FEE OF $18. AND TOTAL TOO OF $78.
[01:00:01]
30 DAYS TO PAY THIS TICKET. >> CAN I MAKE PAYMENTS ON THIS TICKET? YOU WOULD HAVE TO GET TO THE CLERK. IF NOT, YOU COULD BE SENT OVER TO COUNTY COURT WHERE YOU WOULD INCUR ADDITIONAL GUYS AND COSTS.
30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> ALL RIGHT.
>> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR. >> YOU ARE WELCOME.
>> I BELIEVE THEY CAN PAY YOU IN ONE PAYMENT.
>> WHERE DO YOU GIVE IT? >> IN THE SAME BUILDING ON THE THIRD FLOOR. YOU CAN GIVE ME A CALL, I AM
[A. 23-1249 CE 1802 S US Highway 1 L & W RESORTS & ENTERPRISES OF FORT PIERCE LLC Heather Debevec]
>> OUR NEXT CASE IS 23-1249, 1802 SOUTH U.S. HIGHWAY 1 L&W RESORTS AND ENTERPRISES OF FORT PIERCE, LLC.
>> WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> OCCASION NUMBER 231802 SOUTH HIGHWAY 1, ENTERPRISES OF FORT PIERCE LLC.
CASE INITIATED MAY 5 OF THIS YEAR FOR VIOLATIONS IPMC 302.7 ACCESS RADIO HE STRUCTURES AND SECTION 117-3B REMOVAL OF SIGNS.
OBTAIN A PERMIT FROM THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT TO REPAIR THE STRUCTURE WHICH HOLDS THE AERIAL SIGNAGE.
OBTAIN A PERMIT FOR THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT TO REPAIR OR REPLACE THE DAMAGED FALLEN SIGN. THE CITY REQUESTS THAT A SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS VIOLATION EXISTS.
I SAW VIOLATION FOR SIGNS. I SPOKE TO THE OWNER OF THE RESORT STATING SHE WAS TRYING TO WORK WITH HER CONTRACTOR TO GET A FIRM DECISION ON THE POLES THAT HOLD UP THE AERIAL SIGN.
I HAVE PHOTOS OF WHICH TO SUBMIT.
>> BEFORE WE SUBMIT THE PHOTOGRAPHS, CAN I SEE THE PHOTOGRAPHS REALLY QUICK? OKAY.
SO -- SIR, WHAT IS YOUR NAME? MY NAME IS HALL OF FAME LIN, HELEN IS MY WIFE. DO YOU OWN THE PROPERTY?
>> YES. >> WHAT I ASKED THEM TO HOLD OFF ON FOR. THERE IS A PROGRAM WITH THE CITY RELATED TO BASICALLY A GRANT TO REPLACE SIGNS.
I AM NOT SURE IF YOUR PROPERTY QUALIFIES.
DID YOU KNOW ABOUT THAT PROGRAM? NO.
>> IS THAT SOMETHING WOULD YOU LIKE TO LOOK INTO TO RECEIVE GRANT FUNDING TO SEE YOU ARE ELIGIBLE TO HAVE THE SIGN RELAYED OR ASSIST WITH REPLACING THE SIGN?
>> WHO WOULD I SEE FOR THAT? YOU WILL HAVE TO CONTACT THE
CITY OFFICE. >> THEY ARE GOING TO TELL YOU
RIGHT NOW. >> BUILDING DEPARTMENT.
>> MISS VANDERHORST. >> SHOULD WE CONTINUE.
>> PERMIT WAS ISSUED. >> THE SAME DAY, I THINK.
I THINK HE PULLING LEGS. BUT TYPICALLY ON MY END, I CAN'T DO ANYTHING. BECAUSE THEY TOLD ME -- OUR COMMUNICATION -- THE INFORMATION WE RECEIVED SEEMS THEY ARE -- QUESTION CAN'T POSSIBLY KNOW ANYTHING.
>> WE CAN SET IT THE NEXT HEARING DATE, SPECIAL
MAGISTRATE. >> TALK TO MISS VANDERHORST.
>> NOVEMBER 1 AT 1:30. >> NOVEMBER 1, OKAY.
I DON'T KNOW IF THAT WILL BE ANY HELP FOR ON OUR LAST
COMMUNICATION. >> SIR, YOU NEED TO GET WITH THE
THEY SAID THEY WERE SUPPOSED TO DO SOMETHING ON THE 6TH.
>> SIR, PLEASE GET WITH -- >> WE WILL BE IN COMMUNICATION.
OUR NEXT CASE IS 12 OPINION 1032, 523 SOUTH U.S. HIGHWAY 1.
>> CAN YOU GO TO -- HEALTHER IS GOING OUTSIDE.
>> ARE YOU ABLE TO PRESENT OR ARE YOU GOING OUTSIDE? SHE WANTED ME OUT THERE, SO I AM CONFUSED.
[A. 23-386 119 Wisteria Ave Jean Harvey Peggy Arraiz]
[01:05:01]
>> I CAN JUMP TO 6 A. >> OUR NEXT CASE 23-386119 WISTERIA APPLICANT AVE. JANE HARE JEAN HARVEY.
WAS MISS HARVEY WHEN WE SWORE EVERYBODY IN.
SPECIAL MASTER, 23-386 NOR 119 WISTERIA AVENUE OPENED BY MISS JEAN HARVEY. IT WAS FEBRUARY 14, 2023 AND BEFORE YOU FOR A MASSEY HEARING. FINES HAVE BEEN ON THE PROPERTY BUT NO RANK HAVE BEEN FILED. CODE SECTIONS IN VIOLATION, 123-37 SUBSECTIONS 12 LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE.
ON JUNE 7, 2023, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE ROSS FOUND MISS HARVEY IN VIOLATION AND ORDERED TEN DAYS TO COMPLY OR BE FINED $100 A DAY. ON JUNE 22 OF THIS YEAR, THE AFFIDAVIT OF NONCOMPLIANCE WAS ISSUED WHICH IS WHAT INITIATED THE FINES. ON JULY 5, 2023, A MASSEY NOTICE WAS SENT TO THE OWNER. JULY 11, THE OWNER CAME TO THE OFFICE AND DID SUBMIT HER REQUEST FOR A MASSEY HEARING WHICH -- I AM NOT SURE IF IT WAS INCLUDED IN --
>> IT IS ACTUALLY AN ATTACHMENT. >> JUST AN ATTACHMENT.
>> DO WE HAVE THE PAPER COPY TO PROVIDE? YEAH, I DO I HAVE THE PAPER VERSION TO PROVIDE SO I HAVE MISS HARVEY'S REQUEST FOR REVIEW AS WELL AS PHOTO THAT WERE --
>> THAT HER REQUEST. AND WE HAVE A SERIES OF PHOTOS TO PRESENT TO SHOW THE WORK THAT HAS PROGRESSED OVER TIME, THE MOST RECENT ONES BEING YESTERDAY YOU ARE ACTUALLY IN THE PHOTOS.
>> HAS MISS HARVEY GOT TO SEE THEM?
>> I DON'T BELIEVE SHE HAS SEEN THE PHOTOS.
>> DO YOU WANT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE TO REVIEW THE LETTER
>> THIS HAS TAKEN A LOT OUT OF ME AND I DON'T HAVE ANY ELECTRICAL CUP AND I HAVE A CLIPPER -- AND I NEED A WORK -- LIKE -- WHAT WAS THE QUESTION? LET ME ASK STAFF IF YOU ARE IN
AGREEMENT TO GIVE HER MORE TIME. >> IT IS A MASSEY HEARING AND THERE ARE FINES RUNNING. SHE IS HERE TO ADDRESS THE
GIANTS. >> ARE NEW AGREEMENT TO STOP THE
FINE. >> I WILL LEAVE THAT UP TO THE
SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. >> MISS HARVEY, THE LETTER YOU WROTE TO US. DO YOU WANT THE SPECIAL
MAGISTRATE TO READ THE LETTER. >> RIGHT NOW TO READ IT? DWREM. MOVE THAT IN AS EXHIBIT ONE.
AND EXHIBIT TWO WILL BE THE PHOTOGRAPHS.
>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE TO GO ALONG WITH THOSE PHOTOGRAPHS.
STAFF WANTS TO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT MISS HARVEY HAS BEEN DOING WORK ON THE PROPERTY AND THE MOST CURRENT PHOTOS ARE ON THE TOP.
THERE IS A CHANGE THAT HAS HAPPENED WHERE SHE HAS BEEN
DOING WORK. >> ANYTHING FURTHER?
NOT AT THIS TIME. >> MISS HARVEY, HOW CLOSE ARE
YOU OF CLEARING EVERYTHING UP? >> WELL, I HAVE DONE SO MUCH AND SO PROUD OF MY YARD. AND, YOU KNOW, IT -- THINGS THAT I HAVE THERE FOR 30 YEARS, IT MEANS SO MUCH.
AND I -- I GOT SO I COULD CUT SOMETHING DOWN AND IT LOOKED REALLY NICE. I AM PROUD OF THE RESULTS THAT I HAVE AFTER THEY KEPT -- THEY EVEN CAME OVER AND TOLD ME, YOU KNOW, WHAT NEEDED TO BE SHORTCUT SHORTER AND REALLY HELP ME A
[01:10:05]
LOT. ONE OF MY BUSHES THAT I HAD.I STARTED -- IT WAS A FIRE BUSH AND JUST A BABY, YOU KNOW, IT JUST HAD A LITTLE -- A LITTLE BRANCH ON IT.
AND I STUCK IT IN. AND IT GREW AND IT IS THIS TALL NOW. HAD -- IT HAD 100 SWALLOWTAIL BUTTERFLIES JUST COMING IN -- COMING IN ALL THE TIME.
AND I FELT SO PROUD OF THAT. SO I AM PROUD OF SCHIFF GOOD MEMORIES WITH EVERYTHING IN MY REGARD BUT I CUT EVERYTHING BACK THAT I COULD AND I WILL CONDITION TO DO THIS EVERY WEEK BECAUSE IT GROWS SO FAST. BUT I APPRECIATE THE ADVICE AND THE INFORMATION THAT THEY GAVE ME AND TAMPA REALLY HELPED ME.
>> OKAY. HOW MUCH -- IS SHE IN COMPLIANCE, ALMOST? THERE HAS DEFINITELY BEEN WORK BEING DONE. JUST AS A REMINDER, WE ARE HERE AS A MASSEY HEARING. THE QUESTION IS DO THE FINES CONTINUE OR STAY THE FINES AND HOW LONG.
>> LET'S STAY THE FINES FOR NOW. HOW MUCH DO YOU THINK YOU CAN HAVE ALL OF THIS DONE IN 30 DAYS? I THINK SO. I -- I AM GOING TO GET -- I AM GOING TO TRY TO GET HELP. BECAUSE SOME OF THE THINGS.
I AM GOING TO SUGGEST -- MISS ARRAIZ SAID BECAUSE OF THE WEATHER WE ARE HAVING MORE THAN 30 DAYS.
>> I WILL GIVE YOU 60 DAYS. AND TRY TO GET EVERYTHING DONE AND GET ALL THE HELP YOU NEED, ALL RIGHT.
>> OKAY, THANK YOU. >> I BELIEVE THAT HEARING IS
DECEMBER 6 AT 1:30. >> THANK YOU SO MUCH, Y'ALL.
>> YOU ARE WELCOME. GOOD LUCK.
>> THANK YOU. >> HAVE A GOOD ONE, MISS HARVEY.
>> FINES CONTINUE ON THAT ONE? NO, SHE STOPPED THEM THANK YOU.
SORRY ABOUT THAT. I AM GOING TO -- DO I NEED TO SAY IT ON THE RECORD IF A CASE HAS BEEN PULLED?
CAN YOU GET HEATHER -- >> NO NOT TO CONTINUE.
PULLING COMPLETELY. >> STAFF PULLED IT? WE DISMISSED IT? WHICH CASE?
E-5-E. >> STAFF HAS REQUESTED A
CONTINUATION ON IT. >> SO WE WILL RESET IT.
>> WE ARE GOING TO RESET IT. >> OKAY.
>> WHERE IS HEATHER. >> SHE IS TALKING TO -- THE OTHER CASE. CAN WE SKIP TO ANOTHER CASE? OUR NEXT CASE 23-1840, SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK.
SCOTT ALLAN BAILEY. CAN WE IF TO CHARMAINE.
THE NEXT CASE 23-1862, JAYCEE PARK, JANELLE KRISTA PEREZ.
[D. 23-1862PK Jaycee Park Janelle Krista Perez Charmaine Kirkland]
>> WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> GOOD AFTERNOON, YOUR HONOR, CASE NUMBER 231862 IS A PARKING CITATION THAT WAS ISSUED AT JAYCEE PARK TO A MISS JANELLE KRISTA PEREZ.
CASE INITIATED JUNE 24, 2023. CITATION NUMBER 20101, CODE SECTION 24- 31C, RESTRICTED. FINE OF $50.
ADMINISTRATION FEE OF $10. AND LATE FEE OF $18 TOTAL DUE OF $78. IF THE SPECIAL MANAGE FREIGHT FINDS THE VIOLATION EXISTS WILL BE DUE AS INDICATED ABOVE.
FAILURE TO PAY WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.
AND I HAVE PHOTOS TO DEPICT THE TIME OF THE VIOLATION.
>> AT THIS TIME, THE CITY WILL MOVE IN AS COMPOSITE 1, THE
PHOTOGRAPHS. >> THEY WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. ANYTHING FURTHER?
NO, MA'AM. >> AND IS JANELLE PEREZ HERE IN ALL RIGHT, I FINE SHE IS NOT PRESENT AND NEITHER IS HER
[01:15:03]
REPRESENTATIVE ON HER BEHALF. HOWEVER, BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND THE TESTIMONY PRESENTED I FIND THAT A VIOLATION EXISTS AS SHE IS THE PARTY RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION.I WILL IMPOSE A $50 FINE, A $10 ADMIN FEE AND LATE FEE OF $18 FOR TO TOTAL DUE OF $78 PAYABLE WITHIN 18 DAYS.
FAILURE TO PAY COULD RESULT TO THE CASE BEING TRANSFERRED OVER TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM AND INCUR ADDITIONAL GUYS AND COSTS.
[C. 23-1209 CT 2425 Mohawk Avenue Marquis Brown Heather Debevec]
30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU.
NEXT CASE MARQUIS BROWN, 2425 MOHAWK AVENUE, 23-1209.
>> WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> SORRY, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.
>> YOU HAVE BEEN BUSY THIS MORNING.
>> THIS CASE NUMBER 23-1209, 2425 HOE HAWK AVENUE.
MARQUESE BROWN. OCCASION INITIATED APRIL 21 OF THIS YEAR. IT WAS FOR CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION 1619 FOR CODE SECTION 125-315, SUBSECTIONSI, 2 ANDB.
COMMERCIAL VEHICLE. THE CITY IS REQUESTING IF THE BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE AS INDICATED ABOVE, THE $260.
FAILURE TO PAY SUCH FINE WILL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM AND I DO HAVE PHOTOS OF
WHICH TO SUBMIT. >> DO THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY
>> WILL MOVE EXHIBIT ONE, THE PHOTOGRAPHS.
>> THEY WILL BE ADMITTED AS SU
SUCH. >> I FIND THAT THE MARQUIS BROWN IS NOT PRESENT NEITHER IS HIS REPRESENTATIVE ON HIS BEHALF.
HOWEVER, BASED ON THE TESTIMONY AND EVIDENCE PRESENTED I FIND HE IS RESPONSIBLE FOR PARKING A COMMERCIAL VEHICLE IN A RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD. HE WAS GIVEN NOTICE TO MOVE THE TRUCK. AND HE DIDN'T DO IT.
I WILL IMPOSE A $250 FINE. $10 ADMIN FEE FOR A TOTAL DUE OF $260. I WILL GIVE HIM 30 DAYS TO PAY.
FAILURE TO PAY COULD RESULT FOR THIS MATTER TO BEIS TRANSFERRED OVER TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM AND ADDITIONAL GUYS AND COSTS.
30 DAYS TO APPEAL. THANK YOU, OUR NEXT CASE IS 1153. 412 BAKERS MANAGEMENT PROPE PROPERTIES.
[B. 23-1153 CE 412 N US Highway 1 BAKERS MANAGEMENT PROPERTIES Heather Debevec]
>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, 1753, BAKERS MANAGEMENT PROPERTIES.
CASE INITIATED ON CACHE MAY 19 FOR ACCESSORY STRUCTURES AND SIDEWALKS AND DRIVEWAYS. TO OBTAIN A BUILDING FROM THE PERMIT DEPARTMENT AND REPAIR THE POTHOLES AND DEVELOPING POTHOLES IN THE PARKING LOT. THE CITY REQUESTED IF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION EXISTS THE VIOLATORS BE GIVEN 30 DAYS TO OBTAIN A PERMIT.
THE IMPC 2.07 HI WOULD LIKE TO REQUEST AN R&D ON.
I HAVE PHOTOS TO SUBMIT. >> DO THEY FULLY DEPICT THE
VIOLATION AS YOU SAW IT. >> YES.
SORRY. >> THE CITY WILL ADMIT THE
PHOTOGRAPHS. >> THEY WILL BE ADMITTED AS SU SUCH.
[C. 23-1152 CE 430 N US Highway 1 BAKER`S MGMT PROPERTIES INC Heather Debevec]
[01:20:07]
>> I FIND THAT BAKER MANAGEMENT PROPERTIES WHOSE REGISTERED AGENT IS VERNON DIXON IS NOT PRESENT OR NEITHER IS A REPRESENTATIVE ON HIS OR HER BEHALF; HOWEVER, BASED ON THE EVIDENCE AND TESTIMONY PRESENTED I FIND THAT A VIOLATION EXISTS WITH REGARDS TO IPMC 302.7 AND POINT 3, SIDEWALKS AND DRIVEWAYS. DO A DETERMINATION THAT IPMC 302.7 ACCESSORY STRUCTURE HAVE BEEN COMPLIED WITH AS OF TODAY'S DATE. I WILL GIVE HIM -- I FIND THAT A VIOLATION DOES EXIST WITH THE REMAINING CHARGE.
I WILL GIVE THEM 30 DAYS TO OBTAIN A PERMIT AND COMPLY WITH ALL PERMIT CONDITIONS. FINE OF $100 PER-DAY BE ASSESSED. HE HAS 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.
FAILURE TO PAY COULD HAVE THE CASE BEING TRANSFERRED OVER TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM WHERE HE COULD INCUR ADDITIONAL GUYS AND COS COSTS.
>> OUR NEXT CASE 23-2032, 523 SOUTH U.S. HIGHWAY 1, JULIO
DELGADO AND REYNA SAMPIERI. >> GOOD MORNING.
>> GOOD AFTERNOON. WHEN YOU ARE READY.
[D. 23-1032 CE 523 S US Highway 1 JULIO C DELGADO REYNA SAMPIERI Heather Debevec]
>> CASE NUMBER 23-10 2, 523 SOUTH U.S. HIGHWAY 1, JULIE YODEL GADDO. REYNA SAMPIERI.
CASE WAS INITIATED APRIL 1, 2023.
IPMC 304.1 AND 30 .2. PROTECTIVE TREATMENT.
OBTAIN A PERMIT FROM THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT TO REPAIR THE BUILDING WHERE IT IS MISSING, MISMATCHED AND ROTTING.
AND PAINT THE BUILDING AS PAINTS IS PEELING.
IF THEY FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS TO OBTAIN A PERMIT.
COMPLY WITH THE PERMIT CONDITIONS OR A FINE OF $100 PER DAY BE ASSESSED. I CHECKED THROUGH OUR SYSTEM, THERE WAS -- IT SHOWS TWO PERMITS -- A PERMIT AND PLAN CHECK. AND I DO HAVE PHOTOS.
>> DID YOU ALL HAVE A CHANCE TO SEE THE PHOTOGRAPHS?
WE KNOW THE PLACE. >> YES, THANK YOU.
>> THE CITY WILL MOVE INTO COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE, THE
PHOTOGRAPHS. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.
WHO IS GOING TO SPEAK FIRST. >> LOCAL HENDER SHOT.
>> TELL ME WHERE YOU ARE WITH THE BUILDING.
LAST THING WE DID WE GOT A PERMIT FROM THE CONTRACTOR, FROM NICK NOLA. HE GAVE IT TO ME YESTERDAY.
WENT AHEAD AND PRINT EVERYTHING. I WAS SO PROUD OF IT.
AND I JUST HOPE FOR THE BEST THAT WE TAKE CARE OF THIS THIS
CAN -- OR HE CAN. >> MISS DEBEVEC, HAVE YOU SEEN THE PERMIT? NO, MA'AM.
>> CAN WE SEE THAT BECAUSE OUR RECORDS ONLY SHOW AN APPLICATION. IT DOESN'T SHOW A PERMIT.
>> THIS IS FROM DANIEL. >> THIS IS SHOWING PERMIT SUBMITTAL AS WELL. IT'S AN APPLICATION.
>> OH. >> SO THERE IS WHAT IS THIS --
>> THE NUMBER TO TRACK THE SUBMISSION.
WE RECEIVE YOUR PERMIT AND GUYS DUE.
IT IS GIVING YOU THE PERMIT. >> IT IS A PERMIT NUMBER, BUT UNDER THE SUBMISSION FOR THEM TO REVIEW IT.
NOT THE ACTUAL PERMIT. >> IT'S AN APPLICATION.
>> CORRECT. >> MY HOPES WENT DOWN.
>> YOU ALL HAVE WORKED HARD SO -- ALL RIGHT.
HOW LONG DO WE NEED TO HOW LONG DO THEY USUALLY TAKE?
>> HEATHER, DO YOU KNOW THE SUBMITTAL.
>> WHAT WAS THE DATE ON THAT, MA'
>> LET ME SEE THE FRONT. I AM IN NAV ALINE.
DOESN'T GIVE A DATE BUT A TIME OF 11:26 ONLY SAYS 11:26 IT
[01:25:15]
PROBABLY IS. HE SENT ME ALL THIS.AND THEY SAID THEY RECEIVED IT. THE.
>> THE PERMITS. >> HOLD ON ONE SECOND.
I AM PULLING IT UP. I AM IN THE SYSTEM.
OKAY, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THE PERMIT APPLICATION WAS SUBMITTEDED TO PLAN CHECK ON 10-2.
SO IT WAS MONDAY THAT THE PLANS WERE SUBMITTED.
SO IT MAKE TAKE 30 TO 60 DAYS TO GO THROUGH PLAN CHECK.
BUT A PERMANENT IN HOUSE AS OFFICER DEBEVEC TESTIFIED TOO
BUT A RECENT SUBMITTAL. >> IS 60 DAYS ENOUGH TIME?
HOPEFULLY. >> IT ALL DEPENDS IF THEIR APPLICATION IS COMPLETE OR NOT. IF ANYTHING IS QUICK RIGHT, AND IF THEY ARE MISSING ANYTHING, THAT SLOWS IT DOWN.
IT DEPENDS WHAT IS SUBMITTED. >> I HAVE ALL THIS SUBMISSION
HERE. >> HAVE YOU SHOWN THAT TO MISS
DEBEVEC. >> WE CAN LOOK AT IT BUT I WILL BE HONEST I DON'T THINK MISS DEBEVEC WILL BE ABLE TO TELL YOU -- BECAUSE IT IS BUILDING. SOMETHING BUILDING -- SCOPE THAT IS BEYOND ME BY MANY LEVELS. DECEMBER 6.
>> ABOUT. >> WE WILL CONTINUE THIS UNTIL
DECEMBER 6. >> STAY ON YOUR GUY.
>> AT 1:30. >> YOU GIRLS HAVE A GOOD ONE.
>> SEE YOU IN DECEMBER. >> SEE YOU IN DECEMBER.
>> THANK YOU. OR NEXT CASE 23-1253, 1012
[F. 23-1253 CE 1012 S US Highway 1 PEKING CHINESE RESTAURANT INC Heather Debevec]
SOUTH U.S. HIGHWAY 1, PEKING CHINESE RESTAURANT INC.>> WHEN YOU ARE READY. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, THIS IS 1012 SOUTH U.S. MILES PER HOUR 1, PEKING CHINESE RESTAURANT.
IT WAS FOR IMMC 302.3, SIDEWALKS AND DRIVEWAYS.
OBTAIN A PERMIT THROUGH THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT AND REPAIR THE PARKING LOT. THE CITY REQUESTS THAT IF A SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION EXIT, VY LATER WILL BE GIVEN 30 DAYS TO SUBMIT A PERMIT AND THEY HAVE A PERMIT ISSUED FROM WHAT I CAN TELL IN MY MY SYSTEM.
>> SIR, HAVE YOU HAD A CHANCE TO SEE THE PHOTOGRAPHS?
>> I SAW IT LAST TIME. >> OKAY.
DO YOU WANT TO LOOK AT THEM AGAIN?
>> NO, IT IS OKAY. >> THE IS IT I WILL MOVE IN
EXHIBIT 1, THE PHOTOGRAPHS. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.
AND SIR, YOU EVER A LOT -- A LOT OF THIS HAD BEEN DONE? NO, THEY JUST CONTACTED ME BEFORE YESTERDAY.
THEY SAID THE TIME TO GET THE JOB DONE.
I TOLD THEM TO GET THE JOB DONE AS SOON AS POSSIBLE.
THEY SAID IT DEPENDS ON THE WEATHER I HAVE THE CONTRACT AND
THE PERMIT PAPER AND EVERYTHING. >> I KNOW YOU WERE HERE BEFORE.
>> YES, LAST TIME. > MY COMPUTER IS BLANK SCREEN.
I AM TRYING TO CONFIRM THE PERMIT.
OH, IT JUST POPPED UP. FOR ASPHALT OVERLAY, SEAL COAT.
IT HAS BEEN APPROVED AND ISSUED. STATUS DATE IS 9/26.
BEAR WITH ME, THE PERMIT WAS ISSUED 9/26.
WE CAN CONTINUE THIS AS LONG AS THE PERMIT IS VALID.
>> THEY WILL DO THE JOB AS SOON AS THEY CAN.
IT DEPENDS ON THE WEATHER. I WILL I HAVE THE CONTRACT AND PAPER. DO YOU NEED THAT? WHAT IS THE FURTHEST HEARING DATE THAT WE HAVE?
>> THE END OF THE YEAR 12-6. >> WE CAN SET IT THERE AS A
[01:30:01]
STATUS AND IF WE NEED TO MOVE IT INTERNALLY FOR THERE.>> THEY SAID DO IT SOON. >> AND JUST STAY IN CONTACT WITH MISS HEATHER AND LET HER KNOW THE STATUS AND WE WILL LET YOU
KNOW IF WE MOVE IT FROM 12/6. >> THANK YOU, GOOD LUCK.
[G. 23-1671 CE 2507 S Indian River Drive DIANE WYNNE Heather Debevec]
YOU ARE GOOD TO GO. THANK YOU.>> OUR NEXT IT WAS 23-1671, 2507 SOUTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE.
>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE CASE NUMBER 231671.
2507 SOUTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE. DIANE WYNNE.
CASE INITIATED JUNE 16. SECTION 123-37, SUBSECTIONS 12, LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE. MOW, TRIM WEEDS FROM BUSHES AND TREES AND REMOVE THE DEAD TREE PIECES AND DEBRIS.
THE CITY REQUESTS THAT IF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION EXIST, WILL BE GIVEN TEN DAYS OR $100 PER DAY FINE
WILL BE ASSESSED. >> ARE YOU MISS WYNNE?
YES. >> DID YOU SEE THE PHOTOGRAPHS?
>> NO. >> I TOOK PHOTOGRAPHS THIS MORNING AND THEY ARE ON MY PHONE.
IF YOU WANT THEM. >> MISS DEBEVEC, YOU MAY HAVE SAID THIS AND I MISSED IT, BUT DO THE PHOTOGRAPHS FAIRLY ADDRESS THE VIOLATION AS YOU OBSERVED IT.
>> THEY DO. >> THE CITY WILL MOVE INTO EXHIBIT COMPOSITE 1, THE PHOTOGRAPHS.
>> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH. ANYTHING FURTHER?
NOT AT THIS TIME. >> IF YOU HAVE PHOTOGRAPHS THAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO SHOW PLACE IT ON THE TABLE BY MISS DEBEVEC, THERE IS AN OVERHEAD PROJECTOR THAT WE CAN USE TO PROJECT WHAT
IS ON YOUR SCREEN. >> PROJECT IT AND SEE IF IT WORKS. HOLD IT IN.
KEEP IT GOING. >> MISS WYNNE, HOW DO YOU
>> YOU WANT TO SWIPE. ARE THERE OTHER ONES YOU WANT US TO SEE? YES.
>> STEP BACK A LITTLE BIT. AS MANY AS WOULD YOU WANT TO SHOW. .
>> THE DEAD TREE IS BEHIND -- IT IS NOT DEAD IS THE PROBLEM.
YEAH, IF IT WERE DEAD, I WOULD HAVE CUT IT DOWN.
>> REMOVED A LOT OF THE DEAD DEBRIS FROM THERE.
WHAT IS IN THERE LIKE A TREE -- A BEEN A IAN TREE THAT FELL.
SHE REMOVED A LOT OF THE DEAD DEBRIS, BUT THERE IS STILL LIKE A LOT LAYING DOWN IN THERE. NOT DEBRIS, BUT FOLIAGE.
>> DID YOU SEE IT, COUNSELOR? I HAVE ONE MORE PHOTO IF I MAY.
>> DID YOU WANT HER TO SHOW ANOTHER --
[01:35:02]
>> MISS DEBEVEC, HER PHOTOGRAPHS CHANGE YOUR POSITION ON THE CASE
AT ALL? >> I WOULD NEED TO GO OUT THERE AND LOOK. I AM HAVING TROUBLE SEEING LIKE THE CENTER. LOOKS LIKE THE TWO SIGNS ON THE NORTH AND SOUTH SIDE LOOK GOOD, BUT I WOULD LIKE TO PHYSICALLY SEE THE CENTER BECAUSE -- IT LOOKS LIKE SHE IS TAKING IT FROM THE STREET. SO BEING ABLE TO ZOOM IN AND
TAKE A LOOK AT WHAT IS THERE. >> SO WOULD YOU LIKE TO CONTINUE THIS FOR THE NOVEMBER DATE TO GO DO THAT?
>> YES, PLEASE. >> NOVEMBER OR DECEMBER.
>> YOU HAVE TIME TO GO OUT THERE BETWEEN NOW AND NOVEMBER.
>> ABSOLUTELY. >> YES, MA'AM, THAT IS THE
REQUEST. >> SO BASICALLY, WHAT WILL HAPPEN MISS DEBEVEC WILL COME OUT AND LOOK AT THE PROPERTY.
IF EVERYTHING IS TAKEN CARE OF, YOU WILL BE DONE WITH US ON
THIS. >> MAY I JUST ADD A FEW COMMENTS? SURE.
>> SO JUST SO IS YOU UNDERSTAND MY INTENTION.
THERE ARE TWO BIG BRANCHES THAT FELL -- THE TREE WAS DAMAGED IN THE -- IN THE HURRICANES WE HAD IN -- WHAT WAS IT -- I THINK IT WAS IAN. I THINK IT WAS LAST SEPTEMBER OR OCTOBER. OR WAS IT APRIL -- ANYWAY, TWO BIG BRANCHES. ONE IS HUGE -- THEY ARE BOTH HUGE. ONE WILL BE MOVED TO THE BACK YARD AND USE IT SORT OF LIKE AROUND A FIRE PIT THAT I HAVEN'T YET CREATED. THE MAIN TREE ITSELF IS STILL ALIVE. SO THE ONE BIG BRANCH THAT HAS TONS OF LEAVES. MAY END UP CUTTING IT DOWN.
THE TREES ARE GOING TO LOOK BARE AND SAD AND THE ONLY REASON I HAVEN'T GONE STRAIGHT TO DO THAT.
THAT IS A SOLUTION. IF IT IS AGREED THAT IS WHAT YOU GUYS WANT ME TO DO, I WILL DO IT.
BUT I HATE TO FURTHER LIMIT THE TREE AND POSSIBLY CAUSE IT TO
DIE. >> SO I WOULD SUGGEST YOU GET WITH HEATHER AND SHEBLG COME OUT AND LOOK AT EVERYTHING AND OUR
ARBORIST MAY BE ABLE. >> THAT WILL BE GREAT.
GET WITH HEATHER AND SHE WILL TELL US HOW TO GO FROM HERE.
>> THANK YOU. >> YOU ARE WELCOME.
>> NEXT CASE. >> OUR NEXT CASE WILL BE 23-1871, 404 JUANITA. ROBIN IVY AND JOHN P. I H
HAVE IVEY. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.
[I. 23-1870 CE 1404 Juanita Avenue ROBIN IVEY JOHN P IVEY Heather Debevec]
CASE 1404 JUANITA AVENUE, 23-1870, ROBIN AND JOHN IVEY.IPMC 702.4, EMERGENCY ESCAPE OPENINGS.
IPMC 304.3, ADDRESS IDENTIFICATION.
SECTION 123-37 SUBSECTIONS 12, LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE.
NUISANCE OF AN OBJECT, OUTSIDE STORAGE.
NUISANCE OF AN OBJECT, NONOPERATIVE VEHICLES.
SECTION 20-28 SUBSECTIONS C, RESPONSIBILITY FOR CONTAINERS.
IPMC 304.2, PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT.
TO REMOVE OR TAKE TOWN THE SHUTTERS FROM THE WINDOWS.
PLACE HOUSE NUMBERS VISIBLE TO THE ROADWAY.
MOW, CLEAN OFF FENCE LINES AND TRIM WEEDS.
REMOVE BRING IN SHED THE SCOOTER APPLIANCES, TOOLS, TABLES, TARPS, CLOTHING, CORDS, CONTAINERS, METAL FRAME.
REMOVE, BRING OR PLACE INFORM A SHED THE ITEMS. THE CITY IS REQUESTING THAT IF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS TEN DAYS TO COMPLY AND $100 PER DAY BE ASSESSED. I HAVE SPOKEN WITH THEM ONCE OR TWICE DURING THAT PROCESS. I KNOW THEY WERE DEALING WITH HEALTH I SHALL PEWS WITH PAM FLEE MEMBERS.
I HAVE PHOTOS OF WHICH TO SUBMIT.
>> SORRY, HAVE THEY HAD A CHANCE TO LOOK AT THE PHOTOGRAPHS? ANYTHING FURTHER? NOT AT THIS TIME.
>> AT THIS TIME THE CITY WILL MOVE INTO COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1,
[01:40:04]
THE PHOTOGRAPHS. >> IT WILL BE ADMITTED AS SUCH.
AND YOU ALL HAVE BEEN SWORN. HOP IS GOING TO TESTIFY FIRST?
HOW WILL YOU RESPOND? >> I SEE SOME OF THE PICTURES, THE COOPER HAS BEEN REMOVED. CERTAIN THINGS HAVE BEEN REMOVED FROM THE YARD. WE HAVE HAD A LOT OF THINGS GO ON. I WAS AT A JOB FOR OVER 20 YEARS. I LOST MY EMPLOYMENT.
STARTED IN A JOB. WAS DOING OKAY AND THEY CUT MY HOURS BACK. MY HUSBAND IS ON AND OFF WITH POLICE WORK HERE AND THERE AND IT IS HARD AND I HAD MASSIVE STRUGGLES WITH FINANCIALS, I MEAN TRYING TO GET EVERYTHING SITUATED, SO, YES, HE DOES REPAIR THINGS, SELL THINGS.
I DON'T KNOW -- I MEAN HIS MOTHER -- -- HAD TERMINAL CANCER. SHE HAS BEEN ILL.
I, MYSELF, HAD TO BE COMMITTED TO FORT PIERCE NEW HORIZONS OF THE TOTAL MELTDOWN OF THE AMOUNT OF STRESS I HAVE BEEN UNDER.
AND AFTER THAT, MY -- THIS -- RECENTLY MY COUSIN, SHE PASSED AWAY UNEXPECTEDLY. SO IT HAS BEEN ONE THING AFTER ANOTHER. I JUST STARTED A NEW JOB THREE WEEKS AGO. I HAD TO RETO MY MORTGAGE TO JUST BE ABLE TO GET BY. YOU KNOW, I AM STRUGGLING.
I MEAN MY CAR -- IT -- MY PERSONAL CAR GOT -- YOU KNOW, I DON'T HAVE A VEHICLE TO GET BACK AND FORTH.
I AM JUST OVERWHELMED AND I UNDERSTAND THE PROPERTY HAS STUFF ON IT. I FINALLY WAS ABLE -- MY HUSBAND WAS ABLE TO GET A HOLD OF A FEW PEOPLE, A BUSINESS -- WE ARE GOING TO BE GETTING A TRAILER HOPEFULLY BY TOMORROW TO START DUMPING -- HE REMOVED A LOT OF SCRAP METAL ON THE PROPERTY.
IT IS NOT COMPLETELY DONE YET, BUT I AM ASKING FOR LENIENCY TO GET THIS DONE. IT IS A LOT OF WORK.
I PHYSICALLY -- PHYSICALLY CANNOT DO IT AND I DON'T KNOW WHAT ELSE TO SAY. IT IS ALL I CAN SAY.
THEY DID A GOOD AMOUNT OF WEED EATING SOME THE OTHER DAY.
AS FAR AS THE BOAT GOES, I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHAT THE DEAL IS WITH THE BOAT. OPERATIONAL.
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN. I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY I CAN'T HAVE MY BOAT IN MY YARD. NOW THE OTHER VEHICLE, I CAN UNDERSTAND THAT, BUT I DON'T UNDERSTAND THE TRAILER IS OPERATIONAL FOR WHAT. I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHAT IT IS THAT THEY ARE ASKING FOR. WE HAVE BEEN THERE FOR A COUPLE OF YEARS NOW. WE HAD NO PROBLEMS PER SE.
I DON'T WANT TO ADMINISTER PROBLEMS. UNDER UNDERSTAND.
I GOT MY FIRST PAYCHECK AND I CAN BARELY AFFORD MY MORTGAGE.
TIGHT. >> AND IF YOU CAN ASK ONE QUESTION REGARDING THE BOAT AND THE TRAVEL TRAILER.
OUR ORDINANCE REQUIRES THEM TO BE BOTH OPERABLE SO THEY CAN -- SO THE TRAVEL TRAILER HAS TO BE TOWED WITH TIRES AND HAVE A VALID REGISTRATION. HAS TO BE REGISTERED.
WHEN YOU HIT BOTH OF THOSE MARKS THEN IT CAN BE PARKED ON THE SIDE OF YOUR HOUSE. > YOU HAVE TO REGISTER.
>> YOUR BOAT HAS TO BE REGISTERED AND THEY ARE NOT.
>> AS FAR AS THE BOAT BEING REGISTERED, NOT SO MUCH BE ISSUE BUT THE TRAILER. THE TRAILER IS GOING ALONG THE GROUND. LONGS THE BOAT IS ON THE TRAILER AND THE TRAILER IS REGISTERED, THAT IS WHAT NEEDS TO BE --
>> LIKE I SAID, FINANCIALS ARE A LITTLE TIGHT SO I GOT TO DO WHAT IS FIRST IF YOU GUYS ARE WILLING TO WORK WITH US AND GIVE US SOME MORE TIME STARTING TO GET TRACTION AND MY NEW JOB HAS MORE STABILITY, SO FINANCIALLY, I PHYSICALLY CAN'T DO IT.
MY HUSBAND CAN ONLY DO SO MUCH AND I HAVE FRIENDS AND FAMILY THAT ARE CHIPPING IN TO HELP US GET THIS KNOCKED OUT.
[01:45:11]
>> THE WAY THE CODE IS, IT NEEDS TO BE INSIDE A CLOSED BUILDING.
IN VIOLATION. >> TO YOU HAVE A FAR RAJ OR.
>> I DON'T HAVE A GARAGE. >> I WILL STAY THAT IS A SOLUTION. IF THEY PUT UP A PROPERLY PERMITTED PRIVACY FENCE THAT SURROUNDS THE PROPERTY SO IT IS NOT -- BECAUSE JUST NOT BEING VISIBLE FROM THE STREET ONLY COMPLIES TO THE STREET. SO IF YOU HAVE A NEIGHBOR THAT YOU CAN STILL SEE AND A NEIGHBOR SAYS IN YOUR BACK YARD STILL A VIOLATION. AND A PRIVATELY FENCE AND PROPERLY PERMITTED IS A SOLUTION OTHERS HAVE USED.
>> YES, MA'AM. >> PROPERLY PERMITTED SO YOU DON'T END UP WITH A DIFFERENT VIOLATION OF SOMETHING NOT BEING
PERMITTED. >> HAVING A TRAILER.
NOT A BOAT, SO TO SPEAK. WE WERE BUILDING THE BOAT -- WHEN WE WERE RENTING THE HOUSE. THE HOUSE CAME UP FOR SALE.
I DIDN'T WANT TO MESS UP. MY DAD RETIRED 25 YEARS FROM THE SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT. BOUGHT THE HOUSE BECAUSE IT IS A BEAUTIFUL PIECE OF PROPERTY. I HAVE KNOWN MY NEIGHBORS FOR EVERY 30 YEARS. THE TRAILER AND THE TRUCK -- REGISTERED TRUCK THAT IS GOING OUT.
WE ARE DOING ALL WE POSSIBLY CAN.
I AM TRYING NOT TO CAUSE NO CHAOS WHATSOEVER.
I KNOWN MY NEIGHBORS. BORN AND RAISE IN ST. LOUIS COUNTY AND WILL MAKE IT AS EASY AS POSSIBLE FOR EVERYBODY.
>> ALL RIGHT, ANYTHING FURTHER. >> I DO HAVE A IF HE ABOUT THE LONG ROAD. THE ROAD.
THE SIDEWALK. WHAT IS TECHNICALLY OUR RESPONSIBILITY TO THAT FENCE LINE EXACTLY? BECAUSE I WANT TO KNOW EXACTLY. BECAUSE AS FAR AS I AM CONCERNED, I DIDN'T LITTER ALL THE WAY DOWN THE SIDEWALK, YOU KNOW -- I AM SUPPOSED TO BE THAT WALK BY?ASH FROM PEOPLE - I MEAN, I WILL DO WHAT WE CAN, BUT THERE IS A TON OF TRASH.
>> TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION, ALONG THE RIGHT-OF-WAY AND HERE, TECHNICALLY -- THERE IS NO LAW THAT SAYS YOU ARE REQUIRED TO DO THAT. I DON'T KNOW IF WE CITED YOU FOR
THAT. >> I WANT TO MAKE SURE BECAUSE I WAS TOLD IN THE PAST. AND I KNOW IT NEEDS TO BE TRIMMED DOWN. I LIKE IT TO KIND OF BE A LITTLE BIT FILLED OUT SO IT IS NOT SO VISIBILITY TO THE BACK YARD, EVEN FOR OUR OWN PRIVACY TO BE ABLE TO ENJOY THE.
>> IS THERE A FENCE THERE. >> FRAMED OR REMOVED? IT WILL SHOW IT CLEARED OFF A LOT OF THAT.
>> A FILE OF THAT STUFF. >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, STAFF IS GOING TO RECOMMEND CONTINUING THIS FOR THE 60 DAYS.
ALLOW HEATHER TO WORK WITH THEM AND WE WILL BRING THIS BACK BEFORE YOU ON THE DECEMBER 6 HEARING.
>> THANK YOU, GOOD LUCK. >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
APPRECIATE YOUR TIME. >> YES, MA'AM, GOOD LUCK.
>> WHEN IS THE NEXT DATE? >> DECEMBER 6 AT 1:30.
[I. 23-881PK South Causeway Park Talisson Pedro Alves Michael Rabenecker]
>> YES, MA'AM. >> OUR NEXT CASE 23-881 SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK. TOWSON PETITIONED THROW ALVES.
THIS IS GOING TO BE WITH AN INTERPRETER AND I AM GOING TO GO AHEAD AND CALL HIM IN.
LANGUAGE LINK. PLEASE ENTER YOUR ACCOUNT NUMBER FOLLOWED BY THE POUND SOUND. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A THIRD PARTY CALL, PLEASE PRESS 1.
PRESS 2 WITHOUT MAKING A THIRD PARTY CALL.
>> PRESS TWO -- >> PLEASE ENTER YOUR EMPLOYEE ID
FOLLOWED BY THE POUND SIGN. >> IF THIS IS CORRECT, PRESS ON ONE.
[01:50:08]
>> HELLO, THIS IS YOUR SPANISH INTERP
INTERPRETER. >> ARE YOUY, THIS IS KATHERINE.
I AM CALLING LIVE IN THE COMMISSIONER CHAMBERS TODAY FOR OUR HEARING. INTERPRETER, I AM GOING TO HAVE TO SWEAR YOU IN. SO YOU CAN TRANSLATE FOR THE
VIOLATOR FOR THE CASE. >> ALL RIGHT.
>> PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE
>> DO YOU PROMISE TO TRANSLATE FROM ENGLISH TO SPANISH AND FROM
>> THANK YOU. >> WE WILL NEED TO SWEAR M
MR. ALVES IN. >> FIRST I WOULD HAVE TO EXPLAIN THAT I WILL INTERPRET EVERYTHING THAT IS SAID.
ALL INFORMATION IS FOR THE QUALITY.
>> AND MADAM INTERPRETER, THERE IS NO CONFIDENTIALITY.
WE ARE IN A PUBLIC HEARING THAT IS BEING RECORDED AND LIVE
TELEVISED. >> CONFIDENTIAL FOR ME FOR ME THIS FOR MY SHOP, I MEAN. UT - I HAVE ABOUT THE SPEECH WITHOUT THE PARK IF NEED. THANK YOU.
IF YOU CAN PLEASE TRANSLATE. PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND.
AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.
>> DO YOU SWEAR OR AFFIRM THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE ABOUT TO
WILL BE THE TRUTH? SIR, YOU ARE GOING TO HAVE TO
SPEAK UP SO WE CAN HEAR YOU. >> YES.
>> THANK YOU. >> OKAY, MICHAEL.
>> YOUR HONOR, THE NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU IS CASE NUMBER 2 23-881, PARKING VIOLATION AT SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK.
THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON MARCH 25, 2023.
THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE I IS TALISON PEDRO ALVES.
>> CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 192
19211. >> A PARKING VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE CODE 34-31-E. NO PARKING AT ANY TIME.
THE CITY IS REQUESTING THE CITY IS REQUESTING A $50 FINE . A $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE. A LATE FEE OF $18 PER PAIR . A TOTAL OF $70. IF THE VIOLATION IS FOUND TO EXIST, THE FINE WILL BE INDICATED AS ABOVE. FAILURE TO PAY THE FINE WILL RESULT IN A CITATION, FORWARDED TO THE COURT. I HAVE PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE , THEY ARE DATED , AND THEY ARE TIME STAMPED.
[01:55:10]
THESE ARE THE VIOLATIONS THAT I WITNESSED. >> SIR, DID YOU HAVE A CHANCE
TO LOOK AT THE PHOTOGRAPHS? >> YES. >> THANK YOU.
>> AT THIS TIME THE CITY WILL HAVE EXHIBIT NUMBER ONE . >> THIS TIME WILL MOVE THE
PHOTOGRAPHS, IT IS NOW EXHIBIT NUMBER ONE . >> IS THERE ANYTHING THAT YOU
WOULD LIKE TO SAY? YOU DO NOT HAVE TO . >> I AM SORRY, I CANNOT HEAR
YOU. >> IS THERE ANYTHING THAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO SAY? BUT YOU DO
>> PLEASE, TELL US WHAT YOU WANT TO SAY. >>
>> I APOLOGIZE, I AM SPEAKING SPANISH, AND HE DOES NOT UNDERSTAND. HE DOES SPEAK
>> SO WE NEED A PORTUGUESE INTERPRETER. DO I HAVE TO CALL AGAIN?
>> YOU WILL HAVE TO CALL AGAIN. >>
>> I WOULD LIKE TO REQUEST A PORTUGUESE INTERPRETER. >> ONE MOMENT.
>> I DO HAVE A PORTUGUESE INTERPRETER ON THE LINE. >> THIS IS CATHERINE , I AM CALLING LIVE , THIS IS NOT CONFIDENTIAL, IT IS BEING RECORDED. PLEASE RAISE YOUR
RIGHT HAND. >> MY NAME IS BOBBY L BAIRD >> DO YOU SWEAR TO TRANSLATE
[02:00:07]
ENGLISH TO PORTUGUESE AND PORTUGUESE TO ENGLISH? >> YES.
>> PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.
>> ARE ABOUT TO GIVE IS THE TRUTH?
>> YES. >> THANK YOU. >> DO YOU UNDERSTAND ALL OF
THE TRANSLATIONS THAT WERE PROVIDED? >> YES.
>> PERFECT . >> THE NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU 23-881 . A PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED ON SOUTH PARK. THE CASE WAS INITIATED MARCH 25, 2023. THE VIOLATOR IN THE CASE, IS PEDRO ALVES . THIS CITATION IS 19219 . A PARKING VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 51E . NO PARKING AT ANY TIME. THE CITY IS REQUESTING A $50 FINE BE ASSESSED. $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE . A LATE FEE OF $18 . FOR A TOTAL OF $78 . THE CITY REQUEST THAT IF THIS VIOLATION DOES EXIST, THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED WHAT WAS INDICATED ABOVE .
FAILURE TO PAY WILL RESULT IN I CITATION , BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.
>> THE PHOTOGRAPHS , DO THEY ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION?
>> YOU NEED TO SEE THEM AGAIN ?
>> NO. >> AT THIS TIME WE WILL MOVE IT TO EXHIBIT NUMBER ONE. THIS
IS FROM THE FRONT. DO WE HAVE ANYTHING FURTHER? >> NO, MA'AM.
>> IS THERE ANYTHING YOU WOULD LIKE TO SAY? >> NO .
>> BASED ON THE TESTIMONY PRESENTED I FOUND THAT MR. OLIVER IS IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE PARKING ZONE VIOLATION. THERE WILL BE A $50 FINE. THE ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10. A
[02:05:13]
LATE FEE OF $18. FOR A TOTAL OF $78 . YOU HAVE 18 DAYS TO DO THIS. FAILURE TO PAY IN THIS CASE WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. YOU WILL INCUR ADDITIONAL FEES ANDCOST. YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >>
>> HOW DO I PAID THIS FINE? >> YOU CAN GO UPSTAIRS TO THE FINANCE DEPARTMENT TODAY.
TODAY. >> OKAY . >> WE ARE GOING TO PROVIDE YOU
WITH THE PAPERWORK RIGHT NOW. >> >> DO I HAVE TO PAY IN CASH? I JUST HAVE MY CARD RIGHT NOW.
>> THANK YOU. >> WE ARE GOING TO DISCONNECT THE CALL. AND SHE IS GOING TO
HELP YOU. AND THANK YOU TO THE INTERPRETER. >> DO WE HAVE ANY MORE CASES?
[G. 23-889PK 200 Blk North Indian River Drive Jaret Michael Yavorsky Michael Rabenecker]
>> 23-8890, JARRETT MORRISSEY. >> THIS IS A PARKING VIOLATION, ON MYRTLE DRIVE, THIS IS A REGULAR CITATION CASE. THIS IS A PARKING VIOLATION . THE CITY IS REQUESTING A $50 FINE, FAILURE TO PAY WILL BE FORWARDED TO
THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. >> THIS IS EXHIBIT NUMBER ONE, THE PHOTOGRAPHS. BE BACK
IN A MOMENT. >> BASED ON THE EVIDENCE , YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE. YOU HAVE
18 DAYS TO PAY THEIR -- . >> NEXT IS 23-934 ANTHONY STEVENS THE SECOND.
[H. 23-934PK Jaycee Park Anthony Stevens, II Lauren Stevens Michael Rabenecker]
>> THE NEXT CASE 23-934 THAT TO PLACE AT JC PARK, THIS IS ANTHONY STEPHEN. AND THIS IS
[02:10:02]
19221 , RESTRICTED PARKING FOR VOTE TRAILERS ONLY . A $50 FINE . A $10 ADMINISTRATIONFEE, ADD A LATE FEE OF $18, A TOTAL OF $78 . >> WE DO NOT HAVE ANYBODY HERE FOR ANTHONY. I DO FIND THAT A VIOLATION DOES EXIST. THEY WILL HAVE 18 DAYS TO PAY , FAILURE TO PAY WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT.
>> THE NEXT CASE 23-872 A PARKING VIOLATION AT SOUTH PARK. THIS IS A REGULAR CITATION CASE. THIS IS CHARLES MALLORY , AND THIS IS 19200 PARKING VIOLATION. AND WE ARE REQUESTING A $50 FINE , $10 FOR ADMINISTRATION THE, $18 FOR A LATE FEE, WITH A TOTAL
OF $78 . >> THEY ARE NOT PRESENT. I WILL FIND THEM GUILTY OF THE VIOLATION , A $50 FINE , A $10 FEE FOR ADMINISTRATION, AND AN $18 FEE , A LATE FEE .
YOU HAVE 18 DAYS TO PAY, OR IT WILL BE FORWARD TO THE COUNTY COURT.
[K. 23-1609PK Jaycee Park Julicia Monds Michael Rabenecker]
>> NEXT CASE 23-1609 , I PARKING VIOLATION AT JC PARK. THIS IS A REGULAR CITATION CASE, THE NUMBER IS 19860 , PROHIBITED PARKING AT ALL TIME . THERE IS A $50 FEE. A $10 FEE FOR ADMINISTRATION , AND AN $18 LATE FEE, A TOTAL OF $78 .
>> DO WE HAVE ANYTHING ELSE? WE DO FIND THEM IN VIOLATION . $50 FEE. A $10 FEE FOR ADMINISTRATION, $18 LATE FEE, 18 DAYS TO PAY, 30 DAYS TO APPEAL.
[N. 23-1031PK South Causeway Park Osner Orelien Michael Rabenecker]
>> THE NEXT CASE 23-1031 , AT SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK. THE VIOLATOR IN THIS CASE IS
[02:15:05]
ORLEAN , THIS IS A PARKING VIOLATION. THE CITY IS ASKING FOR A $50 FEE. $10ADMINISTRATION FEE, AND $18 FOR A LATE FEE . >> NOW WE HAVE PHOTOGRAPHS.
>> DO WE HAVE ANYTHING ? IS HE PRESENT OR DOES HE HAVE A REPRESENTATIVE ? SO THERE WILL BE $50 FEE. $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE, AND $18 FOR A LATE FEE. A TOTAL OF $78 . FAILURE TO PAY THE FINES , IT WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM, YOU HAVE 18 DAYS TO
[A. 23-1840PK South Causeway Park Scott Allan Bailey Larry Stephens]
PAY, 30 DAYS TO APPEAL . >> GOOD AFTERNOON, YOUR HONOR.
>> GOOD AFTERNOON. >> 23-1840 , THIS IS ON SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK. THE VIOLATOR CAME BACK, CITATION NUMBER 553 , NO PARKING AT ANY TIME. $50 FEE. $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE, AND $18 FOR A LATE FEE. A TOTAL OF $78 . A FAILURE TO PAY, IT WILL BE FORWARDED TO
THE COUNTY COURTS. >> DO WE HAVE ANY PHOTOGRAPHS? THEY ARE NOT PRESENT , NOR IS THERE A REPRESENTATIVE. SO I AM GOING TO ASSESS $50 FEE. $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE, AND $18 FOR A LATE FEE. TOTAL OF $78.. PAYABLE IN 18 DAYS. FAILURE TO PAY THE FINES, IT WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM, YOU HAVE 18 DAYS TO PAY, 30 DAYS TO APPEAL .
[B. 23-1556 PK South Causeway Park Anthony Patrick Carrion Larry Stephens]
>> 23-1566 . >> THIS WAS ON SOUTH CAUSEWAY PARK , THIS IS ANTHONY CAMERON . THE CITATION 19440 , CODE 3491 . AT THIS TIME IT IS $50 FEE. $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE, AND $18 FOR A LATE FEE. TOTAL OF $78. FAILURE TO PAY THE FINES, IT WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM, YOU HAVE 18 DAYS TO PAY, 30 DAYS TO APPEAL . I DO HAVE PHOTOS. IT
IS TIME STAMPED AS WELL. >> THIS IS EXHIBIT NUMBER ONE, THE PHOTOGRAPHS.
>> ANTHONY PATRICK, IS NOT HERE, NOR A REPRESENTATIVE FROM $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE, AND $18 FOR A LATE FEE. TOTAL OF $78. . HE WILL HAVE 18 DAYS TO PAY.
[02:20:08]
FAILURE TO DO SO, TO PAY YOUR FINE, WILL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THECOUNTY COURT'S . >> 23-1153 , U.S. HIGHWAY NUMBER ONE. APRIL 28 , OF THIS YER. THIS IS SECTION 17- SUBSECTION B . THEY PUT TRIM OVER THE BUILDING, ACROSS THE LAUNDRY MAT THAT -- LAUNDRY MAT. AND HERE WE HAVE MISSING LETTERS ON THE FRONT
OF THE BUILDING. I DO HAVE PHOTOS. >> DO YOU HAVE ANY PHOTOGRAPHS
? >> LET ME SEE WHAT I HAVE FOR THE 26TH.
>> DOES THIS NOW SHOW THEY ARE IN COMPLIANCE? IS IT COMPLIANCE?
>> ARE ALL OF THE PHOTOGRAPHS DATED AND TIME STAMPED? THIS IS EXHIBIT NUMBER ONE, THIS IS
THE PHOTOGRAPH. >> I FIND THEY HAD A PREVIOUS VIOLATION. THE PARTIES SHOULD
BE ADVISED THAT A FINE WILL OCCUR . >> 23-2348 , 129 GARDENIA
AVENUE . JULIA MORROW . >> THE CASE WAS INITIATED AUGUST 9 , THERE IS A PREVIOUS
[H. 23-2348 CE 120 Gardenia Avenue JOSE A ANDRADE JULIAN R ZAMORA Heather Debevec]
ORDER FROM DECEMBER . THIS IS ABOUT OUTSIDE STORAGE, THERE ARE ITEMS , THE CITY REQUESTED THE VIOLATOR WILL BE GIVEN 10 DAYS . I DO HAVE PHOTOGRAPHS.>> DOES THIS ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION ? IT'S THE SAME REPEATED VIOLATOR?
>> YES, MA'AM. >> I FIND THEM IN VIOLATION OF SECTION 2425 . I AM GOING
[02:25:01]
TO ASSESS THEM $500 FINE, THEY WILL HAVE 18 DAYS. >> 23-51 , ROBERT TRUST.
[J. 23-1531 STR 2400 S Ocean Drive V712 ROBERT L MILES (TR) Heather Debevec]
>> 23-1521 , 1200 OCEAN DRIVE , ROBERT TRUST. JUNE 16, OF THIS YEAR, SECTION 22-29 ENFORCEMENT . THEY , THE CITY REQUEST THAT THEY REGISTER THEIR BUSINESS. THIS IS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE STATE STATUTE. $4000 WILL BE ASSESSED TO BE PAID WITHIN 30 DAYS THE ADVERTISEMENT MUST ALSO BE REMOVED . A TAX RECEIPT MUST BE OBTAINED .
FAILURE TO COMPLY WILL RESULT IN A $250 FINE PER DAY. OR CEASE ALL RENTAL ACTIVITIES. I DO HAVE EVIDENCE TO SUBMIT . THIS CONSISTS OF VARIOUS ADS AND
THIS IS THE PAPERWORK. AND ONE MONTH RENTAL IS $4800. >> THE REQUEST IS $4800. THE
CITY HAS A PACKET OF INFORMATION. >> NO ONE IS HERE ON BEHALF OF THE PARTY WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATION. CEASE RENTING AND OBTAIN A TAX RECEIPT, REGISTER WITH THE CITY. AND I AM GOING TO ADOPT ALL OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS.
THEY WILL HAVE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU.
>> AND YOU ARE WELCOME. >> WHICH ONE IS NEXT? >> WE ARE DONE.
>> A NOTICE OF HEARING WAS SENT TO ALL OF THE VIOLATORS. THIS WAS DONE BY CERTIFIED MAIL. THIS WAS SENT THROUGH REGULAR MAIL. IT IS ALSO POSTED AT CITY HALL. AND IF THE GREEN CARD IS NOT RETURNED TO THE DEPARTMENT WITHIN 10 DAYS OF THE HEARING, THIS MEANS THAT CARD WAS RETURNED. IF THERE GREETING CARD IS RETURNED UNSIGNED, WITHIN 10
DAYS OF THE HEARING, THEY ARE REQUIRED TO COME TO CITY HALL. >> THANK YOU EVERYBODY.
>>
* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.