May 01, 2024 Special Magistrate Hearing

[1. CALL TO ORDER]

[00:00:16]

>> THIS MAY 1ST, 2024, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING IS NOW CALLED TO ORDER. COULD WE PLEASE STAND FOR THE PLEDGE OF

ALLEGIANCE? >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH

[A. ADMINISTRATION OF OATH TO DEPARTMENTAL WITNESSES]

LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. >> IF YOU COULD PLEASE REMAIN STANDING PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. DO YOU SWEAR THAT THE TEST MANY ABOUT TO GIVE A BE THE TRUTH? TWO ASPIRIN

>> THANK YOU. >> WE WILL JUMP INTO THE

[A. 24-573 PK 200 Block Orange Avenue Cheryl Lynn Waters Heather Debevec]

>> THE CITY IS GOING TO PRESENT ITS EVIDENCE AND THEN YOU WILL HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY. COULD YOU STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD,

PLEASE? >> GOOD AFTERNOON SPECIAL REGISTRATION. THIS IS 24-573 IT IS A PARKING CITATION ISSUED IN THE 200 BLOCK OF GORGE AVENUE ON MARCH 1ST OF THIS YEAR.

CITATION 15 402 FOR CODE SECTION 34-30 1D OVER THE TWO HOUR PARKING LIMIT THE CITY REQUESTS -- THE CITATION IS $50 PER THE ADMINISTRATION FEE IS $10 AND LATE FEE IS WAIVED TOTAL DUE WOULD BE $60 FOR THE CITY IS REQUESTING IF THE VIOLATION EXISTS THE FOLLOWING THE ORDERED PRINTED BY BS IS DEFINED IN THE AMOUNT OF $60 PER DAY TO PAY WOULD RESULT IN PHYTATE TATIAN -- CITATION TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS WHICH TO SUBMIT ALONG WITH A COPY OF THE APPEAL SUBMITTED BY MS. WATERS.

>> ARE YOUR PHOTOGRAPHS DATE AND TIME STAMP?

>> YES, MA'AM. >> ARE THE DATES AND TIMES ACCURATE DOCUMENT DEBATE ACCURATELY PREDICT -- SHOW THE

VIOLATION YOU OBSERVED? >> YES, MA'AM.

>> THE CITY MOVES THESE INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT

ONE. >> THE PHOTOS PRESENTED WILL BE ENTERED AS SITTING'S COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE.

I READ THE -- >> DO YOU HAVE NOTHING FURTHER

TO ADD? >> I DO NOT.

>> IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO RESPOND, PLEASE. YOU HAVE ALREADY BEEN SWORN SO YOU CAN GO AHEAD

>> MY DAY MY FRIEND AND I HAD COME DOWN TO AN EVENT AT THE FEDERAL COURTHOUSE BUT WE INITIALLY PARKED IN A PARKING LOT AND THEY MADE US MOVE BECAUSE THEY SAID IT WAS ONLY FOR MEDIA. AND THEN WE WENT TO TRY AND FIND PARKINGAND THERE IS POLICE BLOCKING A LOT OF THE STREETS. I WENT TO GO TO THE PUBLIC PARKING GARAGE. WHEN I WENT THERE, IT WAS CLOSED I DROVE AROUND UNTIL I FOUND A PARKING PLACE. I FOUND THAT PARKING PLACE SO WE PARK THERE AND WE WENT OVER TO THE EVENT AND WENT BACK TO THE CAR . I FORGET ABOUT WHAT TIME AND IT WAS LUNCH TIME. WE PUT SOME PAMPHLETS THAT I PICKED UP IN

[00:05:08]

WE DECIDED TO GO TO LUNCH AT COBB'S LANDING. WE WENT TO LUNCH AT COBB'S LANDING. WHEN WE CAME BACK, I HAVE THE TICKET BECAUSE IT HAD BEEN MORE THAN TWO HOURS AND I DO NOT HAVE A TICKET, I FIGURED THEY WERE NOT GIVING OUT TICKETS BECAUSE THEY CLOSE THE PUBLIC PARKING GARAGE. THERE WAS NO PLACE TO PARK. IT WAS CRAZY THAT THEY. -- THAT DAY. IT WAS A PLACE TO

PARK FOUR TWO HOURS. >> I WAS GOING TO PARK IN THE

PUBLIC GARAGE PER >> WHEN YOU MADE THE DECISION TO PARK IN THE TWO HOUR PARKING, YOU KNEW IT WAS TWO

HOURS. >> BECAUSE YOU CLOSE THE PUBLIC PARKING GARAGE, I FIGURED THEY WERE NOT GOING TO GET OUT TICKETS BECAUSE MY CAR HAD ALREADY BEEN THERE LONGER THAN TWO HOURS. INSTEAD OF MOVING IT BECAUSE THERE WERE SO MANY CARS DOWN THERE AND I KNEW FRIDAY FESTERS THAT NIGHT, I JUST LEFT THE CAR THERE AND WE PUT OUR STUFF IN THERE AND WENT TO

COBB'S LANDING FOR LUNCH. >> YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE? I JUST WANT TO ASK ONE QUESTION. I ASSUME THAT YOU DON'T NECESSARILY GET TO YOUR CAR RIGHT AT THE TWO HOUR LIMIT.

>> WE USUALLY GIVE THEM A LITTLE LONGER, TWO HOURS AND 15 MINUTES BEFORE WE GO BACK OUT AND START THE PROCESS OVER.

>> THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT TO DO IT IN TWO HOURS.

>> OUR FIRST WALK-THROUGH THEY MIGHT HAVE BEEN PARKED THERE FOR AN HOUR ALREADY DURING OUR FIRST WALK-THROUGH. WE HAVE TO DO THE ENTIRE DOWNTOWN. SOMETIMES THAT TWO HOURS FOR OUR PURPOSES MAY HAVE BEEN THREE HOURS IN REALITY BECAUSE WE DID NOT GET THERE UNTIL AFTER THEY WERE PARKED THERE FOR AN HOUR. WE CANNOT BE THERE IMMEDIATELY AS SOON AS A PARK.

THE CLOCK DOES NOT RUN AS SOON AS THE VEHICLE IS PARKED AND STARTS RUNNING WHEN WE DO OUR FIRST INSPECTION.

>> I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THE FIND OF $60 IS DUE AND PAYABLE IN 14 DAYS OR IT WILL BE TURNED INTO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM AND THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL IF YOU

DISAGREE. THANK YOU. >> ARE NEXT CASE IS 24- 568.

[B. 24-568 200 Blk Ave A Angela Roesemann Doyle Isaac Saucedo]

DOYLE. >> HELLO.

THIS IS CASE NUMBER 24-568 , 200 BLOCK OF AVENUE A INITIATE ON MARCH 1ST OF 2024. THE OWNER IS ANGELA ROSEMAN DOYLE. THE CITATION NUMBER IS 17200 IN SECTION 34- SUBSECTION D . THE FIND IS $50 WITH AN ADMIN FEE OF $10 FOR A TOTAL DUE OF $60 FOR THE CITY IS REQUESTING THE MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS, THE FOLLOWING BE ORDERED. THE VIOLATOR BS TESTIFIED OF THE AMOUNT OF $60 AND FAILURE TO PAY SUCH FINAL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING POURED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS AND ALSO THE APPEAL THAT WAS SUBMITTED.

>> ARE YOUR PHOTOS DATE AND TIME STAMP?

>> YES BUT TWO -- ON THOSE DATES AT THOSE TIMES PER

>> YES, THEY DO. >> THE CITY PUTS THESE INTO EVIDENCE AS TO THE EXHIBIT ONE.

>> PHOTOS ENTERED WILL BE CITY COMPOSITE ONE.

>> ANYTHING FURTHER? >> FROM ME, NO.

>> I WORK HERE ON SECOND STREET . WE ARE RENTERS IN THE BRAWLER SOME BUILDING. WE HAVE BEEN RENTING FOR ABOUT FIVE YEARS.

MY EMPLOYER IS HERE WITH ME TODAY AND I DO NORMALLY PARK IN THE GARB -- PARKING GARAGE BUT IT WAS CLOSE THAT DAY DUE TO

[00:10:06]

NORMALLY IS NOT. >> JUST FOR CLARIFICATION BUT BUT PARKING GARAGE WAS NOT CLOSE DUE TO THE TRUMP TRIAL.

IT WAS UNDER MAINTENANCE. WE HAVE BEEN CLOSING THE FLOORS INDIVIDUALLY FOR THE WEEK TO 10 DAYS PRIOR. IT HAPPENED TO BE THAT WE WERE AT THE POINT OF CLOSING -- ONE FLOOR WAS DEDICATED FOR THE LAW ENFORCEMENT AREA. WE WERE ACTUALLY UNDER MAINTENANCE. THINGS WERE GETTING -- HAVE THE PARKING CLOSE WAS FOR THE ENTIRE WEEK.

>> THERE WERE COPS EVERYWHERE, IT WAS CLOSED.

>> SIR, IS THAT YOUR EMPLOYER?

>> YES. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO CALL HIM AS A WITNESS, HE NEEDS TO COME FORWARD AND BE SWORN AND INTRODUCE HIMSELF. WOULD YOU LIKE TO CALL HIM AS A WITNESS?

>> YES, PLEASE. >> PLEASE GIVE US YOUR NAME

>> ANNE KITTRELL. ARE YOU SWORN IN AT THE BEGINNING?

>> I DID. IT REEKS OF RIDICULOUSNESS TO SAY IT WAS NOT CLOSE FOR THE TRUMP TRIAL. THERE WERE COPS ALL ACROSS THE AREA. THERE WERE BARRICADES THAT WE COULD NOT GET INTO THE PARKING GARAGE. IT WAS CLOSED FOR PARKING. TO SAY IT WAS NOT

CLOSED IS NOT ACCURATE. >> ARE YOU THE OWNER OF THE

BUSINESS? >> WE RENT, ON SECOND STREET.

>> WHERE DID YOU PARK THAT DAY?

>> I DO NOT PARK, THERE ARE NO PARKING AREAS.

>> IS YOUR ONLY EMPLOYEE? >> NO. SHE WAS THE ONLY ONE IN THE OFFICE AT THAT TIME. WE WILL PAY THE 60 BUCKS BUT IT SEEMS LIKE THE PRINCIPAL OF CLOSING ANY AVAILABLE PARKING AND THAT ISSUING A TICKET FOR TWO HOUR PARKING WHEN THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NOWHERE TO PARK. SHE WAS NOT HERE FOR MUCH TO GO TO THE TRUMP TRIAL SHE WAS NOT HOLDING UP A PICKET SIGN. IT IS ABOUT, EITHER GO TO WORK OR RISK A $60 FINE ARE DON'T GO TO WORK . IT FEELS LIKE IT IS NOT A LOGICAL EXPLANATION THAT

THE GARAGE WAS OPEN. >> NO, SIR.

>> SHE SAID ONE FLOOR WAS OPEN FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT BEEN IN THE PARKING LOT WAS NOT CLOSE DUE TO THE TRUMP TRIAL. HE MET YES, IT WAS. THERE WAS COPS EVERYWHERE

>> SIR, WE HAVE HAD MULTIPLE OCCASIONS WHERE MR. TRUMP HAS COME INTO TOWN AND THE GARAGE HAS BEEN OPEN BECAUSE THAT HAS BEEN OUR POLICY. THE PARKING GARAGE WAS UNDER REPAIR.

>> WE DID NOT GET A TICKET ON THOSE PARTICULAR DAYS WHEN IT WAS OPEN, WE PARKED THERE. I WILL TRY AND FINISH WHAT I AM SAYING THE PARKING GARAGE WAS NOT CLOSED DUE TO THE TRUMP TRIAL. THEY DECIDED TO SCHEDULE SOMETHING ON A TIME WE WERE SCHEDULED TO HAVE REPAIRS TO THE BUILDING. THERE ARE PLENTY OF FREE PARKING AND LONG-TERM PARKING IN THE DOWNTOWN AREA BUT THERE IS A COUNTY PARKING GARAGE, THE PARKING LOT AT THE MARINA A PARKING LOT BY SAINT ANDREWS. THERE IS MULTIPLE NON- TWO HOUR PARKING AREAS AVAILABLE. UNFORTUNATELY THEY HAPPEN TO GET SCHEDULED AT THE SAME TIME AS OUR MAINTENANCE RESPONSIBILITIES. NOTHING WAS CHANGED OTHER THAN THE FACT THAT MAINTENANCE WAS UNDER THAT DAVID

>> THE PLACE WAS A ZOO. I DON'T KNOW WHO WAS HERO WHO WASN'T. DOWNTOWN WAS LOCKED UP. IF IT WAS CLOSED OR WAS NOT CLOSED , THERE WERE 400 COP CARS IN THEIR OCCUPYING THE

PARKING SPOTS. >> I HEARD THAT AND I HEARD THE EXPLANATION. UNFORTUNATELY , I MEAN THERE ARE OTHER OPTIONS.

YOU MIGHT NOT WITH THE CROWDS THAT WERE HERE. YOU MAY EVEN THE LADY BEFORE ME SAID SHE WAS HERE FOR THE EVENT AND CANNOT FIND PARKING FOR THE INFLUX OF PEOPLE GOING WHETHER THE GARAGE

WAS CLOSED OR NOT. >> WHEN YOU PARKING IT SAYS TO -- TWO HOUR PARKING, I WOULD ARGUE IT SHE SAID IT.

>> IT IS UNFORTUNATE WHEN YOU RENT AND PAY TO BE DOWN HEE, MAYBE WE NEED TO FIND ANOTHER LOCATION. I HAVE THIS ISSUE

[00:15:06]

A BEST BLOCKING IN IT. >> I UNDERSTAND THAT BUT IT IS NOT THE ONLY PARKING GARAGE FOR ONLY PARKING LOT IN TOWN.

>> I DID NOT KNOW HOW MUCH I COULD DRIVE AROUND BECAUSE THAT DAY WAS WAY MORE THAN AN AVERAGE DAY. I COULD NOT FIND ANYWHERE TO PARK TO BE AT MY JOB. I DON'T HAVE ANYTHING

ELSE TO ADD. >> DOES THE CITY HAVE ANYTHING

ELSE? >> NO, MA'AM.

>> UNFORTUNATELY, I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND I UNDERSTAND YOUR FRUSTRATION WITH IT. I THINK TWO HOUR PARKING IS VERY CLEAR. THE FACT THAT IT MADE IT MORE DIFFICULT TO FIND ANOTHER SPACE IS NOT EXCUSED WHEN YOU TAKE THAT RISK. I FIND THE FINE OF $60 IS DUE PAYABLE IN 14 DAYS OR THE CASE WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM BUT YOU DO HAVE THE RIGHT TO APPEAL. YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO APPEAL IF YOU CHOOSE TO DO SO. THANK YOU FOR COMING IN.

[E. 24-605 PK 100 Blk Orange Avenue Jan Paul Nagel Michael Rabenecker]

>> OUR NEXT CASE WILL BE CAPITAL FOR E. 24-605 100 BLOCK ORANGE AVENUE. JAN PAUL NAGEL .

>> ARE YOU JAN PAUL NAGEL ? >> YES, I AM.

>> GOOD AFTERNOON, YOUR HONOR MY NAME IS MICHAEL RABENECKER.

BUT FOR YOU THIS AFTERNOON IS CASE VIOLATION IS IMPROPER PARKING. THE CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 16918, A VIOLATION WITH HORNS 34-30 1A, IMPROPER PARKING. THE CITY IS ASKING FOR A $50 FINE AND ADMINISTRATION FEE OF $10 FOR A TOTAL DUE OF $60 FOR THE SAME REQUEST THAT THE SPECIAL MINISTRY FINDS THAT THIS BE ORDERED. AND FAILURE TO PAY SUCH A FINE WILL RESULT IN CITATION BEFORE TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS INTRODUCED THAT ACCURATELY PORTRAY THE VIOLATIONS EYEWITNESS. INFORMATION IS

INCLUDED. >> HAS A RESPOND HAD AN OPPORTUNITY THE PHOTOGRAPHS? WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE THE

PHOTOGRAPHS? >> I'M NOT GOING TO DISPUTE

THAT. >> THE CITY WILL MOVE THESE PHOTOGRAPHS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPILED A BIT -- COMPOSITE

EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOGRAPHS OMITTED WILL BE SUBMITTED AS TO THE COMPOSITE ONE.

EXCUSE ME A MINUTE WHILE I READ WHAT YOU SUBMITTED.

THE RESPONDENT IS STATING THAT WHEN HE PARKED THERE WAS A LARGE TRUCK . IS THE VIOLATION THAT HE WAS OVER THE LINE?

>> YEAH , IMPROPER PARKING. HIS FRONT TIRE IS OVER THE LINE .

IN THE PICTURE ON THE SCREEN .

>> I SEE THAT. HIS EXPLANATION WAS THAT WHEN HE PARKED, THERE

WAS A TRUCK -- >> THERE WAS A TRUCK BEHIND IT.

[00:20:01]

>> IT WAS SUNDAY MORNING AND THERE WAS ONLY LIKE THREE VEHICLES ON THE STREET. IT WAS NOT A BUSY DAY. WE WENT TO BREAKFAST. I KNEW I PARKED OVER THE LINE BECAUSE I WANTED TO BE COURTEOUS TO THE PERSON BEHIND ME. WE WERE ONLY THEE FOR 45

MINUTES. >> OTHER IF THERE WAS ONLY THREE VEHICLES ON THE STREET, MAYBE COULD HAVE FOUND A SPOT

THAT YOU FIT INTO. >> I FIT IN THERE, PERFECTLY

>> A THIRD OF YOUR CAR IS OVER THE LINE.

>> MY TIRE IS OVER THE LINE. I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE SAYING.

I ONLY WANTED TO GIVE COURTESY TO THE ONE BEHIND ME. I DID NOT THINK IT MATTERED. I UNDERSTAND IT MIGHT BE BUSY BUT SUNDAY MORNING, ANYWAY . THAT IS ALL I HAVE TO SAY.

>> THANK YOU. I FIND THAT A LITTLE -- I FIND THAT THAT IS THAT YES, IT IS A TECHNICAL VIOLATION. I DON'T KNOW. WHEN YOU HAVE PHOTOS OF -- YOU ARE SAYING --

>> I SUBMITTED THAT TO YOUR CLERK.

>> I AM NOT DISPUTING I AM OVER THE LINE.

>> I UNDERSTAND. >> I JUST THINK IT WAS

UNNECESSARY. >> IS AT THE TRUCK IN THIS

PHOTO OR A DIFFERENT TRUCK? >> IT WAS A DIFFERENT TRUCK.

>> IT WAS IN FRONT TWO CORRECT TUMOR

>> IT WAS BEHIND HIM. >> I FIND THAT IT IS 50/50. IT IS A TECHNICAL VIOLATION BUT IS NOT LIKE YOU PARKED KNOWINGLY DOING SOMETHING THAT IS A VIOLATION. I WOULD DISMISS IT.

>> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU FOR COMING IN.

[K. 23-2806 PK 600 North Indian River Drive Kevin Hudson Michael Rabenecker]

>> OUR NEXT CASE IS 4K, CASE 23-2806 600 NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE, KEVIN HAD. -- KEVIN HUDSON.

>> THE NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU IS CASE NUMBER 23-2806 , PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT THE 600 BLOCK NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE. THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON OCTOBER 15TH, 2023. THIS IS A REGULAR PARKING CITATION PRESENTATION. THE OWNER OF THE VEHICLE CAME BACK AS A KEVIN HUDSON. THE PARKING VIOLATION , THE CITATION NUMBER IS 20547. A PARKING VIOLATION OF CITY ORDER 34-30 1C, RESTRICTED PARKING PARKING FOR BOAT TRAILERS ONLY.

THE CITY IS ASKING A $50 FINE BSS AND ADMINISTRATION FEE OF $10 FOR TOTAL DUE OF $70 PER THE CITY REQUESTED THE SPECIAL MASTER FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS THE FOLLOWING THE ORDERED, THE PILOT BSS DEFINED AN AMOUNT OF $78 PER AND THE FAILURE TO PAY CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS AND THEY ACTUALLY BETRAY THE VIOLATIONS EYEWITNESS.

>> HAVE YOU SHARE THE PHOTOGRAPHS WITH THE RESPONDENT? SIR, WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE THE PHOTOGRAPHS? YOU MAY

GUESS, PLEASE. >> ARE YOU MR. HUDSON?

>> YES.

[00:25:14]

>> THANK YOU . >> THE CITY WOULD MOVE THESE PHOTOGRAPHS INTO EVIDENCE AS CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE.

>> PHOTOGRAPHS TO BE SUBMITTED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE. MR. HUDSON, WOULD YOU LIKE TO STATE ANYTHING?

>> YES. ON THE DATE IN QUESTION I WENT OUT TO FISH ON THAT SUNDAY MORNING. I WAS THERE FOR APPROXIMATELY FIVE MINUTES BUT I LITERALLY GOT OUT OF MY JEEP TO CHANGE UP MY FISHING GEAR THAT I TOOK ONE CAST AND THEN WHEN I RETURNED TO THE VEHICLE I HAD A TICKET POSTED IN THE AMOUNT OF TIME, I FELT THAT THE OFFICER WOULD HAVE SAW ME CHANGING OUT MY GEAR FROM THE BACK OF MY CAR AND ADVISED ME NOT TO PARK THERE. FURTHERMORE, I HAVE MY OWN EVIDENCE WERE THERE ARE NO POSTED SIGNS STATING BOAT TRAILERS ONLY. THE ONLY NOTATION THAT I MISSED . I CAN ADMIT THAT I DID MISS WAS THAT IT SAYS, BOAT TRAILER PARKING IT DOES NOT SPECIFY ONLY. IN THAT SAME PARKING LOT, THERE ARE OTHER SPACES THAT ARE THE SAME LENGTH AS THE SPOT I WAS PARKED AT. THEY DO NOT HAVE ANYTHING WRITTEN ON THEM WHETHER IT IS BUT PARKING ONLY OR EITHER/OR. THAT IS WHY I WOULD LIKE TO CONTEST THIS AND ENTER MY EVIDENCE INTO COURT AS

WELL. >> MR. HUDSON, HOW MANY PHOTOGRAPHS DO YOU HAVE A YOUR PLACING INTO EVIDENCE?

>> I HAVE A TOTAL OF SEVEN PHOTOS.

>> WHEN WITH THE PHOTOGRAPHS TAKEN?

>> YESTERDAY. ON THIS PHOTO YOU WILL SEE THAT THERE ARE THE CARS PARKED IN THAT SAME AREA THAT I WAS PARKED IN AS WELL AS THE CITY'S EVIDENCE THAT THERE IS ANOTHER VEHICLE PART JUST A PARKING SPOT OVER THAT DID NOT HAVE A BOAT TRAILER ON IT AS WELL. I WOULD LIKE TO GO AHEAD AND SEMATECH, PLEASE.

>> WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE HIS PHOTOGRAPHS BEFORE I SUBMIT

THEM? >> I WOULD, PLEASE.

>> I DO NOT NEED TO SEE THEM. >> I WOULD, PLEASE.

THE TOP PHOTO IS WHAT I WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT ON.

>> MR. HUDSON HAS MOVED THESE INTO EVIDENCE AS RESPONDENT'S

COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOGRAPHS WILL BE ENTERED AS RESPONDENT'S COMPOSITE ONE.

>> THESE PHOTOS WERE TAKEN YESTERDAY, NOT THE DAY YOU WERE

PARKED. >> CORRECT. TO SHOW THE AREA THAT IS IN QUESTION. MA'AM, I HAVE VISITED THAT AREA MANY TIMES I HAVE LIVED IN FORT PIERCE FOR OVER 20 YEARS BUT I HAVE PARKED IN MANY SPOTS. IT WAS NEVER AN ISSUE. LIKE I STATED, THERE WERE NO POSTED SIGNS STATING BOAT TRAILER PARKING ONLY. AS WELL AS ON THE CEMENT. IT DOES NOT SPECIFY BOAT TRAILER PARKING ONLY BE ONE CAN ASSUME THAT IT IS OPEN FOR EITHER/OR, ESPECIALLY IF THERE ARE OTHER SPOTS IN THAT AREA THAT ARE THE SAME LENGTH THAT DO NOT HAVE ANYTHING

WRITTEN ON THE CONCRETE. >> I WOULD ASSUME THE OPPOSITE.

IF IT IS UNMARKED, IT IS OPEN. IF IT IS MARKED FOR TRAILERS,

THEN IT IS FOR TRAILERS. >> I WOULD LIKE TO COMMENT ON THE ONE PHOTO HE TOOK OF THE EXTRA AMONG SPACES. THAT IS EXACTLY CORRECT. THEY ARE CALLED MULTIUSE SPACES. THEY ARE NOT MARKED AS BOAT TRAILER PARKING BECAUSE IT CAN BE -- OPEN TO BOTH CARS AND/OR BOATS. THE ONES FOR BOAT TRAILER ARE MARKED BOAT TRAILER PARKING. NO ONE THAT ARE MULTIUSER NOT

MARKED AT ALL. >> I UNDERSTAND THAT. TO BE A LITTLE CLEARER WITH THE ORDINANCE, PLACING THE WORD ONLY WOULD HELP TREMENDOUSLY JUST SO THERE ARE NO QUESTIONS.

>> NO,, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. >> ANYTHING FURTHER TWO

[00:30:13]

>> THERE IS LIMITED SPOT FOR BOAT TRAILER PARKING THERE. IT IS ONLY THAT EIGHT OR 10 -- THOSE ARE THE ONLY ONES . THE OTHERS ARE FLEX. THERE IS PLENTY OF PARKING FOR CARS. THE ONES BY THE WATER ARE FOR BOAT TRAILER PARKING AND IT IS

LIMITED. >> I WOULD AGREE. I DON'T THINK THE WORD ONLY -- I THINK IT IS CLEAR THAT BOAT TRAILER PARKING IS UP FOR BOAT TRAILERS.

>> JUST TO ADD A, I DID NOT SEE ANYBODY . IF I COME ACROSS SOMEBODY THAT THEY WOULD ASKED ME TO MOVE , WE GIVE THEM THE OPPORTUNITY TO MOVE. THE CAR IS NOT OPEN. I DO NOT SEE ANYONE THERE. THE TICKET WAS WRITTEN . I DID NOT SEE ANYONE LOADING OR

UNLOADING. >> I WOULD LIKE TO ADD ONE THING EITHER ON OR OFF THE RECORD. IT IS DIFFICULT FOR FISHERMEN, LIKE MYSELF, THAT ONLY HAVE THE OPTION TO FISH ON MY TO FISH IN FORT PIERCE. WE CURRENTLY HAVE A NUMBER OF DOCS THAT ARE CLOSED DOWN. FOR US THAT ARE NOT FORTUNATE ENOUGH TO OWN A BOAT, OUR SPACES ARE SHRINKING DAY BY DAY. I UNDERSTAND, YOU KNOW, THAT IT IS PRINTED ON THE GROUND THERE, BOAT TRAILER PARKING. IF I WOULD HAVE SAW ONLY, I WOULD NOT HAVE PARKED THERE. THIS IS DISCOURAGING FOR RESIDENTS OF FORT PIERCE AND OF ST. LUCIE COUNTY THAT CANNOT AFFORD A BOAT . AND WE ARE KIND OF LEFT .

>> I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ARE SAYING BUT IT IS NOT LIKE YOU -- IF YOU DON'T HAVE A BOAT, IT DOES NOT MEAN YOU DON'T HAVE A PLACE TO PARK. YOU JUST DON'T HAVE THAT PLACE TO PARK.

>> I UNDERSTAND BUT I WANTED TO PUT THAT OUT THERE.

>> I APPRECIATE IT. I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THE FINE WILL BE -- I WILL WAIVE THE LATE AN ADMINISTRATIVE FEE AT THE FINE OF $50 IS PAYABLE WITHIN 14 DAYS . IF NOT PAID, IT GOES TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. YOU DO HAVE THE RIGHT TO APPEAL AND YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO DO SO.

>> I WILL MAKE THAT PAYABLE FROM THE SUMMONS I RECEIVED? HER USE THE INSTRUCTIONS ON THE SUMMONS?

>> I CAN SEND YOU A LINK TO PAY ONLINE.

>> SHORT. >> YOU WANT TO PROVIDE ME WITH

YOUR EMAIL? >> OFF THE RECORD.

>> MR. HUDSON, THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE DOES NOT AN ACT THE CODES OR HAVE INPUT INTO THAT. IF YOU HAVE A CONCERN ABOUT THE CITY, YOU MIGHT WANT TO BRING IT UP WITH THE CITY MANAGER OR

CITY COMMISSION. >> UNDERSTOOD. THANK YOU.

>> THANK YOU.

[C. 24-0180 PK Jaycee Park James Michael Wood Charmaine Kirkland]

>> OUR NEXT CASE WILL BE 4C IN CITATIONS. 24-180, JC PARK.

JAMES, MICHAEL WOULD -- JAMES MICHAEL WOOD.

>> YOU CALL IT, WE WILL DO IT

>> GOOD AFTERNOON JAN. 24-0180 IS A PARKING CITATION ISSUED AT JAYCEE PARK TO A JAMES MICHAEL WOOD. PATIENT INITIATED JANUARY

[00:35:03]

FAILURE TO PAY IN A FINE WILL RESULT WITH THE CITATION BEING PAID TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM BUT I DO HAVE PHOTOS TO PICK THE TIME AND DATE OF THE VIOLATION.

>> CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT

ONE. >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS A CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE. BASED ON THE PHOTOS AND THE TESTIMONY, I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $78 PAYABLE WITHIN 14 DAYS OR THE CITATION WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM THERE IS A 30 DAY

RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU.

[D. 24-598 PK 100 Blk Melody Lane Ronald Benham Michael Rabenecker]

>> OUR NEXT ONE WILL BE TELEPHONE. IT IS 4D IN CITATIONS BRING CASE 24-498. 100 BLOCK MELODY LANE. I WILL GO AHEAD AND CALL HIM IN NOW.

>> HELLO. >> HI, RON BIRD THIS IS

CATHERINE I'M CALLING YOU LIVE >> HOW ARE YOU TODAY?

>> I'M CALLING YOU LIVE IN OUR CHAMBERS TODAY FOR THE HEARING.

>> OKAY. LET ME PULL OVER, JUST A SECOND. I AM GOOD.

>> I WILL GO AHEAD AND SWEAR YOU IN. PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD

>> RONALD BENHAM. >> YOU SWEAR THAT THE TESTIMONY YOU ARE ABOUT TO GIVE A BE THE TRUTH?

>> I DO. >> THANK YOU. WE WILL BUT THE CITY PRESENT THEIR CASE FIRST AND THEN YOU HAVE A CHANCE TO

SPEAK AFTER. >> OKAY.

>> THANK YOU. >> THE NEXT CASE BEFORE HE IS CASE NUMBER 24-598, A PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED OF THE 100 BLOCK OF MELODY LANE . THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON MARCH 1ST, 2024. THE OWNER OF THE VEHICLE CAME BACK AS A RONALD BENHAM THE PARKING CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 16907, A PARKING VIOLATION OF C ROAD CLOSE FOR SPECIAL EVENT. THE CITY IS ASKING THAT A $50 FINE BSS, $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE FOR A TOTAL OF $60 PER THE CITY REQUEST IF THE VIOLATION EXISTS THE FOLLOWING BE ORDERED , THE BSS DEFINED IN THE AMOUNT OF $60 AND VALUE TO PAY SUCH A FINERESULT IN CITATION BEING POURED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE THAT OUR DATE AND TIME STAMPS FOR THE ACTIVE TRADER VIOLATION AS I WITNESSED IT.

>> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE

EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE. HAS THE RESPONDENT SEEN THESE PICTURES?

>> YES, I HAVE. >> THANK YOU. THEY WILL BE ENTERED AS THE CITY'S COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE.

>> IS THE RESPONDENT'S APPEAL PAPERWORK ATTACHED TO BEST? WAS THAT PART OF THE COMPOSITE? HIS APPEAL PAPERWORK IS ATTACHED IF YOU WANT TO SEE THE REASON FOR THE APPEAL.

>> IT WOULD BE THE LAST FEW PAGES.

>> NORMALLY, I DO MOVE MY CAR FOR THESE EVENTS . HOWEVER, THIS TIME I WAS AN HOUR LATE TO DO AN BOAT EMERGENCY CONSISTING OF A GASOLINE BILGE. I AM LEAVING FOR THE SUMMER BACK TO

[00:40:08]

WASHINGTON. >> ANYTHING ELSE , MR.

RABENECKER ? >> NO, MA'AM.

>> MR. 1023, WOULD YOU LIKE TO ADD ANYTHING ?

>> THAT PRETTY MUCH STATE THAT WHAT I WAS GETTING READY. I WAS GEARING UP TO HEAD THERE. I THOUGHT I WAS WILLING GASOLINE WILL I WAS DOWN INSIDE IT. I HAD TO DEAL WITH THAT GASOLINE.

I HAD AN EXIT EARLY CAN AND IT HAD DEVELOPED A SPLIT IN THE SITE AND WAS LAYING ON THE SIDE IN THE COCKPIT OF MY BOAT. IT LEAKED A FAIR AMOUNT OF GAS IN THE BOAT. I LIVE THERE IN THE WINTER AND PARKING IS AT A PREMIUM DOWN THERE. I MOVE MY CAR DILIGENTLY ALL THE TIME. THAT TIME, I JUST GOT WAYLAID

WITH THE GASOLINE. >> NOTHING FROM THE CITY.

>> WELL, I UNDERSTAND YOU MAY HAVE BEEN WAYLAID BUT THE VIOLATION DOES EXIST. I WOULD FIND THAT THE $60 VIOLATION WILL BE ASSESSED AND PAYABLE WITHIN 14 DAYS OR WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.

>> THERE CAN BE NO FORGIVENESS OR ANYTHING FOR EXTENUATING CIRCUMSTANCES? IN THIS CASE, AN EMERGENCY? I MOVE MY CAR ALL THE TIME DOWN THERE. A LOT OF TIMES IT IS HARD TO FIND A PLACE TO PARK THEIR. AS A RESIDENT THERE, I AM REALLY FAMILIAR WITH THE ENTIRE SITUATION ON THE FIRST FRIDAY OF EVERY MONTH AND ALL OF THAT. I JUST GOT CUT UP IN AN

EMERGENCY. >> MR. BENHAM, MY NAME IS PEGGY AND I AM THE DIRECTOR OF THE DEPARTMENT.

>> DID YOU COMMUNICATE WITH THE MARINA OFFICE AT ALL?

>> I DID. >> WHO DID YOU SPEAK WITH AT

THE MARINA OFFICE? >> I THINK KYLE, THE NEW DOCKET

MANAGER -- DOCK MASTER. >> THIS IS NOT THE FIRST TIME A SITUATION LIKE THIS HAS OCCURRED. WE TYPICALLY ARE REACHED OUT TO BUY MARINA OFFICE, WHICH IS WHY I AM ASKING THEY DID NOT REACH OUT TO US ON THIS ONE. WE DO NOT TAKE PEOPLE'S WORD FOR IT. WHEN ANOTHER DEPARTMENT CONTACTS US AND SAYS THIS IS AN EVENT THAT HAPPENED.

>> I DID GO IN AND TALK TO THEM. THEY JUST SAID -- I MEAN, TELL THEM THAT AND THAT IS WHAT THEY WILL DO FOR YOU.

>> THE CITY AGREES TO DISMISS THE CITATION.

>> ALL RIGHT, THEN. MR. BENHAM, THE CITY HAS AGREED TO DISMISS THE CITATION FOR THANK YOU FOR YOUR TESTIMONY TODAY.

>> THANK YOU VERY MUCH AND HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY. IT IS COLD UP HERE, I WANT YOU TO KNOW. I MISS THE WARMTH.

>> WE WILL STAY. >> BYE-BYE.

>> SEE YOU UP HERE IF THERE IS A HURRICANE. THANK YOU VERY

MUCH, HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY. >> YOU TOO. BYE-BYE.

>> OUR NEXT CASE WILL BE 4F IT CASE NUMBER 23-2435 JETTY PARK AND 27 SEAWAY DRIVE. -- SORRY.

>> WE WILL GO BACK NOW. IS THAT ANOTHER TELEPHONE?

>> THAT IS JUST REGULAR ORDER NOW.

>> WE WILL BUT THE COAT OFFICER GO FIRST. SORRY, MICHAEL.

[A. 24-0018 CE 1204 Avenue K John Lee Sr Beatrice Roberts Albertha Williams Manuel Fernandez Jr.]

>> MY APOLOGIES OUR NEXT CASE IS 5A IN VIOLATION 24- DASH 18 . JOHN LEE SR., BEATRICE ROBERTS AND ALBERTO WILLIAMS.

[00:45:06]

>> GOOD AFTERNOON, YOUR HONOR. I HAVE CASE NUMBER 24-18 AT 1204 AVENUE K. THE OWNERS ARE ALBERTO WILLIAMS . IT WAS INITIATED JANUARY 18, 2024. THIS IS A REGULAR CODE CASE.

THEY WERE CITED FOR 302 .7, ACCESSORY STRUCTURE. IP MC 304.2, PRODUCTIVE TREATMENT. THE CITY REQUEST THAT IF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS THE FOLLOWING THE ORDER THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 30 DAYS TO DO THE FOLLOWING AND REMOVE OR REPAIR BUT WHAT IT AND SHAMING THANKS ON THE PROPERTY. TO PRESSURE WASH AND DETERIORATION HAS OCCURRED.

FAILURE TO COMPLY WILL RESULT IN UP OF $250 A DAY BE ASSESSED . I HAVE PHOTOS THAT HIRE DATED AND STAMPED AND ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATIONS AS I WITNESSED.

>> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOGRAPHS INTO EVIDENCE . WE HAVE THREE SETS OF PHOTOGRAPHS. ONE SET TAKEN JANUARY 2ND ONE SET TAKEN FEBRUARY 20TH AND THE THIRD TAKEN APRIL 30TH. I WILL PUT THEM IN REVERSE DATE ORDER. SITTING'S COMPOSITE ONE.

>> PHOTOGRAPHS WILL BE ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE AS CITY'S

COMPOSITE ONE. >> ANYTHING ELSE, MR.

FERNANDEZ? >> NO, MA'AM.

>> ANY COMEDIC AGE WITH THE OWNERS?

>> ZERO COMMUNICATION. >>

>> I HOPE NOT. >> I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS ON THE VIOLATOR BE 30 DAYS TO DO THE FOLLOWING, REMOVE OR REPAIR THE WOODEN AND CHAIN-LINK FENCE ON THE PROPERTY. AND PRESSURE WASH AND PAINT WITH PEELING DISCOLORATION AND DETERIORATION THAT HAS OCCURRED. FAILURE TO COMPLY AND 30 DAYS WILL RESULT IN A FINE OF TWO $50 A DAY BEING ASSESSED. THEY HAVE A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL.

>> THANK YOU , YOUR HONOR. >> OUR NEXT CASE IS FIVE C

[C. 23-2540 CE 210-212 Avenue D J CURTIS BOYD Heather Debevec]

>> THIS IS CASE 23-2540, 2010 AVENUE D WITH JAY. CURTIS BOYD.

IT WAS NISHA ON SEPTEMBER 15 OF 2023. PER SECTION 125 SUBSECTION B AND 5. FENCE MAINTENANCE, PERMIT REQUIRED. A SPECIAL MAGISTRATE SHOULD EXIST AND THE FOLLOWING IS ORDERED.

THEY HAVE 30 DAYS TO OBTAIN A PERMIT FOR THE FENCE THAT WAS INSTALLED. FAILURE TO COMPLY WILL RESULT IN A FINE OF $100 PER DAY BEING ASSESSED. I DO HAVE PHOTOS IN WHICH TO SUBMIT.

>> ARE THESE PHOTOS DATE AND TIME STAMP?

>> YES, MA'AM. DO THEY ACTIVELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION

THAT YOU WITNESS? >> YES, MA'AM.

>> THE CITY MOVES THESE INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT

ONE. >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE.

>> JUST TO CLARIFY HE HAS INSTALLED A FENCE WITHOUT A

PERMIT, CORRECT? >> CORRECT.

>> WHAT IS THE STATUS OF THE PERMIT AT THIS TIME PERIOD

>> I CHECKED WITH ELDON YESTERDAY THEY ARE SAYING THERE IS THAT APPLICATION THAT WAS RECEIVED ON 4/23 /24 AND APPROVED ON 4/26. ONCE THE APPROVAL IS OBTAINED THEY HAVE TO APPLY FOR THE PERMIT. I HAVE NOT RECEIVED SUCH APPLICATION

AT THAT TIME. >> THE RESULT CITATION IS IN

SEPTEMBER OF 2023 >> YES, THE ORIGINAL NOTICE WAS

[00:50:06]

HE JUST DID NOT GET THE PERMIT.

>> AND STILL DOES NOT HAVE THE PERMIT?

>> YES. >> DOES THE CITY HAVE ANYTHING?

>> HE DOES HAVE APPROVAL FROM HEAD START PRESERVATION BOARD.

THE PERMIT APPLICATION HAS BEEN PUT IN BUT THAT CITY IS STILL ASKING FOR A FIND OF THE VIOLATION AND HE BE ALLOWED 30

DAYS TO OBTAIN THE PERMIT. >> I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THAT RESPONDENT IS ORDERED TO CORRECT IT WITHIN 30 DAYS BY OBTAINING A PERMIT FOR THE FENCE. FAILURE TO COMPLY WILL RESULT IN A FINE OF $100 A DAY BEING ASSESSED. THERE IS A 30

[D. 23-3133 CE 2011 Valencia Avenue Thomas Hamilton Jr, Cynthia Hamilton, Geraldine Clark Heather Debevec]

DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU.

>> OUR NEXT CASE IS FIVE D IN VIOLATIONS. CASE 23-3133. 2011 VALENCIA AVENUE. THOMAS HAMILTON JR., CYNTHIA HAMILTON AND GERALDINE CLARK.

>> THIS IS CASE 23-3133, 2011 VALENCIA AVENUE. THOMAS HAMILTON JR., CYNTHIA HAMILTON AND GERALDINE CLARK. CASE NISHA JOINED 19 OF 2024. SECTION 2419, 2420, SUBSECTION 1 AND 5.

302.7, ACCESSORY STRUCTURES. THE CITY IS REQUESTING THAT A MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION OF SECTION 2419, 2421, ONE AND FIVE, UPSET -- ACCESSORY STRUCTURES DID EXIST BUT WAS CURED PRIOR TO TODAY'S HEARING. THE CITY IS REQUESTING THAT THE VIOLATOR BE NOTIFIED THAT IF A VIOLATION OF THOSE SECTIONS OCCURS AGAIN ON ANY PROPERTY OWNED BY THE VIOLATOR, STATUTE SUBSECTION THREE ADDITIONAL TIME TO CORRECT THE VIOLATION IS NOT REQUIRED AND THE MATTER WOULD BE SCHEDULED FOR HEARING BEFORE THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE MAY ORDER A FINE TO ACCRUE FOR EACH DAY THE REPEAT VIOLATION CONTINUES BEGINNING WITH THE DATE THE REPEAT VIOLATION IS FOUND TO HAVE OCCURRED BY THE CODE ENFORCEMENT OFFICER .

>> CAN WE SCROLL DOWN, PLEASE? >> SUBSECTION TWO A. THE REPEAT VIOLATION MAY BE UP TO $500 PER DAY. I DO HAVE PHOTOS IN WHICH

TO SUBMIT. >> ARE THESE PHOTOS DATE AND TIME STAMPED? THANK YOU. MOVE THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS

COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE .

IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE? AND THEY HAVE COMPLIED?

>> YES, MA'AM. THEY HAVE CORRECTED THE VIOLATIONS.

>> I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION OF SECTION 24-19 , 24-21 , SUBSECTION ONE AND SUBSECTION FIVE, NUISANCE AS OUTSIDE STORAGE AND IPC M3 DID EXIST AND WAS CURED PRIOR TO TODAY'S HEARING. HOWEVER, THE VIOLATOR WILL BE NOTIFIED THAT A VIOLATION AS STATED ABOVE WILL RESULT IN ANY PROPERTY BEING OWNED BY THE VIOLATOR TO BE ASSESSED WITHOUT FURTHER HEARING THAT PER STATUTE SECTION 162.06 , SUBSECTION THREE OF FLORIDA STATUTES, ADDITIONAL TIME TO CORRECT THE VIOLATION IS NOT REQUIRED AND THAT THE MATTER CAN BE SCHEDULED FOR HEARING BEFORE A SPECIAL MAGISTRATE. THAT STATES THAT YOU 162.09 SUBSECTION ONE, THE MAGISTRATE MAY ORDER A FIND TO ACCRUE FOR EACH DAY THE REPEAT VIOLATION CONTINUES BEGINNING WITH THE DATE THE REPEAT VIOLATION IS FOUND TO HAVE OCCURRED. BY THE CODE IMPORTANT IS -- ENFORCEMENT

[00:55:04]

>> THANK YOU. >> OUR NEXT CASE IS FIVE E IN

[E. 24-0294CE 2614 Avenue I Queen Gibbs Charmaine Kirkland]

>> GOOD AFTERNOON, YOUR HONOR. 24-0294 . LOCATION, 2614 AVENUE I OWNER, QUEEN GIVES PREDICATION NISHA FEBRES SECOND, 2024. CODE VIOLATIONS SECTION 24-19, 24-20 , 24-21 SUBSECTION ONE AND FIVE. NUISANCE IS AN OBJECT OUTSIDE STORAGE FOR SECTION 123-37, SUBSECTION 12 LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE. IP MC 302 POINT SECOND GRADE IF THE SECOND MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION EXISTS THAT THE FOLLOWING BE ORDERED. THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO REMOVE ALL PLYWOOD AND CEMENT BLOCKS. TRIM ALL OVERGROWN BUSHES, TREES SHRUBS AND GRASS. FAILURE TO COMPLY WILL RESULT IN A FINE OF $250 PER DAY BEING ASSESSED. I DO HAVE PHOTOS TO DEPICT THE TIME

AND DATE. >> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE .

>> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE . NOTE, THESE PHOTOS WERE TAKEN ON APRIL 24TH.

>> YES, MA'AM. >> THE CONDITION STILL EXISTED AT THAT TIME. IS OR ANYTHING ELSE?

>> NO, MA'AM. >> I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS -- THE VIOLATIONS EXIST AND THAT THE FOLLOWING BE ORDERED. THE VIOLATOR IS TO REMOVE ALL PLYWOOD AND CEMENT BLOCKS, RICHER AND -- REPAIR OR REMOVE THE FENCE. FAILURE TO COMPLY RESULT IN A FINE OF $250 A DAY BEING ASSESSED AND IF NOT COMPLETED IN 10 DAYS. THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL.

>> THANK YOU. >> OUR NEXT CASE IS 5G IN

[G. 24-0485 CE 3010 Carver Street Yvonne Jones Charmaine Kirkland]

>> CASE NUMBER 24-0485. 3010 CARVER STREET . OWNER IS EGON JONES CASE NISHA FEBRUARY 23RD, 2024 . VALUATIONS ARE SECTION 26 DASH THREE STORAGE OF COMMODITIES SUBSECTION 10 .

NUISANCE AS AN OBJECT SECTION 2419 SUBSECTION 11 NUISANCE AT AN OPPOSITE -- OBJECT OUTSIDE STORAGE FOR SUBSECTION ONE AND FIVE, NUISANCE AS AN OBJECT OUTSIDE STORAGE FOR THE CITY REQUEST THAT IF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS THAT THE FOLLOWING BE ORDERED BUT THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO REMOVE ALL MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS FROM INSIDE A TRAILER AND PLACED THEM IN A GARAGE OR SHED. REMOVE ALL NON-OPERABLE VEHICLES FROM THE PROPERTY . REMOVE THE KITCHEN TABLE AND CHAIRS AND ALL OTHER FURNITURE FROM THE PROPERTY.

REMOVE TARPS, WOOD, BUCKETS AND ANY OTHER ITEMS IN THE ABOVE-MENTIONED ORDINANCE AND STORE OUT OF PUBLIC VIEW, GARAGE OR SHED. FAILURE TO COMPLY WILL RESULT IN A FINE OF $100 PER DAY BEING ASSESSED. I DO HAVE PICTURES , DATE AND

[01:00:02]

>> YOU HAVE BEEN OUT TO THE PROPERTY TAKING PHOTOGRAPHS

THREE TIMES? >> YES.

>> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE

EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE . THE LAST PHOTOS WERE TAKEN ON APRIL

19 ? >> YES.

>> I FIND BASED ON THE TESTIMONY AND THE PHOTOGRAPHS INTRODUCED THAT THE VIOLATIONS EXIST AND THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO REMOVE ALL THE MISCELLANEOUS ITEMS FROM THE TRAILER AND PLACED THEM IN A GARAGE OR SHED. REMOVE NONOPERABLE BEAGLES FROM THE PROPERTY, REMOVE KITCHEN TABLE AND CHAIRS AND ALL OTHER FURNITURE ON THE PROPERTY AND REMOVE TARPS, WOOD, AND ANY OTHER ITEMS THAT ARE IN THE ORDINANCE AND STORE OUT OF PUBLIC VIEW . FAILURE TO COMPLY WILL RESULT IN A FINE OF $100 A DAY BEING ASSESSED BUT THERE IS

A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU.

[F. 23-2435 CE CT Jetty Park / 2017 Seaway Dr Karl Kahmann Michael Rabenecker]

>> WE ARE GOING TO JUMP INTO CITATIONS. OUR NEXT CASE IS 4F.

23- 2435, JETTY PARK. 2017 SEAWAY DRIVE, CARL COMMON.

>> THE NEXT CASE BEFORE HE IS 23-2435. A CODE ENFORCEMENT VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT JETTY PARK. THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON AUGUST 2620 23. THE OWNER WAS KARL KAHMANN. THE CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 1383 CODE ENFORCEMENT CITATION .

VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 28-31 , SUBSECTION 28, PROHIBITED ACTIVITIES , SELLING ITEMS IN THE PARK. THE CITY IS ASKING THAT ONE $50 FINE BE ASSESSED AN ADMINISTRATION FEE OF $10 FOR TOTAL DUE OF $60 PER IF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION EXIST THE FOLLOWING THE ORDER, THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $60 AND FAILURE TO PAY WILL RESULT IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS THAT ARE DATE AND TIME STAMPED AND THEY ACTUALLY BETRAY THE VIOLATIONS AS I WITNESSED IT.

>> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE

EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE .

>> I FIND BASED ON THE TESTIMONY AND THE PHOTOS SUBMITTED THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A FINALLY AMOUNT OF $60 CONSISTING OF ONE $50 FINE AND AN ADMINISTRATIVE FEE FOR $10 FOR TOTAL OF $60. THE VIOLATION WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM IF NOT PAID WITHIN 14 DAYS AND THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL.

[G. 23-2834 PK 100 Blk Orange Avenue Penske Truck Leasing Company Michael Rabenecker]

>> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR. >> NEXT CASE IS 4G IN CITATIONS 23-2034, 100 BLOCK ORANGE AVENUE. PENSKE TRUCK LEASING .

>> THEY NEXT CASE IS 23-2834 , PARKING VIOLATION OCCURRED OF THE 100 BLOCK OF ORANGE AVENUE. THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON OCTOBER 15, 2023. THE OWNER CAME BACK AS PENSKE TRUCK LEASING COMPANY. THE CITATION NUMBER IS 20549, PARKING VIOLATION OF CITY ORDINANCE 21-34, PARKING IN THE OPPOSING TRAFFIC LANE. THE CITY IS ASKING THE $50 FINE BE ASSESSED AN ADMINISTRATION FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18. THE

[01:05:12]

BUT >> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE .

>> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE .

BASED ON THE TESTIMONY AND THE PHOTOS AND I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $78 CONSISTING OF A $50 FINE , A $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE AND A LATE FEE OF $18 FOR A TOTAL OF $70. FAILURE TO PAY THE FINE WILL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM IF NOT PAID IN 14 DAYS. THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT

[H. 23-2682 PK 500 Blk S 8th Street Christine Zgura Michael Rabenecker]

TO APPEAL >> THANKS, YOUR HONOR.

>> NEXT CASE IS 4H BIRD 23-2682. 500 BLOCK OF SOUTH EIGHTH STREET. CHRISTINE ZGURA.

>> THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON OCTOBER 1, 2023. THE OWNER OF THE VEHICLE CAME BACK AS A CHRISTINE ZGURA . THE CITATION NUMBER WRITTEN IS 20526, A PARKING VIOLATION 34-31, PARKING ON A CITY RIGHT AWAY. A $50 FINE SHOULD BE ASSESSED AN ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10 A LATE FEE OF $18 FOR TOTAL OF $78 THE CITY REQUEST AT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXIST THE FOLLOWING THE ORDER FOR THE VIOLENT ABUSE AS DEFINED AMOUNT OF $70 AND FAILURE TO PAY RESULTS IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. THEY ACTUALLY BETRAY THE VIOLATIONS AS I WITNESSED IT.

>> CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS CITY COMPOSITE

EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE . I FIND THAT THE PHOTOS AND TESTIMONY SHOW THAT THE RESPONDENT IS IN VIOLATION OF THE PARKING ON THE CITY RIGHT AWAY. AND WILL BE FINED AND ASSESSED A FEE IN THE AMOUNT OF $70 CONSISTING OF A $50 FINE, ADMINISTRATION FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 FOR A TOTAL OF $78 TO BE PAID WITHIN 14 DAYS OR WILL BE FOUR TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. THERE IS A

[I. 23-2803 PK 500 Blk Pinewood Drive Ean Holdings, LLC Michael Rabenecker]

30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> THANKS, YOUR HONOR.

>> OUR NEXT CASE IS 4I. CASE NUMBER 23-2803 , 500 BLOCK PINEWOOD DRIVE. EAN HOLDINGS LLC .

>> THE NEXT CASE BEFORE HE IS CASE NUMBER 23-2803, PARKING VIOLATION AT THE 500 BLOCK OF PINEWOOD DRIVE. THE CASE WAS IN OCTOBER 8, 2023. THE OWNER CAME BACK AS EAN HOLDINGS LLC . THE CITATION NUMBER IS 20540, PARKING VIOLATION OF ORDERS 34-30 1L, PARKING ON THE CITY RIGHT AWAY. A $50 FINE BE ASSESSED AND A $10 ADMINISTRATION FEE AND LATE THE $18 FOR TOTAL DUES AND EIGHT DOLLARS FOR THE CITY REQUEST THE SPECIAL MANAGEMENT FINDS THE VIOLATION EXIST THE FINE BE ORDERED IT WILL BE ASSESSED THE AMOUNT OF $78 AND FAILURE TO PAY RESULTS IN CITATION BEING FOUR TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE STATE AND TIME AND ACTUALLY VIOLATE -- ACTUALLY BETRAY THE VIOLATION AS I

WITNESSED IT. >> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE .

>> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE . I FIND THAT THE PHOTOS AND THE TESTIMONY SHOW THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $78 CONSISTING OF A FINE OF $50, ADMINISTRATION FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18. IF NOT PAID WITHIN 14 DAYS , IT WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. THERE IS A

30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU.

[J. 23-2835 PK 500 Blk Pinewood Drive Ean Holdings LLC Michael Rabenecker]

>> OUR NEXT CASE IS FOR J , 23-2835. 500 BLOCK PINEWOOD

DRIVE , EAN HOLDINGS LLC PER >> THE NEXT CASE BEFORE HE IS

[01:10:01]

>> LATE MOVE THESE PHOTOGRAPHS INTO EVIDENCE AS EXHIBIT ONE.

>> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE

EXHIBIT ONE PER >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE POINT BASED ON THE TESTIMONY AND PHOTOS SHOWING THAT THE VEHICLE IS PARKED IN THE CITY RIGHT AWAY, I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXIST AND THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $78 BASED ON A FINE OF $50, AND MINISTRY DOES -- ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10.

FAILURE TO PAY THE FINE IN 14 DAYS WILL RESULT IN THE

[L. 23-3103 PK 600 North Indian River Drive 12 AB Lot Thomas Mikovsky Tonya Mikovsky Michael Rabenecker]

IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> OUR NEXT CASE IS 4L IN CITATION FOR 23-3103. 600 NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE.

>> THE NEXT CASE BEFORE HE IS CASE 23- 3103, PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED AT THE 600 NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE.

THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON DECEMBER 8, 2020 THE OWNER OF THE VEHICLE CAME BACK AS A THOMAS MIKOVSKY AND A TONYA MIKOVSKY . BLESSED IS NUMBER WRITTEN IS 19976, PARKING VIOLATION OF 34-30 1E, PERMITTED PARKING BUT THE CITY IS ASKING A $50 FINE BE ASSESSED WITH A MINISTRATION $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 WITH A TOTAL FEE OF $78 PER IF THE VIOLATION EXIST THE FOLLOWING THE ORDERED PART OF THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A FINE AMOUNT OF $78 AND FAILURE TO PAY SUCH A FINE RESULT IN CITATION TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE THE DATE AND TIME AND THEY PORTRAY THE VIOLATION AS I WITNESSED IT

>> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPSITE

EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE . PHOTOS CLEARLY SHOW THE VIOLATION OF PROHIBITED PARKING EXISTS AND THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $78 TOTAL FOR A FINE OF $50 WITH ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10 A LATE FEE OF $18 PER FAILURE TO PAY WILL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL.

[M. 24-322 PK 100 Blk Marina Way James Burnley Michael Rabenecker]

>> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR. >> OUR LAST CASE TODAY IS FOR

CAPITAL AND IMPRINT 24-322. >> THE NEXT CASE BEFORE YOU IS 24-322 , PARKING VIOLATION THAT OCCURRED OF THE 100 BLOCK OF MARINE AWAY. THE CASE WAS AND ISSUED ON FAIRBURY SECOND, 2024. THE OWNER OF THE VEHICLE CAME BACK IS JAMES BRADLEY THE CITY'S NUMBER IS 20592, VIOLATION A CITY OR 34-30 5A, CLOSE DO A SPECIAL EVENT. THE CITY IS ASKING THE 50 FALLER FINE BE ASSESSED . A LATE FEE OF EIGHT DOLLARS FOR A TOTAL OF $78. THE CITY REQUEST IF THE MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION EXIST THE FINE BE ORDERED. THE TO BE ASSESSED A FINE AMOUNT OF $78 AND FAILURE TO PAY THE FINE RESULT IN CITATION BEING FOUR TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. I HAVE PHOTOS TO INTRODUCE DATE AND TIME AND THEY PORTRAY THE VIOLATIONS I WITNESSED.

>> THE CITY MOVES THESE PHOTOS INTO EVIDENCE AS COMPOSITE

EXHIBIT ONE . >> PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS CITY'S COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE. BASED ON THE TESTIMONY AND THE PHOTOS ENTER, I FIND THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED A FINE IN THE AMOUNT OF $78 , CONSISTING

[01:15:06]

30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU, YOUR HONOR.

>> THANK YOU. >> I'M GOING TO GO AHEAD AND

[1. 24-227 PK 100 Blk N. 2nd Street Cades Joseph Michael Rabenecker]

[2. 24-585 PK 100 Blk Atlantic Ave Jacqueline Marie Tobias Charmaine Kirkland]

[3. 24-0340 CE 317 North 27th Street Wendy Franklin Charmaine Kirkland]

[4. 24-0443CE 702 N 29th Street Daniel Alejandro Gonzalez Tolentino (TR) Charmaine Kirkland]

[5. 23-2846 PK 600 North Indian River Drive Odalys Mayedo Michael Rabenecker]

[ 23-2398 CE CT 3012 Sunrise Blvd Luis Macias M. Rabenecker]

[7. 24-0343 CE 424 North 23rd Street Charles Walcott Charmaine Kirkland]

[8. 24-316 PK 200 Blk North Indian River Drive Michael Tar Michael Rabenecker]

[9. 24-250 PK 600 Blk Ave D Tyson Transportation LLC Michael Rabenecker]

>> 24-316 200 BLOCK OF NORTH INDIAN RIVER DRIVE . TARP.

[10. 24-328 PK 100 Blk AE Backus Avenue Ean Holdings LLC Michael Rabenecker]

[11. 24-154 PK 200 Blk AE Backus Ave Katrina Dawson Michael Rabenecker]

[12. 24-245 PK 504 N. 15th Street Unit B Ewald Knolle Michael Rabenecker]

[13. 24-0359 CE 425 North 23rd Street Tijuanna Clemons Charmaine Kirkland]

[14. 23-2114 PK South Causeway Park Lisa Byrd Michael Rabenecker]

[15. 24-231 PK Jaycee Park Sonia Bond Michael Rabenecker]

[16. 24-570 PK 200 Blk Ave A Olivia Tyler Burgess Isaac Saucedo]

HALL. >> THANK YOU.

>> THAT IS IT. DO WE NEED TO READ INTO RECORD THE STIPULATION CASES? THE CASES OF STIPULATIONS WHERE --

>> FOR YOUR RECORDS, THE WAY WE READ --

>>

>> CAN YOU CALL THE STIPULATION CASES? AND THEN WE CAN ADJOURN.

[B. 23-2643 CE 709 S 7th ST Tylan R Willes Manuel Fernandez Jr.]

[F. 24-0341 CE 309 N 27th Street Joyce A Holloway Charmaine Kirkland]

>> THE FOLLOWING CASES WERE STIPULATED TODAY PRETTY CASE NUMBER 23-2643, 109 SOUTH SEVENTH STREET. TYLAN WHILES AND CASE NUMBER 24-331, 309 NORTH 27TH STREET, JOYCE

HOLLOWAY. >>

>> ADJOURNED. >> THIS HEARING IS ADJOURNED.

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.