[1. CALL TO ORDER] [00:00:10] >>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING E TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS, ONE NATION UNDER GOD, INDIVISIBLE, WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. . >> IF HE CAN REMAIN STANDING. PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND. USE FOR THE TESTIMONY ARE ABOUT TO GIVE WILL BE THE TRUTH? THANK YOU. [E. PK2024-99 100 Blk N 19th St John Eugene Reed Charmaine Kirkland] >> FIRST WILL BE PK20 24- 89. JOHN EUGENE REED. YOU CAN COME UP TO THE PODIUM. >> GOOD MORNING. >> GOOD MORNING. >> GOOD MORNING HONOR. CASE NUMBER PK20 24- 99 OCCURRED AT THE 100TH BLOCK OF NORTH 19TH STREET TO JOHN EUGENE REED. AUGUST 29, 2024. VIOLATIONS ARE A CITATION NUMBER 14656 CODE SECTION 34-31E PARKED ON THE SIDEWALK. A FINE OF $50 AND AND ADMINISTER SHOULD BE A $10. $18 LATE FEE. SO TOTAL OF $78. I DO HAVE PHOTOS TO DEPICT THE VIOLATION AS I WITNESSED IT. >> DID MR. REED GET TO LOOK AT THIS? IS THIS MR. REED? >> YES, IT IS. >> FOR THE RECORD, MS. KIRKLAND PROVIDED THE CITY EXHIBIT ONE A THROUGH D, C THROUGH E AND A THERE F, A THROUGH B SHOWS THE TRUCK PARKED ON THE SIDEWALK AUGUST 29TH, 2024 AT 10:21 A.M. AND EXHIBITS 1C THROUGH D, ALSO AUGUST 29TH AT THE SAME TIME IN THE LAST EXHIBIT WOULD BE AUGUST 29TH. DO THESE PHOTOGRAPHS TRULY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION YOU SAW ON THAT DATE? >> YES, MA'AM. >> HE TOOK THE PHOTOS YOURSELF? >> YES, MA'AM. >> STATE REMOVING EVIDENCE CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE. >> CITY ATTORNEY, CAN YOU MOVE THE MICROPHONE A LITTLE BIT CLOSER TO YOU? THANK YOU. >> THE PHOTOGRAPHS WILL BE ENTERED AS THE CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE. >> MS. KIRKLAND, WAS ANYONE AT THE VEHICLE WHEN YOU WERE THERE? >> NO, MA'AM. THE VEHICLES OWNED BY MR. REED. >> I DID A CHECK BY THE VIN NUMBER AND THAT WAS THE NAME THAT CAME UP. >> NOTHING FURTHER FROM THE CITY. >> YOU HAVE NOT BEEN SWORN? OR HAVE YOU? >> NO. >> I WILL DO THAT. >> HE WAS SWORN IN THIS MORNING, YES. >> THANK YOU. YOU CAN GO AHEAD. >> THE ONLY THING I BROUGHT TODAY TO EVEN TRY TO EXONERATE MYSELF IS THAT I CANCELED THE REGISTRATION OF THIS VEHICLE . I SOLD THIS VEHICLE. PRIOR TO COMING TO COURT TODAY, I DID FIND THE PHONE NUMBER OF THE GENTLEMAN. THIS CONVERSATION IS HERE BUT HE WAS A NASTY MAN THAT USED VULGAR LANGUAGE. MORE THAN JUST PAYING THE $78, EVEN IF YOU FIND IT AGAINST ME, WHAT I'M REALLY CONCERNED ABOUT IS THAT THIS IS MINOR . BUT WHAT ELSE WILL THIS GENTLEMAN DO? UPON TALKING TO HIM, I FLIPPED THE VEHICLE, MEANING I HAVE SOLD IT SINCE THEN. WHAT I HAVE BROUGHT TODAY TO EXONERATE MYSELF IS THAT I DID CANCEL THE REGISTRATION. I TAUGHT MYSELF FOR NOT MAKING SOME TYPE OF BILL OF SALES AND I DON'T HAVE BUT TO SHOW YOU. BUT I WILL GLADLY PAY THE $70 IF YOU FIND AGAINST ME BUT I CANNOT STRESS ENOUGH HOW SCARED I AM. THIS IS [00:05:02] PARKED ON THE SIDEWALK, NO BIG DEAL. BUT SUPPOSE YOU COMMIT A CRIME. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO SEE MY EVIDENCE, FINE. IF NOT, IF I CAN PAY THIS ON NOVEMBER 20TH WHEN I GET PAID, I WILL LEAVE. BUT MA'AM, THIS GUY NEEDS TO BE CHECKED OUT. THAT IS ALL I SAY. >> I'M SORRY THIS WAS PARKED ON THE SIDEWALK. SHOULD COVER MY A AND B BY MAKING A BILL OF SALE. I AM AT THE MERCY OF YOU, JUDGE. I DO HAVE THAT ON MY PHONE, THE CANCELLATION OF THE REGISTRATION. >> YOU DID STILL OWN IT AT THAT TIME? >> NO. >> AT THAT TIME, I SIGNED THE TITLE TO THIS YOUNG GENTLEMAN AND AGAIN, NO BILL OF SALE. SHAME ON JOHN REED. I'M AT THE MERCY OF YOU. I DO HAVE THAT CANCEL REGISTRATION IF YOU LIKE TO SEE IT BUT IF NOT, GIVE ME THE NOVEMBER 20TH DATE AND I WILL PAY YOU. MORE IMPORTANT THAN THAT, I WOULD LIKE TO TRACK DOWN THIS DOOR VEHICLE SOMEHOW BECAUSE WHAT ELSE? ARE YOU GOING TO COMMIT A BANK ROBBERY? BUT YOU KNOW, THAT IS ALL I HAVE. >> MR. REED, IF I MAY INQUIRE, WHEN DID YOU SELL THE VEHICLE? >> US ALL THIS IN AUGUST, THE EARLY PART OF AUGUST. >> HOW DID YOU PUBLICIZE THE SALE? WAS IT THROUGH FACEBOOK OR SOME OTHER MEANS? >> CRAIGSLIST. >> WHO WAS THE INDIVIDUAL YOU SOLD IT TO? DID YOU GET A NAME? >> HE IDENTIFIED HIMSELF AS JAMIE SUTHERLAND. >> DOES HE LIVE LOCALLY ? >> HE CLAIMS TO LIVE IN FORT PIERCE. >> WHAT IS THE NUMBER YOU HAVE BEEN COMMUNICATING WITH HIM ON? >> DO YOU HAVE THAT? >> I DO. >> ANY OTHER DOCUMENTS YOU WOULD LIKE TO PROVIDE, WE CAN ENTER INTO EVIDENCE FOR YOU TOO. >> UP CASES YOU. THANK YOU. >> THIS PHONE NUMBER IS 772, 290- 1747. AND I WARNED THE COURT THAT HE IS A VERY NASTY TALKING GUY, TO FEMALES IN PARTICULAR. HE LIKES TO USE THE B WORD. THIS IS ALL HEARSAY AND IT IS REALLY NOT RELEVANT TO THE TRUCK BEING PARKED ON THE SIDEWALK. BUT A LADY FRIEND OF MINE TRIED TO STRIKE A SOLUTION WITH THIS YOUNG MAN BUT HE SEEMS TO LIKE TO USE THE B WORD. I SERVED IN THE ARMY. I HAVE A FILTHY MOUTH TOO BUT I KIND OF WATCH MY MOUTH AROUND WOMEN. A VERY NASTY MAN. >> WHEN YOU SOLD THE VEHICLE, THERE WAS NO TITLE TRANSFER AT THAT TIME? >> I DID. YES. >> BUT HE HAS NOT RECORDED THAT IS WHAT YOU ARE SAYING. >> YES. >> YOU ALSO BROUGHT DOCUMENTS. CAN YOU ALSO HAND THOSE UP TO US, ANY PAPER DOCUMENTS YOU MIGHT HAVE? >> NO PAPER DOCUMENT. I HAD TO TAKE A PICTURE OF IT. IS THAT OKAY? IF YOU GUYS LIKE. JUST PLACE YOUR CELL PHONE ON THE TABLE . >> OKAY. >> TIMED OUT. >> MR. REED, IS THIS THE REGISTRATION YOU STATED YOU CANCELED SINCE THEN? >> YES. >> YOU MIGHT WANT TO CHANGE [00:10:02] YOUR PASSCODE . >> THIS IS BEING RECORDED. >> WHEN DID YOU CANCEL THIS? >> SHORTLY AFTER SIGNING THE TITLE. >> BACK IN AUGUST? >> YES . >> MS. KIRKLAND, SINCE YOU ARE CLOSER, DO YOU SEE DOCUMENTATION OF THAT? >> I DON'T SEE MONEY THERE. >> MS. KIRKLAND, TO FOLLOW-UP WITH THE QUESTION -- >> DO I NEED TO REMOVE THIS DOCUMENT OFF THE SCREEN? >> YES PLEASE. THANK YOU FOR PROVIDING THAT. >> MS. KIRKLAND, DID YOU DO ANY RESEARCH REGARDING REGISTRATION OF THE VEHICLE? >> NO, MA'AM. I RAN THE VIN NUMBER. >> I DON'T HAVE ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS. >> GOD BLESS YOU. >> YOU BELIEVE YOU DID THIS SOMETIME IN AUGUST, EARLY AUGUST? >> YES. SHORTLY AFTER I SIGNED OVER THE TITLE AND ACCEPTED THE CASH. >> I FIND, BASED ON YOUR TESTIMONY UNDER OATH IN THE DOCUMENTATION YOU PROVIDED, THAT YOU DID NOT OWN THE VEHICLE AT THE TIME AND WERE NOT DRIVING IT SO I WOULD DISMISS THE INFRACTION. >> GOD BLESS YOU, MA'AM. THANK YOU FOR HEARING MY CASE TODAY. >> AND HIM -- I DISMISSED? >> YEAH SMOOTH . >> NEXT WILL BE CITATIONS [A. PK2024-88 Jaycee Park Summer Elynn Pauley Charmaine Kirkland] 4APK20 24- 88, JAYCEE PARK, SUMMER LYNN PAULEY, YOUR HONOR, CASE NUMBER PK20 24- 88 OCCURRED AT JAYCEE PARK TO SUMMER PAULEY AUGUST 17, 2024. CITATION NUMBER FOR 10650. CODE SECTION RESTRICTED PARKING. A FINE OF $50 AND AN ADMIN FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 WHICH IS A TOTAL DUE OF $78 AND I DO HAVE PHOTOS TO DEPICT THE VIOLATION AS A WITNESS TO . >> MS. KIRKLAND HANDED OFF EXHIBITS 1A THE B, DEPICTING PARKING AND DESIGNATED SPACES ONLY. A PHOTOGRAPH OF THIS AT JAYCEE PARK AS WELL AS THE VEHICLE IN QUESTION. EXHIBIT 1C THROUGH D, SIMILAR EXHIBIT, PHOTOGRAPHS AND EXHIBIT 1E THROUGH F OF THE LICENSE PLATE AND NOTICE. EXHIBIT 1G THROUGH H WHICH ALSO HAS A PICTURE OF THE VEHICLE. AND THE CITY WOULD MOVE INTO EVIDENCE AT THIS TIME. THE CITY'S COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE. PHOTOGRAPHS WILL BE ENTERED AS THE CITY COMPOSITE ONE . >> IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE? >> NO, MA'AM. >> BASED ON THE PHOTOGRAPHS AND YOUR TESTIMONY THE VEHICLE WAS PARKED IN A NO PARKING AREA AND AS SUCH, IS IN VIOLATION OF THE RESTRICTED PARKING 34-31 SUBSECTION C AND A FINE OF $50 AND AN ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 FOR A TOTAL OF $78 IS DUE AND PAYABLE IN 14 DAYS. IF NOT PAID WITHIN THAT TIME, IT WILL BE REFERRED [B. PK2024-79 100 Marina Way Scott E Swanson Charmaine Kirkland] TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM AND THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> NEXT CASES 4B CITATIONS PK20 24- 79, 100 MARINA WAY, SCOTT E SWANSON. >> 20-POINT FOR-79 OCCURRED AT 100 MARINA WAY TO SCOTT E SWANSON. IS INITIATED AUGUST 2ND, 2024. CITATION NUMBER [00:15:04] 5073, CODE SECTION 34-31A AND IMPROPER PARKING. A FINE OF $50 AND AN ADMIN FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 WHICH IS A TOTAL DUE OF $78 AND I DO HAVE PHOTOS TO DEPICT THE VIOLATION AS I WITNESSED IT. >> MS. KIRKLAND HANDED UP EXHIBIT 1A TO B, PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE VEHICLE PARKED AND THE LICENSE PLATE EXHIBIT 1C THROUGH D WHICH WAS EARLIER IN THE DAY, AUGUST 2ND AT 7:00 A.M. OF THE NOTICE TO VEHICLES NOT TO PARK IN THESE AREAS. EXHIBIT E THROUGH F AGAIN OF THE VEHICLE AFTER 2 P.M., LICENSE PLATE, WHERE WAS PARKED AND EXHIBIT 1G THROUGH H OF THE VEHICLE AND NOTICE GIVEN TO IT. THESE PHOTOGRAPHS TRULY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT THE VIOLATION THAT YOU SAW THAT DATE? >> YES, MA'AM. >> THE CITY WOULD MOVE INTO EVIDENCE EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOGRAPHS WILL BE ENTERED AS THE CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE . >> BASED ON THE PHOTOS AND THE EVIDENCE , PHOTOGRAPHIC EVIDENCE AND THE TESTIMONY, I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THAT THE FINE OF $50 ADMINISTERED A FEE OF $10 IN LATE FEE OF $18 FOR A TOTAL OF $78 IS DUE AND PAYABLE IN 14 DAYS OR WILL BE SENT TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM AND THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL . [C. PK2024-83 Jaycee Park Julio Joel Tavera Charmaine Kirkland] >> THE NEXT CASE IS 4CPK202483, NAY FOR PARK, GIGLIO JOE WELL TO VERA . >> CASE NUMBER PK20 24- 83 OCCURRED AT JAYCEE PARK TO GIGLIO SCHOLL TO VERA. CITATION NUMBER CODE SECTION 34-31C PARKING FOR BOAT AND TRAILER ONLY. FINE OF $50 AND AN ADMIN FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 WHICH IS A TOTAL DUE OF $78. I DO HAVE PICTURES TO DEPICT THE TIME AND THE VIOLATION AS A WITNESS TO. >> MS. KIRKLAND HANDED UP EXHIBIT 1A THERE B AND PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE LICENSE PLATE AND THE VEHICLE PARKED, TRAILER PARKING AND EXHIBIT 1C THROUGH D WHICH ARE SIGNS WITHIN THE PARK AND THE BACK OF THE VEHICLE. AT THIS TIME, THE CITY WOULD MOVE INTO EVIDENCE THE CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE . >> PHOTOGRAPHS WILL BE ADMITTED AS THE CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE. BASED ON THE PHOTOGRAPHS AND THE TESTIMONY, WHICH SHOW THAT THE VEHICLE IS PARKED INAPPROPRIATELY IN A BOAT AND TRAILER ONLY ONLY. I FIND THAT THERE IS A FINE OF TOTAL DUE OF $78 IS DUE AND PAYABLE WITHIN 14 DAYS OR IT WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. AND [D. PK2024-98 100 Blk N 19th St Fabulous Logistics Charmaine Kirkland] THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL . >> NEXT CASE IS 4D CITATIONS PK20 24- 98, 100 BLOCK NORTH 19TH STREET, FABULOUS LOGISTICS. >> CASE NUMBER PK20 24- 98 OCCURRED AT THE 100TH BLOCK OF NORTH 19TH STREET TO FABULOUS LOGISTICS. CASE INITIATED AUGUST 29TH 2024. CITATION NUMBER 14654, CODE SECTION 34-31L PARKED ON THE CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY. A FINE OF $50 AND ADMIN FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 WHICH IS A TOTAL DUE OF $78. AND I DO HAVE PHOTOS TO DEPICT THE VIOLATION AS I WITNESSED IT. >> I HAVE A QUESTION. >> YES. >> I KNOW THAT THIS IS PK20 24- 99 AND ON THE SCREEN, IT IS 98. DO YOU KNOW WHICH ONE IT IS? >> IT IS SUPPOSED TO BE 98. WHAT CASE DO YOU HAVE? >> I HAVE 99. >> DOES IT SAY FABULOUS LOGISTICS? >> THAT WAS MR. REED. JOHN REED WAS NUMBER 99. >> THAT IS A DIFFERENT CASE. YOU SHOULD BE LOOKING AT PAGE 13. >> OKAY, SORRY. >> IT'S OKAY. EXHIBITS 1A [00:20:12] THERE B SHOWING THE TRUCK PARKING EXHIBIT 1C THROUGH D AND THE VEHICLE PARKED AND NOTICE OF THE VIOLATION ON THE VEHICLE 1E THROUGH F WITH THE LICENSE PLATE AND 1G THROUGH H. SO THE VEHICLE PARKING AUGUST 29TH. >> THE CITY MOVES INTO EVIDENCE CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE. >> PHOTOGRAPHS WILL BE ENTERED FOR THE CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE . >> BASED ON THE PHOTOGRAPHS SUBMITTED AND THE TESTIMONY, I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND A FINE OF $50 AN ADMINISTRATIVE FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 FOR A TOTAL OF $78 IS DUE AND PAYABLE IN 14 DAYS OR THE CITATION WILL BE FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT [F. PK2024-100 100 Blk N 19th St Danny Lyn Prevatte Charmaine Kirkland] SYSTEM AND THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU. THE NEXT CASE IS 4F CITATIONS CASE NUMBER PK20 24- 100. 100 BLOCK NORTH 19TH STREET. DANNY LYN PRIVETTE. >> THIS OCCURRED AT THE 100TH BLOCK OF NORTH 19TH STREET TO DANNY LIN PRIVETTE. AUGUST 29, 2024. CITATION NUMBER 146 -- 14657. 31L PARKED ON CITY RIGHT-OF-WAY'S. A FINE OF $50 AND ADMIN FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 WHICH IS A TOTAL DUE OF $78. AND I DO HAVE PHOTOS TO DEPICT THE VIOLATION AS I WITNESSED IT. >> MS. KIRKLAND HANDED UP EXHIBIT 1A THERE B WHICH SHOWS THE VEHICLE AND ITS LICENSE PLATE, EXHIBIT 1C TO D AND ALSO THE VEHICLE AND PARKING AND NOTICE OF THE VIOLATION AND EXHIBIT E THROUGH F, THE FRONT OF THE VEHICLE. AT THIS TIME, THE CITY WOULD MOVE INTO EVIDENCE THE CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE . >> PHOTOGRAPHS WILL BE ENTERED AS THE CITY COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE. BASED ON THE PHOTOGRAPHS AND THE TESTIMONY, I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS IN THAT A FINE OF A $50 AND A NEW MINISTER TO FEE OF $10 AND A LATE FEE OF $18 FOR A TOTAL OF $70 IS DUE AND PAYABLE IN 14 DAYS OR IT WILL TO THE COUNTY [A. PK2024-77 100 Melody Lane Carol Edwards Charmaine Kirkland] COURT SYSTEM AND THERE IS A 30 DAY RIGHT TO APPEAL. >> THANK YOU. THE LAST CASE TODAY IS AN OLD BUSINESS. CASE NUMBER PK20 24- 77, 100 MELODY LANE, CAROL EDWARDS . >> THIS IS THE CITY'S MOTION TO VACATE THE ORDER DETERMINING VIOLATION AND NOTICE OF FINES AND COSTS DATED OCTOBER 16TH OF THIS YEAR. >> THE CASE WILL BE VACATED BASED ON THE CITY'S RECOMMENDATION. >> THANK YOU . >> I'M GOING TO GO OVER THE [B. IDENTIFICATION OF CASES IN COMPLIANCE OR RESCHEDULED] IDENTIFICATION OF CASES AND COMPLIANCE ARE RESCHEDULED. CASE NUMBER PK20 24- 89, NAY FOR PARK, LATRENA LASHAY ADAMSON. CASE NUMBER 21-04 24- 1309 NORTH 19TH STREET, GRIET LLC, LOT CLEARING CASE 223 INDIAN HILLS DRIVE. CASE 20 24- 193, 223 INDIAN HILLS DRIVE. CASE 20 24- 195- , 2112 SOUTH THIRD STREET. PK20 24- 78, 100 MARINO WAY, ALBERT THOMAS KIRBY THE THIRD. >> LOT CLEARING CASE 20 24- 188. 1908 COCONUT DRIVE. >> FOR CASES REQUIRING A HEARING FOR STATE STATUTE 162.12, NOTICE OF HEARING WAS SENT TO THE VIOLATORS CERTIFIED MAIL. OF THE GREEN CARD IS RETURNED SIGNED, IT IS PLACED IN THE FILE. OF THE GREEN CARD IS RETURNED UNSIGNED OR UNCLAIMED, AN AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING WITH A NOTICE OF HEARING IS SENT TO THE BUYER [00:25:01] LATER, REGULAR U.S. MAIL. 10 DAYS PRIOR TO THE HEARING, A NOTICE OF HEARING IS POSTED ON THE BULLETIN BOARD AT CITY HALL. A NOTICE OF HEARING IS ALSO POSTED AT THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION WITH AN AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING. IF THE GREEN CARD IS NOT RETURNED TO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT DEPARTMENT WITHIN 10 DAYS BEFORE THE HEARING, THE POSTING IS COMPLETED IN THE SAME MANNER AS IF THE CARD WAS RETURNED UNCLAIMED. FOR CASES NOT MANDATED BY STATE STATUTE, MAILING OF THE NOTICE OF HEARING ARE HANDLED IN THE SAME MANNER AS STATED PRIOR. IF THE GREEN CARD IS RETURNED UNSIGNED, UNCLAIMED OR NOT RETURNED WITHIN 10 DAYS OF THE HEARING, A NOTICE OF HEARING IS POSTED ON THE BULLETIN BOARD AT CITY HALL. >> THANK YOU. >> IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE? >> NO. * This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.