Jan 08, 2020 Special Magistrate Hearing

[1. CALL TO ORDER]

[00:00:07]

THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE HEARING IS NOW CALLED TO ORDER. I AM A SPECIAL MAGISTRATE AND JUST TO REMIND YOU THAT THE PROCEEDINGS TODAY ARE RECORDED AND TELEVISED.

IF WE COULD ALL RISE FOR THE PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE. >> I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT STANDS, ONE NATION UNDER GOD INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL.

>> THANK YOU. IF THE CITY'S OFFICERS COULD BE SWORN AT THIS TIME.

[A. ADMINISTRATION OF OATH TO DEPARTMENTAL WITNESSES]

[SWORN] >> AND IF YOU COULD READ IN THE CASES THAT ARE IN COMPLIANCE OR

[B. IDENTIFICATION OF CASES IN COMPLIANCE OR RESCHEDULED]

RESCHEDULE? >> THE PARKING CITATIONS FOR A CASE 19 2614 RILEY CASE 19 2722 ARMENTA AND CASE G 19 2755 JERNIGAN ARE ALL PAID. WE HAVE PULLED 5C, 1929 811 BEACH CT. 5D IS IN COMPLIANCE, 1920 JULY 25, 2018 100 OLEANDER AVENUE 5G IS IN COMPLIANCE, CASE 19 2714 2102 GULF VIEW CT. .

5J CASE 19 1887, 115 ROSELYN AVENUE IS IN COMPLIANCE. AND 5K, CASE 19 2746, 3101

OLEANDER AVENUE BAY TUBE HAS BEEN PULLED. >> AS WELL AS I AND L. ALSO CASE FIVE I CASE 19 0360 Ã606 AZALEA AVENUE HAS BEEN PULLED, AND CASE 19 2747, 3101 OLEANDER

AVENUE BAY THREE HAS BEEN PULLED >> AND ALSO Ã

>> OKAY 19 2748, 3101 OLEANDER AVENUE BAY FOR AND WHAT ABOUT FIVE?>> NO.

FIVE WAS GIVEN NOTICE. THE NOTICE WAS GOOD. >> OKAY.

FIVE HAS BEEN PULLED ALSO. >> OKAY. >> THE FIRST CASE IS FORESEE,

[C. 19-2178 PK Orange Ave/IRD lot Render, Dontallis Lorenzo John Futch]

192178 ORANGE AVENUE, INDIAN RIVER DOCTOR LOT RENDER >> MAN PROCEED WITH QUESTIONING? THANK YOU.OOD MORNING, OFFICER FLETCHER.

I BELIEVE YOU WERE SWORN PREVIOUSLY, CORRECT >> RIGHT

>> AND CAN YOU STATE WHAT IS YOUR TITLE? >> I AM PARKING SPECIALIST CODE

ENFORCEMENT >> OKAY. AND DID YOU WRITE THE PARKING

CITATION IN CONNECTION WITH CASE NUMBER 19 Ã2178? >> YES.

>> WHAT DATE DID YOU ISSUE THAT CITATION?> IT WAS ISSUED ON OCTOBER 16.

>> 2019? >> YES. >> DID YOU ISSUE THAT WITHIN

THE CITY LIMITS OF FORT PIERCE? >> YES.> WHAT WAS THE NATURE OF THE VIOLATION YOU OBSERVE?

>> TWO HOUR PARKING. >> DID YOU OBSERVE THE VEHICLE RETURNED TWO HOURS LATER AND

OBSERVED THAT THE VEHICLE HAD NOT BEEN MET? >> YES, I DID.

>> DID YOU TAKE ANY PHOTOGRAPHS THAT THEY COMMIT >> YES

>> DID A FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT HE SAW >> YES

>> OTHER TIMESTAMPS >> YES >> AT THIS TIME THE CITY WOULD

[00:05:05]

>> COMPOSITE ONE IS ENTERED AS EXHIBIT 1 FOR THE CITY. >> THANK YOU, MA'AM.

IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE THAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO SAY REGARDING THE EXHIBITS OR REGARDING YOUR

OBSERVATIONS ON THAT DATE? >> NO, MA'AM. >> NO FURTHER QUESTIONS.

>> OKAY. ANYTHING ELSE?> NO, MA'AM. >> OKAY.

I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION DOES EXIST BASED ON THE EVIDENCE PRESENTED AND THAT THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE OF $78 AS INDICATED AND FAILURE TO PAY SUCH FINE WILL RESULT IN

THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. >> FOR CLARIFICATION, IS IT 30

DAYS TO PAY? >> YES > THANK YOU. >> THE NEXT CASE IS FOR D, 19

[D. 19-9046 PK Orange Ave/IRD lot Render, Dontallis Lorenzo John Futch]

9046 LOT RENDER. >> MAN PROCEED? >> DID YOU ISSUE THE CITATION

IN CASE NUMBER 19 Ã9046? >> YES, I JUST COULDN'T >> WHAT DATE

>> OCTOBER 7, 2008 HE APPEARED >> AND DID YOU ISSUE THAT WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS OF FORT

PIERCE? >> YES, I DID. >> WHAT WAS THE NATURE OF THE

VIOLATION YOU OBSERVE? >> IT WAS A TWO HOUR PARKING VIOLATION.

>> DID YOU OBSERVE THE VEHICLE RETURNED TWO HOURS LATER AND OBSERVED THAT THE VEHICLE HAD

NOT BEEN MET? >> YES, I DID. >> DID YOU TAKE ANY PHOTOGRAPHS

THAT THEY COMMIT >> YES, I DID >> DID A FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY

DEPICT WHAT IS DOCUMENT >> YES >> AND OTHERS WOULD ARREST

TIMESTAMPS? YES, THEY ARE. >> RUNS TIMESTAMPS ACCURATE?

>> YES. >> AT THIS TIME, THE CITY WOULD MOVE THE PHOTOGRAPHS IN CITY'S COMPOSITE 1 AND ALSO NOTE FOR THE RECORD AS TO THIS CASE THAT THERE IS NO RESPONDENT PRESENT.

>> THE PHOTOS ARE ENTERED AS CITIES EHIBIT 1. >> IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU

WOULD LIKE TO SAY? >> NO, MA'AM. >> I HAVE NOTHING FURTHER.

>> OKAY. I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS IN THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE OF $70 AS INDICATED AND FAILURE TO BE DEFINED WITHIN 30 DAYS WILL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.

[E. 19-2662 212 N 2nd St Gibson, Jacquelyn Marie John Futch]

NEXT IS FORKY, 1926 TO 12 NORTH 2ND ST. GIBSON. >> OFFICER FLETCHER DID YOU

READ DISSERTATION IN CONNECTION WITH 19 Ã2662? >> YES, I DID, WHAT DATE DID

YOU ISSUE THAT CITATION? >> OCTOBER 9, 2019 >> DID YOU ISSUE THAT WITHIN

THE CITY LIMITS OF FORT PIERCE, YES I DID >> WHAT WAS THE NATURE OF THE

VIOLATION >> IT WAS A TWO HOUR PARKING VILLAGE

>> DID YOU OBSERVE THE VEHICLE RETURNED TWO HOURS LATER >> YES I DID

>> DID YOU TAKE ANY PHOTOGRAPHS A DAY? YES I DO

>> DO THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW? >> YES THEY DO

>> DID YOU OBSERVE WHETHER OR NOT THE TIMESTAMPS ON THE PHOTOGRAPHS WERE ACCURATE?

>> YES, THEY ARE PURE >> SO AT THIS TIME THE CITY WOULD WITH THE PHOTOGRAPHS AND AS THE CITY'S COMPOSITE EXHIBIT NUMBER ONE AND I WENT UP THERE DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE

RESPONDENT PRESENT THIS MONEY. >> OKAY. >> IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU

WANT TO SAY THAT THE PHOTOGRAPHS COMMIT >> NO, MATTHEW

>> ARE NOTHING FURTHER. >> THE PHOTOS SUBMITTED WILL BE ENTERED AS EXHIBIT 1 FOR THE

CITY. >> THANK YOU. I'VE NOTHING FURTHER.

>> I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THAT THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE OF $70. AND THE FAILURE TO PAY DEFINED WITHIN 30 DAYS WILL RESULT IN CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. NEXT IS FOR F CASE 192731

[F. 19-2731 PK Atlantic Ave Williams, Everton Dennis John Futch]

ATLANTIC AVENUE. WILLIAMS. >> DID YOU WRITE THE CITATION

IN CONNECTION WITH CASE NUMBER 90 Ã2731? >> YES, I DID.

>> WHAT DID YOU READ THAT CITATION? >> OCTOBER 17, 2090.

>> DID YOU READ THAT WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS OF FORT PIERCE? >> YES, I DID.

>> WHAT WAS THE NATURE OF THE VIOLATION YOU OBSERVE? >> THE VEHICLE WAS PARKED IN

THE WRONG DIRECTION. >> OKAY. DID YOU PERSONALLY OBSERVE THE

VEHICLE? >> YES >> DID YOU TAKE PHOTOGRAPHS

COMMIT >> YES, I DID. >> OKAY.

THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT IS DOCUMENT >> YES

>> IS MORE THAN ONE PHOTOGRAPH? >> YES. >> OKAY.

AT THIS TIME THE CITY WOULD MOVE THE PHOTOGRAPHS AND AS CITIES COMPOSITE ONE AND ONE OF

THE REGULAR DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE RESPONDENT PRESENT. >> IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO SAY ABOUT THE PHOTOGRAPHS WHILE I WILL WAIT TO SEE IF THEY CAN ABET IT

FIRST. I APOLOGIZE. >> YES.

THE PHOTOS WILL BE ENTERED AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1 FOR THE CITY.

[00:10:02]

>> THANK YOU, MA'AM. IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO SAY ABOUT THE PHOTOGRAPHS?

>> NO, MA'AM. >> I HAVE NOTHING FURTHER, MA'AM.

>> OKAY. I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS THAT THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE OF $78, AND FAILURE TO PAY SAID AMOUNT WITHIN 30 DAYS WILL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.

[H. 19-2756 PK Atlantic Avenue Danita, Forman Paige John Futch]

>> FOR H CASE 19 2756, ATLANTIC AVENUE, DENITA. >> OFFICER MACK, DID YOU READ

THE CITATION IN CONNECTION WITH CASE NUMBER 19 Ã2756? >> YES, DID YOU

>> WHAT DID YOU LIKE THAT CITATION? >> OCTOBER 17, 2019.

>> THREE WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS OF FORT PIERCE? YES, I WAS PERPLEXED WHAT WAS

THE NATURE OF THE VIOLATION YOU OBSERVE? >> IT WAS A TWO HOUR PARKING

COLLISION >> DID YOU OBSERVE THE VEHICLE RETURNED AND THAT IT HAD NOT

BEEN MET? YES, I DID. >> DID YOU TAKE ANY PHOTOGRAPHS

>> YES I DID >> DO THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT IS

DOCUMENT >> YES THEY DO. RATHER TIMESTAMPS?

>> YES, MA'AM. >> ARE THE TIMESTAMPS ACCURATE? >> YES, MA'AM.

>> OF THE CITY WOULD MOVE THE PHOTOGRAPHS AS CITIES COMPOSITE 1 ON NOTE OF RECORD THERE DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE A RESPONDENT PRESENT. I WANTED FOR THE RECORD THERE DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE A RESPONDENT PRESENT THIS MORNING.

>> THE PHOTOS PRESENTED AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT ONE OF WILL BE ENTERED AS ÃON BEHALF OF

THE CITY. >> THANK YOU. IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT

TO SAY ABOUT THIS CASE? >> NO, MA'AM. >> THANK YOU.

NOTHING FURTHER ON THIS CASE. >> OKAY. I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THAT THE VIOLATOR BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE OF $78 AND FAILURE TO PAY THIS AMOUNT WITHIN 30 DAYS WILL RESULT IN THE CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM.

>> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, WE HAVE A LATE ENTITY WHO JUST WALKED IN.

IT IS CASE FOR F THAT YOU JUST ROLLED ON TO HAVE ANY PROBLEM REOPENING THAT MATTER?

>> NO, I DON'T. >> WE ARE GOING TO CALL CASE 192731 ATLANTIC AVENUE,

WILLIAMS. >> YOU CAN COME FORWARD. YOU CAN COME UP TO THE

MICROPHONE. >> GOOD MORNING, SIR. I WILL HAVE THE CLERKS WHERE

YOU END. [SWORN] >> WE WILL START FROM THE BEGINNING. OKAY AT THIS TIME I WILL INQUIRE AGAIN OF OFFICER FUTCH.

DID YOU ISSUE THE CITATION IN CONNECTION WITH CASE NUMBER 19 Ã2731?

>> YES I DID >> WHAT DATE DID YOU ISSUE THAT CITATION

>> OCTOBER 17, 2019. >> DID YOU ISSUE THE CITATION IN THE CITY OF FORT PIERCE?>

YES, I DID. >> AND WHAT WAS THE NATURE OF THE VIOLATION THAT YOU OBSERVE?

>> PARKING IN THE WRONG DIRECTION >> CAN YOU DESCRIBE HOW THE VEHICLE WAS PARKED IN WHICH WAY IT WAS FACING AND WHY IT WAS IN THE WRONG DIRECTION?

>> WAS FACING ÃIT WAS FACING ALL OF THE CARS PARKED IN THE CORRECT DIRECTION AND THE PICTURES DEPICT THAT ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE ROAD. THEY ARE FACING ÃIT'S FACING

THE SAME AS THE CARS ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE ROAD. >> SO DO THE PICTURES FAIRLY

AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW THE DEAD? >> ABSOLUTELY

>> ARE YOU THE ONE THAT TOOK THE PHOTOGRAPHS? >> YES, MA'AM.

>> SO THE PHOTOGRAPHS WERE PREVIOUSLY ADMITTED ON GOING TO ASK YOU, THEY BE ADMITTED INTO

EVIDENCE AS TO THESE COMPOSITE ONE. >> YESTERDAY PHOTOS SUBMITTED PREVIOUSLY WILL AGAIN BE READMITTED AS EXHIBIT 1 FOR THE CITY.

>> THANK YOU, MA'AM. I APOLOGIZE FOR INTERRUPTING. I JUST KNOW THE PHOTOGRAPHS ARE UP ON THE SCREEN RIGHT NOW SO THAT MR. WILLIAMS CAN VIEW THEM.

IS THERE ANYTHING THAT YOU WANT TO SAY WITH REGARD TO THE PHOTOGRAPHS THAT ARE UP ON THE

SCREEN RIGHT NOW?> NO. I THINK IT'S PRETTY OBVIOUS. >> OKAY.

I DON'T HAVE ANY FURTHER QUESTIONS. >> I DIDN'T KNOW I WAS GOING TO GET A TICKET. I HAVE NEVER BEEN TO COURT HERE SO I DON'T KNOW HOW TO PARK I

JUST SAW AN EMPTY SPACE >> YOU UNDERSTAND WHY THE CITATION WAS ISSUED FOR BECAUSE

[00:15:08]

YOU PARTS ÃIF YOU SEE IN THE PICTURES YOU ARE PARKED >> YES.

YES, I SEE IT. NEXT TIME I WILL KNOW WHAT TO DO.

>> OKAY. DOES THE CITY ATTORNEY HAVE ANYTHING?

>> NO, MA'AM. >> I DON'T THINK ÃI FIND YOU DID PARKED IN THE WRONG

DIRECTION SO THE TICKET WAS ISSUED CORRECTLY. >> THE TISSUE TICKET WAS ISSUED. I TELL YOU THE TRUTH, I DON'T REMEMBER EVERYTHING BECAUSE I WAS GOING THROUGH SOME STRESS. MY GRANDMOTHER DIED SO I DIDN'T REMEMBER ANYTHING.

I THINK IT WAS ABOUT $50. I DIDN'T REMEMBER IT. >> DO YOU NEED MORE TIME TO PAY

IT? >> I CAN PAY AT LEAST BEFORE THIS WEEKEND

>> SO 30 DAYS IS ENOUGH TO PAY >> YES, MA'AM. >> OKAY.

THE TOTAL DUE BECAUSE THERE IS A LATE FEE IS $78. AND YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO PAY IT

>> OKAY, MA'AM. THANK YOU SO MUCH >> THANK YOU FOR COMING IN.

>> OKAY.> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE WE HAD ANOTHER LATE ATTENDEE. IT WAS ITEM NUMBER E, GIBSON.

>> OKAY. WE WILL CALL THIS CASE OVER. CASE 19 2662 212 NORTH 2ND ST.

GIBSON. >> PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE

RECORD. [SWORN] >> MAY HAVE PRECEDED THIS TIME? THANK YOU, MA'AM. GOOD MORNING, OFFICER FUTCH. DID YOU READ THE CITATION IN

CONNECTION WITH CASE NUMBER 19 Ã2662? >> YES, I DID.

>> WHAT DATE DID YOU ISSUE THAT CITATION? >> OCTOBER 9, 2019.

>> WERE YOU WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS OF FORT PIERCE? >> YES, I WAS.

>> CAN YOU TELL US THE NATURE OF THE VIOLATION YOU OBSERVE? >> IT WAS A TWO HOUR PARKING

PVIOLATION OF HER >> DID YOU OBSERVE THE VEHICLE RETURNED TWO HOURS ÃMORE THAN TWO HOURS LATER AND OBSERVED THAT THE VEHICLE HAD NOT BEEN MOVED?

>> YES, I DID. >> DID YOU TAKE ANY PHOTOGRAPHS THAT DAY?

>> YES I DID >> DO THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT IS OFTEN

A >> YES >> DO THE PHOTOGRAPHS HAVE

TIMESTAMPS ON THEM? >> YES, THEY DO. >> BROTHERS TIMESTAMPS

ACCURATE? >> ABSOLUTELY. >> OKAY SO AT THIS TIME THE CITY WOULD MOVE TO READMITTED THE PHOTOGRAPHS AS CITIES COMPOSITE 1.

>> ALL RIGHT. THE PHOTOS WILL BE READMITTED AS THE CITY'S EXHIBIT 1. YOU

CAN SEE THEM UP ON THE SCREEN. >> AND IS THERE ANYTHING YOU WANT TO SAY WITH REGARD TO THE

PHOTOGRAPHS? >> NO, MA'AM. >> I DON'T HAVE ANY FURTHER

QUESTIONS. >> DO YOU WANT TO SPEAK TO WHAT ÃDO YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS?

>> I WAS IN MY VISOR AND I TOTALLY FORGOT ABOUT IT. I HAVE THE MONEY TO PAY IT

TODAY. >> OKAY. YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO PAY IT SO IF YOU CAN GIVE HER SOMETHING TO PAY TODAY. THEN THANK YOU FOR COMING IN.

>> I APOLOGIZE. I WAS STUCK AT THE OTHER COURTHOUSE.

>> NOT A GOOD DAY. >> I LIVE IN VERO SO I COULD CLOSE.

>> YOU ARE FINE. ISAAC WILL HELP YOU. THANK YOU.

[I. 19-2767 PK 218 N 2nd Street Stubley, Adam Lee John Futch]

>> OKAY WE HAVE ONE MORE CITATION CASE BEFORE I 1927 TO 18 NORTH 2ND ST., STUBLEY

THROUGH >> OFFICER FUTCH DID YOU WRITE THIS CITATION IN CASE 2767

>> YES >> WHAT DATE DID YOU ISSUE THAT > OCTOBER 21, 2019

>> WERE YOU WITHIN THE CITY LIMITS OF FORT PIERCE? >> YES I WAS

>> WHAT WAS THE NATURE OF THE VIOLATION AFTER >> IT WAS A TWO HOUR PARKING

VIOLATION >> FOR YOU TO OBSERVE THE VEHICLE RETURNED MORE THAN TWO

HOURS LATER AND OBSERVED THAT THE VEHICLE HAD A MOVE >> YES

>> DID YOU TAKE ANY PHOTOGRAPHS THAT THE >> YES I DO

>> TODAY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW? >> YES, THEY DO.

>> OTHER TIMESTAMPS ON THE PROGRESS >> YES THERE ARE.

>> ARE THIS ACCURATE? >> YES. >> OKAY.

AT THIS TIME THE CITY WOULD MOVE THE PHOTOGRAPHS IN CITIES COMPOSITE ONE THAT I WILL NOTE THAT THERE DOES NOT APPEAR TO BE A RESPONDENT PRESENT THIS MORNING.

. >> THANK YOU. >> PHOTOGRAPHS PRESENTED WILL

BE ATTENDED AS CITIES EXHIBIT COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1. >> THANK YOU, MAC.

[00:20:10]

IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO SAY ABOUT THIS CASE? >> NO, MA'AM.

>> I HAVE NOTHING FURTHER, MA'AM. >> OKAY.

I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THAT THE VIOLATOR WILL BE ASSESSED THE TOTAL DUE OF $78 AND FAILURE TO PAY SUCH FINE WILL RESULT ÃWITHIN 30 DAYS WILL RESULT IN THE

CITATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE COUNTY COURT SYSTEM. >> WE HAVE 58 CASE 19 2935 508

[A. 19-2935 CE 508 Means Court Dunbar, Joseph Dunbar, Micheal Heather Debevec]

MEANS COURT. DUNBAR. >> THANK YOU.

PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE RECORD.

[SWORN] >> GOOD MORNING. HEATHER DEBEVEC CITY OF FORT PIERCE CODE ENFORCEMENT CASE NUMBER 19 293-5508 MEANS COURT OWNED BY JOSEPH AND MICHAEL DUNBAR. CASE WAS INITIATED ON NOVEMBER 5 OF 2019 SECTIONS 1646, 1647, 1648 SUBSECTION 4. PARKING ON OTHER THAN PAVEMENT REQUESTING THAT VEHICLES NEED TO PARK IN THE DRIVEWAY TO THE SIDE OR THE REAR OF THE HOME. HE CITY IS REQUESTING THAT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS THE VIOLATION OF THE FILE COMPLY OR FIND THE $50 FOR THE ABSS. I DID NOT HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH PLEASE POST THIS MORNING AS I WAS SPEAKING WITH SOMEBODY ELSE SO I WOULD LIKE TO ASK IF THEY WOULD LIKE TO REVIEW THE PHOTOS THAT I HAVE BEFORE I SUBMIT THEM. AND SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I BELIEVE PEGGY CLICKS THROUGH THE PHOTOS YOU WILL SEE THEY HAVE START ADDED SOME PAPERS TO TRY AND RECTIFY THE PROBLEM AS YOU CAN SEE BY THE LAST PHOTO HERE.

BUT BEFORE WE TALK ANYMORE ABOUT THE PHOTOS, I JUST WANTS TO FORMULATE MOVE AND AS CITIES

BECAUSE IT WILL. >> TODAY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW?

>> YES, MA'AM. I WILL ADMIT THE PHOTOS AS CITIES EXHIBIT 1.

>> AND FOR THE RECORD, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, ON THE AGENDA ITEM, IT DOES HAVE 2015 NATIONAL CODE BUT THE CITY HAS PULLED THAT ONE. WE ARE NOT MOVING FORWARD WITH

THAT ONE. >> OKAY. THANK YOU.

>> OKAY. WOULD YOU LIKE TO MAKE A STATEMENT?

>> WHAT ARE WE HERE FOR TODAY? IS WE ARE WHAT ARE WE EXACTLY HERE FOR

>> THE VEHICLES, THE LIGHTS Ã >> VEHICLES THAT ARE PARKED IN THE FRONT YARD.

>> IN THE FRONT YARD. >> YOUR HONOR, WE WAS TOLD BY THE POLICE DEPARTMENT NEXTAR THAT IF WE PUT OUR VEHICLES OR EVEN MY GUESTS PUT THEIR VEHICLES ON THE ROAD THERE'S A DANGER TO THEIR HEALTH. THAT'S THE ONLY REASON WHY THE VEHICLES WERE ON THE GRASS.

ALL MY GUESTS HAVE TO PUT THEIR VEHICLES IN THE YARD. AND WE HAVE TALKED TO THEM ABOUT IT, I CAN'T FIGHT THE POLICE AND I CAN'T FIGHT TO SUPERPOWERS.

FIRST OF ALL IT'S THE CITY IN THAT SOCIETY. SO SOMEBODY HAS TO COME TO A CONCLUSION SO I CAN PUT MY Ã EITHER LET MY GUESTS PART ON THE THING BECAUSE I HAVE KIDS.COM, I HAVE A LOT OF FAMILY. AND HE WILL PARK ON THE STREET, BUT FOR THE POLICE SAFETY I PUT THEM ON THE GRASS. IF YOU THINK I WANT MY GRASS DEAD? I PUT GRASS THERE WHEN I CAME HERE.

I DON'T WANT NONE OF THAT BUT I HAVE TO THINK ABOUT THE OFFICER'S SAFETY.

WHEN THEY COME OUT WHEN THEY HAVE EMERGENCIES THEY HAVE TO COME OUT THROUGH MY EXIT AND THEN THEY COME OUT AND THEY CAN RUN RIGHT INTO A CAR. THEY KNOCKED ON THE DOOR AND THEY SPOKE WITH MY WIFE. AND I WILL LET HER TELL YOU HER SIDE.

>> HE SAID FOR EMERGENCY PURPOSES WHEN THEY COME OUT BECAUSE THEIR GATE IS LITERALLY MAYBE THREE OR FIVE FEET MORE FROM WHERE THE CARS ARE AND THEY WHIPPED THIS WAY AND WITH THAT WAY AND WHEN THEY HAVE AN EMERGENCY THEY HAVE ALMOST HIT ONE OF OUR VEHICLES.

[00:25:01]

FAST. >> SHE IS CORRECT. IT'S NEXT TO THE SUBSTATION AND I DO HAVE AN EXIT THAT IS ADJACENT TO THE DRIVEWAY. SHE IS CORRECT ON THAT.

>> OKAY. SO BUT THE VIOLATION IS THE THEY ARE IN THE GRASS AS

OPPOSED TO ON THE PAVEMENT? >> YES, MA'AM. BECAUSE THE ORDINANCE IS THAT THEY NEED TO BE EITHER PARKED IN A DRIVEWAY IN A TIGHT SPACE OR TO THE SIDE OR REAR OF THE HOME, WHICH AS I STATED, THERE APPEARED TO BE ATTEMPTING TO CORRECT THIS BY ADDING THE PAVERS TO EXTEND THEIR DRIVEWAY A LITTLE BIT, WHICH MAY SOLVE SOME OF THE PROBLEM.

>> AND IF I CAN JUST ÃTHERE APPEARS TO BE ADDITIONAL SPACE HERE TO PARK THESE TWO VEHICLES. THEY WOULD JUST NEED TO BE TOO DEEP.

AND IT LOOKS LIKE THERE IS AMPLE ROOM IN THE DRIVEWAY TO PARK THEIR VEHICLES IN THE DRIVEWAY. IT WOULD REQUIRE SHUFFLING TO MOVE THEM, BUT IT DOES APPEAR THAT THERE IS ROOM IN THE DRIVEWAY TO PARK TWO VEHICLES DEEP.

>> EXCUSE ME. MY GUESTS I STILL AM GOING TO END UP IN THE GRASS.

I HAVE PEOPLE THAT COME TO MY HOUSE TO VISIT. THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYING.

RIGHT NOW IT APPEARS THAT WAY BUT I STILL HAVE GUESTS THAT COME THROUGHOUT THE DAY.

I HAVE DAUGHTERS, HIS SONS, I HAVE 11 KIDS. SO ALL OF THEM COME TO MY HOUSE. THEY VISIT THEIR FATHER. I AM JUST LETTING YOU KNOW.

EVEN IF YOU WANT ME OVER HERE AND THERE EVENTUALLY SOMEBODY IS GOING TO PARK ON THE GRASS AND EVENTUALLY YOU ARE GOING TO TRY TO FIND ME IT'S GOING TO BE THE SAME RESULT.

>> I AM GOING TO ASK THIS CASE BE CONTINUED AND I WILL DISCUSS THIS WITH THE POLICE DEPARTMENT BECAUSE IT'S NOT ILLEGAL TO PARK IN THE STREET BUT IT IS ILLEGAL TO PARK ON THE GRASS.

SO I AM GOING TO REQUEST THIS CASE BE CONTINUED SO I CAN >> OKAY.

WE ARE GOING TO CONTINUE IT Ã DOES HEATHER HAVE YOUR CONTACT INFORMATION?

>> EXCUSE ME. I STILL HAVE TO WORK EVERY DAY. SO DO YOU HAVE A SPECIAL DAY ON

SATURDAY OR SOMETHING IF I HAVE TO COME BACK HERE AT ANY TIME? >> I AM HOPING WE CAN RESOLVE THIS WITHOUT YOU COMING BACK. OKAY? IF YOU CAN MAKE SURE HEATHER HAS YOUR CONTACT INFORMATION AND WE WILL BE IN CONTACT WITH YOU AFTER I DISCUSSED THIS WITH

THE POLICE DEPARTMENT. >> ALL RIGHT. >> I UNDERSTAND YOU'RE GETTING CONFLICTING MESSAGES. SO WE NEED TO RESOLVE THAT SO YOU HAVE ONE CLEAR MESSAGE.

AND I BELIEVE THAT ONCE YOU GET THAT MESSAGE YOU WILL LISTEN Ã YOU WILL COMPLY WITH THAT

MESSAGE WHENEVER IT COMES TO BE.KAY? >> THAT'S THE ONLY THING WE ARE

HERE FOR. >> LET'S JUST MAKE SURE HEATHER HAS YOUR CONTACT INFORMATION

AND THEN WE WILL BE IN TOUCH. >> OKAY. WHAT ABOUT THE TEMPORARY LIGHT

>> JUST BE ADVISED 90 DAYS IS THE MAXIMUM FOR ANY TEMPORARY LIGHTING.

YOUR HALLOWEEN DECORATIONS YOU ARE REACHING THE END OF THAT TIME FRAME.

HALLOWEEN WAS OCTOBER 30 SO THEY ARE GOING TO HAVE TO BE DOWN THIS MONTH.

AND THEN YOUR CHRISTMAS DECORATIONS HAVE TO COME DOWN WITH THE 90 DAYS OF THOSE

GOING. >> SOME OF MY TEMPORARY LIGHTING WASN'T THERE FOR THE PDECORATION, IT WAS ALWAYS THER BECAUSE I USE IT AS A RELIGIOUS PURPOSES AS WELL AS IN MY

PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS. >> UNFORTUNATELY YOU CAN DO THAT BUT YOU NEED TO HAVE THEM PROPERLY INSTALLED PERMANENT LIGHTING YOU CAN'T USE THE TEMPORARY LICENSE BACK.

SO THERE'S NOTHING AGAINST THE LIGHTING IF IT'S DONE PROPERLY AND THERE'S PERMITS HOLIDAY LIKE RESTAURANT YOU THAT IS DONE CORRECTLY. THE TEMPORARY LIGHTING, THE CHRISTMAS LIGHTS THAT YOU BUY OR THE HALLOWEEN LIGHTS THAT YOU BUY THEY ARE NOT MADE TO WITHSTAND LONG-TERM USE OUTSIDE. AND SO THEY CANNOT BE USED MORE THAN 90 DAYS. IF YOU WISH TO HAVE OUTDOOR LIGHTING FOR SOMETHING LIKE THAT JUST HAVE IT DONE WITH THE PROMISE LIGHTING AND DONE CORRECTLY.

>> DO I NEED A PERMIT FOR THAT? >> I WOULD TALK TO THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT

>> I WOULD TALK TO THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT AND ASK THEM. RIGHT?

>> ALL RIGHT. >> THANK YOU, SIR. >> MAY I GET A PHONE NUMBER FOR ONE OF YOU, PLEASE? I THINK THAT'S FROM THE OTHER GENTLGENTLEMAN.

[B. 19-1592 CE 806 N 22nd Street Williams, Dan Heather Debevec]

>> THE NEXT CASE WE HAVE IS A 5B CASE 1915 928064 22ND ST. WILLIAMS.

>> GOOD MORNING. PLEASE PLACE YOUR RIGHT HAND IS TO ENABLE THE RECORD.

[SWORN] >> SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, HEATHER DEBEVEC CODE ENFORCEMENT THIS

[00:30:09]

IT WAS REQUESTED THAT HE OBTAIN A PERMIT FROM THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT AND PREPARE A PLACE OF THE TRIM ABOUT THE PORCH AND THE TOP NORTHWEST CORNER. THE CITY REQUEST IF THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 30 DAYS TO OBTAIN A PERMIT AND COMPLY WITH THE PERMIT CONDITIONS FOR A FINE OF $50 PER DAY BE ASSESSED.

I DID NOT HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SHARE PHOTOS WITH MR. WILLIAMS THIS MORNING SO I'D

LIKE TO GIVE HIM THAT OPTION NOW. >> HEATHER, I MUST'VE MISSED THIS DURING THE REVIEW. I DON'T BELIEVE THIS REPAIR REQUIRES A PERMIT.

I THINK IT'S MINOR ENOUGH IN A PERMIT WAS REQUIRED. BUT THE TRIM IN QUESTION Ã

>> THE TRIM NEEDS REPAIRED BUT I DON'T THINK IT REQUIRES A PERMIT.

WE WILL JUST PUT THOSE PHOTOS UP. >> DID YOU SWING BY THERE

MONDAY? >> AND WENT BY THERE ON TUESDAY.

>> HE DIDN'T SEE THE PAINTING DONE? >> PATRON STILL NEEDED TO BE DONE. BUT THE PAINTING HAD BEEN DONE AND ALL OF THE OTHER STUFF THAT WE HAD DISCUSSED PREVIOUSLY. THE PHOTOS START FROM WHEN THE CASE INITIATED AND THEN AS YOU GO THROUGH YOU WILL SEE THAT IT GOES UP TO WHERE I TOOK MY LAST PICTURE YESTERDAY.

>> JUST YESTERDAY SO YOU DID SEE SOME PROGRESS, RIGHT? >> SO IF YOU COULD JUST TAKE A LOOK AT THE PHOTOS, WE ARE GOING TO PUT THEM IN EVIDENCE AND THEN WE CAN TALK ABOUT IT.

>> OKAY [INDISCERNIBLE] >> I HAVE BEEN UNDER THE WEATHER.

>> WE WOULD DISCUSS THEM IN JUST A SECOND. >> WE HAVE TO ENSURE YOU HAVE A

CHANCE TO LOOK AT IT >> SO AT THIS TIME THE CITY WOULD MOVE THE PHOTOS AND AS CITIES COMPOSITEONE. TODAY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW?

>> YES >> THE PHOTOS ARE ADMITTED AS THE CITY'S EXHIBIT ONE.

HAVE YOU HAD A CHANCE TO LOOK AT THEM? >> AND THE PHOTOS ON THE SCREEN, JUST FOR THE RECORD IS DATED YESTERDAY 1/7/2020 AT 8:00 IN THE MORNING SO DOES ACTUALLY SHOW THE IMPROVEMENTS THAT THE GENTLEMAN HAS ALREADY NAMED AND THEN I'M GOING TO POINT OUT THE TWO SPOTS FOR YOU RIGHT HERE. SO WE ARE ABLE TO DOCUMENT OKAY. AND THAT LITTLE PIECE. THAT'S ALL WE HAVE LEFT

>> AND HE HAS 30 DAYS TO GET THAT DONE. >> WILL FIND THAT THE TREND IS STILL LEFT AND THEREFORE THE VIOLATIONS OF BUT THAT YOU HAVE 30 DAYS TO GET IT DONE BEFORE

IN FINE >> THANK YOU. BUT IF HE FAILS ÃARE YOU GOING

TO READ AN OFFICIAL ORDER? >> YES. ÃIT'S JUST THE TRIM ABOVE THE AND THE TOP NORTHWEST CORNER. I FIND A VIOLATION EXISTS THE VIOLATOR HAS 30 DAYS TO OBTAIN ÃTO PREPARE AND COMPLY OR A $50 A DAY FINE AND WILL START UNTIL 30 DAYS.

>> THANK YOU. YOU WILL GET SOMETHING IN THE MAIL BUT STAY IN TOUCH WITH

HEATHER. OKAY? >> B.

>> THANK YOU. >> WE HAVE CASE FIGHT THE CASE 1920 402207 DIXIELAND DOCTOR,

[E. 19-2402 CE 207 Dixieland Drive Castor, Natcha Heather Debevec]

CASTOR. >> PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE

RECORD. >> NATCHA CASTOR >> SIMON CASTOR [SWORN]

>> THANK YOU. >> THE CITY OF FT. PIERCE CODE ENFORCEMENT CASE NUMBER 19 Ã24 02207 DIXIELAND DOCTOR OWNED BY NATCHA CASTOR. CASE WAS INITIATED ON OCTOBER

[00:35:05]

SECTION 1646 1647, 1648, SUBSECTION FOR PARKING ON OTHER THAN PAVEMENT.

THE PARKING ON OTHER THAN PAVEMENT I DO REQUEST A REVIEW AND DETERMINATION ON.

SECTION 1646, 1647, 1648 SUBSECTION 1, SUBSECTION 5 FOR OUTSIDE STORAGE.

REQUESTING THE REPAIR THE FENCE IN THE FRONT WHERE IT IS SAGGING AND DISCONNECTED FROM THE POLLS. REMOVE OR REPLACE INTO A SHED THE SCRAPS THAT ARE BEHIND THE HOME, VARIOUS ITEMS. THE CITY REQUEST THAT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO COMPLY OR A FINE OF $50 PER DAY DSS TO SPEAK WITH SOMEONE LIKE YOU AND THEY DID HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO REVIEW THE PHOTOS.

>> ARCTIC IS FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT HE SAW? >> YES, MA'AM

>> SO I WOULD LIKE TO MOVE THE PHOTOS AND AS COMPOSITE EXHIBIT 1.

>> THE PHOTOS SUBMITTED ARE ADMITTED AS CITIES COMPOSITE AND YOU HAVE HAD A CHANCE TO

REVIEW THEM? >> I'M SORRY? >> YOU HAVE HAD A CHANCE TO

LOOK AT THESE? >> YES. >> OKAY.

DO YOU WANT TO TESTIFY AS TO Ã >> SOME OF THEM HAVE BEEN TAKEN CARE OF THAT DAY.

[INDISCERNIBLE] WE DID NOT HAVE A PLACE TO PUT THIS STUFF AND I OFFERED THEM TO PARK THERE AND PUT THIS STUFF IN HER VAN. [INDISCERNIBLE] FOR THE GARBAGE CAN WE DID NOT KNOW WE COULD NOT PUT THEM UNDER THE [INDISCERNIBLE] SO WHEN SHE SAID THAT WE PUT THEM IN THE BACK NOW [INDISCERNIBLE] I STILL NEED SOMEWHERE TO PUT THEM.

AND SHE TELLS ME TO PUT THEM IN A PLACE WHERE THEY CAN BE VIEWED FROM THE SHED AND WE ARE

IN THE ALLEY WAY TO DO THAT. >> THE VIOLATION STILL EXISTED LAST PHOTO Ã

>> WHAT HE IS REFERRING TO IS THE ORIGINAL VIOLATION INCLUDED A BOX TRUCK.

WHICH HE HAS REMOVED FROM THE PROPERTY. HE WAS ALSO REFERRING TO THE PLACEMENT OF THE GARBAGE CANS AND THE ORIGINAL VIOLATION AND ALL OF THAT HAD BEEN CORRECTED

>> THE PROBLEM WE STILL HAVE THE FENCE NEEDS TO BE REPAIRED, AND THERE IS STILL ITEMS IN THE BACK OF THE PROPERTY THAT NEEDED TO BE EITHER PUT INTO AN ENCLOSED TRAILER INTO A SHED INTO SOMETHING THAT CANNOT BE VIEWED BY THE NEIGHBORS OR FROM THE STREET.

>> WE WERE PLANNING ON EITHER TAKING THE WHOLE FRONT OUT, BUT WE HAVE LITTLE KIDS AND I'M SCARED TO DO THAT BECAUSE YOU HAVE CARS FLYING IN THE STREET AT UP TO 80 MILES AN HOUR.

SO CAN I HAVE 60 DAYS TO REDO THE WHOLE FRONT? BECAUSE RIGHT NOW I CAN'T DO

IT. [INDISCERNIBLE] >> DOES THE CITY Ã

>> STAFF IS ACCEPTABLE TO 60 DAYS TO REPAIR THE FENCE. HOW LONG WOULD YOU NEED TO FIND

SOMETHING Ã >> BACK, WE WILL TAKE CARE OF [INDISCERNIBLE]

>> WE WILL PUT THE TRASHCAN AWAY >> IS NOT THE TRASHCAN I'M

TALKING ABOUT THESE PILES ALL NEED TO BE REMOVED. >> THIS WILL BE TAKEN CARE OF RIGHT AWAY. THE FIRST ONE WE TOOK THEM OUT BUT THIS THING JUST CAME HOME WITH THEM AND I ALLOWED MY KIDS TO SCRUB THEM. I AM TEACHING THEM HOW TO WORK

[00:40:05]

>> CAN YOU DO THAT IN THE 10 DAYS THAT'S RECOMMENDED? >> YES, MA'AM.

>> OKAY. >> SO 10 DAYS FOR THAT. AND 60 DAYS FOR THE FENCE.

>> AND REVIEW AND DETERMINATION FOR THE PARKING. >> OKAY.

YES. THE PARKING IS SOMETHING THAT THE CITY IS GOING TO REVIEW?

>> SO SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, WITH REGARD TO THE PARKING, WE JUST ASK YOU TO FIND THAT A VIOLATION EXISTED BUT THA IT HAS BEEN CURED AND WE TYPICALLY ADVISE RESPONDENTS THAT IF THEY HAVE A REPEAT VIOLATION OF THE SAME NATURE THAT THEY COULD FACE INCREASED FINES.

>> DO YOU UNDERSTAND THAT? THE PARKING IS SOMETHING YOU HAVE CORRECTED, BUT IF YOU AT THIS TIME, BUT IT DID EXIST AND IF YOU HAVE A REPEAT VIOLATION, DEFINE WILL BE MORE.

>> SO SOMETIMES IF WE HAVE ÃDO WE HAVE TO HAVE A PERMIT IF WE WANT MORE PARKING LOT BECAUSE WE HAVE KIDS THAT ARE GOING TO HAVE CARDS SO SOMETIMES WE LIKE TO PARK THEM ON THIS SITE.

I DON'T KNOW HOW IT WORKS. DO WE HAVE TO HAVE A PERMIT? >> REMEMBER WE WERE OUT FRONT AND I EXPLAINED TO YOU AS LONG AS YOU ARE PAST THE CORNER OF YOUR HOUSE THAT WOULD BE THE SIDE SO ANYWHERE FROM THE CORNER OF YOUR HOUSE BACK IS THE SIDE OR THE REAR OF THE

HOME, YOU CAN PARK BACK THERE. >> OKAY. EVEN IF IT'S ON THE GRASS?

>> YES, MA'AM. THAT WOULD BE THE SIDE OR THE REAR OF THE HOME AND THAT IS

ACCEPTABLE. >> OKAY. >> I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THAT THE VIOLATORS WILL BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO REMOVE THE SCRAP PIECE ÃTHE VIOLATION NUMBER THREE WHERE THEY HAD REMOVED THE SCRAP PIECES FROM THE SIDE OF THE HOUSE, AND WITH REGARD TO DEFENSE YOU WILL HAVE 60 DAYS TO COMPLY WITH THAT. THE PARKING HAS BEEN CORRECTED, BUT AGAIN, IF YOU HAVE ANOTHER VIOLATION ÃYOU WILL BE FIND MORE.

AND IF YOU ARE NOT IN COMPLIANCE AFTER THIS 60 DAYS OR THE 10, IT ÃDEFINE WILL BE

$50 PER DAY. >> THANK YOU, SPECIAL MAGISTRATE.

AND STAY IN TOUCH WITH HEATHER. >> YES, I WILL. >> WE HAVE CASE 5F 1929-909102

[F. 19-2999 CE 102 Hialeah Avenue King, Larry & Vicky Heather Debevec]

HIALEAH AVENUE KING. >> PLEASE RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND AND STATE YOUR NAME FOR THE

RECORD. >> VICKI KANE >> K.

[SWORN] >> CODE ENFORCEMENT THIS IS CASE NUMBER 19 Ã2999.

102 HIALEAH AVENUE OWNED BY LARRY AND VICKI KING. THE CASE WAS INITIATED ON NOVEMBER 8, 2019. IT WAS FOR SECTION 22 Ã68 SUBSECTION ONE SUBSECTION 2 SUBSECTION B FOR COMMERCIAL VEHICLE. THAT WHEN I AM REQUESTING AN RMD ON. SECTION 15 Ã1.104.5 UNSAFE BUILDING FOR A COVERED WINDOW.

SECTION 1646, 1647, 1648, SUBSECTION 4, PARKING ON OTHER THAN PAVEMENT.

REQUESTING TO REMOVE THE SHUTTER FROM THE FRONT WINDOW. PARKED VEHICLES IN THE DRIVEWAY TO THE SIDE OR THE REAR OF THE HOME. THE CITY IS REQUESTING THAT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS VIOLATION EXISTS THE FATHER TO BE GIVEN 10 DAYS TO COMPLY REFINE A $50 PER DAY BSS. I DID NOT HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH THEM THIS MORNING. IF THEY WOULD LIKE TO REVIEW THE PHOTOS BEFORE WE SUBMIT THEM. MR. AND MRS. KING DO YOU WANT TO REVIEW THE PHOTOS BEFORE I TURN THEM IN? YES? NO?

>> ARE GOING TO PUT THEM ON THE SCREEN SO YOU CAN LOOK AT THEM ON THE SCREEN.

YOUR HONOR, I DID SPEAK WITH MR. KING A FEW DAYS AGO. AND HE DID SEE THAT THE REASON THAT THE SHUTTER WAS LEFT ON THE ONE WINDOW IS HE STATED IT WAS A BATHROOM AND HE WAS

[00:45:07]

>> IT'S STILL NOT CORRECTED? >> THE SHUTTER IS STILL THERE, BUT THAT YOUR DETERMINATION AT

THIS POINT. >> SO AT THIS TIME, WE WOULD MOVE THE PHOTOS AND AS COMPOSITE ONE. DO THEY FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT WHAT YOU SAW?

>> YES, MA'AM.OKAY. THE PHOTOS SUBMITTED BY THE CITY WILL BE ADMITTED AS CITIES

COMPOSITE 1. WOULD YOU LIKE TO SAY ANYTHING? >> THE PICTURES THAT I AM LOOKING AT IS NOT WHAT IS ACCURATE AT THIS TIME. BECAUSE WE STILL HAVE THE PARTS TRUCK ON THE GRASS AND THE TRUCKS IS NOT PARKED ON THE GRASS.THE SEMITRUCK IS NOT

THERE. >> AND THE SEMITRUCK WE ACTUALLY ÃI WILL MOVE FORWARD ON THE FOREST. WE CONFIRMED THAT THE SEMITRUCK IS GONE WITH ALL OF THESE PHOTOS COULD REJECT IT AGAIN THIS MORNING. THIS IS THIS MORNING AT 6:30 AND WHAT WE ARE DEALING WITH NOW IS PARKING ON THE GRASS AND YOU CAN SEE THE ONE VEHICLE HERE PARKED ON THE GRASS. OKAY? ANYONE SHUTTER ON THE LETTER.

THE COMMERCIAL VEHICLE IS FOR REVIEW AND DETERMINATION ONLY. THIS IS ACTUALLY 6:30 THIS

MORNING AND THERE IS STILL A VEHICLE PARKED ON THE GRASS. >> WE USE THAT AS THE DRIVEWAY.

>> I UNDERSTAND BUT THE RULE IS NO PARKING ON THE GRASS IN THE FRONT YARD.HEY WOULD NEED TO

MOVE THOSE VEHICLES INTO THE DRIVEWAY. >> DO YOU UNDERSTAND?

>> I DO. I UNDERSTAND, BUT, YOU KNOW, OUR YARD IS THE BEST JERK ON THAT STREET. AND SHE CAN TELL YOU THAT. THE BEST LOOKING YARD ON THE STREET. WELL MANICURED AND EVERYTHING. I HAVE PICTURES HERE FOR MY NEIGHBORS ACROSS THE STREET THEY ARE ON THE GRASS, HAVE MULTIPLE VEHICLES ON THE GRASS AND WE HAVE ONE AND WE COMPLIED WITH EVERYTHING BUT ONE VEHICLE WHEN THEY HAVE CARS ACROSS THEIR DRIVEWAY. I MEAN ACROSS THEIR YARD. BIG BOATS IN THEIR YARD, ON THE GRASS. AND NOTHING IS BEING SAID. THEY HAVE ALL OF THEIR SHUTTERS UP. AND IT'S BECAUSE OUR NEIGHBOR Ã THIS ONE NEIGHBOR BECAUSE OUR NEIGHBORS WANTED TO COME WITH US THIS MORNING AND I SAID NO. WE DON'T NEED A CIRCUS.

BUT IT'S JUST, WHEN NEIGHBOR, SHE FOUND THIS AVENUE BECAUSE SHE'S BEEN TELLING US WE AREN'T SUPPOSED TO BE RELIT BECAUSE OF OUR COLOR AND SHE CALLED THE POLICE AND THE POLICE TOLD HER SHE'S NOT ALLOWED TO CALL ANYMORE.SHE HAS BEEN TAKING MY MAIL OUT OF THE MAILBOX.

HE HAS BEEN HARASSING ME AND I HAVE BEEN THERE FOR NINE YEARS.

NOW, SHE HAS DONE FOUND THIS AVENUE AND SHE'S GOING TO KEEP JUST TRYING

>> SO SPECIAL MAGISTRATE, I AM GOING TO MAKE A RELEVANCE OBJECTION HERE.

PI THINK THE ISSUE IS WHETHER O NOT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND I THINK THAT'S WHERE WE SHOULD

FOCUS OUR ATTENTION THIS MORNING. >> OKAY.

IF OTHER NEIGHBORS HAVE VIOLATIONS, THAT'S NOT WHAT WE ARE HEARING TODAY.

JUST HEARING YOURS. SO IF YOU COULD JUST ADDRESS >> AND PLEASE NOTE IF IT HAS NOT ALREADY BEEN ADDRESSED, WE WILL ADDRESS IT IF THERE'S EXISTING VIOLATIONS ON THE

STREET >> WEEK SHOWED IT TO HER BUT SHE SAYS THAT'S NOT HER JOB.

THAT SOMEBODY IS >> WHAT I HAD SAID >> IS IT BELONGS TO WHATEVER

THE GUYS NAME >> WHAT I SAID IS CHAD HAD CASES ON THAT STREET HE IS

ALREADY WORKING ON IT. IT'S BEING >> NOBODY IS DOING ANYTHING.

>> AGAIN, >> WE WILL CORRECT WHAT WE HAVE TO CORRECT, BUT IT'S JUST ÃHE SAID HAS BEEN CORRECTED I DIDN'T LOOK THIS MORNING BECAUSE I'M FRUSTRATED.

AND I JUST AGGRAVATED WITH THE BECAUSE WE HAVE BEEN HARASSED EVER SINCE WE'VE BEEN AT THAT ADDRESS. AND I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU ALL ARE SAYING TO CORRECTED AND I KNOW ONE THING, IT WON'T BE THE LAST TIME I COME BEFORE YOU BECAUSE SHE IS GOING TO KEEP CALLING WHOEVER AND WE ARE GOING TO KEEP COMING. IF WE LEAVE SPIT ON THE GRASS WE ARE GOING TO BE BACK HERE. SHE DOESN'T WANT US THERE. AND SHE'S GOING TO KEEP TRYING TO FIND THINGS BUT THERE'S NOTHING WE CAN DO ABOUT THE WAY SHE FEELS ABOUT WE ARE NOT

SUPPOSED TO BE THERE. >> OKAY. ALL RIGHT.

>> BUT WHATEVER WE HAVE TO DO. I WILL SEE YOU AGAIN, I GUARANTEE YOU.

[00:50:05]

>> LET'S HOPE NOT.> SHE'S GOING TO KEEP CALLING. >> THE CITY IS ASKING FOR 10

DAYS. I DON'T SEE IT. >> YES.

I WILL DROP THIS DOWN. >> IS THAT SUFFICIENT? CAN YOU COMPLY AND 10 DAYS WITH

THOSE TWO THINGS? >> YES, MA'AM. >> I WILL FIND THAT THE SEMITRUCK VIOLATION HAS BEEN TAKEN CARE OF, THAT THE FRONT WINDOW AND THE PARKED VEHICLE AND THE GRASS WILL BE CORRECTED WITHIN 10 DAYS. AND IF NOT, A FINE OF $50 A DAY

WILL BE ASSESSED. >> YES, MA'AM. HAVE A BLESSED DAY.

>> THANK YOU MR. AND MRS. KING. >> OUR NEXT CASE IS 5H 1920 707-2106 GULF VIEW CT.

JBM PROPERTIES, LLC. >> CAN WE JUMP DOWN AND WE WILL COME BACK TO THAT ONE

>> WE HAVE CASE 1829 403606 S. OCEAN DOCTOR TARR TARR >> OKAY.

[A. 18-2943 Massey 606 S Ocean Drive Tarr, Steve Peggy Arraiz]

MR. TARR WANT TO PURCHASE THE PROPERTY MAKE SURE ALL THE CORRECTIONS WERE MADE TO THE VIOLATIONS. THE VIOLATIONS WERE INTERNATIONAL PROPERTY MAINTENANCE CODE 302.7 ACCESSORY STRUCTURES. 1646, 1647, 1648 ONE OF FIVE OUTSIDE STORAGE AND THREE INTERNATIONAL PROPERTY MAINTENANCE CODE 3 OF 4.2 FOR PROTECTIVE TREATMENT. SPECIAL MAGISTRATE ROSS FOUND PALM HAVEN OCEAN DEVELOPMENT LLC RESPONSIBLE FOR THE VIOLATIONS AND FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH RESULT IN A $50 A DAY FINE. ON APRIL 13, 2019 INSPECTION WAS MADE THE PROPERTY WAS NONCOMPLIANT AND THAT'S WHEN THE FINES BEGAN AND THE FINES WERE STOPPED ON SEPTEMBER 17, 2019 ONCE THE PROPERTY WAS BROUGHT INTO COMPLIANCE. MR. TARR HAS PUT A REQUEST IN FOR A REDUCTION. JUST A QUICK REVIEW OF THE CRITERIA PER ROLE I THINK IT'S 16 THE GRAVITY OF THE VIOLATION WAS MINOR. ANY ACTIONS TAKEN BY THE VIOLATOR TO CORRECT THE VIOLATIONS TO THE PROPERTY WAS SOLD THE NEW OWNER MADE THE CORRECTIONS TO COMPLY WITH THE VIOLATIONS AND NUMBER OF TIMES ABOUT HER WAS PREVIOUSLY FOUND IN VIOLATION WAS ZERO. SO IN MR. TARR'S REQUEST, LET ME JUST GO HERE.

AND MR. TARR IS HERE TODAY IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, BUT HE HAS OFFERED TO PAY WHAT WE HAVE ALREADY ESTABLISHED IS THE ADMINISTRATION CHARGES OF $1153.12 IN STOCK IS AGREEABLE TO THAT ACCEPTING THAT AS A SETTLEMENT FOR THE CASE.> OKAY.

MR. TARR, DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING YOU WOULD LIKE TO SAY? I AM FINE WITH THIS.

I WILL APPROVE THE AMOUNT OF $1153.12 IN SETTLEMENT OF THE MATTER.

PAYABLE ÃHOW MUCH TIME DO YOU THINK YOU NEED? >> 30 DAYS? OKAY. I WILL SAY 30 DAYS, OKAY? IF YOU CAN DO IT BEFORE THEN, THAT'S GREAT. ALL RIGHT. SO 30 DAYS TO PAY THE AMOUNT AND FULL OF $1153.12. THANK YOU. MR. TARR, YOU CAN, GET THIS.

IF YOU WANT TO GET THIS Ã FINANCE WON'T ACCEPT YOUR CHECK WITHOUT SOMETHING.

THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE WAITING TODAY. >> OKAY.

[H. 19-2707 CE 2106 Golfview Court JBM Properties LLC Heather Debevec]

[00:55:07]

>> HEATHER DEBEVEC CITY OF FT. PIERCE CODE ENFORCEMENT CASE NUMBER 19 Ã2707.

2106 GULF VIEW CT. OWNED BY JBM PROPERTIES, LLC. CASE WAS INITIATED ON OCTOBER 17, 2019. EXTERIOR STRUCTURE.304.1 PROTECTIVE TREATMENT, SECTION 16 25, SUBSECTION C RESPONSIBILITY FOR CONTAINERS. WE ARE REQUESTING THEY OBTAIN A PERMIT FROM THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT TO REPAIR AND REPLACE THE WEIGHT OVER THE CARPORT. PAINT THE HOME AND SHUTTERS AS MANY AREAS ARE PEELING AND FADING. STORE RECYCLED TRASH AND YARD BINS TO THE SIDE OR THE REAR OF THE HOME. THE CITY IS REQUESTING THAT SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FUNDS WILL USUALLY LIST THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 30 DAYS TO OBTAIN A PERMIT AND COMPLY WITH ALL CONDITIONS WERE FINE OF 50 DEALERS A DAY BE ASSESSED BY SPICE BUT WITH THE PROPERTY OWNER.E HAS BEEN DOING SOME WORK ON THE PROPERTY. HE WAS NOT ABLE TO BE HERE TODAY AS HE IS ON THE OPPOSITE SIDE OF THE COUNTRY. I DID EXPLAIN TO HIM THAT WE REQUEST THE 30 DAYS AND HE SAID THAT THAT WAS APPROPRIATE FOR HIM AND I DO HAVE PHOTOS SHOULD

YOU WISH >> SO I WOULD ASK IF THE PHOTOS FAIRLY AND ACCURATELY DEPICT

WHAT YOU SAW >> YES MEN >> AND I WOULD ESTIMATE THE

PHOTOS AND AS CITY'S COMPOSITE ONE. >> I WILL ADMIT THE PHOTOS

SUBMITTED BY THE CITY AS COMPOSITE CITY WERE NUMB. >> I FIND THAT THE VIOLATION EXISTS AND THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN 30 DAYS TO COMPLY OR A FINE OF $50 A DAY WILL BE

[N. 19-2750 CE 3101 Oleander Avenue - Bay 5 R Stein LLC Isaac Saucedo]

ASSESSED. >> THE LAST CASE IS 1927 503101 OLEANDER AVENUE BAY 5R STEIN

LLC. >> GOOD MORNING. I THINK THERE MIGHT BE A LITTLE BIT OF A CONFUSION. IT'S ACTUALLY BAY THREE. BAY THREE SIGNED THE HAND

DELIVERY. >> OKAY. >> BAY FIVE

>> WE WILL DO THIS ONE AND THEN GO BACK TO L. >> OKAY.

>> CAN YOU CLARIFY WHETHER WE HAVE SERVICE AS TO FIVE AND? >> NO.

>> WE DO NOT? >> NO. THEY DID NOT SIGN I WASN'T ABLE

TO GET HOLD OF ANYONE. >> LET ME JUST REVIEW THE CASES COULD WE HAVE 19 2746.

THAT IS BAY TO NUMB. WAS THERE SERVICE ON THE PROPERTY?

>> BAY 2 THAT'S THE ONE WHERE THEY APPLIED FOR THE BTR. >> SO WE PULLED THAT ONE FOR ACTIVE. 19 2747, WHICH IS 3101 OLEANDER AVENUE, BAY 3. DID THEY RECEIVE

NOTICE?> THEY DID. >> OKAY. 19 2748, 3101 OLEANDER AVENUE,

BAY 4 TODAY RECEIVED NOTICE? >> KNOW >> IS SO THAT ONE WAS PULLED

ALREADY. >> 19 2750 3101 OLEANDER AVENUE BAY 5 TODAY RECEIVED NOTICE

>> SO WE WILL BE PULLING THAT ONE DUE TO A NOTICE ISSUE AND WE WILL GO BACK TO ÃWE WILL

[L. 19-2747 CE 3101 Oleander Avenue - Bay 3 R Stein LLC Isaac Saucedo]

CALL 19 2747, 5L, 3101 OLEANDER AVENUE, BAY 3. >> THIS IS CASE NUMBER 19 2747, 3101 OLEANDER AVENUE, BAY 3. THE CASE WAS INITIATED BY MYSELF ON OCTOBER 20 OF 2019.

THE OWNER IS R STEIN, LLC OF 670 WEAVERVILLE HIGHWAY SUITE 6 THE VIOLATIONS WERE SECTIONS 19 Ã16 A IMPOSED, 1920 7B DOING BUSINESS WITHOUT A TAX AND NINE Ã20 7C.

THE CITY REQUESTS THAT THE SPECIAL MAGISTRATE FINDS A VIOLATION EXISTS THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN ZERO DAYS TO COMPLY OR A FINE OF $150 PER DAY BE ASSESSED AND ORDER ALL UTILITIES TO THE PREMISES BE SUSPENDED WHILE THE VIOLATION CONTINUES.

[01:00:05]

>> SO CAN YOU EXPLAIN IN LAYMAN'S TERMS THE NATURE OF THE VIOLATION? WHAT IS THE PAPERWORK THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO GET, DID THEY GET THE PAPERWORK? AND WHAT PRACTICE WERE THEY ENGAGING IN IN VIOLATION OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES.

>> WE RECEIVED A COMPLAINT STATING THAT THEY ARE OPERATING A BUSINESS WITHOUT A CURRENT BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT. SEVERAL OF THE UNITS, AS YOU CAN SEE, BECAUSE OF THE CASES THAT I HAVE SCHEDULED, THEY ARE OPERATING WITHOUT A BUSINESS. SOME OF THEM ARE SAYING THEY ARE JUST STORING ITEMS BUT WHEN YOU GO AFTER YOU PHYSICALLY SEE THEM I AM WORKING ON VEHICLES OR YOU NAME IT. I DID ÃWHEN I WENT OUT AND I GAVE THE NOTICE, I DID SPEAK TO THE GENTLEMAN THAT WORKS THERE. HE SPOKE ÃCALLED HIS BOSS. ACTUALLY SPOKE TO THE OWNER OF THE BUSINESS AND I EXPLAINED TO HIM EVERYTHING THAT NEEDED TO BE DONE.

HE NEEDED TO OBTAIN A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT IN ORDER TO KEEP THE BUSINESS RUNNING.

I THINK THERE MIGHT BE A LITTLE BIT OF CONFUSING BECAUSE HE IS STATING THAT HE DOES HAVE SOMETHING OR A BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT, HOWEVER WE CHECK OUR SYSTEM WE HAVE ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. I THINK HE MAY BE CONFUSED WITH HAVING ST. LUCIE COUNTIES BUSINESS TAX RECEIPT AND NOT WITH THE CITY OF FT. PIERCE. I EXPLAINED TO HIM HE NEEDED

BOTH >> AND HE SEEMS TO UNDERSTAND THAT WHEN YOU EXPLAIN IT?

>> I BELIEVE SO. HE WAS SUPPOSED TO CALL ME BACK AND I HAVEN'T HEARD ANYTHING FROM HIM. THE GENTLEMAN IS WORKING THERE I EXPLAINED IT TO HIM TOO, AND HE WAS AWARE OF EVERYTHING THAT'S GOING ON. I HAVEN'T HEARD ANYTHING

>> WITH REGARD TO THIS PARTICULAR UNIT, WHAT KIND OF WORK OR BUSINESS DID YOU

OBSERVE TO BE OPERATING? >> IT LOOKS LIKE AN ORDER RECORD.

>> WHAT DID YOU SEE WHEN YOU WENT THERE? >> THERE IS VEHICLES THAT ARE ALL TAKEN APART, I MEAN, THE GENTLEMAN THAT WORKS THERE, HIS HANDS ARE FULL OF GRACE.

THERE'S TIRES, THERE'S ÃI MEAN, ANYTHING THAT YOU CAN IMAGINE THAT YOU WOULD SEE IN

AN AUTO REPAIR SHOP >> AND WHEN YOU TALK TO HIM DID THE GENTLEMAN WHO WAS WORKING ON THE PREMISES ÃWHEN YOU TALKED TO HIM DID HE INDICATE THAT'S WHAT WAS OCCURRING

THERE, THAT THEY WERE FIXING VEHICLES? >> NO.

>> OKAY. WAS IT APPARENT TO YOU FROM WHAT YOU OBSERVED THAT THAT'S

WHAT WAS OCCURRING THERE? >> THAT'S CORRECT. >> OKAY.

AND THIS IS A COMMERCIAL TYPE AREA? IT'S NOT A HOUSE?

>> CORRECT. >> IS THERE ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO ADD OR THAT YOU OBSERVED THAT I DIDN'T ASK ABOUT THAT LED YOU TO BELIEVE THAT A BUSINESS WAS OPERATING

ON PREMISE? >> NO. I MEAN, JUST AS I PREVIOUSLY STATED, EVERYONE AT THIS LOCATION HAS A BUSINESS.HEY HAVE A BUSINESS OF SOME SORT.

I DO SEE PEOPLE COMING IN AND OUT. IT'S A VERY BUSY LOCATION.

IT'S NOT JUST A STORAGE FACILITY. >> OKAY.

AND WHEN YOU SPOKE TO BOTH OF THE PARTIES IN RELATION TO THIS, THE OWNER AND THE GENTLEMAN WHO HAD GREASE ON HIS HANDS BUT THEN HE SAID, DID EITHER OF THEM DENY THAT A

BUSINESS WAS ONGOING? >> ABSOLUTELY NOT. >> THEY JUST THOUGHT THEY HAD

THE CORRECT PAPERWORK WHEN THEY DID IT? >> CORRECT.

>> THANK YOU. NO FURTHER QUESTIONS. >> AND JUST ONE QUESTION.

THE CITY IS ASKING FOR ZERO DAYS TO COMPLY? >> YES, MA'AM.

PRIOR TO THE INFORMATION BEING FORWARDED TO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT DEPARTMENT, THE CITICORP'S OFFICE MAKES A PHONE CALL AND SEND TWO LETTERS. SO WARNINGS AND NOTICES HAVE BEEN ISSUED AND GONE OUT AND ONLY ÃTHEY RECEIVED NO RESPONSE JUST A COMPLAINT TO

COME DOWN FOR FOLLOW-UP. >> SO WITH NOTICE AND MORNINGS HAVE BEEN ALREADY ISSUED.

>> OKAY. WELL I FIND THAT THE THREE VIOLATIONS EXIST, SECTION 9 Ã 16 A, NINE Ã20 7B, AND NINE Ã 20 7C. AND THAT THE VIOLATOR BE GIVEN ZERO DAYS TO COMPLY. NOTICE HAVING BEEN GIVEN TO THEM AND THE FINE OF $150 A DAY WILL BE ASSESSED AND ORDER THAT ALL UTILITIES TO THE PREMISES WILL BE SUSPENDED AS LONG AS

THE VIOLATION CONTINUES. >> THANK YOU. >> THANK YOU, MA'AM.

>> SO SPECIAL MAGISTRATE ANY PARTIES THAT DID NOT ÃTHAT WERE NOT PRESENT TODAY I WOULD LIKE TO ASK OUR CLERK WHETHER OR NOT THEY RECEIVED NOTICE AND HOW THEY RECEIVE NOTICE.

[01:05:07]

>> DO YOU WANT ME TO READ IT? FOR CASES REQUIRING A HEARING PER STATE STATUTE 162 Ã12 NOTICE OF HEARING WAS SENT TO THE VIOLATOR'S CERTIFIED MAIL. IF THE GREEN CARD IS RETURNED SIGNED IT IS PLACED IN THE FILE. IF THE GREEN CARD IS RETURNED UNSIGNED OR UNCLAIMED, AN AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING WITH THE NOTICE OF HEARING AND CLOSE IS SENT TO THE VIOLATOR REGULAR U.S. MAIL. 10 DAYS PRIOR TO THE HEARING AND NOTICE OF HEARING IS POSTED ON THE BULLETIN BOARD IN CITY HALL.

A NOTICE OF HEARING IS ALSO POSTED AT THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION WITH AN AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING. IF THE GREEN CARD IS NOT RETURNED TO THE CODE ENFORCEMENT DEPARTMENT WITHIN 10 DAYS BEFORE THE HEARING, THE POSTING IS COMPLETED IN THE SAME MANNER AS IF THE CARD WAS RETURNED UNCLAIMED. FOR CASES NOT MANDATED BY STATE STATUTE, MAILING OF THE NOTICE OF HEARING ARE HANDLED IN THE SAME MANNER STATED PRIOR.

IF THE GREEN CARD IS RETURNED UNCLAIMED OR NOT RETURNED WITHIN 10 DAYS OF THE HEARING A NOTICE OF HEARING IS POSTED ON THE BULLETIN BOARD IN CITY HALL.

>> ARE THERE ANY OTHER CASES AND NO NEW BUSINESS? >> NO, MA'AM.APPY NEW YEAR.

>> THANK YOU. THIS HEARING IS CONCLUDED.

* This transcript was compiled from uncorrected Closed Captioning.